When and why kings decided that they wouldnt participate in wars?

I know that Charles XII of Sweden was killed while he was inspecting his soldiers on a trench, but it looks like royal families started to participate less in wars till a point that is almost no participation among the majority of families.

The major explanation i got is the most obvious: you can die in a war, and it can cost the succession line of your house.

But that doesnt makes sense to me: did the monarchs that took part of their wars through the annales of history never thought of that? Just later, some monarchs were like: "oh, I can die in war and mess up my family line, so Its better staying home". Just doesnt seem logic since earlier monarchs probably had come up with this and they still leaded their troops.

2 Answers 2022-11-27

Give a gift of History with the AskHistorians 2022 Holiday Book Recommendation Thread!

The holidays season is approaching as November ends. Happy holidays to one of the most fantastic communities on the net!

It’s been a wild year, and sadly many of last years issues continue now. I planned to run this later in December, but figured now is the best time considering all the problems with shipping and stuff selling out that keeps happening.

Tis coming up to the season for gift giving, and its a safe bet that folks here both like giving and receiving all kinds of history books. As such we offer this thread for all your holiday book recommendation needs!

If you are looking for a particular book, please ask below in a comment and tell us the time period or events you're curious about! Please don't just drop a link to a book in this thread. In recommending, you should post at least a paragraph explaining why this book is important, or a good fit, and so on. Let us know what you like about this book so much!

Don't forget to check out the existing AskHistorians book list, a fantastic list of books compiled by flairs and experts from the sub. Or you can browse last years thread, or the year before while we wait for new suggestions to come rolling in!

Have yourselves a great holiday season readers, and let us know about all your favorite, must recommend books! Stay safe out there!

21 Answers 2022-11-27

What are the best texts about interactions between Gaels and Picts in early medieval Scotland?

Really interested in reading about the formation of a Scottish Gaelic culture and how Gaelic-speaking newcomers interacted with the preexisting populations whom outsiders called Picts

1 Answers 2022-11-27

I am a wealthy, educated Roman citizen in the first century CE. What am I knowledgeable about?

Let's say I live in Herculaneum. I've been given the best education, but what were they educating me in? I'm assuming math is a given, but what historians have I read? Who are popular scientific writers? I'm contemporaries with Pliny the Elder, but is his writing popular enough while he's alive for me to know? What philosophers are commonly read? Is religion considered a topic for intellectuals, or do they see it as superstitious?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

How do historians determine the reliability of a historical text/source?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

To circumvent the naval articles of the Versailles treaty, the Weimar government created a dummy company in the Netherlands (IvS) to develop U-Boats. How did the UK, France, or the Netherlands not figure out who was behind the company? Did the Germans use any other dummy companies?

2 Answers 2022-11-27

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | November 27, 2022

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2022-11-27

If you were enlisted in World War 1 in 1914 on the Western Front, how likely were you to survive to the end of the war?

2 Answers 2022-11-27

How was the economy of Egypt affected by Mansa Musa visiting Cairo on his way to Hajj in the year 1324?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Did Hirohito really just "turn good" after WW2?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Empress Matilda was William the Conqueror’s eldest daughter, Stephen of Blois was William the Conqueror’s grandson from his youngest daughter, so why was he considered the rightful monarch?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Are there identifying marks on a German WWI helmet that could help it be repatriated?

I know this is a huge long shot, I’m sorry if this is stupid. I’m American. My great great grandfather brought home a German helmet and some leather pieces that came with it, including a fabric piece (lapel?) with a stitched 242 on it. There are parts of the leather pieces that appear to be blood-soaked. He wrote a note saying he “found it in the Belleau Woods.” Anyways, are there any special marks on these fabric pieces or the helmet itself, such as a serial number, that I could potentially use to return it to surviving family? If not, is there anything important or interesting we can extrapolate from the 242, or the helmet itself? Thanks, please let me know if wrong sub.

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Graham Hancock's Netflix: Can someone debunk each one of his points in his episodes?

I know nothing of archaeology, evidently.

But I would like an explanation to each of the points Hancock brings up in his Netflix episodes so I can understand. I cannot find anyone that does do this extensively and in layman language without simply stating he is a hack.

I know it's a lot to ask, but it would be amazing if I'm at least pointed to some reading.

1 Answers 2022-11-27

How did ancient romans flirt?

