Does Judaism only date to 150 B.C.?

New book published by Yale, written by an archaeologist.

Letters from around 400 B.C. indicate the Judeans were naming their children after various gods, taking oaths by various gods and donating money to many various gods.

They contain no mention of Moses or any other figure from the Old Testament.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICrwEdofLA8

https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/2022-11-15/ty-article/when-did-judaism-emerge-far-later-than-assumed-new-theory-suggests/00000184-7605-deef-a3cd-765584c70000

1 Answers 2022-12-21

How historically accurate is the book “Thug or a million murders” by James L. Sleeman about Thugs' suppression made by William Henry Sleeman?

I am currently reading this book and I'm wondering if it is historically correct, is completely inaccurate, or contains any truth.
I'm particularly interested about Thugs' origin and the claim that the “sculptures in the Caves of Ellora” (the author says they were created in the eighth century) depict Thugs' operations.
Did Thugs really existed? Did they operated in the way described in the book?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

I’m a Medieval peasant during the Black Death outbreak, what measures am I taking to avoid catching the disease?

Am I avoiding people? Do I try avoid crowded spaces? Do I still attend mass on Sundays? Do I stay clear from animals? Do I bathe more regularly? Etc.

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Who were the "Sabians" mentioned in the Quran?

I've seen a wide range of theories about the identity of the Sabians, an unidentified religious group who (from what I understand of the relevant verses) are described in the Quran alongside Muslims, Jews and Christians as being among those who may receive salvation.

I'm curious if there's an academic consensus, or a hypothesis with strong evidence, as to which religious group the term "Sabian" referred to, and if there's an understanding of why their identity has been so poorly recorded, considering that they're grouped together with what are now the major Abrahamic religions.

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Why didn’t Hitler re-annex the North Schleswig after occupying Denmark?

So Hitler wanted to create a German realm where all Germans live in? But even after occupying Denmark he did not re-annex North Schleswig that was German before WWI and even had a sizeable German population. Why is that?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Why did small countries survive?

This question is mostly about countries like Andorra, San Marino, and Liechtenstein. Why and how did these countries survive other countries expanding and the unification wars around them?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

1917 charge scene, would the field be like that?

I finally got around to watching 1917 a while ago, being a longtime fan of war movies and WW1 in general I was excited for it. I won't do a full review but overall I liked it even if it wasn't as good as some people made out. (The new version of All Quiet on the Western Front was excellent though, go watch it!)

So my question is about the scene when the main character is running across the soldiers charging over no man's land. I remember seeing them charge across a lush green field and thinking how unlikely it was that there'd be a field like that anywhere on the Western Front, especially in 1917 after 3 years of war. It took me right out of it, now while I'm pretty sure the battlefield would look more like the lunar hellscape we associate with WW1 I'm not entirely sure, stranger things have happened.

So how likely was it that there would be a field like that on the Western Front of 1917?

https://youtu.be/RXRLqK6S02g the scene in question

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Did medieval people really believe in dragons/sea monsters or it was a just a weird belief like Aliens are today?

2 Answers 2022-12-21

How did people managed their poop before public toilets?

Well before sewage was a thing, people dwelled in enclosed, public or semipublic places, sometimes eating and drinking (e.g. inns and markets, monastries, courts). How did people in, let's say, late medieval (or early modern Europe) solved their natural urges in a civil manner? Did people use chamberpots out of their chambers? Were there designated interior places? Or would people just wander out and into the woods? Or were alleys generally very disgusting places? Were visitors expected to hold some kind of hygienic standards?

Further, was there an observable evolution of customs in time (consistent convergence of uses with increments in technical knowledge and demographic concentration) or is it just the recurrent "it was different for every civilization and historic period, significantly influenced by diverse geographic, economic and cultural factors".

As an obvious follow up question, when and where did public toilets first appear (i.e. "private" enclosed areas in public or semipublic places dedicated to defecation), and when did people start expecting them as a given thing (e.g. modern regulation for customer bathrooms in the gastronomic industry).

This questions were not typed in the bathroom.

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Why has railway artillery become obsolete?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Pompey made his last stand in Greece and failed, Brutus and Cassius made their stand in Greece and failed, why did Marc Antony make his last stand in Greece instead of invading Italy with his numerically superior forces?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

What are good books on the early modern ages?

Can someone recommend me a book from the fall of Constantinople to the age of industrialization I would like if its not Europe centered only it doesn’t matter to me if its more than 1 volume and you can recommend me books about a specific time in that age but i would rather a book that goes through the whole early modern ages

1 Answers 2022-12-21

There's a popular claim that Coca Cola invented the modern Santa, and a lot of other Christmas traditions. Is it true? How much influence has Coca Cola or other secular companies had on the "image" of Christmas?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

What happened to all of the Napoleonic-era cannonballs?

As I understand it, the Napoleonic Wars saw a dramatic increase in the use of artillery, including but not limited to solid, round-shot cannonballs. In some battles, the total number of artillery rounds fired by both sides soared into the hundred-thousands. At Wagram in 1809, the number was about 200,000, while at Leipzig in 1813, the number was an astounding 400,000!

