Nazi Germany had strict laws on animal cruelty and environmentalism relative to its time, how did the Nazis reconcile this respect for animals with their disrespect and abuse for certain human life?

Adolf Hitler himself was a vegetarian, and much of his inner circle was composed of people who abhorred animal experimentation and other practices. How did the Nazis reconcile such views with their willingness to disregard the rights and safety of other humans?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

What was the most common occupation in the American Colonies during the American Revolution?

We were learning about The American Revolution and I was curious: What were some of the most prevalent occupations during this time? I'm sure farmers, indentured servants, and slaves were among the most common. Which common occupation had the most influence? (Slaveowning Merchants? Printers? etc.) Thanks.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

How did people in ancient times completely destroy cities? Cartharge as example

I've always wondered how these ancient civilizations were able to completely level cities when it comes to warfare. Nowadays we have bombers, artillery etc. which are able to destroy cities but what measures were taken in ancient times to ensure "total" destruction?

Thanks in advance :)

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in September 28 2017:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2017-09-28

Did Martin Luther condemn peasants because he truly believed that they were acting like savages, or was he trying to look good for the political leaders that the peasants went against?

Or was it a mixture of both? Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

How deadly were combat engagements in ww2?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

At what point did the fall of the Western Roman Empire become inevitable?

I know there have been many questions based upon the fall of Rome, however what they oft fail to mention or include is the fall of the Western Roman Empire as a whole.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

How did allied leaders travel safely to attend those famous conferences during the Second World War?

We all know those famous photographs of Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt from the various conferences they attended during the war. According to wikipedia, Churchill and Stalin first met at the second Moscow Conference of 1942, while Churchill and Roosevelt had been meeting in person (mainly on North American soil) since 1941, and all three of them first had a conference in Tehran in 1943.

It seems, however, like it would have been really hard to safely get these leaders to the same place to have these meetings. This is for a few reasons:

-This was before there were reliable airliners capable of transoceanic flight

-The North Atlantic was threatened by German U-boat activity

-The Pacific was, likewise, threatened by Japanese aircraft and submarines.

-The Soviet Union was separated from Western Europe by the entirety of the Third Reich, as well as their allies (Romania, Italy, etc.)

-These leaders would have made very tempting targets, and German spies would no doubt have been trying to figure out their travel plans so that they could be attacked en route.

So how did they do it? How do you get a VIP halfway around the world when much of the territory you have to cross is controlled or threatened by the enemy?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Books that deal with India's caste system and white supremacism

Are there any books that deal with those topics and compares them? I know too little about the Indian caste system but I'm writing a paper about it and thought it would be a good idea to compare it to white supremacism. I don't know, maybe I'm saying something stupid. What are your thoughts?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Where did the racial theory of there being 3 races, descended from Noah's 3 sons, originate? How did it spread?

I thought this was a late-medieval European theory, but I heard one of my Saudi Arabian students talk about it recently, and so I wondered where the theory originated (obviously Muslims also have the story of Noah and his sons, so could come up with the idea as easily as Europeans), and how it spread (for example, was this an indigineous Arab theory, or one spread there by say, the British Empire).

1 Answers 2017-09-28

How influential was Hugh Hefner and "Playboy" magazine in the sexual revolution, and the general shift in sexual mores, of the mid-20th century?

With Hefner's passing today, this seemed an appropriate question to ask! While today Playboy is seen, if anything, as kind of stodgy I'd venture, given the proliferation of pornography that is far beyond the airbrushed centerfolds which made it famous (and really, hasn't that been the case for a few decades now? Compare to Penthouse or Hustler, which forced Playboy to change things up to a degree), my vague impression is that it was pretty progressive in its own way back when it debuted, pushing a fairly shocking openness to sexuality, and accompanying it with progressive minded reporting and literature (Some people really do read it for the articles!!!). But was "Playboy" itself leading the wave of the '50s-'60s, or more just riding it and benefiting in the popular mindset due to its enduring place in the pop-cultural landscape?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

When in history did we start to use GDP as a measure of wealth of a country ?

2 Answers 2017-09-28

What would a "typical" raid on a Roman villa look like during the 3rd Servile War?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

When did surnames become a "thing" (i.e. a hereditary legal requirement)?

I was venting to my sister about a difficult day I'd had at the library because like 90% of the men mentioned in a particular bishop's register were called John and it was hard for me to keep track of them. She asked why I didn't just refer to them by surname - but that's not always possible with medieval surnames. Many people didn't even claim to have a surname (e.g. 'John, of the village of Hampstead ...). As far as forming one went, I guess you could technically have

  • father's name (John Wayne)
  • patronym (John Watson)
  • occupation (John Smith)
  • place of birth, especially for monastics.

