How seriously are claims of pre columbian English discovery of America taken by the historian community?

I'm specifically referring to the common theory cited by some that English Fisherman discovered Newfoundland before John Cabot. evidence for this supposedly comes in the form of a letter by John Day, to the "Grand Admiral" of Spain:

It is considered certain that the cape of the said land (Land found by John Cabot) was found and discovered in the past by the men from Bristol who found 'Brasil' as your Lordship well knows. It was called the Island of Brasil, and it is assumed and believed to be the mainland that the men from Bristol found.

This seems to imply that John Cabot's land was discovered previously by men from Bristol looking for the fictional island of Brasil. Similarly, he was not only receiving money from Italian bankers, but supposedly mentioning this land in his original loans according Margret Condon, an archivist.

John Cabot, of Venice, on 27 April [1496], is debited for £10 sterling, paid in cash to Lorenzo Morandi towards the 50 nobles sterling [£16 13s 4d] our Aldobrandino Tanagli ordered us to pay him so that he could go and find the new land

However, there isn't much information out there on this and it seems a bit speculative, Is there a general consensus among historians about the voracity of these claims? If not, is there any further reading or sources regarding 15th century English Exploration? Thank you.

https://www.heritage.nf.ca/articles/exploration/john-day.php

https://www.heritage.nf.ca/articles/exploration/new-findings-cabot.php

1 Answers 2019-12-15

Given that the Norse people were somewhat aware of the existence of North America, were the Scandinavian people aware of the continent's existence well beyond the viking age?

1 Answers 2019-12-15

Did ancient civilians get PTSD? What do we know of the psychological effects of war on noncombatants, and how they dealt with them?

1 Answers 2019-12-15

The idea of the 'Sinicisation' (becoming Chinese) of the Manchus during the Qing Dynasty is no longer particularly accepted by historians of the period. But what of earlier conquest dynasties like the Mongol Yuan or the Xianbei Northern Wei? Has there been a shift there as well?

1 Answers 2019-12-15

What were relations like between the Golden Horde and the Teutonic Order?

2 Answers 2019-12-15

Were Any White People Killed in Hiroshima or Nagasaki?

Were any Americans or Europeans present in the cities of Hiroshima or Nagasaki when the bombs struck?

1 Answers 2019-12-15

Books on medieval Russia

Looking for good books on medieval Russia. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2019-12-15

How did Shinto, Buddhism, and other religious beliefs fit together during feudal Japan?

(for context, I'm researching for a story set around that period)

From what I have heard of the era, buddhism was very prominent during the time. Buddhist temples, warrior monks, all of that stuff. But from what I know of modern Japan shinto was a big part of that too. And in many texts they make mentions of gods and their machinations with earth (for example, in the Bansenshukai), but that can be interpreted differently if different religion could be what they're reffering to.

So, for both the common folk and the samurai classes, what were their beliefs? What religions were practiced and how were they combined? Were religions in general stricly seperate from eachother or a combined set of beliefs?

Thank you in advance for the help, my research of this is pulling up dry.

1 Answers 2019-12-15

Exactly how much of an impact did Mao Zedong's Red Army have in World War 2?

It's quite difficult to find a clear answer that isn't muddled by bias, propaganda, or lack of proof. I know that Edgar Snow, who spent time in Yan'an with the Communist Party during the war, stated in his book that the Chinese Communists fought more bravely than the cowardly Nationalists, who had low morale and retreated easily, and described their guerrilla strategy in a similar manner to how the current Chinese government portrays the events of the war.

However, Snow has been accused of being biased towards the communists, and his books have been accused of being historically innaccurate. Most of the other threads I've read here refute the Chinese Communist Party's claims of having done the majority of the work in the war and instead claim that Mao actively avoided fighting the Japanese and instead was building his forces for a continuation of the civil war after WW2 ended. This to me seems more logical and practical than a small insurgent band that was just on the verge of being wiped out a year before managing to become a big player in the war.

