Was Robert E. Lee actually a good general?

I'm not trying to rip off the previous question posed about George Washington, but a comment by u/secessionisillegal got me thinking. The user commented to paraphrase, "Robert E. Lee who was much loved by his troops but his battlefield prowess was spotty and, ultimately, unsuccessful." As a man raised in Virginia and a fan of history, I was always taught of General Lee's brilliance on the battlefield when odds were forever not in his favor. Despite the obvious Gettysburg battle, was not General Lee a brilliant tactician?

3 Answers 2017-09-22

It is 1922, and I am a moderately successful shop owner from Indiana who wants to invest his money in the stock market. Which companies of that time period would be considered safe or prudent investments and how would I transfer my money to buy shares of a company?

What sort companies did people of that era believe to be smart investments and how did an average person transfer their money to Wall Street in exchange for stock?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

What was life like for the escaped slave community living in Canada and how well did Canadians receive these refugees?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

Where did vegetarians get vitamin B12

How did ancient vegetarians, for example buddhists, get enough vitamin B12? Did they simply drink enough milk or use other dairy products, or did they collectively have health issues due to deficiency?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

Why did Mark Antony hate Cicero enough to have him assassinated?

What exactly constituted the beef between Cicero and Mark Antony? I know Cicero accused him of being gay, but was there more to it than that? Was Cicero being slanderous towards him, or were his criticisms justified?

Was Mark Antony a bad guy in general by the standards of who he was as a Roman politician? Obviously murder is wrong even if someone is trying to ruin your reputation, and he must have really hated Cicero's guts to display his head on a pike in the Forum, but it seems like assassinations of political opponents was pretty commonplace in Rome.

2 Answers 2017-09-22

Why did the tunic fall out of favor in Europe?

It seemed like such a ubiquitous piece of clothing that just ceased to be worn in mass by the end of the Middle Ages.

I’m mostly interested in the transition from it in Britain.

1 Answers 2017-09-22

When did the concept of 3 meals a day originate, how did it spread, and how did it affect day to day life?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

In the current frontpage question about George Washington, a responder claims that he was facing "seriously competent enemies". What made the British military of this time so fearsome and powerful compared to other nations?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-09-22

When Eazy-E recorded "Real Muthafukkin G's" with Dresta and B. G. Knocc Out, was he expecting them to become big things like Dr. Dre's protégés Snoop Dogg and Eminem did?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

I'm a soldier I the civil war, even revolutionary war. How and when do I get paid?

Follow up: If i die, would my family get paid and how?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

How did Hitler actually write Mein Kampf?

Did he have a typewriter in prison or did he write by hand? Are there any first drafts left or personal notes and commentaries? I was always interested how he was allowed to write and was able to get the necessary tools in prison, and also whether there are any of the artifacts left from that time. Considering that the Nazis had a tendency to make any objects related to Hitler near sacred.

1 Answers 2017-09-22

How did Japanese feudalism during the Shogunate compare to that of Western Europe during the high middle ages?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

Were the early American colonists disproportionately from any specific places in England or were all places in England fairly equally represented in the American colonies?

Were there any specific areas of origin in England that were over or under represented? If so what were they and what was the reason for this disparity in representation?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

In 1975 why was Gough Whitlam dismissed as Australian prime minister?

Might need to ELI5 because I have done some reading around the Constitutional crisis and I'm still not totally clear on the reasons.

1 Answers 2017-09-22

Did Prussia really spend 90% of its budget on its military?

I am reading a book, "The Art of Warfare in the Age of Napoleon" which has made the above claim, at least during the 18th century. However, this is a staggeringly high percentage and I find it hard to believe. Is it true, and if not, what did Prussia actually spend on its military?

Additionally, what did other European powers of that time (18th century) spend on their militaries?

2 Answers 2017-09-22

Need help learning interesting stuff about Benjamin Franklin

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-09-22

How did the Allies ‘turn the tide’ of war in the Pacific in WW2?

I recently took a class in military history where the subject of the war in the Pacific was glossed over and not explained thoroughly. I understand Midway was a major turning point in the battle for the Pacific, but what else did the Allies do to secure their chances of winning?

1 Answers 2017-09-22

What does it mean when a ruler conquers lands? For example, when leaders expanded their empires, did they kill the indiginous people or simply gain power through taxation?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

Is there any record of what Pompey saw in the Holy of Holies in 63BCE?

I've heard it mentioned that after conquering Jerusalem and putting it to the sword, Pompey entered the Holy of Holies in the Holy Temple of Jerusalem.

Is there any record of what he saw while he was in there?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

Are there any good studies/articles about the urban division of Berlin?

Hello! I have been looking for a read that tackles the urban impact of the wall on the city of Berlin during its existence and after its destruction in 1990, but I haven't been lucky enough to find something that talks about this exact subject. Any suggestions?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

Why did Nazi Germany waste so much time and resources on superweapon projects during the war? Was there no one in Germany military high command that petitioned for a more effective use of resources?

As a follow-up question:Could discontent over this waste of resources have played a part in the assassination attempt on Hitler in 1944?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

In the event of cheating or other underhanded conduct during a duel, how would cheating be determined and by who? Would the legal system take over from there, presumably charging them with murder?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

Can there be genocides before nation states? Is the mass slaughtering of some tribe by a another tribe in ancient world considered as genocide?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

How tall/large were English longbowmen?

I've heard that many English archers were recruited from the peasantry and expected to practice their shooting weekly either at home or in a group setting. I've also assumed that "able bodied" men capable of bending an English warbow appeared in a variety of sizes, but a handful of archery experts on YouTube insist that there were unwritten height standards that the nobility enforced. I know next to nothing on this subject myself; I'm curious what reddit's opinion of this is.

2 Answers 2017-09-21

Did the Ottoman declaration of a holy war during World War One actually influence any Muslims?

1 Answers 2017-09-21

⯇ 3117 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start