How historically accurate is the TV series Vikings when it comes to tribal interactions, daily life, politics, values and culture?

So I'm less interested in how accurate the depiction of specific characters is but rather the daily life aspect and interactions between groups. Were settlement of that size common? Would they have had access to clothes in bright colors? Is it reasonable to think that there were regular religious travels all the way from Kattegatt to Uppsala? Do we imagine tribal warfare being conducted in the manner presented? Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-07-30

How did England and the Byzantine Empire regard each other during the Middle Ages?

The Byzantines considered themselves culturally Roman and regarded Constantinople as the seat of Roman power after the fall of the Western Empire. The idea of a separate Eastern/Greek identity was superimposed by historians long after the Ottoman conquest in the 15th century. Did the Byzantines consider Britannia a lost former colony overrun by barbarians? Did they have a sense of ancient connection and a cultural memory of Londinium as a vestige of bygone Roman power? How did they approach diplomacy with medieval England?

Conversely, did the English have an understanding of the Byzantine Empire (as Rome) being past rulers of the Isles? Did this change after the Norman conquest in the 11th c.? Did they have a connection through the Roman cultural vector of the church? Did they consider the Pope to be the authentic representative of Rome and the Byzantine rulers to be foreign/oriental/illegitimate? Did they understand the Romanness of various elements of their culture and surroundings (e.g. Hadrian’s Wall, amphitheaters, baths, forts, etc.)?

Fwiw, I have a solid grounding in the withdrawal of Roman interests between the 380s and early 400s (i.e. Saxon/Pictish/et al raiders, Magnus Maximus, Constantine III, the emergence of barbarian and Romano-British warlords, and so on).

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Part 1 of 2: When did the dilution of wine stop being popular in Europe?

The Ancient Greeks almost always diluted their wine. They also lambasted anyone who didn't, such as the Gauls and the Macedonians. Ancient Romans also frequently diluted their wine, but didn't seem to be nearly as disparaging of the drinkers of undiluted wine.

Nowadays, in almost every culture that permits the drinking of wine, it is considered improper to dilute it. If I were to go drinking with friends and dilute my wine, I would get strange looks. Also, when I visited Greece and Italy (in 2016 and 2018, respectively), the people of those regions nowadays drink their wine undiluted.

When, and how, did drinking diluted wine, change from being the "right way" to being the "wrong way" to drink wine?

Part 2 of 2: Why did Coffee appear to have been discovered so late?

2 Answers 2020-07-30

When/how did the lion become associated with England?

The lion is the national animal of England and is still prevalent in many areas of English society. The earliest use of the lion I can think of concerning England would be with Richard I’s nickname the ‘Lionheart’. If anyone has any further details on how England and the lion became almost synonymous I would be interested to know.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Did Che Guevara burn books, banned music and oversaw executions during the Cuban revolution?

So, I was a watching a tv show about Cuban immigrants in US called "One day at a time". In that show, when an American wears Che Guevara t-shirt, the Cuban family gets offended and compares it to wearing a shirt with Hitler’s image on it in a Jewish family’s home. And they add "He burned books, personally he banned music, he personally oversaw executions, he’s a mass murderer!".

Link for more context : One Day at a Time Calls Out the Che Guevara T-Shirt in One Perfect Scene

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Book Recommendations Sought - Dutch History (inc. Boer States and the East India Company)

Goedemorgen!

I recently moved to the Netherlands from the UK, and I'm looking to vastly improve my understanding of Dutch world history.

Beyond the basics, I don't know that much about the pre-modern period, so I'm looking for general primers as well as adjacent history such as:

  • The Dutch East India Company
  • Dutch American and Asian Colonies
  • The Orange Free State
  • The Transvaal

Hard mode:

  • The books are Dutch Language.
  • The books are by Indonesian, Suriname or South African authors.

Very Hard Mode:

  • The books give a multi-or-alternative viewpoint treatment of Dutch history. Specifically, I'm looking to avoid a situation such as: You pick up a biography of Winston Churchill, and it almost completely ignores his role in the Bengal famine - instead focusing on what an ePiC cIGar MaN he was.

