Why were entertainers looked down on in Ancient Rome?

From what I understand one of the big ways in which Nero shocked proper Roman society was by personally performing on stage, which I'm told was treated with about as much respect as prostitution.

But everyone likes music and to be entertained, and in the days before TV and recordings I would have thought entertainers would be MORE treasured than today. Why did Romans looks down their noses at musicians and actors?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

How did Japan come to dominate the video game industry in the 90s?

They had the Gameboy (in 1989), SNES, Sega Genesis (in 1989) and Playstation as well as iconic games/characters like Sonic the Hedgehog, Mario Bros, Legend of Zelda and Pokemon. How did Japan achieve this ?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

What did Socrates do for a living? Seriously.

I know - he was a philosopher, fine. But, how did he buy food? Or pay for anything? Was he paid to be a philosopher? If so, by whom? Same goes for other philosophers - was it a full-time job or did they have something on the side?

2 Answers 2020-03-13

Why was Mussolini so hated? What are the bad things that came from him directly or indirectly?

I saw a post from Jim Carrey making fun of the death of Mussolini, it seemed awful at first but then I realized that a lot of people hate him and that I don't know anything about him, so there must be a bunch of things I'm guessing.

1 Answers 2020-03-13

BETA Test: AskHistorians Weekly Round-Up and Newsletter | 2020-03-13

Hello /r/AskHistorians!

We are pleased to be testing out the Mass Mailer feature for a new /r/AskHistorians Weekly Round-Up. This is a new Beta feature that the site Admins have been kind enough to allow us to be involved in the testing of. This being the third test, we really want to hear your feedback on what you would like to see this feature look like in the future. Not everyone got the mailer, as it is an A/B test, but we welcome feedback from everyone!

We have a brief survey which you can find here that we would greatly appreciate participation on, and also please consider weighing in here in the thread to offer your feedback and discuss things further! If you really don't want to receive this though, there is an option to opt-out, while remaining subscribed to the subreddit, at the bottom of the message you received.

Either go to the profile of /u/ModMessages and click 'Block' OR simply click 'Block User' at the bottom of the message to use one less click

A Recap of AskHistorians 2020-03-06 to 2020-03-12

Popular This Week: You might have clicked too early, so here are the responses to some of the most upvoted questions from the past week:

Things You Probably Missed: Great stuff flies under the radar every week! Here is a selection of responses the Mod Team enjoyed, but didn't get the attention they deserved:

Features You Might Have Missed:

Features Coming Up:

  • 2020-03-15: "Rules Roundtable III: No Example Seeking or Poll-Type Questions"

Plenty more you might have missed though, so as always, don't forget to check out the most recent Sunday Digest or else to follow us on Twitter!

Again, this is a new feature that we are only just starting to test out. How it is tweaked and changed depends on what we hear back from you. We want to know how this feature can better serve our readership. Please participate in the survey, or this thread, to share your thoughts!

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Why did England yo-yo viciously between Catholicism and Protestantism, whereas most other countries seemed to settle on one or the other?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

How old is cardamom farming in Guatemala, and how did it come to the country?

I don't believe it is a native crop to Guatemala, but now around 60% of global production is from that country, and cardamom production is a big income earner for Guatemala.

So who is responsible for bringing it to the country? And when did it happen? Was it a purposeful attempt at growing a "cash crop", or was it a happy accident?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Where did this stereotype of the French Foreign Legion come from?

When I was growing up, the stereotype of the French Foreign Legion we always heard about was that a man would get rejected by a woman and then be so hurt and upset that he would run off to France to join the Foreign Legion there. I've duckduckgoed this, but am not finding information about it. I have found information about the Legion accepting people who have been misfits or refugees and want to start a new life, but I'm not finding anything at all about the stereotype of joining due to heartache. It seemed to come up a lot in Looney Tunes cartoons.

Does anyone know if there was a source of this stereotype?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

What happened to laws already in existence when the USA constitution went into effect?

Did new laws have to be written to replace existing laws, or did those remain in place untouched? Was there some limbo where no laws existed? And what happened to any British laws?

2 Answers 2020-03-13

Can we judge the Ottomans by “modern standards”

We often hear about judging western historical figures, usually American founding fathers, by “modern standards” and the general consensus seems to be that we should, as the people they conquered and enslaved did not wish to be conquered and enslaved. But does that apply to non western peoples like the Ottoman Empire. Yes they were tolerant compared to the dismal standards of Europe, especially their arch rival Hapsburg Spain, but at the same time their armies massacred entire cities, conscripted young boys into their service, forced women from conquered people’s to become sex slaves, and the Sultans regularly murder their infant brothers upon accession. Again I don’t want to indulge in “terrible Turk” propaganda. They were doing all this at around the same time their rivals were preforming such atrocities as the Atlantic slave trade or wiping various native cultures off the map. But the question still stands, should we still glorify the Ottomans, or should we heap the same scorn upon them that “problematic” western historical figures like Thomas Jefferson revive, or is there a way in between. Sorry if I ramble or if I got too political.

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Were ships from ~1400 to ~1800 self suficient?

Im thinking colonizers and war ships from the napoleonic wars. Who where at sea for months at a time. Boilimg sea water to making it drinkable and fishing enough? Did they do this? Colud they have survived indefeidley(asuming they dont get sick nor go crazy) if needed? Were they reliant on shore? I know thet stacked food and wine and what not, but meaby the purpose of that was to make de journey plesant.

1 Answers 2020-03-13

We’re there conspiracies about the Spanish Flu being a hoax?

I’m seeing a lot of conspiracy theorists saying that COVID-19 is a liberal/media hoax. Were there similar theories during the Spanish Flu epidemic, especially since there was a war going on at the time?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Were pirates so violent as we imagine?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Friday Free-for-All | March 13, 2020

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

6 Answers 2020-03-13

Did non White soliders in WW1 fight in predomily white regiments or within regiments created for non Whites?

