The historical record is filled with examples of race science and people employing racial categorizations to describe people. But underlying all of that has been a scientific truth: from a scientific perspective, every human being is essentially equal. Races do not inherently exist in the human body. Cultures do not inherently exist. Those things are all constructed by whatever society a person happens to live in. The march of science would ultimately provide no more specificity than “Homo sapiens”.
I realized that I don’t really have any examples of early philosophers who believed this. Outside of the American abolition movement, I don’t know of anyone who taught against racial classifications. Are there philosophers who believed the “savages” of Africa were, in a very meaningful way, identical to the aristocracy of Europe?
I feel like maybe Jesus Christ—to the extent he was an actual person who actually held beliefs and taught them to people—is one of the only figures I’m familiar with who taught something like that before 1700. But as far as secular philosophers go, I’m not familiar with any, and I am interested to know of any.
2 Answers 2022-09-29
Today, the Democratic Party is clearly defined as the party of liberals and progressives, while the Republican Party is clearly defined as the party of conservatives and libertarians. However, prior to the mass migration that occurred in the 1960s as a result of the Civil Rights Movement, it seems to me that the lines were extremely blurred—conservatives were in both parties, and liberals were in both parties. So what was the actual difference?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
1 Answers 2022-09-29
Hi all, my girlfriend's birthday is coming up and she's been interested in that time period recently, so I thought it'd be nice to gift her a book about it. I don't really know where to look for recommendations for history books and I wouldn't know which ones are good or bad eitherways, so I figured I'd just ask. She's currently studying a history degree, so the book doesn't need to be entry level, she knows her stuff.
I hope this is the right sub for a question like this, if not be sure to let me know which one would be right.
2 Answers 2022-09-29
Here is a description of the book, titled Lourenço da Silva Mendonça and the Black Atlantic Abolitionist Movement in the Seventeenth Century:
“This groundbreaking study tells the story of the highly organised, international legal court case for the abolition of slavery spearheaded by Prince Lourenço da Silva Mendonça in the seventeenth century. The case, presented before the Vatican, called for the freedom of all enslaved people and other oppressed groups. This included New Christians (Jews converted to Christianity) and Indigenous Americans in the Atlantic World, and Black Christians from confraternities in Angola, Brazil, Portugal and Spain. Abolition debate is generally believed to have been dominated by white Europeans in the eighteenth century. By centring African agency, José Lingna Nafafé offers a new perspective on the abolition movement, showing, for the first time, how the legal debate was begun not by Europeans, but by Africans. In the first book of its kind, Lingna Nafafé underscores the exceptionally complex nature of the African liberation struggle, and demystifies the common knowledge and accepted wisdom surrounding African slavery.”
The book was just released in August, but what has been the academic reaction so far? If true, why has this topic been overlooked until now?
2 Answers 2022-09-29
How did this slave trade sustain itself? What was its nature before the colonial movement resulted in a huge influx of American colonists? How did that immigration change the slave trade, and how did the trade finally come to an end?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
1 Answers 2022-09-29
2 Answers 2022-09-29
The 1890s were famously called "The Gay Nineties" after the fact. It's not hard to find a wealth of writing that waxes rhapsodic about this better, vanished time. So... why? Nobody's calling the 1930s a time of ease and plenty, and I've heard that the Panic of 1893 was in some ways worse than the Great Depression. Why lionize this particular era?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
I recently watched a video by Sam Aronow on Youtube regarding the Reform movemennt in the US and was wondering how it was that, with so many Jewish Americans arriving to Israel after independence today we see little Reform representation. In fact, Reform is the one branch of modern Judaiism not legally recognized in Israel's religious courts. You can have a Reform synagouge, but the Rabbinate is Conservative and Orthodox only, from what I understannd. How did this happen under years of a Socialist government? Was this ever even a question among Labour Zionists? Was the Reform movement so localized to the US that it didn't matter?
2 Answers 2022-09-29
Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
2 Answers 2022-09-29
By the time she was thirty, Lydia Maria Child was a beloved novelist and children's author, but she shocked her readers in 1833 by publishing a book-length condemnation of slavery that was so radical that polite society turned against her. My book, "Lydia Maria Child: A Radical American Life," tells the story of how she came to this moment and how she lived as a result.
