How were Union veterans who declined to reenlist treated when the returned home after their 3 Year terms expired but the Civil War still raged?

Most of the volunteers who joined up at the early part of the war did so on three year terms. And although many chose to re-enlist and finish the fight, plenty more decided they had done enough and returned home in 1864.

How were these men treated by their communities? Was there a sense that they had served with honor and should be welcomed back with as having done their part and now it was rightfully someone else's turn, or was there a sense that they were running away from a job not yet finished, and subject to community censure?

How much would these reactions vary geographically? Would a New England community view a man differently than one in the Midwest under the same circumstances? What about politically? Were Democratic strongholds more understanding of the non-reenlistments versus areas which were heavily Republican?

How did other veterans themselves view such men? Especially during the war as they stayed around and saw these men leaving, but also in later years at reunions and in general commemoration of the war?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Anthropology major + Genetics minor?

Not strongly chemistry suited but I believe Genetics and Anthro together is a rising field. Would love to do research and archiving with different museums and the genetics minor may help supplement that.

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Why didn’t the allied powers try converting handguns into semi-automatic and fully-automatic weapons during WWI like the central powers did?

During WWI the central powers turned pistols/handguns into semi and fully automatic weapons. Germany turned the Luger PO8 into a carbine/short rifle type thing. Austria-Hungary turned the Steyr M1912 into two different fully automatics, the Dopperpistole and the Repetierpistole. They also turned the frommerstop into a fully automatic gun. Why didn’t the allies turn any handguns into automatic rifles and SMGs?

2 Answers 2019-12-13

When and why did white people start feeling superior?

I know this is a difficult question. It's hard to pinpoint a moment of white superiority in history. But I was wondering: all the colonialism, slavery, entitlement, oppression,... When and why did this feeling of superiority start?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

I’ve become very fascinated by the Native Americans, but am struggling to find non - biased information on them.

There seems to be so much bias around the native Americans in terms of how violent/peaceful they were. Some people want to make them all out to be dumb, brutal savages. And other people want to say they were never prone to violence at all. I believe both of these views reject documented history outright. However, it still makes it difficult to know if what I am reading or listening to is reliable or not.

I realize everyone is biased to some extent so it may not be helpful to ask, but I figured I’d try anyway. Does anyone know of any sources to learn about native Americans that avoid the biases of both extreme views I mentioned above?

3 Answers 2019-12-13

How did the British military look after widows in the 17th or 18th century?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Why was the global population growth so slow in pre-industrial times despite high fertility rates?

The world population has increased from ~200M in 1 AD to ~900M in 1800, which is around a 0.08% growth per year. From what I know and have read online, the average fertility was quite high, somewhere above 5 (I do apologize for generalizing across the whole history in this section, but it is my impression that this number didn't vary massively between different times and places before the Industrial Revolution). Also, as far as I know, the infant mortality before modern medicine was around 30-45%, so an average woman is probably going to have more than two children survive to adulthood. The average life expectancy at birth in most places hovered around 30-40 years, so taking into account infant mortality it should rise by quite a bit for those who survived to adulthood.

Given those rough numbers, we "should" see, on average, several children per family surviving to adulthood, each having several children of their own and so on, which would have led to a rapid increase of population; so why didn't it happen?

The first thing that comes to mind would be wars and accompanying famines and illnesses; however, the destruction of the two world wars and Taiping Rebellion has not had a significant long-term impact on the populations of their time - e.g. Japan after WW2 has recovered their pre-war population in less than a decade; even accounting for significant infant and maternal mortality improvements in the 20th century, I can't imagine historical wars being worse than that (leaving aside "small" local exceptions like Genghis Khan and Black Death).

1 Answers 2019-12-13

WWI Unit Reports and How to Interpret Them

I have recently discovered that my 2nd cousin, x3 removed was KIA in France in WWI but I'm having a hard time deciphering the report about him. I was wondering if there is a resource that helps break this down or if I need to hunt down each sentence. Thanks in advance!

