The Roman Empire invaded, enslaved, and pillaged other nations. One of the cited causes for the fall of the Roman Empire is barbarian invasion. Could barbarians have just been nations justly retaliating / defending themselves, and the Romans wrote them in their history as the villains?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Why were jews banished and hated through european history?

What made people dislike or even hate jews? Did jews commit unmoral or questionable deeds in these societies?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

I've seen paintings in history books of monks writing books BY HAND during the Dark Ages - what did the monks do if they made a mistake? Pictures I've been able to find make these hand-written tomes look perfect. Did they have some version of whiteout, or were they just really careful?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

With Christianity consisting of less than 5% of Taiwan's population, why did Christianity never make a strong foothold in Taiwan despite the fact that many of its leaders (both before and after the retreat of the ROC to Taiwan), such as Sun Yat-sen, Chiang Kai-shek, and Lee Teng-hui, were Christian?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

How did Christopher Columbus convince his crew to keep going? Weren't his crew afraid that they would die, and even wanted to kill Columbus?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Why weren't the part of Egypt which were greek separated from the Arabic parts and then when independence happened, the greek part given to Greece?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

How did Alexander the Great manage to pacify&secure conquered territory so fast?

It puzzles me that Alexander managed to move so fast from one recently conquered territory to the next target.

How did he have the courage of leaving his back exposed as he advanced, his escape route?

Yes he left garrisons here and there, he appointed viceroys sometimes from among the local population but that doesn't explain it.

Romans had trouble securing their back anytime they had an incursion in new territory, take Gaul and Britannia as examples or even Trajan's conquest in Mesopotamia. Heck, they tried to pacify some regions for decades and barely managed.

So how did he do it?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

Are there any records of other non-European perspectives on the Native Americans?

We all know about how the Europeans reacted to the discovery of the Americas quite a bit. But say, how did the Muslims in the Ottoman Empire or the Ancient Chinese view the Native Americans. I'm pretty sure that if Europeans could ship Africans to the New World, it could also happen vice-versa.

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Why is Denmark culturally Scandinavian?

There's a sea separating them and the rest of Scandinavia, but they're connected to Germany by land. Why are they Scandinavian and relatively not very German?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

Why must we censor and remove each comment just because a moderator deems it "not comprehensive" or sufficient?

Why is that we feel the need to erase each comment and stifle conversation completely? Often times there could be good discussion happening between normal people in the comments about historical topics, whether they're a historian or just a casual history fan. Isn't that a good thing? We can still have comprehensive responses that answer the question and upvote them to the top. But censoring and deleting every normal history fan's comments just turns people off from this sub. Half the time an answer never arises to a good question because the simple answers are deleted and a historian never gets around to responding to the question. I am sure there are others here that would agree with me. We should encourage discussion not censorship.

4 Answers 2020-07-14

Immediately after huge battles (such as D-day), were soldiers given any time to rest?

Given the extreme intensity of certain battles, such as the Normandy Landings, were soldiers given time to rest/take stock before going back into action?

I guess my question is based around the welfare of the troops who had just survived an unbelievable battle and if they were straight back into action or not. Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Since Columbus wasn’t the first European to discover America (i.e., the Vikings), why did his arrival kill so many Native Americans with diseases like Small Pox? Was this the same with the Vikings who came before him?

I know that because Native Americans were unexposed to small pox many of them died of the epidemic which came about from Columbus’ arrival in America. However, since Columbus wasn’t the first European to discover America, and the Vikings arrived hundreds of years before him (albeit in different locations), why wasn’t there some level of inoculation for Native populations against diseases like Small Pox? Were there massive deaths from disease amongst the Native populations who met the Vikings as well?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

Were European medieval hygiene habits and beliefs really as terrible as we’ve been commonly led to believe, or were they, at least in some cases, better than most would think?

One of the most common misconceptions we learn in elementary school is that medieval plate armour was very cumbersome and inflexible. A great many modern experiments, such as those which can be commonly seen on YouTube, show that this is absolutely not the case. This got me wondering — what about hygiene? Was medieval hygiene really as abysmal as we’ve been commonly led to believe? Or was it actually better in some cases, or even fairly so overall?

4 Answers 2020-07-14

[AMA] Hamilton: The Musical - Answering your questions on the musical and life during the Revolutionary Age

Hamilton: The Musical is one of the most watched, discussed, and debated historical works in American pop culture at the moment. This musical was nominated for sixteen Tony awards and won 11 in 2016 and the recording, released on Disney+ on July 4th, 2020 currently has a 99% critical and 93% audience review scores on Rotten Tomatoes.

The musical has brought attention back to the American Revolution and the early Republic in exciting ways. Because of this, many folks have been asking a ton of questions about Hamilton, since July 3rd, and some of us here at r/Askhistorians are 'not going to miss our shot' at answering them.

Here today are:

/u/uncovered-history - I am an adjunct professor at Towson University in Baltimore, Maryland. Today, I'm ready to answer questions related to several Founders (Washington and Hamilton in particular), but also any general questions related to religion and slavery during this period. I will be around from 10 - 12 and 1 - 3:30 EST.

/u/dhowlett1692 - I'm a PhD student working on race, gender, and disability in seventeenth and eighteenth century America. I'm also a Digital History Fellow at the Roy Rosenzweig Center for History and New Media. I can field a bunch of the social and cultural ones, focused on race, gender, and disabilit as well as historiography questions.

