What was the Cambodian Genocide, and why do you guys think is it not that well known in western culture?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

The Great Depression & Latin America

How did the Great Depression affect Latin America?

2 Answers 2020-05-24

In WW2, why weren’t aircraft carrier(s) assigned to the North Atlantic for convoy protection,especially the Mid-Atlantic, especially areas beyond range and protection of land base anti-submarine aircraft? It seems as though carrier escorts could have neutralized the U-boat threat.

2 Answers 2020-05-24

How would peasant or surf in the late medieval/early modern period turn himself into an emerging bourgeoisie?

In the book: The technology trap capital, labour and power in the age of automation by Carl Benedikt Frey he states that a couple of economic historians estimate 28% of the labour force in the 17th century were 'merchants or artisans' as well as a general 'growing middle class' I'm interested in the way this actually happened, for example, how did an individual peasant go from working on a lords farm to owning his own small business? and how we're so many able to do it?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

In Pride and Prejudice, Mr. Darcy has an income of 10,000 pounds a year. How might such a gentleman generate such a large and steady income from his holdings without working, year after year?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Why did the Red Army continue to suffer disproportionately high casualties even when the tide of the war turned decisively in their favor?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Why is H.H. Holmes considered the first serial killer?

From my limited knowledge about him, he seems to lack a few “distinguishing traits” associated with serial killers. He feels more like a criminal of oppertunity/a con-man? Is that accurate?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Two of the Kassite Babylonian rulers held the name "Nazi", Nazi-Maruttash and Nazi-Bugaš. What did the name Nazi mean to the Kassite Babylonians?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

In strategy games like Rome Total War, I can instruct my units where to go by dragging them around on the tactical map and have many more orders ready to be given out at the click of a button. But how were orders like these given out back in the day before radio was invented?

I'm aware of the use of homing pigeons during WWI, I'm mostly wondering about further back in history, like during "Roman times" or during the Napoleonic wars.

1 Answers 2020-05-24

A NSFW question for Roman historians

Does anyone have any examples of and info on the subject of the romans Crucifying entire families? Thank you

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Did Amazons, or a society close too, ever exist?

I’ve read “Amazons” were strictly Greek myth and if so I apologize. But did any strictly warrior women, or tribes run/governed by mostly women ever exist, anywhere?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Part of the reason Henry VIII tried so hard to get a male heir was because he thought his daughters might not be accepted as queen. When Edward VI died, was there any faction pushing to skip the women in favor of a male relative? If not, why were the women more accepted than Henry thought?

The only prior precedent for a queen regnant was Henry I's attempt to get his daughter Matilda recognized as queen and it led to a devastating civil war.

1 Answers 2020-05-24

A Civil War mystery...

Hi historians! I am doing genealogical research on my 3rd Great-Grandfather, Levi Rothschild.

Levi immigrated to the US from the Landgraviate or Hesse-Kassel in 1851, arriving in NYC at age 23. 11 years later, he was enrolled in the NY 103rd Infantry (the Sew-ard Infantry), Company F “German Rifles.” He enlisted as a private on April 21st, 1862. His regiments joined with the Dept. of North Carolina, who by the time he deployed would have already failed at their attempt to destroy the Dismal Swamp Canal.

Here’s where it gets strange. The unit would have seen quite a bit of action by the time he arrived in VA/NC. They likely saw action in many skirmishes and engagements thereafter, but I am novice at navigating the records and timeline.

There’s a gap, and then, a twist. Levi’s muster roll that he died by suicide at Newport News, VA in July of 1862. This seems odd, and I will elucidate as to why.

  1. There is a note in the “notes section” of the muster roll from June (before his declared death) that reads: “June 20/62: Levi Rothschild (enlt, p.c. as above) present not p.d. No (latest?) record found.”

  2. Levi resurfaces in NYC soon after, has more children with the same wife, responds to multiple censuses as living in the same apartment with the same address, and has another death date in the early 20th century. I am quite confident that these are not two similar people with the same name.

