Is there any documentation on the historical shift of literature taught in American high schools from the 19th to 21st century?

What books were they teaching in high schools back then rather than 1984 or Of Mice and Men?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

Why did Australia and New Zealand receive enough European immigrants to overwhelm their respective native populations despite their distance from Europe?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

How did European colonists react to the New World's geography?

There are many geographical features of the New World which are almost preposterously extreme when compared to Europe - the Amazon jungle, the Andes and Rockies, the grand canyon, the great lakes, not to mention hurricanes and tornadoes.

To a European settler coming from placid England or France, some of these things must have seemed so out of proportion that they verged on fictional. Do we have any accounts of what people thought when they experienced these places for the first time? They manage to stun us in the 21st century, even with mass-media. They must have been an order of magnitude more surprising 500 years ago.

2 Answers 2020-01-07

How was homosexuality / bisexuality among the nobility viewed in the Safavid Empire?

I'm reading Abbas Amanat's excellent work "Iran: A Modern History", which covers Iranian history from 1501 all the way to the modern era.

Ismail II had a very short reign of 15 months that was characterized by radical shifts in policy. He was found dead in November of 1577 with his lover, "a young man of humble origins, after a night of nocturnal wandering through the taverns in the capital." (Amanat). Supposedly, he died from opium overdose, but assassination was also a strong possibility due to his alienation of the Qizilbash chiefs.

Does this mean that Ismail was homosexual or bisexual? It's not explicitly stated, but it would seem to be strongly implied.

Moreover, how would homosexuality be viewed in this strict religious Shi'a Islam society? I assume it was officially condemned, but would people "look the other way", so to speak, when someone of noble origin was homosexual? Would've this type of thing been the subject of court gossip? Would someone have gone out of their way to keep this "top secret"?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

The Norse people were shown to be capable raiders, especially in the British Isles. The Anglo-Saxons despite divided were socially and militarily organised, why did they, or others, never seek or attempt to attack Scandinavia?

2 Answers 2020-01-07

During the Black Death, was it possible to catch the Bubonic Plague twice? Or did surviving it confer immunity like smallpox?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

How Eurocentric is the word "medieval"?

I was recently in an interesting discussion about the word "medieval" in an acedemic context (I am not an acedemic). I argued that the word "medieval" is inherently eurocentric as defined by both the Cambridge and Merriam Webster definitions and that referring to other parts of the world during the "medieval" period would be contemporary to the period in Europe. But it was pointed out that the Chinese medieval period seems to have slightly different starting and end points but largely overlap. Does academia ever use the term their medieval period in a malleable way like their iron age or is inherently bound to events in the European world?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

How did large armies in ancient times handle food logistics? Did they strictly live off the land, extort food from cities, or even grow food during long sieges?

2 Answers 2020-01-07

How would people in antiquity learn foreign languages?

Modern world offers a thousand options to learn foreign languages, from traditional classrooms to Duolingo and everything in between. Before this how would people learn a foreign language? When two peoples with no previous contact came into contact, how would they learn each other language?

4 Answers 2020-01-07

How did medieval nations supply their soldiers during wartime?

From what I understand for much of history the creation of weapons and armor was considered an art, with one good weapon taking hours to complete, and needing a lengthy apprenticeship of many years to learn the craft. With these requirements how did nation supply their armies with weapons? What about in times of severe emergency when regular old people had to be drafted to serve did those people just have to make do with whatever resembled a weapon that they had access to?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

I recently read the first volume of the Secret Diaries of Anne Lister and have several questions about early 19th century England with a bonus question about Lord Byron's death.

Where I can, I will provide quotes that prompted my questions.

After supper, firing off the pistol, that had been heavily charged above 3 weeks, out of my room window. The report was tremendous. It bounded out of my hand, forced itself thro' the window & broke the lead & 2 panes of glass. My hand felt stunned for some time.

How did people of Ms. Lister's social class learn to shoot? I was under the impression that both men and women learned to hunt and shoot, and that it was something of a social requirement. This quote gives me the impression that she's not well versed in the use of guns, and other quotes imply that she doesn't know how to reload her pistols. Would this level of knowledge be common amongst her peers, or is she disadvantaged due to her gender or general lack of wealth comparitively?

Miss Ann Paley seems a nice enough woman (girl) but lolls her arm over the chair back or sticks her elbow out with her hand akimbo in rather too masculine a manner...