What I want to know is: when did surnames become 'fixed' and hereditary? When would John Smith's son Thomas remain Thomas Smith and not call himself Thomas Baker or Thomas Butcher?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

What would the average norsemen eat during his average day? (Excluding feasts, and celebrations)

There's really no background as to why I need an answer to this question, but my curiosity got the best of me. Even if anyone doesn't know the answer I would appreciate it if I could be pointed towards where to find my answer. Much thanks !

2 Answers 2017-09-28

Why did the Byzantine empire collapse in 1204?

I'm an avid fan of history and have been reading a few books on Byzantium from authors such as Johnathan Harris, Michael Angold, and a few others with some light reading on Villehardouin and Robert of Clari. To me it seems the Byzantine Empire fell due to it being a shadow of its former self - Possessing only Asia Minor and the Balkans at this time, they no longer had Greek fire which might have been used to stop the crusader ships through barring entry to the Golden Horn. Nor were they able to pay off the Crusaders and Venetians, a feat which they might have been able to accomplish had they still posessed Syria and Egypt, or yet even still had the battle of Manzikert not been lost.

Obviously this is rather simplistic, but; why did the Byzantine empire fall in 1204? and can we argue that it was inevitable that it would collapse sooner or later? But then this brings us back to the resurgence of Byzantine rule in 1261... Thanks for taking the time to read.

3 Answers 2017-09-28

Why is New York City the most ''powerful'' and popular city in the U.S. and not its capital Washington D.C.?

3 Answers 2017-09-28

What are some of the ideological features of Eastern European communist historiography? Were academic Historians under a lot of pressure to toe the party line, and does this render some or much of their work less useful for a student of history today?

I'm asking because I was reading a book about Siberian folk religion written by a Hungarian academic in the 1950s and it lays on the ideology pretty thick, talking approvingly about the "need" for Soviet authorities to proactively crush said folk religions rather than merely letting them "die out", which is somewhat at odds with trends in Western academia supporting the rights of first nations. I wondered if the inclusion of this kind of orthodox communist ideology was a prerequisite for getting your work published in communist countries before 1989.

I was also interested in subtler manifestations of this phenomenon, hoping that someone might comment with a rough guide to interpreting the writings of communist academics.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

I have read many articles praising Germany and Switzerland for their apprenticeship system which makes their Industry globally competitive. How did they develop in the context of Modern Industry? Why didn't it develop in other countries like the US?

3 Answers 2017-09-28

Did Henry II expect a war when he married Eleanor of Aquitaine immediately after her annulment from Louis VII? How is it that the king of England stealing (more or less) the king of France's wife (herself ruler of one of the richest duchies in Europe) didn't cause a war?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

Was there a systematic genocide of Arab christians in the Ottoman empire during WW1?

Were Arab christians facing the same fate as Armenians, Assyrians, and Greeks in Anatolia? if not, what was the difference?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

I grew up in Berkeley CA, everyone hated Columbus, Columbus day, Now I live in Colombia.. Also Southpark just did an episode about Columbus... Was Columbus really bad??? Does he deserve his bad rep?

I have recently read this study on Columbus true motives: https://www.amherst.edu/system/files/columbus.pdf

to me it seems he was not a genocidal maniac as I had been taught at Berkeley High.. I had been taught he was the worst... Seems he was just a devout religious man who did not disrespect indigenous people, he seemed to compliment and have adoration for the caribes.. He had a worldview much much different than today, religion seemed on a completely different level, Christianity to him wasn't christianity, it was absolute truth. Seems he was just a normal explorer that got lucky, and did all he could to fund his final crusade for the spanish crown.. Does he deserve his reputation?

2 Answers 2017-09-28

Could anyone suggest a book about 1100s or 1200s Britain (or the time period inspired Game Of Thrones), basically about the Family Politics in Britain?

A more dramatic retelling would be awesome, and hopefully a non-biased book.

Edit: A YouTube video, documentary or a MOOC will be cool too.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

What is the history of gravy? What's the earliest gravy recipe we have? How similar (or different) is it from the gravy we're familiar with?

1 Answers 2017-09-28

English Parliament, 1265, and related matters.

I'm wondering about the formation of the English parliament, which I'm led to believe occurred in the year 1265. More specifically:

  • What political, social, and/or economic factors influenced the formation of parliament? And how is the English political context different from that of comparable monarchic states?
  • What was the general political position of the common classes? Nobility? Monarchy?
  • What were the powers of early parliament and how did they interact with, or compete with, aristocratic and monarchic authority?
  • I'm led to believe that English parliament has more to do with modern democratic institutions (such as, well, the modern parliamentary institutions of modern nation states) than examples such as republican Rome or Athens. If so, are there particular reasons our modern cultural narrative is modelled on the Greco-Roman example? If not, how did English parliament change and adapt to become the parliamentary systems we have in today's democratic nation states?

As you can probably tell, there are two main thematic questions: What happened? and How was our modern cultural narrative shaped?

Thanks for any insight.

1 Answers 2017-09-28

⯇ 3103 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start