  3. Levi shows up in 1865 on a draft exemptions list, showing as being exempted that year due to “varicose veins”.

My questions: knowing that 45.000 NY’ers deserted (the most of any union state by far) is that the best assumption? Fake suicide or a cover up of the desertion by officers trying to save face?

What does the note on the muster roll mean?

Any clarity would be hugely appreciated, as well as any info about his unit history. Thank you!!

1 Answers 2020-05-24

What was the ‘official line’ of State Shinto in the Empire of Japan regarding death and the afterlife?

Was the rhetoric about becoming a Kami believed by most people?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Is it true that Roman Emperors weren't necessarily as ripped as perceived on the various sculptures and statues ?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Yale University has made available on YouTube a 22-lesson course on the Early Middle Ages by professor Paul Freedman. Is it a good resource for those interested in learning the current academic consensus on subjects such as the fall of the Roman Empire?

Or does it stray from the consensus in ways that are outdated or controversial, and it's best to avoid it if one doesn't already have some familiarity with the subject?

Of course, I don't expect someone to go comb through 20 hours of classes to give me an answer, but I'm interested to know if someone is familiar with professor Freedman and his work, and how it's viewed by other scholars of the Early Middle Ages.

The full course (from 2011) is available here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZC8JcWVRFp8&list=PL77A337915A76F660

1 Answers 2020-05-24

What did "not working in the High ways" mean in 17th century Maryland?

My ninth great grandfather Cornelius Johnson was fined 50 lbs of tobacco for "not working in the High ways." What does that mean?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

What events lead Japan to enter World War II?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Were any official agents of the American colonies remaining in Britain after the Declaration of Independence? What happened to them?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

I know about the Swahili Coast, Ethiopia, Mali - but why didn't sub-Saharan civilizations leave major literary and architectural works?

Made this question before but didn't have any luck.

I do know there were urban civilizations in the Sahel, West, the Horn and the eastern coast of Africa, but why didn't these leave lots of monuments like temples and fortresses,or writings about religion or even bureaucracy? Again, this is not a veiled provocation, but an honest question.

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Critiques on 'The ancient celts' by barry cunliffe?

I'm looking to buy this book, but can't find any scholarly reviews. Are there things I need to be aware of before reading this book? What are it's shortcomings/strengths?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Duke of Suffolk?

Hi, I’m new to this sub so please excuse me if I inadvertently break any rules.

I’m interested in history, especially the Plantagenet and Tudor eras, and I’m confused that there are three men described as “The 1st Duke of Suffolk”

William de la Pole 1396-1450 Charles Brandon 1484-1545 Henry Grey 1517-1554

Please can a historian explain how this can be so, as I would have expected that Charles Brandon would have been the 2nd Duke, and Henry Grey the 3rd Duke. Why are they all described as the 1st Duke?

Hopefully somebody can help me figure this out.

1 Answers 2020-05-24

One of the more lurid tales of WW2 is that the Soviet Union opened the Tomb of Timur and found an inscription promising disaster to those who disturbed the tomb, with Operation Barbarossa starting three days later, who much of this can be verified?

It probably goes without saying that opening the tomb didn't actually activate a Mummy's curse that prompted Nazi Germany to invade the Soviet Union, but the little details are often repeated for the purposes of sensationalism, particularly the idea that the archaeologists opened the tomb just days before the invasion began, that the local people warned them against messing with such things for fear of superstitions like this, that when they opened the tomb they found an inscription stating

“When I rise from the dead, the world shall tremble”
“Whosoever disturbs my tomb will unleash an invader more terrible than I am”

and that the archeologists decided to close the tomb back up and return the remains with full honors buried in Islamic tradition just before the Battle of Stalingrad decisely turned against the Germans. Can any of this stuff be verified at all, such as the supposed curse written on the grave or the Soviets returning the remains just in time for a major victory?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | May 18, 2020–May 24, 2020

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2020-05-24

A common thing in fps games nowadays is to fantasize about a third world war. In the 19th century(or early 20th) did people fantasize about a worldwide war? If so, how did they imagine it?

1 Answers 2020-05-24

1315 / 7255

Back to start