Was redirected here from askreddit, Did ancient societies (B.C.) have any fields similar to present day archeology/anthropology?

1 Answers 2022-07-08

Did Nazi germany have a centralized government?

I mean in the way the u.s.s.r had a centralized gov as in did Nazi germanys federal government have all power over provinces,territories and states? (No states rights)

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Where do I go to get a good education in History? School hasn't done me too well in this regard, but I'd really like to learn!

Any resources would help, as well as an order of progression. I want to have an interest in certain time periods and then know where to go from there to learn it in-depth, which as of now, I don't have good enough general knowledge to do so. I thank you all in advance, and thanks for being here!

2 Answers 2022-07-07

Does anyone have any resources on 16th century Yakutia?

Probably a long shot here but I'm looking for any information about Yakutia and Sakha culture prior to the arrival of the Russians in the 17th century. Unfortunately any such resources would probably be in Russian which I don't speak; I do have google translate for that but it's finding materials in the first place that's the problem.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2022-07-07

At what point did historians attempt to provide a more comprehensive view of American history as opposed to a more patriotic one and why?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Are all genealogy records digitized?

I am struggling to find some of my ancestors even in the 1800s and I am wondering if it is because not all records are digitized?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

How did communists react to the relatively fast collapse of the soviet union? Were there any narratives around its collapse undermining the communist ideology?

How did communists react to the relatively fast collapse of the soviet union? Were there any narratives around its collapse undermining the communist ideology? Did it have any appreciable effects on communist movements only tangentially linked to the soviet union? Like a significant number of people becoming disillusioned with the ideology?

I'm aware that there are a diverse range of communist ideologies and some viewed the soviet union as legitimate and others not. I would compare this question to a similar one that's been answered on how Christians reacted to the fall of Constantinople.

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Do we know why Hitler styled his mustache the way he did? He certainly didn’t sport it in his youth, and it doesn’t appear to have been a popular style based upon a lack of pictures with people having the same type. Did he ever discuss it? Did he feel it was an important symbol?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Is the Xia Dynasty of China part of prehistoric China or ancient China (or something else entirely)?

I'm doing some research into ancient China, and I'm getting confused as to when the first dynasty of China is. From what I understand from my research, it either is the first 'event' after the prehistory ended, or it's still part of prehistory and it ends a couple of dynasties after.

So where do I put it under? Prehistoric China? Ancient China? Both? Neither?

Thanks in advance

1 Answers 2022-07-07

(before 1954) Did asian-americans go to school with white people or black people? or did they have their own schools during segregation?

2 Answers 2022-07-07

Why do people represent northern Ireland with a flag that looks like England's St George's Cross when the UK added St Patrick's saltire to the Union jack to represent Ireland as part of the UK?

Here's a visual representation of what I mean.

1 Answers 2022-07-07

In the HBO series The Gilded Age one of the old money characters quips that well brought up women don't hang out at Delmonicos. But I'd always read that the original Delmonicos was one of old New York's premiere fine dining establishments. So what exactly was this famous restaurant's reputation?

In the HBO series, set in NYC in the early 1880s, one of the old money characters remarks that well brought up young women "aren't the girls lighting the cigars of their escorts at Delmonicos". This seems to imply that someone of good standing in high society (or at least a woman of good standing) wouldn't want to be seen there. And the show does imply that most of the wealthy families in New York had their own cooks and would regularly host others for meals at their homes.

But whenever I've read about Delmonicos during that period (the gilded age) it always comes across as being a prestigious fine dining restaurant that catered to the wealthy and powerful. Was there something about Delmonicos in particular that "old society" didn't like? Was it the kind of place where married men brought their mistresses? Or were private restaurants part of a broader cultural shift between old money and new money?

2 Answers 2022-07-07

Why is it impossible to ask a question on here?

I want to participate in this subreddit, but EVERY TIME I post it gets deleted by the moderators for violating a BS "rule." Ridiculous.

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Is there amy truth to the claim that humans have almost always understood that the Earth was round?

I recently heard someone make the claim that humans have known that the Earth was not flat since at least Ancient Greece and that the Catholic church never said otherwise and never tried to suppress anyone for saying so

3 Answers 2022-07-07

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 07, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

7 Answers 2022-07-07

Why did Nazi Germany ally with Japan?

