Calling All Historians!

I need book recommendations. Preferably books that are about American history, but I’m open to any you think is worth the read.

1 Answers 2020-06-10

On which criteria were the electors in the Holy Roman Empire chosen ?

It's a question that I always thought about. I can understand for Mayence, Trier and Cologne, being archbishoprics their position as electors is justifiable, Bohemia for its importance in the Empire, but for example, why Brandenburg or the Palatinate ? Why such insignificant nations in the greater Empire were chosen ? I think I read somewhere that it was linked to their position before the Golden Bull, but still, why were those specific nations chosen to elect the Emperor ?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

When did riverside baptisms become a thing, and why?

I finally saw the video that goes with Alison Krauss' song Down In the River to Pray (this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSif77IVQdY), and was struck by the historical pictures of the riverside baptisms. When and how did riverside baptisms, as opposed to in-church, with holy water in a font, get started? Is this just an American (Southern?) habit? Just a specific denomination?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

How were the police formed?

I recently started a documentary called plutocracy and it’s alluding to early police being formed to stop unions from being formed. Is there any truth to this?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Is there a Hitler documentary that includes reactions/perspectives of German Civilians, German soldiers, and Jews?

I just watched “Hitler - A Career” on Netflix. If I wasn’t already aware of the Holocaust, I would have little knowledge of concentration camps from this doc alone. It focused on Hitler’s rise and fall with little mention of Jews/camps.

Is there a documentary that talks about the experience of German civilians and soldiers? I imagine many were against the concentration camps. Aside from “brainwashing” soldiers from a very young age, how were the people of Germany convinced to stay on board? I would love to watch a documentary that dives into this.

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Charles' Autopsy

The physician in the autopsy of Charles II gave some very... colorful (if not medically impossible) descriptions like "heart the size of a peppercorn" and "did not contain a single drop of blood." What was going on in these autopsies?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

NASA's plan in the event of Apollo 11 being stranded on the moon was to end all communications with the astronauts. Do we know whether they planned to tell them anything prior to that, or just cut off communication all of a sudden?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

In many Fantasy Novels and Dungeons and Dragons, Taverns/Inns are commonplace. Was there ever a time when the stereotypical "Inn" or "Tavern" actually existed?

In almost every Fantasy novel there is the stereotypical Inn/Tavern. This is usually a barroom with rooms attached, serving food and drinks. Considering most fantasy novels are framed in the Middle Ages, did this exist then or anytime similar or is their existence exaggerated by fantasy novels?

Bonus Question: Did traveling bards actually exist? And how prevalent were bandits in the Middle Ages?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

What did the average Soviet citizen know of the American civil rights movement?

The USSR produced propaganda like this and this about the plight Black people faced in the States, but what did the regular USSR citizen know about the civil rights movement? If I went back to 1970 in the streets of Moscow and asked a person if they knew who MLK, Malcom X, Rosa Parks, or Emmit Till were would they know?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

I saw a documentary that stated that the Hittites fell because of A) civil war and B) Sea Peoples. One documentary said 1) "these are not the same Hittites mentioned in the Bible" while the other said 2) "they are mentioned briefly in the Bible". Which set of facts is correct?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Why did WW1 naval encounters result in often all hands lost, or a very large majority with very very few survivors?

Specifically at the battle of Jutland, ships that were sunk often had all but a few hands lost. But it seems to be a common trend in many WW1 naval engagements. In WW2 survival seemed much more common. What specifically about WW1 naval engagements lead to such a higher hands lost rate?

2 Answers 2020-06-10

Did the democrats and republicans really "switch sides?" If so in what sense?

I hope this doesn't break any of the rules. I know it may skirt the line on the no <20 year rule(since it does have to do with two alive political parties), but I think that it (hopefully) falls in the past enough for it to be non-current-political. If not mods please let me know and I will delete or edit the question to fit back into the rules.

It is a common assertion that at some point after the civil war, the parties "switched." From what I can tell they take it to mean the ideological positions of the democrats became that of the republicans and vice versa. However whenever I ask someone who asserts this (usually to claim that Lincoln was somehow "really" a democrat) I never get a clear answer on what exactly switched about the parties.

For example, the democrats circa civil war were pro-slavery, and now they (at least in rhetoric) stand up against racism. But that doesn't mean that the Republicans became totally pro-slavery (took on the democrats position); I personally don't consider the average modern-day republican racist. Likewise, from my understanding, the original democrats were proponents of small government, and the original republicans were classical liberal, which also tends to favor markets over governments. Of course both sides tend to take a large bureaucratic state as a given.