My question is specifically about the round shot: with so many of these cannonballs littering the various battlefields around Europe, whatever happened to all of them? Given their sheer number, it must've taken considerable time and effort for anyone to collect them all. Did armies make any effort to collect some of them after a battle, or were they mostly left alone for anyone to come along and collect them on their own? If a random person from this time were to come across one of them, what would they have likely done with it? Take it to a blacksmith to melt it down? Sell it? Maybe even keep it as a collector's item?

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Are there any documented cases of German rank-and-file soldiers objecting to the Holocaust on moral grounds and refusing to follow orders at concentration camps, or otherwise openly challenging those crimes against humanity? If so, what happened to them?

2 Answers 2022-12-21

What is the history of the following supposed flat earth argument? Was it ever actually made in earnest?

I once saw it claimed on the internet -- unfortunately, I can no longer find it -- that the following argument was used by European flat-earthers of the 1400s or so. (Obviously this would still have been a fringe position, as in that area the earth had been known to be round for a long time, but the claim was that there were still some flat-earthers making this argument.)

If the world were round, there would be a southern hemisphere. If there were a southern hemisphere, it would be populated, because God wouldn't waste all that space. If the southern hemisphere were populated, it would be possible for us to reach it, because God has mandated us to spread the gospels to all the people of the earth, and God would not assign us an impossible task. But to reach the southern hemisphere, you would have to cross the equator; and clearly anyone crossing the equator would burn up and die. Therefore, the earth must be flat.

(Supposedly, some other people who didn't accept all these premises instead just used this to argue that the southern hemisphere must be uninhabited.)

Now, I love this argument as an example for demonstrating the difference between [validity](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Validity_(logic)) and soundness. The problem is, I can no longer find the source I got this from, and, well, I'm not confident that it's real.

So, is it? Did people make this argument, and if so who and when? Presumably if this is real, it must be from before any European had crossed the equator (which according to a quick search seems to have occurred in 1471?), or at least before such had become widely known. But was it really made?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-12-21

Are there any available biographies in English for Oda Nobunaga, Toyotomi Hideyoshi, and Tokugawa Ieyasu?

I've been told that there are ample sources available in Japanese. I do not know the language unfortunately, so I can't dive into those. The closest I've seen are Taiko (by Eiji Yoshikawa) and a biography or two for Tokugawa Ieyasu by A.L Sadler and Stephen Turnbull (I believe), but I'm uncertain how accurate and up-to-date the scholarship of both are in regards to two of these famous figures.

The former seems more like a historical novel, and from what few threads of the past I can find of Turnbull's name here, there seems to be skepticism, though one thread did mention him going back and correcting himself on some things.

Failing that, are there any resources in English that can substitute literature (if there are none)? I'm interested in their daily life and who they were as people rather than just their accomplishments. Virtues and flaws all. Thank you for your time.

1 Answers 2022-12-21

What Did Safety Equipment Look Like for Construction Workers Before the Industrial Revolution?

I'm curious about what kind of protective equipment that builders would wear during the construction of historical megaprojects. For example, how did workers keep themselves from falling off a cathedral mid-construction? Did they wear a rope belt, or did they simply try not to fall? Did they wear any kind of head protection? How did they avoid injuring themselves from, say, stubbing their toes?

1 Answers 2022-12-20

Why did Alfred the Great call himself “King of the Anglo-Saxons”? (and a little more)

Why did Alfred the Great call himself “King of the Anglo-Saxons”? Why did Æthelstan call himself “King of the English” and why did William the Conqueror call himself “King of England”? Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-12-20

JFK famously told the people of Berlin that he was a doughnut and Carter famously told the people of Poland he lusts for them and is never going back. Are there any first hand accounts from members of the crowds on what they thought of these speeches?

1 Answers 2022-12-20

Why are some Balkan countries islamic and some christian?

Notably, Albania, Bosnia and Kosovo are majority muslim regions. As I understand it, this can be explained by the lengthy Ottoman rule during the 14th-20th centuries. But then why did other regions persist in their christianity? Why was it Serbia specifically that broke up into 2 parts with different religious majorities (Kosovo and not-Kosovo)?

2 Answers 2022-12-20

Historicity of Moses?

What is the general academic picture on the historicity of Moses? Not necessarily the Exodus, mind you (although I'd like to hear about that as well), but Moses specifically.

2 Answers 2022-12-20

Did Japan surrender in WW2 because of the atomic bombs or the Soviet Union entering the war?

I see two conflicting arguments on this topic.

One claims that that the Japanese surrendered because of the bombs, as broadcasted by Emperor Hirohito.

The other claims that Japanese scientists hypothesized that America only had 1 or 2 more bombs and the leaders decided they would be fine only losing a couple more cities. They really surrender because of the Soviet Union but only said the atomic bombs because it was less embarrassing.

1 Answers 2022-12-20

With all the digging done in WW1, was any important archeological artefacts found ? If yes, what did they do with them ? I suppose it would be hard to preserve them due to the war.

1 Answers 2022-12-20

Would a peasant's life in 1000 A.D. be any different than in the year 1300? Would technological advancements have made any meaningful difference to the life of a common peasant? Would a peasant's living standards have been significantly better in 1300?

1 Answers 2022-12-20

12 / 7255

Back to start