I apologize if I use incorrect terminology. I noticed recently that the Christian Bible, Hebrew Bible, and the Quran tell several of the same stories. Is there a single source for them and what group of people and region would they have been from?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

Is there proof that Jesus existed?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

Grover Cleveland was accused of raping a maid during the 1884 presidential election. His campaign called her a liar, and he won anyway. Has evidence emerged since about who was correct? Cleveland also later married his adopted daughter when he was 48 and she was 21. Did that cause a scandal itself?

2 Answers 2020-10-31

How long did it take for post-independence relations between Britain and the USA to cool off?

It seems as though the UK and the USA have been allied forever, but presumably there was a period in which the two nations had some animosity. How long did this last, and what were the key factors/events in the two countries patching things up?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

During the US war of independence how different were the accents of British and American troops?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

What’s going on with this sub? I never see the replies to a question yet it shows say 5 (for example) answers but there’s nothing there. Am I doing something wrong here?

3 Answers 2020-10-31

Confused about diseases: did they decimate native populations or not?

So on this sub, especially in the FAQ around Guns Germs and Steel, there are many many posts of flaired users saying how tired they are of hearing the debunked 'myth' of European diseases taking heavy tolls on Native populations in the Americas. Yet I've never encountered that claim outside of this sub.

I'm currently reading a book that recently came out, This Land is Their Land by David Silverman, and he's discussing the heavy toll diseases took on the New England indigenous populations during the first continuous contact in the 1600s. I'm frustrated because there seems to be such a disconnect from this sub and wider literature. Can someone help me understand what the disconnect is?

2 Answers 2020-10-31

William conquered England in 1066, introducing Norman rule. Only 69 years later, Henry I died without a clear successor and the country fell into anarchy and civil war. Was any thought given to throwing off the Normans completely? If not, why not? How did the Normans become so dominant so quickly?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

Is a masters worth it

  Hi, I just finished up my last semester of my bachelors degree in history and I am trying to decide whether a masters is worth it. I stayed home for my undergrad and have no student debt, so I am not too concerned about the cost of it.
  I am not particularly interested in teaching as a profession or even working in a history related field. I can see myself working in public service. I have done a couple of internships for the government in my home province in Canada. 
   As the youngest of 10 grand children and the only one without a masters or higher, I am looking to get a higher degree. It is something I’ve always wanted to do and it would make my family proud. I know a masters in public admin for example, would better suit my careers goals, but I am just not motivated to continue my education with that. Am I foolish to get a masters in history just because I want to have a masters?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

Need Help finding Sources

Hello,

I'm preparing a historiographical essay and have been stumped with my sources. I'm looking for authors that specifically shaped the way history was viewed regarding the "industrialists of Nazi Germany". Currently I have a big few names: Henry Turner, David Abraham, Peter Hayes, and Gerald Feldman. I'm looking for more names that were important to the discussion of the industrialists in Nazi Germany. Would anyone here have any good recommendations for authors that published scholarly works regarding the industrialists in Nazi Germany?

2 Answers 2020-10-31

How did the American accents come to be? (Deviate from British)

I understand there are many regional accents (both in the UK and US), and I understand Quebec got its accent from rural France and evolved further on its own.

I’m wondering for the US, when did the accents from Britain (since the days of the colonies) start develop on its own and how?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

Is there evidence of the British Museum "borrowing" ancient biblical manuscripts from the European continent and never, to this day, returning them?

Hi and thanks in advance for your help.

I'm doing a bit of creative writing and wanted to source something I heard of once, but I'm not getting anything on google.

Back when I was in seminary years and years ago, a professor said something that, though I don't remember word for word, the jist of which stuck with me.

We were in a New Testament Exegesis class, and he made an offhand comment along these lines of: "And how did the Britism Museum get it? The way they get everything. They stole it!"

He went to explain how in a certain monastery on the continent, some very old fragments of the New Testament were lent to representatives of the British Museum (they were trying to be good academic "sports"), fragments that would have been hand copied by monks of the same monastery centuries earlier.

Supposedly, the British Museum has never returned these manuscripts. The way I remember my professor tell it, there is a door in the monastary with a letter posted on it: a letter from the British Museum stating when the document would be returned.

Anybody have an inkling of what I made me remembering (or misremembering)? If so...

  1. In that monastery in what country might this have happened?

  2. What was the text borrowed (as in, was is *John's Gospel)?

  3. In what year did this happen?

  4. Was the loan for free or for a price?

This for a book I'm writing and, though it's fiction, I like to have my research ducks in a row.

Again, thank you historians!

1 Answers 2020-10-31

What was the average lifespan for a French soldier on the frontlines during the First World War?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

The recent series “The Queen’s Gambit” opens in 1950s America, in an orphanage where black and white children are housed together. Is this accurate, or would orphanages have been segregated in that era?

1 Answers 2020-10-31

What resources are available for this?

I am trying to research buildings and roads that existed in 17th century England. Does anybody know what resources are available for that? Any help would be appreciated, thanks.

1 Answers 2020-10-30

Why is the quality of pop music so bad in the early '60s?

Or is this an ahistorical impression?