If the Nazis where white supremacists then why would they ally with people they saw as less than them? If the axis had won the war would they have betrayed Japan in the future? It seems like a weird partnership.

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Why did the Romanian Iron Guard split into two groups after Codreanu's death?

After Codreanu's death, Horia Sima was put in charge, and the legion split into two groups, the people who followed Codreanu's Ideology and the people that followed Horia Sima's Ideology, but what were the differences between them and why do some people consider Horia Sima a traitor?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

In terms of the ancient manuscripts that historians use as their primary sources, are there digital archives that contain all these ancient manuscripts in one place? If not, do historians have to physically search different libraries/museums to reference these manuscripts?

3 Answers 2022-07-07

What were medieval markets like? What role did they play in the administration of a city, and why was having the right to hold a market important?

As far as I know, markets were an important part of medieval towns, where towns would only be recognized as that if they had the right to hold a market. Why were markets important? Who organized them?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

WW1 footage with what appears to be a black powder firearm?

I am currently watching this documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rai0urG_KGw, and at 37:03 it looks like a man in the bottom right corner of the screen discharges a black powder gun of some sort, judging by the amount of smoke produced. What is the explanation for this? Were there (presumably limited) instances of black powder rifles/muskets being used in WW1?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

How come the lictors in the Roman Republic were trustworthy, in contrast to the Praetorian Guard of the Roman Empire?

A friend of mine recently asked why the senators didn't just pay off Julius Caesar's bodyguards to kill him instead of putting themselves at risk by stabbing him themselves. This creates an interesting question - what made the lictors of the Roman Republic trustworthy?

According to Wikipedia, during the almost 500 years from the founding of the Roman Empire to the Western Roman Empire's fall, 13 Roman Emperors were murdered by the Praetorian Guard. Yet the Roman Republic existed for a similar (if not longer) amount of time, but not a single consul was murdered by the lictors (or perhaps the documentation is missing?). Even as the Republic grew increasingly corrupted, unstable and dictator-prone, the lictors didn't kill any of the consuls or dictators. What was the reason they were more loyal than the Praetorian Guard?

On a similar note, why did the Empire abandon the system of lictors if that system seemed to work better than the Praetorian Guard system they replaced it with?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

How much "economical support" medieval (XII century or Hundred Years War) knight need?

For clarification under "knight" here I mean armoured warrior that fight on horse (at least expected did this).

As far I know, medieval knight need provide their own weapon, armour and other stuff. And they mostly take money for this from their manor/fief.

But how much income they need for this? Not even in actual money, but I more interesting about how much people need knight to have this income.

I read something about 20 pounds in year for one knight as lower line, but how much this actually? Did they need village on 100 households? Or like Novgorod, every ten households can realistically support one knight?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2022-07-07

Before the widespread use of computers and digital data, how did military spy satellites take pictures of specific targets, and how did those pictures get back to the correct spot on Earth?

2 Answers 2022-07-07

Besides John of Damascus work, is there any mention to Muhammad or Islam from outside the Islamic world?

John of Damascus used to debate Muslims a lot, and he’s one of the first critics of “Ishmaelites” as he called them in Concerning Heresy (Perì eréseon). Besides him, is there anyone who mentioned or criticized Muhammad or Islam from that era (6th, 7th, or 8th century)?

1 Answers 2022-07-07

What was the musical instrument industry like in the USSR?

Post-collapse, Sovtek’s Deluxe Big Muff PI pedal became a big-time favorite among some rock musicians. Their MIG-50 amplifier also has a very good rep.

Still, I’ve yet to hear much about the USSR’s musical instrument industry as a whole. I assume, due to Russia’s classical music tradition, it was mostly focused on instruments like the violin, piano, etc, but I might be wrong. I know that by the 80’s they had a very active rock’n roll scene, with bands like Kino being very popular to this day.

What was the musical instrument industry like in the USSR? How did people go around to buying instruments? Were Western brands available for them to purchase or was it limited to local brands only? Were they accessible to ordinary people, price-wise?

My focus is mostly electric instruments, like the guitar, but I’d love to hear everything you have to say about such a wide topic.

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2022-07-06

197 / 7255

Back to start