Why are almost all protestants part of anglo-saxon/germanic cultures. Did their culture encourage them to become protestants?

1 Answers 2022-09-27

Is it known how Native Americans viewed the Civil War? Did tribes involve themselves in the conflict or were any forced to fight for a particular side?

2 Answers 2022-09-27

Has there ever been a dictator that ruled with prosperity and was good natured?

It seems dictators are always ruthless and filling individuals who always seem to lead to their own demise due to power struggles and having to remove opponents. I’m curious to know if history has ever had what would be considered a “good” dictator?

1 Answers 2022-09-27

How did we settle on Dollar as the name of American currency?

1 Answers 2022-09-27

There’s obviously going to be variation throughout history, but what would have been the ratio of “officer” to “enlisted” men in the Antiquity?

Seems like modern militaries have a ratio of about 1 officer to 5-8 enlisted. What would be the ratios in say Classical Greece, Republican/Imperial Rome, or maybe in the Hellenistic Kingdoms? I feel like modern militaries are very officer-heavy compared to the ancient world but I can’t seem to find much to validate that belief.

1 Answers 2022-09-27

Is it likely that the American Revolutionary War could have been engineered by wealthy colonists to advance their own economic and social status?

1 Answers 2022-09-27

Were there any slave plantations in Canada?

I know Canada as we know it today came into existence in 1867 and by that point slavery in British North America had long since been abolished in the 1830s. But even so I know there were some black slaves in what is now adays modern Canada.

So that begs the question, Were there ever slave plantations in Canada like there were in the Southern US and are those buildings still around today?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

When did did steppe nomads begin using shears?

I read that shears were invented in the first century AD by Romans but am curious how long this technology took to spread to the Eurasian steppe and what steppe pastoralists used to gather wool from their sheep?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

To what extent is it fair to say denazification in West Germany was more lenient than in East Germany?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

In the beginning of early human civilization, were there other cultures thriving besides just the middle east and Europe area? If so, why don't we talk about them as much or credit them for certain things like we do the Greeks?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

Was the Pagan pantheon synthesized into Christian art/iconography following the conversion of ‘heathen’ groups to Christianity during the Medieval period?

And if so, do we have surviving works? For example, do we have evidence of artwork from the middle ages that demonstrates pagan groups adapting their polytheistic mythology to fit into their new Christian religion, such as: Jesus with a hammer or other weaponry; the Christian God depicted as Odin hanging from a tree or holding a staff, etc?

For context, I have been reading Gregory of Tours' account of the conversion of Clovis and his people. It seems strange that upon baptism these peoples would immediately stop reflecting their former belief system in their artwork. Rather, it seems more plausible that there would instead be a period where Christianity was seen as an addition to their polytheistic spirituality, rather than a replacement, and over generations we would gradually see the full replacement of pagan beliefs by Christianity (and this would be reflected in the surviving artwork). Is this the case?

I understand this post is essentially two questions wrapped up into one, and I would love to hear any thoughts on this, whether it relates to iconography, or more generally whether there was a synthesis of the two religious practices. Thank you for reading!

2 Answers 2022-09-26

I am a savvy Imeprial Roman general who wants to equip my soldiers with bicycles. Could I pull it off?

I'm a capable and intelligent Roman with command over a legion.

I've noticed when a metal plate is dropped, it can roll a fair distance in a straight line. I've read enough maths & engineering texts to understand the functionality of gears, and I have blacksmiths and leatherworkers who'll devote time to making me the frames & chairs.

Would the resources I can muster be able to generate steel frame bikes with leather seats & inflatable tyres? Could I use them to run rings around the tribes causing ruckus in Germania?

2 Answers 2022-09-26

By being born a slave in the New World, you were considered property of the slave master. Did early abolitionists who campaigned to end the slave trade as a compromise with slave owners try to target this practice as well?

Born to a slave*

1 Answers 2022-09-26

Do populations in regions with difficult climate/terrain actually produce unusually resilient fighters, or is the reputation of places like Afghanistan more related to imperial troops with failing morale going up against people who desperately want to defend their homes?

This question could also be applied to Chechnya, Ethiopia, Vietnam, etc.

1 Answers 2022-09-26

During the 1700's, was there any significant portion of British society that was _morally_ opposed to having an empire because they believed all people had the right to be self-governing?

I don't know how old this school of thought is, and I'm curious about the extent to which it existed in Great Britain at the time. Was there a political party opposed to empire? If not, was it a fringe belief or one that didn't really exist at all?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

why did the IJN in WW2 consider taking Wake Island strategically important, but the US Pacific Fleet did not feel recapturing the island was of value?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

Why did Mother Jones try and stop miners from marching into WV with a fake telegram from the president?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

The last known auroch only died in 1627. There were royal restrictions on hunting them as early as the 1200s. How did 400 years of proto-conservation fail for such a high status, visible animal?

2 Answers 2022-09-26

Ancient History, where to start?

Hey Everyone,

Tl:dr - Need opinions on which to start reading about Ancient History? And what era/civilization/empire excites you personally in the Ancient History?


