Are statues History?

A comment in a debate on the removal of a statue have sparked some interest in whether a statue is history.

Here is an example of some historians discussing the topic with the view that statues are not history for context.

https://www.reddit.com/r/CanadaPolitics/comments/96gm36/first_they_came_for_sir_john_a_ipolitics/e40ezb9/

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Historic Grain Harvests?

How has the yield of typical grain harvests changed through time?

I'm currently living adjacent to some large wheat fields that are being harvested which lead me to askreddit how many loaves of bread you get from a hectare of wheat (~7800 apparently). That then got me wondering about how much more efficient we are today compared to a hundred years ago or a thousand years ago or three thousand years ago or ten thousand years ago.

1 Answers 2018-08-15

"Indeed the consensus now... is that we know less about the historical Mohammed than we do about the historical Jesus"

A claim made by Tom Holland here (35:40 on for those it doesn't work for, but you can roll slightly ahead for context), based on his view that the Islamic sources are late and filled with politically and theologically motivated gloss.

Now, I've seen people rip into Tom Holland for his history on other topics and he clearly has his own political motivations for his positions here but it is an interesting claim. Frankly, I'm a bit uncertain why it seems so surprising to me given that a few facts can be raised in is favor (a lot of the most theologically authoritative Muslim sources are far later than the sources on Jesus- something that) but I am curious if he is exaggerating the consensus.

I vaguely understand that there was a skeptical turn in Islamic historiography since Crone, but I'm curious about whether this particular claim is controversial and if the traditional narrative and the historical one have diverged so much.

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Why didn't the Polynesians ever migrate to any part of Australia when they managed to settle as far west as Madagascar and as far east as Easter Island?

Were there conflicts with Australian aboriginals that prevented them from colonising at least the northern part of Australia, or did the trade winds simply not allow them to travel further south than Papua New Guinea?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Who might have been the original publisher of Cicero's correspondence?

In Syme's The Roman Revolution, he suggests that it was likely Octavianus who was quietly behind the first edition of Cicero's collected correspondence. Later, he mentions that letters between Cicero and Octavianus were conveniently elided from the edition. Is that the main evidence for believing Octavianus was behind the edition of Cicero's correspondence? What does contemporary scholarship tell us about how Cicero's letters come down to us?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

What did the Nazi party think of the Irish? Did they share any of the anti-Irish sentiments found throughout the Anglosphere in the early 20th century?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

I am a blind man in the Middle Ages. How useful am I and what jobs can I do to survive?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

What happened on the Second Punic War between Cannae (216 BC) and Zama (203 BC)

All I know about the Second Punic War is from 219+ (Saguntum) - 216 (Cannae) and 203 (Zama), but what happened between 216-203? I remember that his brother also crossed the alps but that's all

1 Answers 2018-08-15

In Fantasy works and stories set in medieval times, there are often depictions of ‘adventurers’ who roam the lands taking odd jobs, slaying beasts/bandits/outlaws, and treasure hunting. Is there any historical basis in eastern or western medieval cultures for such an occupation?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Sword of office for postmen in Russian Empire?

I was reading Aton Chekhov's the Witch and in the short story a postman gets lost in a snowstorm and stumbles into the home of the protagonist. It mentions him having a "postmen's sword." Were postal employees provided with swords in the Russian Empire? Was it largely ceremonial or was it used to defend the mail?

Thanks

1 Answers 2018-08-15

I recall hearing that Brazil was one of the last places to outlaw slavery, in 1888. What was slavery like in Brazil, and why did it take even longer to outlaw than the United States, which was criticized for holding onto slavery for long?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

If Italians, Irish, Poles, etc weren’t considered ‘white’ by Americans and Europeans until recently, what were they considered before?

Additionally, how did they ‘become’ white?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Why is the n-word such a bad word and what does it mean socially?

I live in a small country in Europe. The word "nigger" is not used here and in fact I only know it on the internet and it seems one of the words with the largest racist conformations in the USA (and that recently generated many controversies), to the point that it is even censored and used n-word in its place.

I'm interested in knowing what it means, understanding its history, those things.

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Was Norway ever invaded by Britain?

