Did ancient cultures use different units of times?

Days, months, and years all seem pretty natural, so I'd have to imagine all cultures used those. But did all cultures have a concept of seconds, minutes, and hours?

2 Answers 2018-06-22

Do we know how Baldwin IV of Jerusalem contracted leprosy? And how did he not infect his household and servants?

I saw a reference of Baldwin needing to be carried on a knight’s Back during a failed raid. Did this require the burning of the clothing and the boiling of the armor?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Searching for a book on Russian tyranny.

Hello folks, I was wondering if there were any scholarly books about the russian revolution that talk about the people at the top pre and post holding power. Interested to see how much power changed political leaders and idealists. I guess if I really get down to it I would like to know if the people at the top were always bad/good people or if they grew into something else after holding significant power? I suppose the book doesnt have to be about the Russian Revolution but I figure that period is chock full of leadership changes.

1 Answers 2018-06-22

During the Great Depression, where did the money come from to initiate the New Deal and WW2 if everybody was broke?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Cinderella is a classic folk/fairytale known to millions that has been told in different versions throughout Europe and Asia. Why does this story, and other similar folk tales show up in many different cultures despite no obvious religious or political significance?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Friday Free-for-All | June 22, 2018

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

11 Answers 2018-06-22

How did people throughout ancient history explain static electricity?

It's crazy that with the lights off, tiny little volts of electricity can literally illuminate the bedroom wall for very brief moments when moving your legs under the blankets creating static shocks. What did people of the past think static electricity was and are there any superstitious explanations of it from ancient history?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Why does Argentina have such a small black population in comparison to other South and Central American countries?

Watching the World Cup, Argentina has no dark skinned players whilst countries such as Brazil and Costa Rica seem to have a large contingent of players who appear to be of African descent, Is there a historic reason for this. Also, is there a reason there are so many Italian sounding names in the Argentine squad?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

How was the 3rd Reich's relationship with the major religions ?

Hi /r/AskHistorians !

I am wondering about the relationship between Hitler's 3rd Reich and the major religions during WW2.

I was taught that the Catholic Church's position was not very clear during that period, and I wonder we have enough evidence to support that claim.

Also, how did the Jewish authorities react to the antisemitic actions of the Reich, if they ever did ?

Finally, what was Hitler's view on muslims, and did he ever try to interact with their authorities ?

Thank you for answering !

1 Answers 2018-06-22

How did the Confederate leadership convince the common Southerner to fight for their cause?

The various declarations of secession, the Cornerstone Speech, etc made it clear that slavery was the main driving point for the Confederate leadership's decision to secede. Combined with the Confederate Conscription Act which made eligible men who owned 20 or more slaves exempt, why did the common non-slave owning Southerner buy into the Confederate cause? From hindsight, it looks like non-wealthy Southerners were fighting on behalf of wealthy Southerners will no real benefit to themselves.

1 Answers 2018-06-22

A few questions about ancient Chinese states and the terminology of "Han Chinese"

1: Did the ancient Chinese Han state and empire, have anything to do with the terminological of "Han Chinese"?

2: Also, throughout Chinese history, these are many state names that are repeated (Chu, Jin, Qi etc) Are these states as their previous counter part? So are they all named by their geographical position?

3: Did all of these states with the same name share any similarity except for their name?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

The idea that children should be a protected class is relatively modern;the notion that 'children should be seen and not heard' was common even a hundred years ago, at least British cultural depictions;how did the idea that childhood is a special time that should be cherished develop? What drove it?

as late as Victorian times, children worked in mills, mines, and chimneys. What triggered the realization that such practices were appalling? Was it driven by politics, morality, religion, some kind of mixture of the three, or smething else?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Did past civilisations try and predict what future technology would be like?

Did the likes of the Greeks and Romans have ideas about what future technology would be able to accomplish, in the same way that we discuss possibilities like holograms, flying cars etc?