Brtish actor Lawrence Fox has been crizcized for saying that Sikhs fought in regiments created just for them rather than predomily White regimnets [like nowadays] how correct is he did they fight in thier own regiments or not? And if they didn't fight in thier own regiments did they cluster or were they singukar in a prodomily white regiment ie a few together in a predomily white regiment? And were they treated was there racism agianst them or were considered eqaul?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Did the Roman Gods have bodies?

I once read that the roman gods, before being influenced by the Greeks, didn't have any spiritualy physical bodies, but were Numina, a shapeless spiritual manifestation. Is this true? To what extent?

I remember candidly that the website I read this on didn't have any citations, but I'll try to find it later to see if I'm mistaken.

1 Answers 2020-03-13

The 'Old Guard' of Napoleon, what underlying causes led to their creation? "Elites" didn't seem to be a major military idea at the time and Napoleon rose from the artillery, where did the idea to create the imperial guard come from?

While "elites" did exist, from the grenadiers in the left of the Line to named and favored regiments like pavlosk grenadiers or Scots Grey's, these seemed tied to being created as an extension of the societal elite "propping up" their own regiments. Some also earned their distinction in combat.

So what was the underlying causes for Napoleonic France to create an elite Force and increase it to such an extent the imperial guard was? Especially as the French state under the revolution lacked the societal elite that would say in England constitute the household guard.

And especially as in My assumption there isn't a big doctrinal precident for it.

And thirdly how it was justified as it drew resources and even ire from the regular army?

Was it Napoleons pet project?

A structural need?

A happenstance?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

At its height, was Ancient Egypt as dry as it's usually represented today?

By that I mean, in movies Ancient Egypt comes across as a dry land full of sand which doesn't make it a good place to develop an agriculture that could support its population. Unless the Nile river produced enough food for the population?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Sports in Stalins USSR

Hello everyone, I'm doing research on sports in the soviet union. My research questions are as follows:

(Under Stalins regime)

- How did the government of the USSR use sports in its policies?
- How did people apply to participate in sports (voluntarily or mandatory)
- Why did or didn't the USSR participate in international sports competitions?

Now I've done research on Stalin before and what I did last time is read actual stuff he wrote on the subject i did research on. I thought it was really interesting to read his work and am wondering if he wrote anything related to sports. If not maybe you know any good articles that can help me on my way.

Thank you for your time

1 Answers 2020-03-13

During The American Civil War, The Confederacy Issued Banknotes - But How Did Southern Banks Operate During The Conflict?

One of those shower thoughts questions - how did banks in the South handle the transition to the Confederacy, the introduction of greybacks, etc.?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

In 1938 Stalin proposed G.M. Malenkov as the Head of the NKVD, however "a majority of the Politburo recommended L.P. Beria for the post"(Getty, Manning). Does this event indicate that Stalin was actually not in control of the party?

https://books.google.com/books?id=NWYvGYcxCjYC&q=Stalin+proposed+the#v=snippet&q=Stalin%20proposed%20the&f=false

(page 38)

1 Answers 2020-03-13

Russian colonization of Asia

When Russia started conquering and settling to the east of the Ural mountains and out of Europe into Asia all the way to the Pacific ocean, was it a state project accomplished by the tzar's army, or a private company project accomplished with contractors? Were the settlers peasants relocated there, or volunteers working for work/land? Was the area largely empty of permanent cities, or was it full of khanates and sultanates that were defeated and conquered?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

How did nations become significantly more technologically advanced than their rivals?

Was it lucky inventions? Was it mass investment and easing up acess to education? Was it huge government spending on research?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

In high and late medieval Europe, German & Yiddish-speaking Jews had very high rates of literacy. However, was this isolated to Hebrew literature or could most Jewish people also read the Latin alphabet?

It's 1300. A German-speaking Jewish man is shown a phonically similar sentence rendered in Yiddish with Hebrew characters, and in German with Latin characters. Can we reasonably expect him to comprehend both?

1 Answers 2020-03-13

did the medieval Christian world perceive the Crusades as a set of linked conflicts? Did the Muslim world?

This is more of a historiographical question, but a few things I've come across lately, plus some old thoughts, have got me curious. Firstly, I was looking up the developing etymology of the word crusade, which seems to evolve after the modern idea of crusades has already begun, following initial language that talks about it as 'pilgrimage'. Secondly, I've been reading about the historiography of the hundred years war.

A lot has been written about how the 100 years war actually involved long periods of peace that at least appear to me like more than just a ceasefire between battles - peaces that at the time were indefinite to their signatories. The grouping together of a century of phased conflict and peace as one long 116 year war seems then, to me, like a (however well or not justified) clear historiographical choice, made long after the fact.

My question is, is this also true of the crusades? Did a member of the third or fifth crusade consider themselves more as participating in a conflict of their time, unique and produced by the politics of their time, or did they see it as one of a set of distinct (numbered) conflicts separate from 'ordinary' wars? If they do, is the numbering arbitrary? are there arguable apocryphal crusades that don't make our traditional hitlist? Am I overestimating the average person's access to history, or even the average knight's?

I suppose another point of comparison is something like the concept of the reconquista, where messy bitty ultimately venal conflict over hundreds of years involving often questionable religious solidarity on any 'side' is simplified into a holy war narrative for later political or historiographical purposes.

And on the flipside, is there any evidence as to whether the Muslim world classified these conflicts as a distinct category of conflict, tied together?

I realise this is a longish and quite tangled question so even just partial /targeted answers would be really appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-03-13

1466 / 7255

Back to start