Did 14 year old Mozart REALLY transcribe the closely guarded Miserere of Allegri after only hearing it at Saint Peter's twice?

https://www.classicfm.com/composers/mozart/guides/mozart-allegri-miserere/

This is a good summary of the general story, but it's hard to find supporting evidence.

Is there evidence of Allegri's Miserere entering the public sphere from a source other than Mozart?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Books/Articles/Videos on Border Culture?

Hey y'all,

First off, I have skimmed through Reddit but can't find a post about this particular topic (if there is please let me know!). I am also unsure whether this is appropriate for this subreddit or for r/AskAnthropology (again, let me know!).

Anyways, I am curious about the development and characteristics of border cultures between two or more nations/kingdoms/cultures. I live in southern Texas, USA so the US/Mexico border is right there. Any books/articles/videos on the development and characteristics of that specific border culture would be great. But as stated at the beginning of this paragraph, I am also interested in border cultures of different places and time periods (for example, the Roman Empire and northern or eastern Europe or the US/Mexico border before the Mexican-American War).

If this request seems too broad (as I assume it is) then any help in direction would be much appreciated.

Oh, and if any of y'all would like to just simply lay out your own knowledge or any advice in researching such a topic, that is also welcomed.

1 Answers 2022-05-13

The British royal family changed their name from Saxe-Coburg and Gotha to Windsor. What other names were considered, and why was Windsor the winner?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

How central was Homeric literature to Classical Greek life? Was the reverence for Homeric poems comparable or wholly different to that of Abrahamic books and religions?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

can spanish virroyalties be not considered colonies?

since they were integral parts of the kingdom of spain

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Did medieval children play in the snow?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

How did the unified Kingdom of East Frankia become the disunified Holy Roman Empire?

I understand the Frankish Empire being split into three parts and each ruler having direct control over their respective realms as kings. What I don't understand is how this kingdom became an empire, and yet direct control was lost as the HERE became... the HRE.

Besides, why was East Frankia a kingdom when Charlemagne was crowned Holy Roman Emperor in 800 CE?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Friday Free-for-All | May 13, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

7 Answers 2022-05-13

In 1990, 71% of Ukrainians voted to preserve the USSR. A year later, 92% of Ukrainians voted for independence. Why the turn of events?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Since 1215, the Catholic Church has banned consanguinity to the fourth degree. Several hundred years later, the Catholic Habsburgs would go against this rule multiple times, to the extent of marrrying nieces. What enabled the Habsburgs to get away with this for so long? How did the church react?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

How do I as a layperson read imperfect sources?

How do I treat history books which are 'outdated'? I was going through La Société Féodale (Bloch, Marc 1940), and I got scared by this foreword from a recent 2010 edition.

Archaeology especially has continued to transform our understanding of early medieval migrations, settlement patterns, ethnicity, disease, diet, gender, commerce and power. However, as a result of all this work Bloch’s own history has been superseded.

... this makes reading Feudal Society today problematic, for it no longer stands as an accurate account of the period ... No one would use the kinds of phrases that remind us that Bloch’s assumptions were still those of Europe’s long nineteenth century: “true savages,” “untutored minds,” “the most vital elements in the nation.” One should not read Feudal Society and think that its depictions represent our current understanding of western European culture between the ninth and twelfth centuries.

...It is remarkable that Bloch got so much right. And it is remarkable that historians still work so much according to scholarly principles he helped established. Yet to read Bloch because he was at the origins of much current historical practice is still to do him a disservice, because Bloch himself abhorred what he called “the Idol of Origins.” He might be flattered that we still read him, but he might also be dismayed.

Why, then, should we still read Feudal Society? Perhaps we should broaden the question: why do we read any old historians? Why do we read Thucydides, Tacitus, Bede, Gibbon, or Toqueville? We read them because they were great stylists who can teach us how to write; because they were powerful minds whose histories are really vehicles for debates about the nature of government, power, reason, or the logic of history itself; because they were such good writers possessed of such powerful minds that even though their histories are now known to be false, partisan or seriously incomplete, they still seem utterly convincing and coherent; the only histories that could possibly be written.

Emphasis mine.

I'm just a layperson who found it in the bibliography of a pop history blog (bibliography is below the blue subscribe button). The blogger who cited it is a historian, and so is the guy who wrote the book, so it at least passes the first stage of the BS test.

However, I recognize the lack of my own competence and intuition in history, and I recognize that a book which is appropriate for an historian may do more harm in the way I am using it, which is as a textbook survey to get a better understanding of the topic.

While there was a post a while back on how to evaluate if a source is credible, I'd like to know if and how laymen should read flawed sources.

Is the foreword just being melodramatic, and I could probably muddle my way through the book with my regular BS detector? Should I even bother with outdated sources at all and only stick to more recent books? Is there a way historians use when dealing with books which have some truths and some falsehoods?

Apologies to the mods, I posted this earlier without skimming the wiki, so I deleted it, went through the wiki, and after not finding anything that answered my question or was in the topic I was interested in, which was freeholder farmers in feudal Europe, I decided to post this question again.

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Approximately where and when did the rumor that public corporations have a "primary legal/fiduciary obligation to generate a return for shareholders" originate (in the US, at least)?