I have seen this claimed in several Youtube videos and sensantionalist media, yet I have not come across British troops landing on Norwegian soil, only Scottish mercenaries in Swedish employment and maritime border violations during WW2.

1 Answers 2018-08-15

I'm starting my masters in three weeks - advice please

With the aim of moving into a PhD program later (yes, I did just read why I shouldn't get one!), what should my hierarchy of priorities be? Grades, networking, publishing, volunteering, teaching (I'm a TA), etc.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2018-08-15

I was listening to an old interview with Paul McCartney from 1966 and he mentions that he's starting to get into Indian music for the first time, whereas before he'd hear it on radio and change the station. What types of Indian music would be on the radio in England in the 50's or 60's?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Did Jewish slaveowners in the South teach their slaves Judiasm?

So we know that many slave owners used Christianity to try to make their slaves submissive. We also know that there were Jewish slaveowners in the America South. Did Jewish slaveowners “raise” their slaves in the Jewish tradition.

2 Answers 2018-08-15

Why is Pyrrhus of Epirus considered a great general, when he essentially lost every foreign war he started?

Pyrrhus consecutively lost campaigns against the Romans in Italy, Carthaginian-backed forces in Sicily, and Spartans back in Greece. This is despite the fact he started every one of these wars so had the choice of engagement, and seems to consecutively have chosen... poorly.

Sure, he's a great tactician, often winning individual battles against larger odds. But at a distance, Pyrrhus seems like one of those generals that keeps winning battles yet losing wars; a reckless, imprudent adventurist, whose recklessness even led to his infamous death from a pot falling on his head. Pyrrhus also had a poor grasp on logistics (as he himself admitted after the Battle of Asculum) and politics (becoming so unpopular he was forced out of the same cities that invited him for protection from the Romans in the first place).

Unlike the likes of Alexander or Scipio, Pyrrhus does not seem like a strategic leader that can finish what he started and complete the conquest. Why is he considered such a great general?

2 Answers 2018-08-15

When Louis Philippe was exiled in America, did he ever talk/run into famous men from American history?

For those who don't know, Louis would be king of France after the July 1830 revolution

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Short Answers to Simple Questions | August 15, 2018

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.

  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.

  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.

  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.

  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.

  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).

  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

25 Answers 2018-08-15

Were there any areas/groups/individuals in Europe who managed to stubbornly remain completely un-Christianized, practicing in secret, up until the modern day?

2 Answers 2018-08-15

Reading list for history of the United States - 1812 - 1861?

This section of US history seems to have been skipped over in the list of selected books available in the sidebar. I am curious about a lot of the chief events -

the War of 1812, the Monroe Doctrine, The Missouri Compromise, Andrew Jackson, the Native Americans and the Trail of Tears, Manifest Destiny and expansionism, the first wave of industries - also all the tensions that led up to the Civil War.

I don't live in the US, or even in the West for that matter. I have read some very bulky US history textbooks, (US history is not covered in our college history syllabus so I went hunting by myself) they touched on all these topics, but it felt very superficial.

So I would be really grateful if anyone could recommend some books.

I found the Slavery reading list to be very helpful.

2 Answers 2018-08-15

Did Julius Caesar ever privately or publicly comment on Cincinnnatus's decision to give up power?

Cincinnatus famously was made dictator twice and voluntarily gave up power each time. This was a famous Roman story, one that Julius Caesar would have been well aware of. Given his own ambitions, do we know what Caesar thought of Cincinnatus and his decision?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

Did European Women Engage in Dueling during the 16th-19th centuries?

I've seen dueling referred to as an exclusively masculine pursuit, but how historically accurate is that? I suppose many women might not have had ready access to weaponry and training with weapons which is sort of a prerequisite for dueling, but was there any social more against female dueling, or is it just under-reported?

1 Answers 2018-08-15

What types of self defense weapons might a middle or lower class person in the 16th and 17th centuries in Europe have?

A popular image is that of people walking around with swords attached to their belts wherever they went but my impression was that swords were prohibitively expensive for most and thus seen as a status symbol.

1 Answers 2018-08-15

⯇ 2455 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start