Is there any evidence to suggest that Native Americans visited other parts of the world?

I'm reading a bit about how many different groups could possibly have visited the New World before Columbus (the Vikings, Indonesia, Japan, etc) with varying levels of quality of evidence to back those possibilities up. It's odd that I don't see much discussion of the possibility that someone from the New World visited elsewhere. Did anyone from the New World ever visit Europe or Africa or Asia or Oceania?

2 Answers 2018-08-14

How did the French citizens manage to storm the Bastille, a massive fort, during the French Revolution?

It is very perplexing to me, how a mob even as large as the one that stormed the Bastille was able to get inside. Wouldn't it simply have been a matter of raising the drawbridge? Was this not done, or did they have help on the inside, or is there some other explanation?

Thank you, you guys are the best.

1 Answers 2018-08-14

The Second World War ended with the invention and use of nukes. Was there a similar device or technology that was being explored to create a quick end to the First World War?

It may not have been a technology quite like a nuclear bomb, but were there further plans for quickly winning the war if it had of carried over to 1919 or beyond?

3 Answers 2018-08-14

Traditional Japanese Houses (800-1300 AD): how did they keep animals/bugs out?

Just thinking about traditional Japanese houses and mansions (800-1300 AD (actually unsure about exact date range)): did they have any clever ways of dealing with pests? Such an open air design seems like it would invite critters in to look for stored food. The wood and paper walls don't seem like they'd be enough to deter larger creatures, like wolves or raccoons. I'd imagine bugs would be pervasive, especially in the humidity of summer.

I noticed many traditional houses sit on stilts/platform; does this design play a strategic role in pest control, or maybe natural air conditioning?

I've included some links to images of the type of houses I'm talking about:

Paper doors outside

House on platform open walls

1 Answers 2018-08-14

"Under God" was added to the US Pledge of Allegiance in 1954; what was the background behind this change? Was there any controversy accompanying it at the time?

1 Answers 2018-08-14

In the early 16th century, codpieces became very popular, but were objects of parody and derision by the end of it. What contributed to the rise and fall of this bizarre fashion trend?

The codpiece is one of the most baffling trends in fashion history to me. Its emphasis on masculinity and projection seems bizarre, not to mention impractical. How did these become an object of high fashion but burn out into ridicule shortly afterwards?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

In the 18th and 19th centuries, British soldiers in India sometimes married Indian women, sending their children back to Britain. What would life have been like for these children? What were the attitudes towards mixed-race people at the time?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

I'm Keagan Brewer, here to talk about medieval European wonders, legends, and supernatural beliefs. Ask me anything!

For a long time, I have been looking at the 'crazy' stories and beliefs from the medieval period to try to understand why they believed them (or seem to have). There are so many good stories that I wouldn't know where to start! I will be here for the next three hours.

I've written two books, one on wonders in general, and another that brings together the sources for the legend of Prester John:

https://www.amazon.com/Skepticism-Routledge-Research-Medieval-Studies-ebook/dp/B01BC2QT54/ref=as_li_ss_tl?_encoding=UTF8&me=&qid=&linkCode=sl1&tag=askhistorians-20&linkId=c80df003fd3e44b79ca1529946ad6e08

https://www.amazon.com/Prester-John-Sources-Crusade-Translation/dp/1409438074

EDIT: 12:05pm I have to head to a meeting now so I’ll be away from here for a while. Please keep posting your questions and thoughts and I will do my best to get to them as soon as I can!

34 Answers 2018-08-13

Austria as part of Germany

Why is it after WW2 Austria was released from German control when they voted and legally joined into Germany. Was it part of the pact after the war that all nations were to be released no matter how they became part of Germany?

2 Answers 2018-08-13

It's generally accepted that the U.S. covertly supplied Israel with nuclear weapons during the Cold War. By comparison, it pressured South Korea to end its nuclear program in 1975. Why the difference in policy?

Why was Israel seen as being worth a potentially-incredibly-damaging arms sale, when South Korea wasn't?

2 Answers 2018-08-13

It's oft said that we have no evidence of mass volleys of arrows in ancient battles. However, the Roman testudo formation was designed specifically to repel mass volleys of missiles. How do historians reconcile these seemingly contradictory facts?

2 Answers 2018-08-13

It's the early 16th century. I'm a young, ambitious, European man looking to make a name for myself as part of the Spanish conquest of the New World. How do I go about joining an expedition and what would life be like once we get to the Americas?