But then again, if the Communists were so insignificant, why did so many prominent figures reach out and even visit Mao in his base in Yan'an? Why did the US perform the Dixie Mission? According to this interview (https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2009/04/09/reference/special-presentations/imperial-army-war-vet-haunted-by-horrors-in-china/#.XfWh65NKhWM ) of a Japanese veteran in occupied China, he was executing prisoners after interrogating them on the whereabouts of the Chinese Red Army, so clearly they must have been performing some sort of resistance rather than simply hiding to cause the Japanese to be concerned about them. Is there any other reliable accounts by Japanese veterans in China? Do any of them give a clear answer to which view of the Chinese Red Army's role in the Second Sino-Japanese war was more accurate?

2 Answers 2019-12-15

Civil War mystery

I had the honor of laying wreaths on veteran’s graves today. One of the gravesites belonged to a very young soldier from Norton, MA named Derick Cobb. I had made a general assumption that because he died in a military hospital that he died of wounds and I was determined to find out where and when he was wounded. It turns out that I found out he died of disease. I then found out he was not alone, that shortly after he died many soldiers from his company died of disease. Was 1863 a very virulent influenzas year? What was likely the cause of their deaths?

He was in the 4th Massachusetts Volunteer Militia, Company F

1 Answers 2019-12-15

Is there any proof that Jesus actually existed?

2 Answers 2019-12-15

Did firearms really give the conquistadors an edge over the native Americans?

I often hear people cite firearms as one of the major reasons why the Spanish were able to conquer the Aztecs and other native civilizations. However, whenever I read accounts of battles between conquistadors and native peoples it seems that horses and armor play a much greater role. There are also good reasons why firearms at that period would be less effective that bows: they're less accurate, they have a much slower fire rate, and they're logistically troublesome. The reason why firearms became popular in Europe seems to be their ability to penetrate plate, but when the combatants aren't wearing substantial armor is there actually an advantage to using firearms?

3 Answers 2019-12-15

Is there a way to teach history to children in school without being overly grotesque (most of reality) and being too white-washy?

e: I didn’t know how to quite word the question when I wrote it, so let me give some more information.

How should a teacher balance the horrors and triumphs of history? How much of the slave trade can be talked about without becoming very explicit? Is it a bad thing being explicit about history to children?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

Can someone please tell me why the WWI memorial in my church says it was from 1914 - 1919?

I live in a small town in Nottinghamshire, England and in my church, there’s a WWI memorial, which I’m quite sure was made in the time period, where it says that it was 1914 - 1919 even though it ended in 1918. Maybe the ceasefire was signed in 1918 but the war didn’t officially end until ‘19 but I’m not sure on that.

1 Answers 2019-12-14

The Confederate Army drank copious amounts of coffee, with soldiers' rations including up to 10 cups a day's worth. Did that coffee come from Brazil, and, if so, did Brazilian coffee plantation owners offer any kind of discount or donation to a fellow slave society fighting an existential war?

Source for coffee ration claim is Professor Jonathan Morris on the BBC show In Our Time.

2 Answers 2019-12-14

What do contemporary academic historians think of Herbert Asbury's series of books on 19th century American crime ("Gangs Of New York", etc.)?

I figure since he was a reporter his historical accuracy was probably on point, but im not sure.

1 Answers 2019-12-14

What are some books on guerrila warfare?

Are there any books written on `guerrilla warfare`?

I came across some books by `Max Boot`. Are there any better or more comprehensive books written on `guerrilla warfare`?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

Why did Imperial Japan attack the United States and Great Britian, rather than coordinate a two pronged attack into the USSR with Nazi Germany? Was there not enough oil in the Caucasus to temporarily relieve Japan of the US oil embargo?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

The Tokugawa shogunate enforced strict religious laws in Japan, so followers of Christianity and unreconciled Jodo Shinshu Buddhists went underground. As these groups were both hostile to the Edo government and centred in Kyushu, did they ever interact?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

Why have Jews, in specific, been so hated

I know the title doesn't put it well but the question is why have Jews, more than any other minority, been discriminated against?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

What caused the Nazis to lose seats during the November federal 1932 elections?

