Could the flight of Protestants in County Cork, Ireland in 1920 be counted as "ethnic cleansing"

Good Evening/Afternoon or Morning

I'm preparing for a seminar at university on "Terror in Ireland 1919-1923" While doing my readings I've been presented with the argument of Peter Hart who claims that Cork's Protestant population fell by around 40% during the period of 1911-1926 with a disproportionate percentage of that drop in the years of 1920-1922.

Hart calls this "ethnic cleansing" and lists nine counties throughout Ireland he claims this takes place, including County Cork. He also positions the IRA as acting as the vanguard of some sort of imagined community, and places their actions against spies and informers as part of a wider campaign of intimidation and terrorising against the Protestant population of Cork.

My question then is this; Did the IRA regularly employ sectarian rhetoric in it's propaganda and literature ect. And if so was this ever followed through upon with specific events targeting Protestants based on their sect?

Thank you

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How common were bandit attacks on stagecoaches and towns like those seen in Western movies?

Movies like The Magnificent Seven and For A Few Dollars More show large criminal gangs attacking towns and ambushing trains and stage coaches, with law and order essentially left in the hands of mercenaries and bounty hunters. I assume that's all a massive exaggeration for narrative purposes, but does the trope have any basis in events?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Is there any evidence for wargaming prior to the twentieth century?

Just to be clear, I'm asking about the hobby of tabletop war gaming with miniatures, not war games as in the training exercises that modern militaries engage.

I have two areas of interest that I'm hoping someone can shed light on.

Primarily I would like to know if there is evidence for any war games existing prior to modern times. It occurred to me (while buying some miniatures to use playing Crossfire) that games may have existed historically that are similar to the tabletop wargaming we have today. It would, after all, just require a set of rules and some miniatures or tokens. However, I have not had luck finding any indication that such games existed. Is there any evidence for historical war gaming? If so, then what do we know about those games and how they were played?

Second, were Go and Chess considered to be representative of military conflict?

I have read claims that the games of Chess and Go were both created to reflect warfare and that they were even considered useful teaching aids for military commanders. I'm not sure if there is good evidence for either of those points though. And, I'm especially skeptical of of the idea that military officers could apply much of that gaming experience to actual combat considering how abstract both games are. So, if there is no evidence of less stylized games, then is there any good evidence for Chess and Go being treated as combat simulations or useful training aids?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

What were some historically significant differences between the structure of the English nobility before the Norman conquest and the structure of the English nobility post-Norman conquest?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

I'm a governor of the first British colony in the Caribbean. What are my duties? How often do trade ships come from England?

What would be some of the strategic or financial reasons to invest in a colony here? What kind of goods were sought after back home?

What would some of my exports be and how self sufficient could my colony be? How often did a trade ship come by and what were they trading for?

What would happen if my countries enemies showed up with a fleet how would I send a message for help? And why would people choose to stay there?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How quickly did the kickflip spread after Rodney Mullen started doing it?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

What happened between Bernadotte and Napoleon?

I've been reading up on the Napoleonic era and I've found some conflicting information. One source says that he was fired on the spot at the battle of Wagram by the Emperor for leading his fleeing men and the other says that he handed in his resignation after his Saxon division had been slaughtered. Both of these stories sound believable, but only one can be the truth.

1 Answers 2017-03-06

What happened to the Russian aristocracy/upper classes that escaped following the 1917 revolution?

Did they end up joining aristocracy of the other countries of Europe? Did they head to the new world? Fade away?

(I'll admit to watching Downtown Abbey which includes some Russian escapees as a plotline, it got me thinking!)

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Have any sailing ships from the 1600s-1800s survived until now?

I hope this is the right place to ask this question. It seems as though we never hear about ships from that time period still being sailed or at least stored and cared for.

2 Answers 2017-03-06

Help identifying a stamp from George III (1772) period in the UK (image inside)

http://imgur.com/a/VPxqK is the image of the stamp. It is on the reverse side of an Indenture describing a lease between two yeoman in the County of York and dated 12 June, 1772. A friend owns the document and was asking me about it, but I know absolutely nothing about this period and my google searches aren't turning anything up - I think I have the wrong keywords. Any help identifying it would be amazing. Thank you.