/u/aquatermain - I can answer questions regarding Hamilton's participation in foreign relations, and his influence in the development of isolationist and nationalistic ideals in the making of US foreign policy.

/u/EdHistory101 - I'll be available from 8 AM to 5 PM or so EST and am happy to answer questions related to "Why didn't I learn about X in school?"

/u/Georgy_K_Zhukov's focus on the period relates to the nature of honor and dueling, and can speak to the Burr-Hamilton encounter, the numerous other affairs of honor in which them men were involved, as well as the broader context which drove such behavior in the period.

We will be answering questions from 10am EST throughout the day.

Update: wow! There’s an incredible amount of questions being asked! Please be patient as we try and get to them! Personally I’ll be returning around 8pm EST to try and answer as many more questions that I can. Thank you for your enthusiasm and patience!

Update 2: Thank you guys again for all your questions! We are sort of overloaded with questions at the moment and couldn't answer all of them. I will try and answer a few more tomorrow! Thanks again for all your support

104 Answers 2020-07-14

A central conceit of the film Master & Commander is the disguising of HMS Surprise as a whaler. Could a 6th Rate Ship of the Line really be made to look like anything other than what it is?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

The US and UK seemingly went into WWII with a large inventory of older destroyers suited for convoy work. Why, then, were escorts in such short supply 1939-1942?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

How cheap is lorica segmentata, what kind of iron they made out from, and how widely avaible they are?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Japanese aircraft carriers WW2

Is it true that the US pilots aimed for the rising sun on the deck of the japanese carriers or is this just a popular myth ?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

The Byzantine Empire is filled with stories of usurpation, lack of legitimacy and frequent civil war. Was this a Roman/Byzantine characteristic? is this trait shared by other Western medieval Kingdons? Are conflicts like these also frequent in islamic nations during the same period?

Thank you in advance for any answers you can provide and thank you for this community as a whole!

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Looking for recommendations of a good biography of Anne Boleyn?

Looking for something pretty in depth as I have read quite a few books that cover her story just not from her point of view. I am hoping to find something somewhat neutral. So preferably not something that either demonizes or hero worships her. I am aware that no biography could be totally neutral but as close as possible would be good. Thanks in advance for all suggestions.

1 Answers 2020-07-14

How did the USA remain a popular destination for immigration even during and in the immediate aftermath of the American Civil War?

According to an estimate by John Huddleston in 2002, the American Civil War claimed the lives of 10 percent of all Northern men 20–45 years old, and 30 percent of all Southern white men aged 18–40.

However, despite this:

  • There didn't seem to be a mass exodus of refugees fleeing the USA to escape the civil war.
  • 70% of European emigration between 1800-1960 went to the USA. Instead of the country being viewed as a dodgy destination in the aftermath of its civil war, it remained a popular destination for immigration, with the number of immigrants in 1870 being even higher than in 1860. Source.
  • Despite suffering a brutal civil war, the USA not only continued to attract immigrants, it also seemed to manage to attract investment, which bankrolled its recovery and continued ascent.

It seems rational to want to flee a civil war, and avoid entering a country which just had one. What made the USA so attractive for immigrants even during and in the immediate aftermath of its civil war?

2 Answers 2020-07-14

After Japan's defeat at Midway, admiral Tamon Yamaguchi chose to stay behind and go down with the ship. Was this a regular occurence for Japanese officers, and if so, did the loss of capable officers due to honorrable suicides have a significant negative effect on the Japanese war effort?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

TUESDAY TRIVIA: “It can hardly be a coincidence that no language on Earth has ever produced the expression 'as pretty as an airport'" (Douglas Adams)- Talk to us about the HISTORY OF TRANSPORTATION!

Welcome to Tuesday Trivia!

If you are:

this thread is for you ALL!

Come share the cool stuff you love about the past! Please don’t just write a phrase or a sentence—explain the thing, get us interested in it! Include sources especially if you think other people might be interested in them.

AskHistorians requires that answers be supported by published research. We do not allow posts based on personal or relatives' anecdotes. All other rules also apply—no bigotry, current events, and so forth.

For this round, let’s look at: TRANSPORTATION! How did people in your time/place get from Point A to Point B? Were there any cool new transportation methods that were invented, and if so did they work? Answer one of these or come up with something else of your own!

Next time: FRIENDSHIP!

6 Answers 2020-07-14

How did Europeans in the middle ages solve private international disputes?

Dear Historians.

Picture Europe in the Middle Ages. An international market takes place with local merchants and international buyers from all over the world. A disagreement arises between seller and buyer.

What is the dispute resolution system? Who solves/judges the issue?

I would think it would be something speedy - the buyer has to return home and going through the national jurisdiction would take time...

I've been trying to research early arbitration systems but not finding much. Would appreciate any leads for further reading!

Many thanks!

1 Answers 2020-07-14

Poking out people's eyes to cripple their economy?

I read this a while back and my memory on it is incredibly fuzzy so I apologize that there's not much to go off of. I remember reading that, during the middle ages, some nation in Eastern Europe went to war with a different nation and as a form of punishing that nation and to hurt them economically, they poked out people's eyes with a hot iron. Does anyone know what war this was? How common were such practices? Were they effective?

1 Answers 2020-07-14

1214 / 7255

Back to start