This may be difficult to pin-down, but, nonetheless, I'm curious.

This is one claim within the field of 'economics', by and large, that I just don't get? Like... as far as I can tell- based on my occasional, independent 'research' on the topic- this.. is kind of a "myth" that, after a while, just 'took on a life of its own', so it operates almost as a sort of "business-world truism"? Especially since, from what I can tell, there are, in fact, *quite a few companies* here in the US that *don't*, oftentimes, make "value for shareholders" their number-1 priority, esp. firms like Costco (or Aldi and/or Trader Joes, to name a few) which, over the years, have, I think, been run on a more "stakeholder capitalism" type of model? And you almost-never hear about those firms getting prosecuted by the gov't, at least for *that* reason alone ("not prioritizing shareholders")

Like... *are* there any major, oft-enforced laws (esp. at the state level) and/or recent court rulings- again, in the US (if not similar nations)- that do, in fact, "require" the executives running publicly-traded corporations to, as their 'main/foremost duty' under the law to "generate value for shareholders"? *Can* a shareholder who, say, owns stock in Walmart, in theory, "sue" the firm if they "have hard evidence" that its executives and managers, "didn't try to maximize return for shareholders"?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

The Catholic church claims to know the complete list of all 266 popes who reigned from the 1st to the 21st century, starting with St Peter himself. They also give exact dates for the duration of their papacies for nearly all of them. How credible is this from the perspective of a historian?

2 Answers 2022-05-13

Prison and police abolitionists suggest that prisons and police were only invented within the last few hundred years. How accurate is this statement from a historian's perspective? Where did police and prisons come from?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

What is the historical reason why Bahasa Indonesia and Bahasa Melayu are mutually intelligible despite the extremely large geographic spread while Tagalog and Cebuano in the Philippines are closer together yet are mutually unintelligible with each other and with both Bahasas?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

What are good books to read about the USSR, for someone who has little knowledge about the subject?

I've gotten back into reading recently and am looking for some recommendations. I don't have much knowledge of the USSR besides the absolute basics. I'd prefer a book that paints a general picture of the Soviet Union, from what life was like for the common people to the general history of the various regimes that held power and important events in the country. I know I'm already asking a lot but most importantly I would like a book that doesn't read like a textbook, but has some character and soul to it. And also, preferably not textbook sized (ie not over 500 pages). I'm not entirely sure such a book exists, or perhaps multiple books covering different parts of the USSR would be better.

edit: also part of my reason for asking this question here is I'm looking for an unbiased source. It's sort of hard to cut through the noise and bias when so many people are extremely biased against or for the USSR.

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Huey Newton gave a famous gay rights speech in 1970, defending their struggles for equality. To what extent did the Black Panthers support LGBT rights?

Text of Newton's speech

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Why does the US have military bases in Germany?

I searched a little bit and wasn't really finding the answer I was looking for with the usual required effort. I would love to hear from a historian about the subject.

Cheers

1 Answers 2022-05-13

The Cold War often focuses on the conflict between the US and USSR as a fight between capitalism and communism. However, China was also developing as a strong communist nation this time. Why is it often left out of the conversation/left out of the conflict?

Especially curious about this because some of the most notable cold war conflicts, such as the Vietnam and Korean Wars, happened in China’s backyard. And today, China has been left out of the conflict.

Another thing that’s interesting is that China, despite known for its tech development, did not focus on developing the same nuclear fire power as the US and USSR have. Why did China not follow suit in the Cold War era?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Two questions about Shakespeare. How well known was Shakespeare outside of England when he was still alive ? Did he live life comparable to modern day celebrities (like signing autographs) ?

1 Answers 2022-05-13

Why didn't William Marbury get his judge commission after Marbury v Madison?

So from my understanding, Marbury v Madison ruled that Marbury had a right to his commission, but that the Supreme Court could only decide the case as an appeal. So why didn't Marbury just take his case to a lower court that would have jurisdiction and then appeal to the Supreme Court if necessary? Did he somehow lose the right to the case after having "lost" it once, did he just not bother, or am I misunderstanding something here?

1 Answers 2022-05-12

Have mental illnesses increased drastically over the past few decades, or is it simply that we know more about identifying them? Have they always been so common?

1 Answers 2022-05-12

What was Israel like before Judaism?

1 Answers 2022-05-12

Between "Funiculì, funiculà" and "Tarantella napoletana" (links inside), how did Neapolitan music become the default "soundtrack" to represent Italy in media made outside Italy?

Tarantella Napoletana

Funiculì Funiculà

1 Answers 2022-05-12

"Double value" medieval soldiers?

I read once about certain elite warriors in an army, that were given twice as much pay as regulars (ostensibly because they were as useful as two men) These fellows would be the ones wielding zwiehanders and other huge weapons, tasked with defending river crossings or other crucial points.
Was this an actual thing, or have I just imagined up something from a fantasy novel? The ideas of zwiehanders, more pay, and guarding bridges/crossings are strongest in my mind.

I'm very interested in this topic, but I can't for the life of me remember where I read it. I'm also not able to find the right keywords to search it up so far.

1 Answers 2022-05-12

255 / 7255

Back to start