I'm super interested in the rock interregnum that took place during the early '60s in the U.S. What accounted for the "death" of rock and roll during that period? Is it simply nothing more than Elvis' stint in the army? Why the sudden popularity of idiotic novelty songs and movie themes during this time? Is there any cultural or history signposts that point to the resurgence of the popularity of guitar-based rock in 1963/4?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

Marshall Plan’s Intra-European Payments Agreement Question

Could anyone explain the 1948 intra-European payments agreement within the Marshall plan clearly, I’m writing about it for a paper but I keep confusing myself

From what I understand European countries amounted massive debts with each other and the USA allocated funds as part of the Marshall plan to facilitate multilateral trade but only member countries of the OEEC were eligible

So the US gave aid, in the form of dollars, to a creditor member country for the amount that they were owed, with the rule that to receive the dollars they had to give the equivalent value in their country’s currency to the debtor member country;

but if this happened then the creditor/ debtor relationship would be destroyed but no one would be better off. Couldn’t the whole of the OEEC member countries just have agreed to write off everyone’s debt and they’d have the same outcome? Am I missing something?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

How did Classical Greek colonies work politically?

Were they independent of the city state that founded them, effectively making them just a new city, or was it like imperial colonialism of the industrial European states where the original sponsor controlled it from afar.

1 Answers 2020-10-30

The psychedelic Mysteries were the most “exceptional and divine” of the many gifts Greece gave to Rome, and a civilizing force, according to Cicero. Can we talk about this?

Here is Cicero from De Legibus:

“For it appears to me that among the many exceptional and divine things your Athens has produced and contributed to human life, nothing is better than those Mysteries. For by means of them we have been transformed from a rough and savage way of life to the state of humanity, and been civilized. Just as they are called initiations, so in actual fact we have learned from them the fundamentals of life, and have grasped the basis not only for living with joy, but also for dying with a better hope.”

So Greece created democracy, philosophy, and whole lot of great art, but the thing the Romans appreciated most was whatever sort of experience they had at the temple of Eleusis outside Athens?

Lots of ancient sources talk about whatever it was that they were doing there vaguely. An inscription from Eleusis reads, "Beautiful indeed is the Mystery given us by the blessed gods: death is for mortals no longer an evil, but a blessing," so the experience seemed to take away a fear of death.

When the Christians started trying to destroy the temple and end the Mysteries, Vettius Agorius Praetextatus, who had been initiated at Eleusis, said destroying the rites “would make the life of the Greeks unlivable” and argued that the temple was the one place that “holds the whole human race together.”

Marcus Aurelius was no spendthrift, and not given to flights of fancy, but when the temple of Eleusis was destroyed by a barbarian raid into Greece, he paid to have it rebuilt immediately, and went there himself.

Do we know why Cicero and so many others ranked the experience they had at Eleusis so highly? Why did they think it was so important to keep it going? Why did they view it as a civilizing force? What exactly went on there?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

Whats the story behind Native American folklore inspired Horror tales?

Things like the Wendigo or SKinwalkers have become a popular horror movie/story theme. Did Native American folklore influence the early settlers and lead to new horror stories, or is it more recent appropriation?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

Belgian independence

Could someone please tell me how it was possible that Belgium became independent after the London Conference if 3 parties (Russia, Austria and Prussia) opposed it and only 2 (Britain and France) were pro?

Thanks in advance

- Confused student

1 Answers 2020-10-30

What did the average Galician think of the Austro-Hungarian government?

Were they generally supportive or against the Austro-Hungarian government?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

I'm a young man bored with life in the Netherlands in the late 17th Century. I go down to the local VOC (Dutch East India) recruiting office to sign up for a job overseas. What can I expect out of the next 20-30 years of my career?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

What happened to the remaining Byzantines after Constantinople was taken over by the Ottomans in 1453?

I would assume that there would have been refugees as the Byzantine Empire was slowly losing its influence and I think that it would have been a difficult task to find refuge in the other major Christian kingdoms as they were Catholic (except for Russia).

And what about the Byzantines who remained in Constantinople and surrendered to the Ottomans, what happened to them? Were they converted, executed or simply allowed to live but without the privilege of being called Romans or members of the Orthodox Church?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

As the Crusades continued to fail or not succeed as expected as the years went by, and as the 4th Crusade was shunned as the Catholic Church, and as the spread of Islam and the Ottomans continued to rise, were there any attempts to reunite the two Churches after the East-West Schism of the 11th Cen?

The Crusades were meant to be a united religious attempt to reliberate important Christian kingdoms while also to limit the spread and power of their main opposing, the Caliphates and later the Ottomans.

And as time went by, the attempts to liberate these cities were less successful than desired and even led to other disasters like the Battle of Zara and the attack of Constantinople which were both Christian cities.

Given that this was a divide between powers that were both Christian and did not want to allow the Islam force to spread as the Byzantine Empire was slowly losing its influence and strength as time went on, where there any attempts of either the Roman Catholic church, or the Orthodox Church to unite the two Churches after the East-West Schism in an attempt to unify against a common threat?

1 Answers 2020-10-30

1025 / 7255

Back to start