Bedankt!

3 Answers 2020-07-30

Why was Saladin mostly forgotten about in the Muslim world until the modern era, whilst he was venerated by the West continuously as a skilled opponent?

Recently read 'Saladin' the John Man biography and while he has some answers to the posed questions, I wondered if there were more takes on the subject matter.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

During the crusades Constantinople was ravaged by crusaders even though it was still Christian why was that?

It doesn’t make sense why they would do that, it almost seemed to undermine their goals... and helped their enemies the Turks.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

By the time of the American Civil War, breechloading rifles such as the Dreyse needle gun had been invented, produced, and in-use for at least a decade or two. Why, then, were muzzle-loaded rifles the standard for troops on both sides of the war? Why had America fallen behind in terms of small arms?

2 Answers 2020-07-30

Does anyone have any recommendations of books on the life of Mehmed II or the conquest of Constantinople in 1453?

Please don’t recommend the Babinger biography or Crowley 1453 book as I am already familiar with those titles.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

In 1804, Haitian Emperor Jean-Jacques Dessalines ordered the massacre of every remaining French person in Haiti (including women and children). What effect did this have on the public opinion towards slavery in the United States? Did it result in Americans becoming more fearful of abolitionism?

1 Answers 2020-07-30

In Assassin's Creed Origins, set in 48 BCE Ptolemaic Egypt, we see rival chariot teams wearing blue and green. Were the "Blues" and "Greens" of Byzantine fame around that far back, or is this an anachronism?

Obviously I know the Blues and Greens from their prominence in the later Eastern Roman Empire and their involvement in Justinian's Nika Riots. But how far back would rival teams have worn these colors? Were they widespread throughout the Hellenistic world? In the game, you meet them at a hippodrome outside of Alexandria. Did they have regional franchises, or might they have traveled around and had supporters in many different cities? And would they have head political clout during this period, assuming they did exist?

Obviously video games take a lot of artistic license, but I'm curious if it's at least historically plausible.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Did Europeans Eat Hedgehogs

I have a simple question, that likely does not have a simple answer.

Hedgehogs are rather bold as far as wild animals are considered. They go where they want, and when they encounter another animal they don’t really run. They rely on their spines to be a (rather formidable) defense. Problem is spines aren’t a formidable defense when a foraging human can just pick the hedgehog up and carry it home to butcher it.

So my question stands: If some of the various cultures of Europe regularly ate hedgehog, who did? Why has the practice not survived to the present day as guinea pig cultivation has in Peru? If eating hedgehog was frowned upon, why?

Thanks for any help!

1 Answers 2020-07-30

The space race was in the 1960’s between the USA and the Soviet Union. The Soviets were there first in 1959 when the crashed an uncrewed space vehicle. The USA had six manned landings between 1969 and 1972. Why did the Soviets give up and never land a person on the moon?

1 Answers 2020-07-30

After the US Presidential elections of 1824, 1876, and 1888 was there any significant movements to reform the electoral college, if any movement, as in those elections the president lost the popular vote but won the electoral college.

These were the elections of John Quincy Adams vs Andrew Jackson (1824), Samuel Tilden vs Rutherford B. Hayes (1876), and Grover Cleveland vs Benjamin Harrison (1888), and I would like to know if there was any significant movements, if any at all to abolish or at the very least, reform of the electoral college by the disgruntled voters of the losing candidate.

The elections of Al Gore vs George W. Bush (2000) and Hillary Clinton vs Donald Trump (2016) also resulted in one of these cases but I already know what happened in these events.

1 Answers 2020-07-30

If a US Army Military Policeman's last date of domestic service was June 5th, 1944, and first date of foreign service was June 6th, 1944, does that mean he was sent to storm the beaches at Normandy? Did the US Army ship troops to anywhere else on that date?

I hope a more specifically personal question is okay to post here.