Fun fact: I am actually a philosopher! I teach philosophy at Colby College, and my earlier books were on the political and aesthetic philosophy of G.W.F. Hegel. But after the election of 2016, I decided I wanted to turn to my own history and to women. That's when I discovered Lydia Maria Child and the riveting and imperfect example she set of how to fight racial injustice. I read Child's life as a way of learning about our moral moment and of figuring out how to live my own life. So even though, as we learned on "The Good Place," everyone hates professors of moral philosophy, I'm hoping you'll love hearing more about Lydia Maria Child. Her life intersected in fascinating ways with John Brown's raid, Robert Gould Shaw's death, and the women's suffrage movement.
You can find more of my writing on LMC at the Washington Post (here and here), the Boston Globe, the American Scholar, and the Paris Review. I've given an interview about her on National Public Radio. The book is available for pre-order here or wherever you get your books!
Also find me on Twitter, lydia_moland.
Update at 12:09: Thank you to everyone for a wonderful AMA--I so appreciated all the questions and the opportunity to share some of LMC's life. Thanks to the moderators too! More soon, I hope.
14 Answers 2022-09-29
If I did understand it and anticipated the possibility of war, what do I do? Were there refugees that fled northward (or in another direction)?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
I'm specifically interested in textile history from prehistory until it became 'commercialized' and no longer was a task women did in the home to provide for their families and communities. In order to narrow down my personal research, I'm trying to figure out when weaving was no longer done by your mother and sisters, but was done in a commercial setting where you would then go buy the finished cloth. I have a feeling it's much later in history than I originally assumed (which would be before the Medieval period, but I've watched a few documentaries and now I think I might be very very wrong).
I'm hoping if the time is later than I think, it opens up more documentaries and books for me to enjoy and learn from. I've exhausted most of the prehistory and ancient history documentaries I can find free, so if I can move to later periods and continue learning about the history of fiber crafts that would be amazing.
1 Answers 2022-09-29
In most fiction I’ve read, a ship’s captain is the ultimate authority, with maybe a second in command that does most of the hands-on work with the crew. But in Clavell’s novel, he paints a picture of the pilot actually being the one in charge, giving order and often a captain deferring to his judgment. Is this how the power dynamic actually worked on ships of the time, or is the author’s creation?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
I read a long while back that the Nazis believed the Croatians to have some “Aryan” blood due to the Germanic tribes with the fall or the Western Roman Empire. Did Hitler or any of his inner circle believe that the Tunisians would have some Aryan blood due to the vandal kingdom? I read that himmler wanted to extract “Aryan souls” to harvest and purify the Reich and the blood.
1 Answers 2022-09-29
i’ve been wondering why the indigenous pantheons of europe all died out with no exceptions, but hinduism and Zoroastrianism survived. Does anyone know the reasons why this may have happened?
3 Answers 2022-09-29
Would they have known much about them or just that they exist? Was there any version of royal celebrity and interest in personal lives like there is today with the UK royal family?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
All the way from prehistory to now.
How much of an impact did it have on your life within and outside of your tribe?
Did its impact change throughout history?
Is this something that historians attempt to study or is it a topic for some other specific subject?
Thanks in advance.
1 Answers 2022-09-29
Other than the immediate effect of decreased productivity having a skilled worker die, how would this affect the family business?
Would the reputation of the business be affected, now that a woman is the "head"? (Or would she be a master now?)
If my husband is in a guild, is it likely I can join as well? How would the business be affected if I'm denied membership due to being a woman?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
According to this Wikipedia article, pre-industrial Japan - a mostly mountainous country around 70% the size of France (a country occupying one of the most fertile regions of Europe) - had about 25% more people than France. Even today, Japan still has almost twice the population of France. Why is this? Is there something special about Japan (or France) that explains this?
1 Answers 2022-09-29
Their demographic study estimated the total war dead at 26.6 million including 20.0 million males and 6.6 million females. I wonder if this had any effect on the marriage practices in the Soviet Union.
1 Answers 2022-09-29
1 Answers 2022-09-29
I'm sitting here, listening as Ian blows through, and I'm curious if there's any research on how the Tocobaga (or other indigenous groups in the gulf of Mexico region) dealt with these storms. I'm particularly curious if there's any evidence of people changing the environment to help mitigate storm effects.
1 Answers 2022-09-29