When did English supplant Latin as the language of science and mathematics?

2 Answers 2017-09-29

Did people make paper airplanes before the airplane was invented?

2 Answers 2017-09-29

How could WWI officers tell if a soldier deserted or was just killed and the body was never recovered?

1 Answers 2017-09-29

What was the Eastern Orthodox Church's perspective on the First Crusade 1095-1099?

I'm trying to make the distinction between the Church as a religious institution and the Empire that it was weaved with at the time. So far, I've found some secondary monographs (especially one by Steven Runciman called "The Eastern Schism") and a primary source that may be helpful is the Alexiad. However, I want to paint a fuller picture. I know primary sources are limited, but maybe there are chronicles of the Orthodox layperson's perspective? I also can't find anything about the Patriarch of Constantinople Nicholas III Grammatikos (other than his background). Most importantly, I like to find and read journal articles, but perhaps I am searching too narrow.

Thanks for your help!

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Old Norse to Younger Futhark Runes?

Hey guys - I've been gathering information about my clan name - "Kerr" - for a while now and one of the most commonly accepted origins for the last name is that it stems from the old norse "Kjárr" - Meaning marsh dweller (we lived in heavily wooded border areas).

I was hoping to convert the Old Norse to Younger Futhark runes but most guides and translators seem to be about converting English to runes rather than old norse - the guide I did find wasn't very beginner friendly and required an intermediate knowledge to use - I can't find much information on accented letters like á for example.

I know there are a few common rules to keep in mind, such as the same symbol never appearing twice in a row etc.

can anyone give me a hand here? thanks again dudes.

1 Answers 2017-09-29

This might sound silly but what did a librarian do in Library of Alexandria at its height?

1 Answers 2017-09-29

When did it become expected of western women to shave?

When did it become societally expected of women to shave their legs and armpits? How did it start? Was it initially seen as indecent, like how shaved genitalia still is seen in parts of the world? When were "women's" razors first introduced commercially?

2 Answers 2017-09-29

How do historians fact check that things recorded a long time ago actually happened? Are there any interesting things people recorded that historians today aren't so sure about?

1 Answers 2017-09-29

What was the name of the person who lived on a mountain or pillar for 30-40 years?

I read a long time ago that a man in either ancient greece or rome lived on a mountain or pillar for many many decades. I remember reading this in the guiness world records.

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Was warfare in Medieval Europe "undeveloped," "inferior," or "ineffective" against/compared to other places in the world during the Dark/Middle Ages?

I know it sounds like a stupid and entirely ignorant question, but as someone who is very interested in Medieval history and hoping to make a living learning/teaching it, I thought it'd be prudent to ask regardless. However, I'll be honest, that's not the only reason I ask.

Recently I've been posed with the argument that the European "style" of warfare during the Middle Ages was generally pathetic compared to the "style(s)" used in other regions, and was overall really ineffective against "superior" foreign tactics/strategy/skill. Most notably were the comparisons to the Mongol Invasions.

Furthermore, they claim that European knights of the period were nothing but a joke; guys riding horse with exceedingly heavy armor used for a extremely limited role on the battlefield and used to scare and kill peasants everywhere else. When faced with foreign forces[Vikings(lol), Muslims, Mongols, etc. as per the argument's examples], they were brought down handily.

I consider both arguments to be entirely nonsensical and might perhaps be fueled by a bit of bias(he notably says we when speaking about how eastern forces easily dealt with knights), but in trying to answer the former, I don't want to just pull things out of my ass. I could just say "that's not true," but then my counterargument would be just as presumably baseless as the original argument. Additionally, while I'd consider myself more learned on the subject since the time I've gotten into Medieval history, my knowledge is still extremely limited. I don't know of all that many battles during the period, even less so if we're talking about the time during the Mongol invasions. So while I think his arguments aren't valid, I don't think I'd perform any service to anyone if I "debunked" them with vague and possibly unfounded examples of why European medieval military tactics and strategy *didn't" suck.

So if possible, could anyone here help me out, sources n' all? Anything about battles or medieval European tactics/strategy that might disprove the points? Or is my opponent right about this? I'm not afraid to admit when I'm wrong so as long as what's being presented in opposition is well-grounded.

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Anybody know a non christian source of information about Dr. Livingstone?

I'm fascinated by this story and want to know more. Anything helps...

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Thoughts on the new Ken Burns Vietnam War documentary? How accurate/biased is it?

Hi,

I hope this question isn't too "off-topic" for this subreddit. Basically, I haven't seen the series yet, but wanted to watch it as I want to learn more about the Vietnam War. Though I've been hearing some mixed things about it. Some say it is very good and pretty thorough, others are criticizing it. This article in particular seems to take issue with it's supposed lack of focus on civilian costs of the war, and a lot of people in the comments say it gives a biased view of the US perspective (that it's not critical enough of US government and military) and that it glosses over or ignores Vietnam's perspective on the war.