Original: NA Marietta, O. Sept 18/17. Br Marietta, O. 22 10/12 yrs. Co H 330 Inf to Mch 6/18; Co B 323 MG Bn to June 5/18; Overseas Cas Cp Merrit NJ to June 29/18; Classification Camp 1 Dep Div to July 15/18; Co D 3 MG Bn to death. Pvt. St Mihiel; Meuse-Argonne; Defensive Sector. AEF June 29/18 to death. KIA Oct 9/18. Notified C.F.W. father, 412 Bellevue Ave., Marietta, O. Body returned to US on SS Wheaton Oct 1921.

My interpretation: "Departed/drafted Marietta, Ohio on Sept 18, 1917. Born in Marietta, 22 and 10months old. Company H, 330th Infanct to ?Mch? in June of 1918. Company B 323rd ?MG? Battalion on June 5, 1918. Overseas ?Cas Cp? maybe left Merrit, NJ on June 29, 1918. Classification Camp 1 Depot Division on July 15, 1918. Company D, 3rd ?MG? Battalion to death. After that, I'm confused about the mention of Pvt St Mihiel?

2 Answers 2019-12-13

Before germ theory, what did people think was the reason for alcohol always being safe to drink without sickness, but not water?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

When and why did affection between male friends become associated with homossexuality?

I have read online (not much of a source, ik) that in the past, it was entirely normal for guy best-friends to be as close as girl best-friends, they'd hold hands, embrace, stuff like that.

Nowadays, of course, any public display of affection tends to imply that the two people involved are dating, and men, especially, avoid showing any proximity -- Physical OR emotional -- to their friends, lest they be thought of as homosexual.

Why did this change? WHY did it change?

@Edit: I am of course referring to western men. I don't know how it is outside the west, or how it was before.

2 Answers 2019-12-13

Do we know anything about Trojan culture?

Do we know what Trojans were like? For example their language or Pantheon? And how close was it to Greek culture?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

How did the Ottomans conquer and maintain Bulgaria so easily?

I was studying the history of the Byzantine Empire and one of the biggest threats lurking around Greek territory was the Bulgarians.

Since their arrival in the Balkans, they constantly defeated the Greek armies, captured or killed emperors, and even when they were integrated into Byzantium by Basil II, they managed to revolt and rebuild an empire with great influence on the peninsula. Hell, they were even responsible for overthrowing the Latin Empire and restoring the Greeks in Constantinople.

So my question is, what changed so much that the Turks could defeat the Bulgarians so easily and keep them under control for so long?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Why does the French Foreign Legion have such a romantic reputation while other foreign formations have been forgotten?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

I read that 90 000 soldiers of Polish Army in the west during WW2 were deserters from Wehrmacht. That seems ridiculously high number to me. Why did Germany recruit Poles, if they were desert so much to fight against them?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Is there any denialism when it comes to the soviets committing atrocities in the Soviet-Afghan war? When the war ended why did anti-american sentiments sink in instead of anti Russian?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Friday Free-for-All | December 13, 2019

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

10 Answers 2019-12-13

Floating Feature: Come and share the history of the world from 240 to 744 CE! It's Volume IV of 'The Story of Humankind'!

5 Answers 2019-12-13

The founder of the modern Japanese education system, Mori Arinori, reportedly wished to replace Japanese with English. Was this just a pipe dream project or was it a serious proposal that might have been implemented had he not been assassinated?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Why is Korea from 1897-1910 known as the ‘Korean Empire’ when it held no territory outside of Korea?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Lots of questions about pirate/sailing history!

Scroll down for questions!

Hello! Sorry for any mistakes make, I'm not quite sure if there's a better place to ask this but I need some confirmation to already confirmed knowledge and information to fill in the gaps.