I'm assuming that flirting happened back then, but if it did, what form did it take? There's a lot of roman history, but I don't know how much information there is on this topic, so for a specific time period i suppose late republic/early empire is where I'm wondering about. How did romance happen back then? I know all about how marriage was mostly for purpose rather than romance but given the content of plays and poems from back then there has to have been love, too. So, how did they flirt? Did they flirt at all?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Why is basketball so popular in the Baltic states?

A recent graphic on another subreddit showed that basketball is the most popular sport in Estonia and Lithuania. Why has it gained such traction there? Did the roots of widespread basketball adoption predate the dissolution of the USSR?

2 Answers 2022-11-27

Why use 'piled-up earth supporting a banner for indicating official rank'?

1. Please show me drawings, illustrations of this usage?

2. I have difficulty imagining or picturing why Chinese officials used "piled-up earth supporting a banner for indicating official rank"?

By definition, "piled-up earth" is earthy, whose synonyms in English are bawdy, crude, lowbred. Obviously, any Chinese official would hate to be seen as "bawdy, crude, lowbred"! Thus why didn't Chinese officials use posher materiel to support their banner indicating their rank?

I scanned Christopher Seeley's The Complete Guide to Japanese Kanji (2nd edn 2006), pp. 518-9.

https://i.imgur.com/2226IBx.jpg

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Is there historical/archaeological evidence of the exile and enslavement of Jews by the Babylonian Empire? If so, how did it impact the development of Judaism?

If so how did the exile impact the development of Judaism

1 Answers 2022-11-27

How can and does the sub and the academy deal with the influence of the political opinions of authors in their production and reproduction of academic material and answers here?

Basically the title. The more obviously politically charged questions in the sub, like the ones about anything related to the USSR, got me thinking about it.

3 Answers 2022-11-27

Around the time of Alfred the Great (9th-10th century) were the Anglo Saxons aware of their history of them migrating from Continental Europe?

I’m wondering if they were aware of three things mostly.

  1. Their migration to Britain from Continental Europe

  2. Their connection to the Germanic peoples like the Saxons

  3. When the Danes settled in England, and brought the Norse Religion, were the English aware that their ancestors worshipped the Same gods? Like we’re they aware that Odin=Woden and Thor=Thunor?

1 Answers 2022-11-27

Do historians have to cite personal letters?

i’m currently writing a comparative book review in which an author uses direct quotations from a private letter between two military generals but it’s not cited. i tried looking for it in their bibliography because they give the date of the correspondence when discussing it but i couldn’t find it.

2 Answers 2022-11-26

Almost everything today feels like it is owned by eight or ten major parent companies. What changed to make the United States go from Anti-Corporate philosophies in the 1890s-1910s during Theodore Roosevelt’s “Trust Busting” era to lead to the modern economic practices?

1 Answers 2022-11-26

[Meta] For lay people, how would historians suggest we choose documentaries to watch?

A few days ago, my brother turned off the TV when my mum was watching Stuff the British stole. He claimed that this documentary is historical revisionism and fills people's heads with the wrong ideas.

So who is right here? I didn't study history in university, so how should lay people choose documentaries to watch?

After all, not all documentaries are reliable. Some of the most famous and influential documentaries, such as Super Size Me and Seaspiracy, although they were not on the topic of history, turned out to have many factual errors.

2 Answers 2022-11-26

Was the need to go to great lengths to defend ones honor as vain as we perceive it today in our modern times? How important was it to gain and protect honor besides the obvious reasons of ego?

I am asking about before the early modern period, but examples from other parts of the world at other times would be welcome. An anthropologist called honor "social currency" in the book "Debt: first 5000 years." Is there any truth to it?

1 Answers 2022-11-26

When Europeans first came to the Americas they spread disease to the natives why didn't the natives also spread disease to the Europeans?

When Europeans first came to the Americas they spread disease causing mass amounts of death for the native Americans. Shouldn't the native Americans have also spread disease to the Europeans causing mass deaths for both sides?

1 Answers 2022-11-26

How did settlers on the High Plains of the US find their plot of land?

My understanding is that starting in 1862 with the first Homestead act, the US government started selling off or giving away 160 acre parcels west of the Mississippi. I've drive through western Kansas and east Colorado and the High Plains in that area is almost featureless, it's just a sea of crops/rangeland/prairie. Before all the road and rail lines, how would have someone from say... Baltimore, known how to get to their plot of land? You can take one of the trails or rail roads most of the way, sure, but how do you know when to get off the train or trail? How do you know where to go from there?

1 Answers 2022-11-26

40 / 7255

Back to start