Ms. Lister often calls other women masculine and her favorite descriptor of others seems to be "vulgar". Would others of this time period have seen masculinity in the simple way a woman holds her arms and hands? It seems fairly obvious that Anne was rather judgemental and snooty, was she more snooty than her contemporaries?

Speaking of the Staveleys (Mrs Staveley too), said no talent could make up for such bad manners. Bold, boisterous, & Mrs Staveley slatternly, strangely singular... Met her walking one day in the town with her hands under her petticoat & she pulled out two great muffins.

So this woman pulled two huge muffins out of her petticoats? Is this slang for something? Who would want to eat muffins that had been nestled so closely to a woman's (who Anne describes as "slatternly") nethers? I have to admit, this is absolutely my most pressing series of questions.

Staid luncheon (didn't eat anything)

Lister frequently appears at social gatherings, but does not eat at them. Would this have been perceived as rude or was it expected that women would eat less?

Mr Duffin & I walked to the theater...

Mr Duffin seems to take her out rather frequently. Would this not have been seen as courting behavior, despite the difference in age?

thought of her using a phallus to a friend

How common would dildos have been at this time in her social strata? What would they have been constructed of and how would they be procured?

Game basket from Lawton containing a fine hare...

Were gift baskets frequently exchanged amongst the gentry during this time period? She mentions them frequently.

The Greek account says his lordship [Byron] died 'about 11 o' clock in the evening, in a consequence of a rheumatic, inflammatory fever, which had lasted for ten days.' 37 min. guns (he was in his 37th year of his age) were ordered to be fired, by sunrise, on 20 April, from the batteries of Missolinghi.

Were 37 guns fired, were many guns fired over 37 minutes, and why were the Greeks so enamored with Byron despite his lack of military experience and bisexual proclivities?

Thank you all so much for taking the time to read this.

1 Answers 2020-01-07

Was honey anciently worth its weight in gold?

I'm watching Doomsday Preppers, and a beekeeper claimed that honey was once used as currency—and that it was worth its weight in gold.

I've found a couple ancient examples of honey used as a currency, but no indication as to the worth of that honey.

How would I go about finding the worth of honey and gold by weight in an ancient civilization?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

Was there a “cult of personality” around Tito in Yugoslavia as their was among Stalin and his “Little Stalins” in the various other Iron Curtain countries?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

How did people historically stay assured in magic and mythology, which we now know today to be entirely false superstitions?

1 Answers 2020-01-07

Were there any pirates involved in the American revolution?

Something I just started wondering about was there any pirates involved in the American revolution?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

My Grandma is Watching a World War II Movie About a B-17 Escaping From the Japanese Invasion of the Philippines at the Beginning of the War. Were There Any B-17s posted in the Philippines in 1941?

2 Answers 2020-01-06

What was going to happen to Hitler if he didn’t shoot himself?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

I am an American artilleryman in WW2 in France. After the battle, I am nearly totally deaf. What is done with me? Do I have access to hearing protection?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

Offensive tactics in Renaissance sieges

I’ve started reading some posts here on siege warfare during the renaissance, but haven’t been able to find much information on how the attackers deployed their troops, so here’s what I’m wondering:

  • Would soldiers scale walls?

  • If yes, would they use siege towers, ladders or something else?

  • How would pike formations be employed by the attackers?

  • Were there any infantry formations that fared better than pike-squares?

  • Would infantry storm breeches?

  • Were there different tactics from what I’ve mentioned in getting your infantry to the enemy?

  • How would arquebusiers / musketeers be employed by the attackers?

  • Did cavalry ever contribute in these battles - if so, how?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

A little help

I am writing a story for school/enjoyment and am trying to be accurate. What kind of swords would be more available to lower class in medieval times?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

Shaving as a concept of feminine ‘requirement’

Where did the concept of women being expected by society to shave their legs and even more intimate areas? Is it a modern phenomenon or one that traces back further than the 20th century? When did it become the norm in British, or Western, society?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2020-01-06

Did antisemitism and/or bigotry change in Germany and Poland after WWII?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

The Ilkhanate was ruled for some time by Khans who followed Buddhism, a religion with little following in their territory. Was this identification just to retain the favour of the Yuan Dynasty or were there other positive incentives?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

Which demonology and witch persecution texts from early modern Europe are considered culturally significant by scholars?

