In his book "Wanderer" Sterling Hayden refers to an incident where Japanese spies stole the plans to an American battleship which they built but it turned upside down when launched. He places this event between the World Wars. Is there any historical basis for this?

2 Answers 2016-12-11

Did early Pagan cultures believe their gods as the absolute, or did they believe that gods held power only in specific regions of Earth?

Did the average Roman, for example, believe that Jupiter would bless him no matter where he stood; or did they believe that as the Romans advanced upon a land, so did the domain of their gods? Would he believe that while in Egypt, his gods held no sway? ESPECIALLY curious about how this idea would've changed under the Ptolemies.

I understand that often connections were made for the sake of assimilating cultures, like making Thor into Zeus. But at times there don't seem to be any connections at all; the only similarities between Ra and Apollo Helios being the sun itself.

I'm also curious about Zoroastrian relations with foreign faiths, what with the monotheism and such.

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Do We Know the Names of Ancient Civilians?

Hello. I have been wondering a bit lately - do we have any lists of civilians from ancient civilisations? Obviously the major players are the ones who tend to get remembered, but do we have access to censuses listing the average joes and their careers?

2 Answers 2016-12-11

Anti-judaism, anti-semitism

Henry Laurens in his lessons on the Arab provinces at the end of the Ottoman period (they are in French) makes a difference between anti-judaism and anti-semitism, the first being more personal and not targeting converts, the second more institutional and continuing to target converts with obvious overlap in themes. Is this a difference which is commonly accepted and used in analyzing related actions?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

How did tactics change throughout WWI?

I know of the 'lions led by donkeys' stereotype of the Great War and that tactics did change but in how?

This question was asked with the Western Front and the trench warfare in mind but I'm interested in all theatres of war, in Europe and other continents.

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Why did it take Europe so much longer to conquer present day USA than it did South America?

I've been doing light reading on the colonization of the Americas and I'm a little confused by the timeline.

Pardon the badhistory:

Columbus discovered the Americas for the Spanish in 1492. Cortez and Pizzaro conquered most of South America by 1533. There were a bunch of limited interactions with present day USA, but it wasn't until 1620 that Europeans landed on Plymouth and even then it didn't exactly instantly conquer the place.

My question is why wasn't there a Cortez/Pizzaro style conquest in the early 16th century on present day USA?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

We all know swamps are humid and unpleasant. Why did the Russians (St. Petersburg) and Americans (Washington DC) insist on building cities on swamps?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

[META] What is the criteria for getting the flair of "Quality Contributor"? How is it different from other topic oriented flairs?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

This week's theme: Canada

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Was Park Chung-hee corrupt?

Given that he was president and virtually a dictator of South Korea from 1963 to his death, did Park Chung-hee at all try and enrich himself while he was in office?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Were the Franks and the dominions of the Merovingians/Carolingians ever culturally homogenous? Did the borders defined by the Treaty of Verdun cause the national and cultural split, or vice versa? When did West and East Francia start identifying themselves as "French" or "German" rather than Franks?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

When did the American public "know" FDR was in the physical state that he was?

It seemed he took great lengths to hide his disability. Was he for the most part, successful? When did it become public knowledge he had a major disability?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

According to an NBC Article, Presidents from Truman to H.W. Bush have been asked by military commanders to launch nuclear weapons at one point during their Presidencies. What spurred this advice from military commanders and why were they so quick to recommend it, knowing the almost certain outcome?

Link to the NBC Article (has to do with 2016 politics but the quote can be found in the second to last paragraph): Link Non-Proliferation Analysis I found (opinion): Link

Edit: Fixed the first link.

4 Answers 2016-12-11

How did knights prevent copying each other's heraldry?

With so many dukes, counts, knights, and lords, I find it hard to believe that nobody's sigil/herald/crest was the same as a different duke's sigil/herald/crest. Has this ever happened, and how did nobles prevent this from ocurring often?

3 Answers 2016-12-11

What did Victorian era women carry in their purses?

Aside from the obvious, like money?

I started wondering this the other day while watching a lady struggle to find something in her massive shoulder bag, thinking that these have been normal fashion accessories for as long as I could remember.