In the past up until a few months ago, i was not interested in history at all because it's not taught well here, it never makes u curious, it makes one run away from it because they make it an essay to memorize.

Recently i was on some site, i saw an article about 'The Battle of Stalingrad'.

Now this bugged me because 10+ years of history and all i remember is this name but i don't remember why and what happened.

This led me to read about it and i ended up loving history because now I've read about both world wars, many wars, revolutions, watch movies, watch documentaries.

Now I wanna get into Ancient History, so what's the best event to start reading it or what particular Ancient History excites you.

Actual history noob here so I hope this question makes sense.

Thanks in advance to all you!


P.S: You can also suggest me some underrated books/documentaries/movies on World War.

I would love to see/read many other point of views.

1 Answers 2022-09-26

How much do we really know about the bronze age collapse and what is the best source?

I recognize that this may be specific by society, but I was curious if there’s a certain type of record, be it weather or written history that help us understand it.

1 Answers 2022-09-26

why did the USSR not fight/ invaded Japan?

In ww2 the USSR was at war with the axis and only shared a land border on Sakhalin, Korea (and I think Manchuria was a puppet of Japan at the time. How come there was absolutely no invasion from the USSR or Japan? Thanks.

1 Answers 2022-09-26

[Meta] I am a regular questioner on this sub. From time to time I see very simple questions on this sub which could be answered rather simply and to which I know the answer. How could I go about doing so as an amateur, without breaking the rules by only citing Wikipedia? [Elaboration inside]

Okay the way I worded the question may sound weird, because the rules state that answers must be in-depth so an answer cannot ever be "simple" or it would be rule-breaking.

But let me illustrate my conundrum with a very recent example:

A day ago someone posted a question about popular warship names in various navies: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/xnkqfv/the_starship_enterprise_traces_its_name_back

In this case I know that the German navy has had four warships with the name "Emden" already, with a fifth, a corvette currently under construction, on its way.

I know the general history behind at least the first Emden and the third Emden (from 1925).

So an answer in this case may go about summarising the history of each of the four ships and why Emden is such a prevalent name in the German navy's history (it's due to the first Emden's highly successful raiding during WW1 while still following the rules of war and being generally considered "gallantly").

So in this case the most important part of the answer, which ships where when named Emden, would be very matter-of-fact-ly. I am not sure how one is supposed to answer that with a source other than Wikipedia. Do I have to look up a book about each of the Emden's and find a sentence that says "This ship was named Emden and was launched in XXXX"?

And then for rest of the answer, the summary for each ship's history, how would one go about doing that? I assume that in that case I would have to read at least one book about each of the Emden's, and then summarise what was written in each book. That seems like a ton of effort and time (by the time I am done the question will be a week(s) old and I will have used up a lot of time for it - I have a full-time job) for an answer which seems more like asking for facts ("What are some commonly reused ship names in various navies and why?"), rather than an analysis, which a question about the causes of the Russian Civil War would require, for example.

I don't know if I could bring across my question sufficiently.

I understand that the rules are the way they are to keep the quality of answers high and make them more trustworthy, but I am just curious if maybe I am not overseeing something here?

In any case, if I am interpreting the rules correctly, that is fine. I am okay with just remaining a questioner on this sub. is just wanted to explore the possibility of writing an answer here and there for fun. But it wouldn't be a deal breaker for me if I wouldn't do so due to the requirements required.

4 Answers 2022-09-26

Between Darius and Darius II, Achaemenid inscriptions only invoke Ahura Mazda by name. Starting from Artaxerxes II, they also invoke Anahita and Mithra. What happened?

Were Anahita and Mithra already popular (including among the royalty) when Artaxerxes II started the practice? What did worship of these three look like in terms of practice?

1 Answers 2022-09-26

Why did the surname of Mussolini not fall out of favor in Italy the way that Hitler did in Germany?

Caio Mussolini, one of Mussolini's grandsons stood for office in 2019, while his cousin, one of Mussolini's granddaughters, Alessandra Mussolini was elected to office and served for years. [Rachelle Mussolini, another granddaughter](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachele_Mussolini_(politician)), is currently a councillor in Rome. All three are considered "far right-wing" in Italy and are not shy about mentioning their relation to the fascist dictator.

Despite my living a stone's throw from the Italian border, I confess I don't know much about the country or its culture. What is it that allows Mussolinis to openly campaign with the surname of Mussolini, while the name "Hitler" is wildly vilified and even the first name of Adolf has seen a sharp drop-off in Germany after WWII (site in Germany, but you can't mistake the graph).

Update: Obviously, that last question about "openly campaign" falls afoul of the 20 year rule, so I withdraw it and would stick with the question in the title.

2 Answers 2022-09-26

How did the very first "rich people" emerge?

How did the very first "rich people" emerge?

Also, were there vast differences in wealth before the creation of currency?

Both my questions apply to any part of the world.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2022-09-26

107 / 7255

Back to start