1 Answers 2017-03-06

If I was a woman back in colonial America, what is the tiniest thing I could do to be accused of being a witch?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-03-06

How little intellectual advancement was there during the Dark Ages? Was it as bad as history says it was?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How did the us army work before it got a large standing army?

How did they train generals for the day that a war might come, were they a part of the army despite there being no war?

How about the 97% percent of the union army during the civil war, was it lead by professional generals, if so who trained them and paid for them before the war? What about the majors sergants and so on, how where the ranks assigned if there was no standing army in which to advance in rank?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Was Christianity started as a cult originally by John the Baptist?

I remember reading somewhere in that time people were expecting apocalypses because of all the bad thing that was going around them in places like Egypt, mass raiding, mass slavery etc.. so looking for an an escape people started practicing ritiauals and John the baptist went around with h is follower Jesus preaching people his form of Judaism which Jesus later picked up.

2 Answers 2017-03-06

New slave labour as economic input into Roman economy?

I've not been able to find any serious discussion of how heavily Rome depended, at any date, on new imports of slave labour. Conditions in mining especially seem to have been bad enough that constant replacement would have been needed.

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How big was technological advancement in the "Dark ages" ?

So I know that Medieval times were not era of stagnation, the infamous "Dark Ages" but how big was exactly technological advancement in that time period?
Comparing V to XV century for example.

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How did the U.S. respond to the Sino-Vietnamese War of 1979?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Was there ever a European version of seppuku?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Why didn't Carthage support Hannibal's campaign against Rome?

It's my understanding that despite his astonishing successes against Roman forces, Hannibal was kept from doing any real lasting damage, or even taking Rome, by a marked lack of support and supplies from Carthage. Why didn't the Carthaginians, seeing Hannibal steamroll through Italy, jump at their chance to take down their rival?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

What did King James I of England hope to achieve by attempting to marry Maria Anna of Spain? (1614 - 1623)

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Were (Christian) religious orders responsible for the development of music notation as we know it today?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

To what extent did Hellenistic culture and religious practices continue under the Parthian and Sassanid empires?

And did Zoroastrians tolerate Greek polytheism?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

[SERIOUS] If people believed the earth was round long before the "discovery" of gravitation, how did they explain people not falling off the other side?

Seriously, the question exactly as it is in the title. Are there any scientific or philosophical texts or anything that explain ancient and medieval people's thoughts on this matter?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

Why were so many Nazi war criminals released very early into their prison sentences?

here is a list of them

excerpts like the following are on almost all of the pages:

After World War II, he was tried in the Doctors' Trial in Nuremberg, convicted of war crimes and crimes against humanity, and was condemned to life imprisonment. His sentence was reduced to 15 years in 1951 and he was released in March 1954. Fischer subsequently regained his license to practice medicine and started a new career at the chemical company Boehringer in Ingelheim, where he stayed until his retirement.

and

At the third Ravensbrück Trial in April 1948, the British court handed her a sentence of life imprisonment. It was estimated that she had selected 3,000 women prisoners for the gas chamber and other execution methods. Rabe was released from prison on February 26, 1954, having served five years and ten months in confinement.

1 Answers 2017-03-06

How often were Christian Holy Days used to harass Jews?

I have a Jewish friend who has mentioned that "in the past," Easter was used as a time for Christians to persecute Jews, for their role in killing Jesus. I know that a lot of tragedies occurred, and "the Jews in Europe" can't be treated as a monolithic group, but as someone wanting to learn more about this history:

  1. Was this a widespread occurrence or was it limited to a few places / time periods
  2. Did it occur on many holy days (e.g. ash wednesday, christmas, etc.,) or was it specific to Easter?
  3. Was there any element of "identifying" who was a Jew and who was Christian -- for example, was the Ash Wednesday practice of wearing ashes on one's forehead ever used to identify Jewish people?

1 Answers 2017-03-06

⯇ 3562 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start