Really during any of the major Persian Empires, but I'm most interested in Achaemenid Persia in this case.
I was having a conversation recently about the Biblical book of Esther and in the early part of the story, Mordecai (Esther's Uncle) refuses to kneel to a Persian government official. The Official is offended and tries to kill off all the Jews living in Achaemenid Persia as a result. The traditional Christian interpretation of the passage is that, to Mordecai, kneeling to the Persian official would've been considered idolatry, and so prohibited by his religion. This just doesn't ring true to me, because Persians would have been Zoroastrians at this point, correct? and didn't really ascribe divine nature to their leadership as far as I can remember.
This is a portion of history I know little about, though, so I figured I'd send it to the experts.
1 Answers 2016-09-27
Today we have charities for any cause you can think of, but I was wondering how people helped one another financially in ancient history. I know in the New Testament it talks about the disciples collecting money from churches to help people in Jerusalem facing a famine, but it seems pretty informal. Are there any known charitable organizations or movements in BC times?
1 Answers 2016-09-27
I've been reading a bit about the punic wars but I don't really know why they actually fought each other and I hoped to get some insight here.
1 Answers 2016-09-27
[This video] (https://youtu.be/BEG-ly9tQGk) shows a Danish man shooting a bow in extraordinary ways. Now I understand if archers did have a quiver it was to hold the arrows inbetween fights while during a fight they held arrows in their hand, but did they all shoot like that? I could see Huns, Mongols, Turks, Persians, maybe Chinese, and maybe even Kievan Rus/ Novgorod/ Muscovy archers shooting like that.
However, I'm not sold on European archers fighting like that. Although the movie is trash, I find it much more believable that European archers shot like they did in Braveheart where they stuck their arrows in the ground and used one at a time, in a stationary position.
2 Answers 2016-09-27
1 Answers 2016-09-27
I mean, what was the actual process for keeping them separate from the wild herds? Were they leashed to tree or posts? Did the people build fences to contain them?
1 Answers 2016-09-27
Hit me up with all your historiography and definitions of total war on the World War II homefront in the US specifically. Or theories of what constitutes total war at large.
I really like this functional definition/description that I've already got:
"Total war [...] incorporated an entire society into the war effort. It emerged from a concert of war an industrialization: industrializaiton allowing for deadlier and greater quanitities of war materials and war necessitating the further rationalization of industrial production." -Patrick Vitale, “Wages of War: Manufacturing Nationalism During World War II,” Antipode 43, no. 3 (June 1, 2011): 783–819.
But I need some more sources and heft. Who are the big authorities I should cite???
1 Answers 2016-09-27
Tell us a story of a time people of the past conspired: triumphant or tragic, condemned or hailed, figment of royal paranoia or legitimate threat.
(Nota bene, the 20-year rule and other AH rules definitely apply.)
Next week: History of Conspiracy Theories and Urban Legends
8 Answers 2016-09-27
I know not to trust these sensationalist headlines, so when I read this article: http://www.express.co.uk/news/history/628827/ANCIENT-ROMANS-America-eerie-discovery-change-history
I was skeptical and still am. My best theory is some abandoned Roman ship carried there by currents, but that's my best guess and nothing more.
I'm not very well versed in Roman or North American history beyond the basics, so I want to know from someone here - did, as far as our knowledge of Roman ships, the Romans have the capabilities to visit North America safely?
If not, then how do you explain the sword and other artifacts in the supposed shipwreck?
Thanks Georgy, my followup is: "Did the Romans have any chance of ever crossing the Atlantic? If not, what fundamental technology or ship construction would have enabled it."
2 Answers 2016-09-27
I was reading this wiki article on a recent lengthy trip down the wikipedia rabbit-hole: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giovanni_da_Pian_del_Carpine
In 1245 Giovanni (or Johannes on wiki) was sent by Pope Innocent IV as the first formal Catholic mission to the Mongols. He eventually made it all the way to Mongolia and the court of Güyük Khan, who had just been enthroned. Amongst other thing, Johannes asked the Khan to convert to Christianity (he said no). Wiki then says:
He [Guyuk Khan] gave them a letter to the Pope—written in Mongol, Arabic, and Latin—that was a brief imperious assertion of the Khan's office as the scourge of God.
My fundamental question is: How were they able to compose it in Latin? AFAIK, the Mongols only even reached the eastern edges of Europe in 1237. So, did the Mongols have their own Europeans kept at court for this purpose? Did they communicate in Arabic as a middle ground language that some Europeans and some Mongols would both know?