I'm making a pirate animation, a small series and wanted to get things right (mostly) in terms of ship specifics and environment. It's a small, jolly pirate crew of 6 on the Bahamas around the time period of 1670s-1720s, in search of the legendary '8th sea'! Time and place aren't super set in stone. We just know we want pirates, tropical, and vibrant colors.

Starting out, we wanted a galleon; but then realized that was way too big for a crew of 6, so are thinking between a Cog or Sloop/Sloop of War; even then, we're still unsure of the sizing and realism. But we eventually settled with the concept that its a small ship modified (and overcrowded with modifications) to technically fit the requirements to be a Galleon so that the captain can brag about owning one.

We know we want the final ship to have around 5 canons, (all top deck,) captain's quarter's, 2 or 3 masts, crow's nest, figurehead, and about 3 sections on top deck. Here is a reference image of the original I drew. https://imgur.com/6xLScgy

Onto the question(s)!

(Please don't feel pressured to answer all of them! Even one answer helps a ton. *** are the super important ones!)

-What requirements does a ship (1600's) have to meet in order to be considered a Galleon?***

-What kinds of ships (1600's) could be manned by a crew of 6, though still seen as impressive?***

-Did pirates call themselves pirates?

-Where did the association of pirates owning parrots come from?

-Do the ropes that raise/lower and turn a mast/sail have technical names?

-I've also been on the hunt for a list of flora/fauna***, common disease/problems (to residence and sailors alike,) religion, myths, weapons, and currency that were present/documented around mid to late 1600 in the Bahamas.

Thanks so much for the help!!

I'll continue to do research of my own, but a lot of these questions that I found the answer to had flaky answers at best, or none at all. I know I didn't give too much narrative about the actual story, (because I'm about a year in and afraid and a bit overprotective of my work!) but I also really appreciate extra information, (even if I didn't ask!) ideas, and tips. (Not the money kind.) So if you're big on the subject, feel free to blast everything you know; literally anything about these topics that you know will help me a lot. Happy sailing!

1 Answers 2019-12-13

If the Dark Ages is a period of time during which we have no written evidence of things, then how do we know it happened at all?

If there was no writing that we can find, no evident development that has lasting impact, how do we know there was a period of exactly just so long as we know it to have lasted? Is it possible we just made up a period of 100 years or so?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

Why did the flintlock pistol/bayonet combo replace pikes and matchlocks?

What benefits were there to the former that made such a massive transition worthwhile?

2 Answers 2019-12-13

Was there any kind of long-distance communication before the invention of morse code?

It's often said that morse code revolutionized long-distance communication, if that's the case then was there any form of long-distance communication before morse code?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

How did snow and "white Christmas" become the nostalgic holiday standard when white Christmases are uncommon for many parts of the world?

While I presume that the initial associations with snow come from the general December/winter months, and the origins of the holiday in places that do see snow, for many parts of the world a white Christmas is an exception, not the norm.

In the Southern Hemisphere, because Christmas is in the beginning of Summer, white Christmases are exceedingly rare except in certain locations. Even in the Northern Hemisphere a white Christmas is often unlikely. London's season low temperature hardly averages below freezing. The majority of the continental United States has less than a 25% of seeing a white Christmas.

So what might the conditions have been that led to a relatively uncommon phenomenon (on average, globally) dictating the standard for Christmas nostalgia? For example, were hot spots of influential Christmas iconography located in places (such as New York City) that had a higher chance of seeing a white Christmas? And how would this view have survived the more common experience of other cultural hotspots (such as Hollywood) where a white Christmas is rare?

1 Answers 2019-12-13

What strategies did the Civil Rights Movement in the US employ?

A lot of what I learned in school portrayed the Civil Rights movement as rather organic, but I've seen some suggestions that it was more planned and strategic. For instance, I read that Rosa Parks was chosen as an icon over another woman (a young, single mother) who stayed in her seat because of public perception. Who were the key players and what strategies did they draw on? What was their inspiration?

Finally, are there any good books you would suggest on the topic?

2 Answers 2019-12-13

1616 / 7255

Back to start