Before posting, I searched this sub for "demonology" and "witch hunt" and I also checked the Popular Questions wiki on witchcraft. I think I'm in the clear. I did give a best effort to not waste anyone's time, at any rate! I also acknowledge that "culturally significant" might be a clumsy way to put what I'm asking, and that's because I'm not sure how to phrase what I'm asking. I think that I'm looking for academically reputable texts from the time period. I'm guessing there are some duds, and not being a historian myself, I don't know enough to identify them.

I'm hoping this could help curate my own collection. Ever since I signed out Rossell Hope Robbins' Encyclopedia of Witchcraft and Demonology from my high school library in the early 90s, I've held a sustained interest in the topic and I've accumulated these books along the way. Unfortunately I'm limited to works that have been written in or translated to English, otherwise they'd just be shelf decoration:

  • 1487 - Malleus Maleficarum (Hammer of Witches) by Heinrich Kramer, translated to English by Montague Summers, published 1971 by Dover copying John Rodker's 1928 printing, rebound to hardcover by Peter Smith

  • 1563 - De praestigiis daemonum (On the Tricks of Demons) by Johann Weyer, translated to English by John Shea, published 1991 by Medieval & Rennaisance Texts & Studies

  • 1563 - Pseudomonarchia Daemonum (The False Monarchy of Demons) by Johann Weyer, translated to English by Natalia Zasadzinska, published 2016 by Abracax House

  • 1584 - The Discoverie of Witchcraft by Reginald Scot, published 1995 by Richard Kaufman and Alan Greenberg copying John Rodker's 1930 printing

  • 1590 - An Examen of Witches by Henry Bouget, translated to English by E. Allen Ashwin, published 1929 by John Rodker

  • 1595 - Demonolatry by Nicolas Remy, translated to English by E. Allen Ashwin, published 1974 by University Books, Inc

  • 1597 - Daemonologie by King James VI of Scotland, published 2013 by Ouroboros Press

  • 1608 - Compendium Maleficarum by Francesco Maria Guazzo, translated to English by E. Allen Ashwin, published 1974 by University Books, Inc

  • 1680 - A Discovery of the Impostures of Witches and Astrologers by John Brinley, published 2015 by Troy Books

  • 1681 - Saducismus Triumphatus or Full and plain evidence concerning witches and apparitions by Joseph Glanvill, published 1966 by Scholars' Facsimiles & Reprints

Are there any clunkers in this list from a historian's perspective? How about notable absences?

A few questions:

  1. Is there academic consensus that Christopher Mackay's translation of Malleus Maleficarum is more accurate than Montague Summers'? I understand Montague was a... colorful character.

  2. Is there an English translation of the fifth book from Formicarius (The Ant Hill) by Johannes Nider, and does this fifth book have its own name?

  3. Is there an English translation of the fifth book from Fortalitium Fidei (Fortress of the Faith) by Alphonso de Spina? I'm pretty sure it's called De bello demonum contra fidei fortalicum but I've also seen it listed as contra demons?

  4. Everywhere I've read, it is said that Fortalitium Fidei is the first book on witchcraft with Formicarius being the second, but when I look at the years they were written, it seems the opposite. I show Formicarius being published in 1437 and Fortalitium Fidei being published in 1470. Is anyone in a position to clear this up?

Finally, these books are on my list. If you've read them, would you recommend them?

  • 1460 - Invectives contre la secte de vauderie (Invectives Against the Sect of Waldensians) by Johannes Tinctor, translated to English by Andrew Gow, published 2016 by Penn State University Press [note: also older than Fortalitium Fidei, I think? I hear this one specifically makes mention of witches riding brooms.]

  • 1580 - De la démonomanie des sorciers (On the Demon-Mania of Witches) by Jean Bodin, translated to English by Randy A. Scott, published 1995 by the Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies. Reviews talk about this one being wildly popular for its time.

Speaking of which, I appreciate your time! Thanks for reading all this. I tried to format out the wall of text as best I could.

1 Answers 2020-01-06

In Fritz Lang's 1931 film "M", the thieves guild enlist the help of the beggars union in their attempts to catch a serial killer in Berlin. Did such things really exist in Weimar Germany?

1 Answers 2020-01-06

1580 / 7255

Back to start