Specifically, would there be any qualifications or disqualifications to joining a conquistador expedition? For example, would they take any European recruits who wanted to join or only subjects of the Crown of Spain?

Also what could I expect to be my reward? Land? Gold? Would knights or other nobility join expecting larger rewards than an average soldier?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Cooking in the Late Roman Empire

Hey there I’m really interested in food as a vehicle for culture, and lately I’ve been finding/reading about recipes and the way that people cooked during the Medieval period. While I was looking for a recipe for a sauce I came across this stuff called Garum which is impressively gross sounding but also impressive because the article compared it to an original ketchup- i.e., something that everybody loved and put on just about everything. That got me wondering what else everybody normally ate in Rome (specifically during the later portion of the empire, post Constantine, pre looting of Byzantium). I’m most interested in what the everyday folk would’ve been imbibing in, those crazy emperors definitely weren’t going out for Roman street food but I kind of want to try it😂

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Did the average pirate truly speak the way that we stereotype in films?

Pretty much exactly what I said. Did pirates speak gravelly and with sentence structure such as “it do be the west winds that are roaring”? Just had a epiphany and realized that I was not sure if the stereotype was in any way accurate.

1 Answers 2018-08-13

If William Wallace and Robert the Bruce didn't wear kilts, why do their statues depict them as such?

My mother in law, bless her heart, is in love with the kilt. As her family name and heritage is directly tied to Robert the Bruce, she has always had a fascination with Scottish knights wearing tartan kilts, at least in court.

When I broke it to her that the kilt didn't come to popularity until a good 200 years after the death of Robert the Bruce, she insisted I needed better information.

What are the chances that William Wallace and the King of Scots wore kilts, at all, during the 14th century? If they didn't, why are their statues depicted with kilts?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

How much is known about the functioning of the Spartan diarchy? Do we know its origin?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Six months after King Henry VII’s son, Arthur, married Princess Catherine of Spain, Arthur died of an unknown ailment. Catherine would later state that the marriage was never consummated. Was a delay of consummation like this normal?

The couple even had a public bedding ceremony (the only recorded one for a royal couple in 16th century Britain), which makes me even more curious as to why the marriage was never consummated. Was there a reaction from either royal family when they learned this news?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

What was the relationship between the IJA and the IJN? At times, they seem to have been overly independent, but the IJN also provided air support deep inland over China in the Second Sino-Japanese War.

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Suggested historians

I am looking to diversify my bookshelf a bit and am seeking suggestions for historians that are not males of European descent. Some areas of interest are the dissolution of Yugoslavia, recent conflicts in the Caucasus, Indo-Pakistani relations, French Revolution, late Republican/early imperial Rome. Basically anything involving the ugliest manifestations of nationalism.

1 Answers 2018-08-13

The Ethopian Army during the First Italo-Ethiopian war had a large amount and variety of semi-modern and modern firearms. Where were they getting them? Did the colonial powers of Europe allow for the sale of such arms and munitions to an African Nation?

2 Answers 2018-08-13

When ancient coffins, urns or sarcophagii are brought into museums for display, are the remains removed before, or are there ancient skeletons lying in museums around the world?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Its the 1800s and railways are being built. How did people prevent trains crashing into eachother?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

why isn't Julius Cesar or Pompey thr great considered the first emperors of rome despite both having the title of dictator for life?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Can anyone tell me about underwater commando battles during WWII?

I'm reading a technical diving book called "Deco for Divers," by Mark Powell. In one section he writes the following:

Siebe Gorman...introduced the technique of using different concentrations of oxygen mixed with nitrogen. This was used to great effect by British commandos during World War Two who used oxygen-enriched air rebreathers. Their rebreathers used mixtures of 45-60% oxygen which had a greater maximum operating depth than their opponents whose pure oxygen rebreathers were limited to 6-10m. The British used this to their advantage and their simple but effective strategy was simply to pull their opponents to deeper depths until convulsions overwhelmed the enemy diver.

I find it hard to believe that enemy divers regularly ran into each other such that a regular strategy developed, but that's where my question lies. Did these encounters actually happen, and how would these engagements come about? What do we know about them?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

Was anything collected at the end of WWII that could yield Hitler's DNA, and could that be used to piece together the claim of Hitler having Jewish ancestory?

1 Answers 2018-08-13

⯇ 2459 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start