I'd also be interested in the reverse of this question, i.e.: Would Pope Innocent IV have had people available to him who spoke Mongol?
Again from wiki: Johannes took with him Benedict of Poland who acted as his 'translator' - (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benedict_of_Poland). What languages he was translating from/to is not clear as wiki only says he spoke Latin.
More generally, I'm surprised this story of an official European Catholic mission hanging out in the Mongol capital for a while isn't better known. Especially given the ongoing fascination with Marco Polo who maybe didn't do anything in the Far East, and if he did, did it much later anyway.
2 Answers 2016-09-27
1 Answers 2016-09-27
As above, did the Spartans really care about the solidarity of the Hellas or did they just wanted to show off their military prowess? I know Sparta wasn't the only city-state that was present and about 1,000 Thespians remained with whatever what was left of the 300 during the last day, but all the stories praise the Spartans. The other city-states are usually added in as a side note.
1 Answers 2016-09-27
i was reading the wikipedia article on fascism a while back, and came across this
Mussolini's transformation away from Marxism into what eventually became fascism began prior to World War I, as Mussolini had grown increasingly pessimistic about Marxism and egalitarianism while becoming increasingly supportive of figures who opposed egalitarianism, such as Friedrich Nietzsche.
[...] Mussolini's writings over time indicated that he had abandoned the Marxism and egalitarianism that he had previously supported [...]
as well as, during a history lesson several days ago, the history textbook mentioned he ran (or helped run) a socialist newspaper in Italy.
wiki link, along with the part where it states that Mussolini originally was a Marxist.
1 Answers 2016-09-27
2 Answers 2016-09-27
I was reading the Wikipedia page for Elizabeth Báthoryry and was surprised to see that there is some dispute over her guilt. It's not unexpected to learn that her crimes may have been exaggerated over the centuries (the bathing in blood detail seems to be a fabrication, for example), but I hadn't heard any theories put forward to suggest she was outright framed until I saw it in the article I linked to above.
How plausible is it that she was the victim of a political conspiracy to falsely accuse her that took on the aspect of a moral panic? Did she maintain her innocence? How reliable is the physical evidence that was collected against her?
1 Answers 2016-09-27
Did people in Medieval Ages ever acknowledge that they have not 'advanced' in technology enough? I hope that you understand what I'm trying to say, lets say that they did not have enough advanced resources to 'craft' something or an idea?
1 Answers 2016-09-27
My teacher was a bit of a wack so I don't know
2 Answers 2016-09-27
1 Answers 2016-09-27
2 Answers 2016-09-27
We now have wire transfers and correspondent accounts. The Templars had what we call letters of credit so that people did not have to physically carry their wealth. The Roman empire was pretty big, how would money be transferred? Cash? Would I need a trusted courier or would I have to carry it myself?
6 Answers 2016-09-27
The modern "paleo" fad diet has popularized the view that the majority of calorie intake in pre-agricultural diets came from meat, but I haven't seen the sources for that claim. I'm interested in any evidence of what the actual makeup of pre-agricultural diets was. Thanks in advance :)
1 Answers 2016-09-27
1 Answers 2016-09-27
Considering the time I would have expected Ferdinand to have 'worn the pants' as they say, but I'm currently in southern Spain on vacation and Isabelle seems to have been an equal force.
1 Answers 2016-09-27
I'm writing a fantasy story, and I need some help. Although my setting is similar to Graeco-Roman Antiquity in terms of culture, in terms of everyday technology, most of the civilised world is parallel to about 900-1000 AD in our world.
I've read around on the history of fishing and come up with a lot of sources. Most of them are about historical fishing as a means of food-gathering, which is helpful for some aspects of my story, but I want to find out more about fishing as a hobby.
Many of the sources refer to fishing rods and hooks very early on (x000 BC), but also independently state that the reel developed much later (in medieval times). Do I take this to mean that a fishing rod would merely consist of a long rod with a line tied to the end? (And a hook, obviously.)
None of the sources I've found confront this issue; how were the line and rod actually attached? Simply by tieing?
Also, what wood was used for the rods? What line?
(Disclaimer: I've said "ancient" in the title because that's the easiest way of saying "before medieval times" so as to avoid inventions like the reel. Anything from Roman to Anglo-Saxon era fishing techniques will do, really; I just want to know anything I can.)
Many thanks in advance for any help!
EDIT: Also, exactly how would one cast the line into the water? And how would you drag the fish back to shore when it's caught?
2 Answers 2016-09-27