Or was it just a case of someone using the current technology would come up with an idea of how to improve/invent something?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Is there any estimation as to how much information regarding the Yijing (I Ching) has been lost?

This question obviously covers a very broad time period; unfortunately I don't know much about the Yijing, but I have a vague understanding that Mao's cultural revolution would likely have destroyed a lot of the scholarship surrounding it, I'm just not sure to what degree. I'm sure I remember reading about a famous pre-20th century Chinese Library burning down, but I might be mistaken.

As well as hints about lost information, I'd be very interested to hear about obscure or esoteric arrangements, uses, and texts surrounding the 64 symbols. I'm aware of two or three arrangements - are there more?

The Zhou Yi is magnificent, but for some reason very little attention is paid to anything else. Is this because of a lack of information, my not knowing where to look, or was the Zhou Yi really pretty much it?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Admiral Zheng He is commonly regarded as Muslim, but he also wrote about his devotion to the sea goddess Tianfei. Was syncretism with polytheistic aspects common among 14th and 15th century Muslims in Ming Dynasty China?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Did the Ottomans have plans to retake Mecca after WWI?

During the Arab Revolt, Mecca was lost to the Arabs fairly early in 1916. As the holiest city in Islam, you would think that the religious legitimacy of the Ottoman sultan as Caliph would depend on them maintaining control of the city. However, it seems that the Ottoman plans for late in the war and post-war took a more pan-Turkic route rather than a pan-Islamic one, especially after the capitulation of Russia. Was there a plan in place to re-establish Ottoman control over cities like Mecca, and to a lesser extent Jerusalem and Baghdad, or were they considered essentially lost to the British and the Arabs?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Germanic literature in early modern Europe.

Early Modern English scholars like Laurence Nowell and Sir Robert Bruce Cotton seem to have studied or at the very least had an interest in Anglo-Saxon literature (as evidenced by their ownership of the only manuscript of Beowulf). Was this interest in old Germanic literature paralleled in other Early Modern European literary circles? For example, did Scandinavian scholars of the 16th and 17th centuries study the Sagas? Did their French and Imperial counterparts study old Frankish literature?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

What was food like for soldiers fighting in WW2 on all the major powers sides? (British, American, German, Soviet, Japanese)

Would solders fighting in WW2 eat canned rations front the start of their service all the way through till the end of the war or would their be other types of food or actual cooked meals given to them from time to time?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

What was the difference between women and men’s labor camps during Nazi Germany?

I understand they deprecated the genders into different camps. But where these camps identical? What differences were there in the types of labor?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Was duelling just well ordered public murder?

I know nothing of duelling, but I imagine it fulfilled an important legal role in some societies. What were some duelling laws, was it as simple as a public declaration of intent to murder, and that made it less illegal?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Are the old Disney movie's portrayal of racial groups (Dumbo's Crows, Peter Pan's Indians, ETC.) Only a modern controversy or did people have problems with them back when they came out too?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Why are there polytheistic, monotheistic and even atheistic schools of Hinduism?

Hinduism has always been a very confusing religion for me. Having been to Nepal (a very Hindu country) I found it strange that people would talk about the many different Hindu gods and yet would also frequently make reference to "God" in a seemingly monotheistic sense.

I later learned that Hinduism in fact has many different "schools" with wildly-differing philosophies. All are based on the Vedas, but some are monotheistic, others polytheistic and others agnostic or atheistic. I don't know how much influence these schools have over your average lay Hindu, but it is strange that such contradictory philosophies are supposedly part of the same religion. So how did these different schools develop and why are they all considered part of Hinduism while the Buddhists and Jains (who are also related) are not?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

After horses were introduced to the Plains Indians, did they develop similar horse archery tactics as the Steppe nomads?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

Would it be fair to argue that World War I and World War II was just one thirty year conflict?

I don't personally believe them to be so, but just for argument's sake.

2 Answers 2018-06-22

How long did it take for early humans to travel during the migration periods, and how far could they get?

1 Answers 2018-06-22

⯇ 2558 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start