1 Answers 2016-12-11

What made historians "dump" positivism, determinism and eurocentrism?

The answers to this question got me thinking that, without a formal education in history, my education and the overwhelming public discourse concur in agreeing with an obsolete interpretation of history regarding the supposed technological, moral and "civilizational" progress. What I learned and the public opinion in my (European) country still largely agrees with 19th century notions.

My perhaps biased opinion is that it is only natural that in a society that values human rights and technological progress, and where as a culture we (largely) agree that striving to achieve in those fields is our way to go, that we consider ourselves as more advanced when compared to the past, and look at History as the path to the goals we seek in our future.

(For the record, I'm not saying that I agree with that, only that it seems to be counter-intuitive; I agree with current historians)

What I want to ask is:

If (as I suppose) it is only natural to think like historians would do in the past, how did history as a science manage to break with those notions? What and who lead the way? And when?

Apologies if I did not make myself clear, or if the question is too broad. I accept suggestions :)

1 Answers 2016-12-11

SEATO was Southeast Asia's answer to NATO. But it dissolved in 1977, when the Cold War was as very much alive. Why didn't the alliance last longer?

3 Answers 2016-12-11

Franz Ferdinand and Hungarians

I asked this in the Wien reddit.

"I have read 3 books since on the Habsburgs, Austria-Hungary since and I cannot get enough. In all my readings one of the queries I still have in my noggin' is, why did FF hate Hungarians so much? The books mention many times that he despised Hungarians more than anything but, none of them go into detail explaining why. Wondering if anyone here could provide any insight on the matter or, is this one ot those things that everyone knows but, nobody knows why. Thanks!"

I understand he was offended when the Hungarians in a regiment spoke Hungarian while he was around but surely, that cannot be the only reason he despised them.

Curious if anyone here has any insight on this!

Thanks

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | December 05, 2016–December 11, 2016

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

9 Answers 2016-12-11

opinion about Avignon popes in the 14th century? Thank you

What did Petrarch and other people in the 14th century think about the Avignon popes and their court?

Thank you

1 Answers 2016-12-11

[Meta] Inquiry on the weekly themes.

As I understand it, the point is to promote questions for subjects that are not usually asked about.

But who actually picks the themes? Because currently we have nationalism, then we'll have Canada, and finally the 1970s. I have personally seen a fair number of previous questions on these subjects, but so far I've never seen a single question for, idk, the Indian Ocean trade or the Great Lakes kingdoms of Africa.

How can I suggest new themes?

4 Answers 2016-12-11

Were ancient pagan commoners expected to know the basic of their religion like today's Christians and Muslims are?

Also, how knowlexgable would a regular pagan have been? And did they have their own versions of church depending on the pagan religion? Sorry if this is a bit messy thought just came to me before bed and I don't want to forget it.

1 Answers 2016-12-11

How did the Austrian - Austriohungarian empire succeed with such a diverse population (Slavs - Austrians - Hungarians..)?

My teacher gave me a project to do about the 18th century Austrian Empire. In school we aren't taught about 18-19th century Europe and i was fascinated about how so many different ethnicities were under one empire. And by that time people started thinking that they are unique 'most revolutions happened at that time, so it isnt the same situation as the roman empire. There were Hungarians, Austrians (German speaking people in general), slavs (Czechs - Slovakians etc.)!

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Did any African city (south of the Sahara) reach a population of 200,000 before 1800?

I know Timbuktu may have exceeded 100,000, and there were a number of cities like Kumasi in Asante whose populations were in the upper tens of thousands. But were there any cities with more than 200,000 people?

1 Answers 2016-12-11

Did the Yongle Emperor really kill 2800 of his own harem?

The story goes that the Yongle Emperor killed 2800 concubines, serving-girls, eunuchs, and others in the Forbidden City in 1421, apparently to quash humiliating rumours by killing all the witnesses. But most accounts I've found are from tabloids and blogs, and I'm having trouble finding any real, reliable literature.

Did it happen? If it did, why and how? It seems overkill relative to the motive.

1 Answers 2016-12-11

⯇ 3758 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start