It seems to me more like there was an evolution of ideas so that both parties occupied ideological positions that were different than the one that they had before, but also different than what their counterpart had before. It would seem strange to me that so many people would change their party to the opposite rather than just join the other party. So is there any truth to the switching sides argument, or is it just an urban legend?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Maryland is the home of rye whiskey in the United States, and was long famous for producing among the most-loved spirits in the country. However, it is only now that producers are re-discovering Maryland rye, and it isn't anywhere near it's level of national prominence. What happened?

I imagine the short answer to this question is simple: Prohibition. It killed off so many producers. However, I'm curious how and why other whiskey-producing areas - notably, Kentucky bourbon - managed to survive when Maryland did not. Maryland rye seemed to completely disappear from production as a whole category of spirit. We don't even know what kind of recipes and blends the early producers of rye in Maryland used, only that we see it written about as a prized substance.

Any help, food historians?

2 Answers 2020-06-10

Why isn’t the French Revolution called the French Civil War?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Is there any correlation between the secret Austro-Serbian alliance(1881),which made Serbia like a Austrian vassal, and the assassination of Franz Ferdinand(1914)? I mean they both happened on the exact same day, June 28th

As the title suggests... If there is by any chance any correlation it would be a huge NO U moment from the Serbs. But my hopes are low... Thanks in advance for any answers!!

1 Answers 2020-06-10

In the film "Gangs of New York", there's a scene where several newly migrated Irishmen are being conscripted into the Union army immediately upon their arrival to the ports of New York. Is this a realistic depiction of what happened? Are there any recorded instances of this or similar events?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

What were the protests like at the start of the French Revolution? What were the protests about?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

What would the culture of chess be line in 18-19th century Scotland? What would be considered 'risky play"?

Chess is such an ancient game, I'm really curious to know if it might have a different culture, or if there was a general "European" etiquette of Chess.

I only know a little bit, but from reading it looks like there's a bunch of risky, almost gambly moves. Like a risky open, or stuff like that. But a lot of what I read tends to talk about the Cold War. What about chess earlier in the mid 1700's?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

Why did it take until the 1900's before flying was invented, when the kite was invented in the 5th century?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

How did portugal get so backward by the start of the 20th century and why did they almost completely stagnate before the 1930s?

Portugal was one of the richest country on earth in the 15th and 16th century. I know that the 1755 earthquake was a big reason Portugal went that way, but, I find it hard to believe its the only reason.

By 1913, GDP per capita (from Maddison) was $1,250 which was lower than even Russia’s at $1,488. Literacy Rate was also around 20-25%.

1 Answers 2020-06-10

After the Panama canal was made, why didn't Panama become an economic crossroads powerhouse?

Not sure if that question makes sense. But considering all the traffic that flows through the Panama canal why hasn't this become the crossroads of the world? It seems like they would be able to capitalize on manufacturing & tansit ships like Istanbul/Constantinople.

Or am I blind?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

We use MM (1,000 1,000s) to denote millions now. Did the people of the Roman Empire have a concept of millions, and, if so, did they use this convention as well?

I am curious because it is so common to see millions now, especially notional figures, but I doubt there would have been a need for such large denominations in the time of the Roman Empire—especially given that, though they traded with currency, it would be highly impractical to have a million physical anything sitting around.

1 Answers 2020-06-10

How well does the film "Gone with the Wind" represent the Antebellum South, and how is its representation connected to contemporary views of that era?

[Gone with the Wind](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gone_with_the_Wind_(film)) is a celebrated 1939 film (based on a 1936 novel) set in 1861 in the American South, which is in the news today for a controversy about its depiction of that era. When the story was written, its setting was almost as far in the past as the film's premiere is for us today.

So how accurately and fairly does this work of fiction depict its historical setting? How was that depiction of the 1860s influenced by popular views in the 1930s, and did the film in turn contribute to popular views of the antebellum period and the American Civil War?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

What would Herodotus' writing process have looked like?

With the Histories being so lengthy, there mustve been volumes of scratch paper and notes he took while interviewing people.

These days journalists have tape and digital recorders and plentiful cheap paper, but with paper being such a luxury back then, how would Herodotus and other authors of the Classical era go about drafting, brainstorming, compiling, editing etc before putting out a finished work?

1 Answers 2020-06-10

NFLD Royal Naval Reserve: Rank & Insignia Identification

This is an old photo of my grandfather (and also here). He retired as a commander in the Royal Navy, and settled in Newfoundland, Canada. I never met him, he died before I was born.
Question to those familiar with naval uniforms: what kind of uniform is this? What rank? What is the significance of the shoulder epaulets & sleeve decorations? (I have no idea where the sword comes from, or what it represents). Thanks for any and all help.

1 Answers 2020-06-10

1281 / 7255

Back to start