I found a record of my Pap's application for veteran compensation, and those are the service dates he had filled out. I don't know anything else about what his position/rank/etc. might have been (if those are even applicable?), but I know he was Military Police. He entered active service in Pittsburgh, PA if that makes a difference.

To me these dates make it sound like he got on a plane in the US on June 5th and was shipped somewhere to begin battle on June 6th. Am I interpreting that correctly? The only thing I know of happening on June 6th 1944 was the invasion at Normandy, and when I google that date that's the only info that comes up. Did the US Army send troops anywhere else on that date? If so, is there any other information I could look for in my Pap's records that could indicate where he might have been sent? i.e. if only soldiers from XYZ locations or XYZ enlistment dates were sent to Normandy, etc.

Here's a screenshot of the relevant part of the paperwork.

I haven't found any other documents about his service so far, and sadly he passed away a long time ago and I'm no longer in contact with any living relatives on that side of my family, so I have no other way of finding out about his time in the service. If you all could help me out I'd be super grateful.

2 Answers 2020-07-30

Humans have been fermenting alcoholic beverages since prehistoric times. When I homebrew, I must painstakingly sterilize, as errant microbes can literally render my beer undrinkable. Prior to the discovery of microbes and sterilization, how was the quality of alcohol maintained/explained?

I realize that this is a question that casts a pretty wide net (at the least, all of human civilization), but I'm interested in any culture's perspective at any point in history.

Did beer/wine/other beverages just 'go bad' at random? Why didn't it all go bad? Some brewers have been creating their same beer or wine for hundreds of years without lapse in quality.

How was this explained? How effective was quality control?

Thank you in advance!

2 Answers 2020-07-30

Why didn’t the Allies experience any supply-line issues during World War II?

Germany had supply line issues because of the fact that they were getting so long during Operation Barbarossa. Why didn’t the Allies experience this?

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Women having longer hair than man seems to be universal across many different cultures all across history. How, why and when did this particular beauty standard take form?

1 Answers 2020-07-30

Is there any concievable way the Japanese could have beaten the United States in the Pacific War?

Let's suppose that everything went right for the japanese. Luck is on their side, they sink both Yorktown and Lexington in the Battle of the Coral Sea, then both Enterprise and Hornet at Midway. Pushing on, they win the Guadalcanal capaign and...

What would it have taken to bring the USA to the negotiation table? Would capturing Hawaii cut it? Total dominance of the pacific? Was it just impossble?

1 Answers 2020-07-29

When did the barbarians (goths, vandals, huns, etc) become pro roman?

The Germanic tribes were the ones constantly fighting the roman empire and sacked Rome several times but later became seemingly obsessed with becoming the Romans as in the Holy Roman Empire. How did this shift happen?

1 Answers 2020-07-29

Two out of every five construction workers fell to their deaths or were disabled while building New York's skyscrapers in the 1920's. Was there a procedure in place in the event that someone falls to their death? Was seeing the aftermath of a deadly fall considered part and parcel of life in NYC?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDN4c2wnx3E

1 Answers 2020-07-29

Was Pearl Harbor successful in allowing the Japanese to increase their influence in Asia and the Pacific?

One of the Japanese main goal in World War 2 was to acquire land as its economy was suffering due to minimal natural resources and inability to contend with Western goods. As a result they entered the war, aiming to acquire land. So, did attacking Pearl Harbor assist them in acquiring land?

1 Answers 2020-07-29

How did Richard I come to be so fondly lionized in British cultural memory given how marginal of a King he seems to have actually been?

Although the Lionheart was, apparently, known to be a pretty good warrior, he seems to have been a pretty terrible King, spending almost no time actually in England, and much more concerned with the Crusades or goings-on in France. The main contribution he seems to have made to England as King was draining the treasury to pay for his ransom.

Yet he is a romanticized figure beyond any other medieval King of England, and perhaps beyond any King regardless of time period. Why did this come about!?

3 Answers 2020-07-29

Did Caligula approve of his nickname?

1 Answers 2020-07-29

1183 / 7255

Back to start