After reading the Mongol Empire by John Man and currently reading the historical fiction series by Iggulden I would like to find out more about them.
Any recommendations?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Not intended to be racial in nature. I was wondering that given the scale of the empire back then, it seems impossible for the Romans to have completely emigrated from that region when the Ottomans took over.
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Specifically in countries that gained independence from Austria, Russia, and Germany during/after WWI, such as Poland, the Baltic states, Czechoslovakia, and Hungary. We're these countries mostly dictatorships like Germany, Spain, and Italy? Or were they better able to form stable democratic governments?
I'd also be interested in the situation in the previously Ottoman states, Bulgaria, Romania, Greece, and Yugoslavia.
1 Answers 2017-01-14
It's interesting to me in that it seems like an early admission of at least some wrong doing was involved colonial/american settlers settling what was once native land.
1 Answers 2017-01-14
You may have seen them refered to before as Pelasgians, Eteocretans, Eteocypriots, Lemnians, Minoans, etc. Sometimes the terms are used interchangeably, other times not. Some posit a connection to the Sea Peoples, or the Tyrsenian language family, but neither connection has gained wide acceptance to my knowledge.
Wikipedia says this of the Pelasgians:
The name Pelasgians was used by some ancient writers to refer to populations that were either the ancestors of the Greeks or preceded the Greeks in Greece, "a hold-all term for any ancient, primitive and presumably indigenous people in the Greek world".
[...]
A tradition also survived that large parts of Greece had once been Pelasgian before being Hellenized.
Who were these supposedly pre-Greek (and pre-IE?) inhabitants of the Aegean? What are the leading theories? How could they persist into the era of writing with so little written about them?
Is the scenario I envision of them as indigenous inhabitants of the Balkans just like the modern Basques or Sami at all acurate? Did they eke out a living in remote mountain valleys while the newcomers in the plains below ignored them? Were they all enslaved? Gradually assimilated?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
1 Answers 2017-01-14
1 Answers 2017-01-14
In the musical les miserables, jean valjean is released from French prison in 1815 after a 19 year sentence. Shortly after release he has a brush with the law and is nearly returned to prison. He laments the close call noting that prison would mean going "back beneath the lash, upon the rack." Where French prisoners of this period actually subjected to rack torture?
While we're on the subject, could you actually get 19 years for stealing a loaf of bread at that time?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
From what I know, it seems fascism takes advantage of certain traits in a population. Nationalism, unity, prosperity. Powerful leaders mobilize an entire nation by crafting a common enemy, almost an 'us vs them' mindset. Why is it then only relatively recently we have had such large fascist movements? Or was it always the case, but we just saw it as the norm, people battling and swearing loyalty 'for the king'?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
For example, we have King George or Queen Elizabeth. On the other hand we have President Obama. What historical development contributed to this phenomenon?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
What was going down in the Russian political circles from Stalin's death to Khrushchev formally taking power?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
[deleted]
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Title
1 Answers 2017-01-14
We've always heard ABCs in that order? Is there a reason? Do other languages have a similar progression?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
This painting has some mysterious objects on the left plate (a red shape, some popcorn sticks, and a... a thing shaped like a "D" hanging off the edge of the plate). This other painting by the same artist has similar objects (again left plate). I have been curious about this for a long time and it just occurred to me that someone on reddit might know the answer or be able to give me an idea where to go to find out. Thanks!
edit: I think the popcorn looking stuff may be ragged comfits, similar to birignoccoluto
edit2: The letters are probably banketstaven Thanks for all the help!
3 Answers 2017-01-14
I'm reading the three musketeers. Which I believe is based on 18th century France, but I'm sure you guys will correct me if I'm wrong. The protagonists of the story (of which I'm only half through reading) all lackeys. Characters who seem to have no set reward for their duties, but rather share in the exploits of their masters in admiration and in hope to share their fame or glory.
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Aside from the fact that they were forcibly conquered, how much did being under Roman rule actually affect the average non-roman's life? Were most enslaved or allowed to remain free? Aside from not having voting and government rights were they otherwise treated as an obvious underclass? Would quality of life noticeably improve or worsen? Or did they just tend to see it as one master being traded for another?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Was "Istanbul" not commonly known, and if not, when did that change?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
Today, when someone mentions a "spooky" or "scary" looking house one often imagines an old Victorian house with wrought iron fencing, overgrown lawns, etc. A google image search of "haunted house" turns up many, many "scary" Victorian houses.
Did people in the English speaking world in the Victorian era look at, say, old decrepit Georgian style buildings as being scary in the same we see old, ill-kept Victorian buildings?
1 Answers 2017-01-14
I understand that ancient Greek cults were not the secretive organizations we associate today with the word "cult", but some of them were secret and members had to be initiated.
How was decided who would be told about the existence of a cult and offered an opportunity to be initiated?
Thanks.
1 Answers 2017-01-13
Would the ancient Chinese refer to year 1620 as something other than the Gregorian year? Would they even use digits to label it? I know nothing of how traditional Chinese time is recorded.
1 Answers 2017-01-13
In general it seems like the entire arms race of dreadnoughts pre-ww1 was massively anticlimactic with large fleets dreadnoughts never really coming together as was expected. Why did this happen? How was seemingly the entire world so wrong about what naval combat would look like?
One thing I have heard is that WW1 era dreadnoughts were very limited in their ability to use indirect fire because of the shallow angle of their main guns. This seems like a major limitation and given the prominent role of artillery barrages during WW1 it seems like designing ships that could provide effective ship to shore artillery barrages would have been part of the logical design progression of these ships. The Gallipoli campaign in particular seems like an place where effective indirect fire against the enemy positions would have been really helpful.
Did the allies recognize this shortcoming in light of their failure to capture the Dardanelles? Did dreadnoughts/battleships with increased indirect fire capabilities ever see combat in WW1? If not what factors prevented this technology from reaching the battlefield?
2 Answers 2017-01-13
Hello! First of all, I hope it's the right subreddit for this. I'm writing a fantasy/medieval story and I need information about some armor. The societies I'm writing about are not 100% accurate historically but I'd like for the tools, armors and weapons to be accurate.
I'll link some pictures of armors I would like to describe in my books. Could you tell me if it's efficient/realistic,its flaws and what century it was used in?
Some of the armors I'm submitting are leather plus chainmail. Is it any good?
Last point: I'd like my armors not to be full plate as it seems it's really hard to kill people wearing them (from what I read/watched on the subject). I guess what I'm looking for is the time/era just before that? It's a bit hard to explain and I'm sorry I can't be more accurate.
armor 1 armor 2 armor 3 armor 4 armor 5 armor 6 thanks for your time!
2 Answers 2017-01-13
Is the etymology related or is it just a coincidence?
1 Answers 2017-01-13
Whenever I see a deleted post on /r/AskHistorians, I find my curiosity piqued.
Since I never see the original text, I can't help but wonder what happened to get it removed.
So, I want to ask the moderators:
As a ballpark estimate, how many of the posts that you delete do you feel are
people honestly trying to answer the OP (i.e. offering a one sentence answer,
using anecdotal evidence, echoing Wikipedia, or just otherwise "failing in good faith") versus
posts trying to just make a cheap joke versus honest to goodness trolls?
Obviously, the notion of "good faith" is slippery one, as is trying to ascribe motives to any given poster,
but I was curious about "gut feelings" on this. Feel free to define "good faith," "troll," and any other pertinent
term as you see fit.
And, as always, I want to thank the mods for their work here. It is greatly appreciated.
3 Answers 2017-01-13