During the November 1932 federal elections, the Nazi party lost 34 seats, what caused that?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

Why were mercenaries paid in precious metals coin and why did they accept coinage?

I'm reading a bit about the history of money and it seems that precious metals were rarely used for coin with the exception of war - ransoms and mercenaries. How did mercenaries convert their precious coin to more local and usable currencies? Were there coin changers?

Why did mercenaries accept this form of payment in the first place? How did convergence on acceptance of precious metal coinage historically occur?

2 Answers 2019-12-14

[NSFW] How was masturbation viewed in Hellenismos / Orphicism?

Repost from /r/hellenism*, guess this kind of topic isn't allowed or something, not entirely sure.*

Hi all, I'm a little new to Hellenismos, and I had a question that has been hard to find an answer for, pun intended. Ahaha, sorry, couldn't resist.

My question is... how is masturbation viewed in Hellenism? I've read many different theories. For example, I read here that it's okay, according to one redditor, because sexuality is a gift from Aphrodite:

"Natural human activities such as sex and so on, are not sins, quite the contrary. Sexuality in humans and other life forms is a gift of Aphrodite. Her power is inescapable and it would be unnatural to fight it."

But here, I read this:

"Thus retreat from the world was recommended by philosophers such as Plato, and many wise men, like Apollonius of Tyana in the first century c.e., took vows of chastity. Related is the philosophical ideal of imperviousness to all earthly circumstances (apathy, ataraxy). Within Orphicism, Pythagoreanism, Stoicism, and Cynicism there were strains that viewed the physical as far inferior to the spiritual. The essential ancient conception (the soma sema doctrine, for example, in Plato's Gorgias ) was that the soul, caught in the "grave" of the body, should be liberated through a weakening of precisely this body. Examples of this idea occurred in the Eleusian fasts, in Neoplatonism, and—most clearly delineated—in Manichaeism. Passive asceticism was considered the best means to attain this liberation. Ascetic tendencies supported, furthermore, a strand of ancient medicine that energetically recommended abstinence from sexuality, as the discharge of semen was thought to weaken the body and soul of both men and women."

I've read everything from it being completely okay, to things like it not being okay, to having a balance, I've read that ancient Greeks would sometimes "devote an act" of sex or masturbation to Aphrodite... I've even read online that you can offer "special offerings" to the Gods, by offering them semen or sexual discharge, because it has a lot of energy, right behind blood.

It's very confusing as a new Hellenist. I do not want to offend any of the Theoi, for sure, but... what the heck do I do with my body when it comes to masturbation, porn, "special offerings," etc.?

Thanks for any help!

1 Answers 2019-12-14

How would schools from colonial times differ from schools today? How are they the same?

So I was listening to Hamilton when this struck me the other day. They make references to going to college and getting their degrees, and it for me thinking how would college from then compare to now. As well as lower grades like secondary and elementary schools, to what extent were they around? Or was it mostly private home tutors. I haven’t been able to find that much info saying that far back so I thought maybe the fine people of reddit could enlighten me.

1 Answers 2019-12-14

“ My political opinions lean more and more to Anarchy (philosophically understood, meaning abolition of control not whiskered men with bombs) – or to ‘unconstitutional’ Monarchy.” a quote from Tolkien. Did anarchy mean something different in the early 20th century than it does now?

This is a quote from high fantasy author J. R. R. Tolkien, who is the author of the widely known work Lord of the Rings. I read an analysis of this quote saying that anarchy meant abolition of the state as an entity separate from the people, and that Tolkien was expressing support for monarchy as the means of achieving this. It was essentially a rejection of the jingoism and national chauvinism and racism he probably saw a lot of during the first and second world wars.

Is this an accurate analysis of that quote or is Tolkien actually expressing support for anarchy as we would understand it today?

1 Answers 2019-12-14

1614 / 7255

Back to start