Has anyone here seen it and can give their thoughts? Note, I'm not asking for someone to list out all the nitpicked minor inaccuracies and little details. I'm just looking for big picture things. Obviously almost every documentary has some issues, but I just want to know if there are any glaring fundamental flaws before I spend hours watching it.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Where did the mythological popes end, and the historical ones start?

I will make one thing clear from the get go: this question is asked from the perspective of an atheist. And based on my world view, I am pretty certain of two things:

  1. Pope Francis is very much a real person

  2. The existence of the first pope, St Peter, is debatable

However; there is an alleged unbroken chain of 264 other popes, connecting the two men through history. So my question is this: Who is the earliest "historical" pope, meaning the first pope that we know was an historical figure?

2 Answers 2017-09-29

If Hitler studied Napoleon extensively, why did he still invade Russia?

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Are there instances of young boys marrying older women in Medieval/Renaissance England?

I know there are instances of older men marrying young girls (though from what I understand it wasn't as common as thought) such as Margaret Beaufort marrying Edmund Tudor when she was 12 and he was 24, but was the opposite true as well?

2 Answers 2017-09-29

When Bismarck said "An appeal to fear never finds an echo in German hearts," did he mean that the Germans could easily be motivated by fear or that they couldn't?

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Was Neil Armstrong not the first man on the moon?

Hello historians! Today in class I mentioned that the first man on the Moon was Neil Armstrong. To my surprise, I was quickly corrected by about half of my classmates (about 10) and the professor, who told me that I was, in fact, wrong; the USSR had actually sent a man to the moon a year before the US. Being a space nerd, I was shocked by my apparent basic misunderstanding of history, so after class I asked about it. One of the students told me that in reality, the Soviets had sent a man to the surface of the moon in a capsule, but that he never actually did any EVA- and the US government hid it from us to keep us patriotic and happy. I've looked around but I can't find any information on a Soviet manned lunar mission predating ours. This seemed odd to me, as one would think that if the government were hiding these things from us, they'd also hide the Venera missions, when the Soviets sent something to another planet for the first time. Am I a complete idiot or is this some conspiracy theory? Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-09-29

Inter Tribal warfare of native americans

How was warfare of Native Americans fought and what was it fought over pre Colombian times.Were they fought like european wars just with lesser technology?Or were natives to spread out to focus on warfare for resources and territory?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Did the Ancient Romans drench themselves in the blood of an animal they were sacrificing?

I'm watching HBOs Rome which is supposed to be a far more accurate depiction of Rome compared to most other media portraying it, and in a scene where the character Atia is sacrificing a bull to the gods, her and an altar are beneath where the bulls throat is cut and she is drenched in its blood. Is this a real thing they did? What did they believe the benefit of this was? Was it to a specific god or gods?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

I'm a king in an average sized European castle in the Middle Ages. How do I get candles? Surely my candle use would be enormous. Do I have a guy whose sole job is candle maker, or do I have to import them from somewhere else?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Is there any evidence that the Ostrogoths used slingers in late antiquity Rome? My university runs a historical tabletop war gaming interterm in which students battle each other using 4th century historical correct armies. You are allowed to add units to your roster as long as you have proof.

As stated above each student battles one another in a tournament system that uses units from a roster. Units cost different based on a variety of stats including morale armor and unit type, as well as any special weapons they might carry. I.e. Bows and ranged weapons add 20 points to the overall costs

My army for this class is the ostrogoths, and I am fairly certain they had slingers based on other Germanic tribes including the visigoths. I've read several scholarly articles as well as 2 books. Unfortunately it doesn't seem like the early goths cared much for their scholars. :(

1 Answers 2017-09-28

In Western Europe in the Middle Ages, was it really the case that priests or monks could and did engage in deadly combat, so long as they used a blunt weapon (due to a very literal interpretation of a prohibition on shedding blood)?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Kids these days like to pretend sticks are guns by repeatedly going "pew, pew, pew" like modern day automatic firearms. But did kids in the 1700's do the same thing except they would pretend to do the loading procedure for a musket every time they "shoot?"

I.e., would a kid in the 18th century who's playing with a stick and pretending it's a musket pretend to pull the hammer to full-cock, pour the powder in the barrel, shove the ball down the barrel with the ramrod, etc.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

After the Romans defeated a kingdom's or tribe's armies, how did they maintain control of the area?

This is obviously a very broad question. I imagine it must have been very hard to maintain control of a hostile populace before the invention of radios, internal combustion engines, aerial surveillance and accurate maps.

But the Romans did so anyway, even if they had to spend decades fighting a guerilla war in parts of Spain and Israel. Hell, it seems like Caesar pacified Gaul mostly by fighting a series of conventional battles of the course of a decade. How did the Romans get the locals to buy-in afterwards?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

in Band of Brothers, the 101st seems to be far more competent than their German opponents. How realistic is this?

2 Answers 2017-09-28

⯇ 3101 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start