When larger realms like the Frankish Empire were divided upon inheritance, what happened with vassals who had holdings in different parts of the realm?

For instance, Clovis I divided his realm among his four sons, who all became independent. Charles Martell divided his realm among his two sons. The realm of Louis the Pious was also divided into three parts in the Treaty of Prüm/Verdun, one of which would become the kingdom of France.

Now my question: If a vassal of one of these kings had holdings in, say, East Francia and Lotharingia, would he give up part of his holdings (if yes, would he be compensated in any way?), or would he owe fealty to multiple kings?

Were there different solutions between peaceful inheritances (Like after Charles Martell's death) and less peaceful divisions (like the Treaty of Prüm)?

3 Answers 2016-04-25

Would crucifixion usually be done by its ropes or nails?

Crucifixion in media is usually depicted done with nails through the wrist and feet, but I understand it was also done with ropes alone. Which would be the usual method for Rome around the late Republic?

3 Answers 2016-04-25

Would it be accurate to claim that Germany is the reason that Great Britain & France became allies?

England & France have not always been besties. We all know it. However, I was always curious what changed in the late 1800s/early 1900s where over hundreds of years of prior conflict became a strong alliance in 2 world wars, as well as in founding the EU, being part of NATO/UN, etc. Point is, I've recently heard in a lecture that Germany was responsible for these two becoming allies in the first place. My teacher told us that Germany's naval power threatened British supremacy in the seas, and France was a surefire ally to any anti-German nation after the Franco-Prussian War, so the two teamed up. However, is there more to this? Did England not see France as a threat at all? Was France not jealous of British dominance abroad, or did they see an alliance with such a powerful country as helpful in maintaining their colonies in North Africa, for example? Did any other European countries (Italy, Austria-Hungary, Ottoman Empire, & Russia come to mind, for their various roles in WWI) play into this forming of an alliance? Because as a French-American living in the States, it seems to me like the Modern Era relationship between the French & British is a real special one overall.

1 Answers 2016-04-25

What's the name of those classical Greek/Roman masks?

Something like the front plate mask worn by Tigris in Gladiator but without the full helm http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_kUiKkNDIwhU/SkVJ-pTUJxI/AAAAAAAAARI/B199WUGDrUg/s1600/T1.jpg

The ones that look more like the carved face of a statue rather than the more surreal ones used in plays

Is there a name for this style of mask?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

What goods in the American west were manufactured via large scale factories in distant cities vs small scale local craftsmen?

I am assuming the industrial revolution had a large impact on the American frontier, but I'm not sure how large.

1 Answers 2016-04-25

Why were Austria-Hungry and the Ottoman Empire dismantled following WWI, but not Germany?

So I was reading another post that mentioned the treaty of Sevré and the break up of the Ottoman Empire. Why was Germany not divided up like the other two? Since they were the youngest of the central powers, at 48 at Versailles, wouldn't it have been easier for the entente to dismantle them?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

What led to Haiti's current position as poorest nation in the Americas?

Haiti is poorer than any other country in the Americas, but I don't know enough about its history to see what makes it unique among its neighbors. The Dominican Republic, Cuba, Jamaica and the Bahamas are all much stronger economically.

Related questions:

  • Was there something unique about French colonial administration in the region which made the area poorer? The other four countries in the region I compared it to were all English or Spanish colonies.

  • Jamaica and the Bahamas have similar histories to Haiti--they are primarily populated by the descendants of African slaves brought to the islands by European colonizers. But unlike Haiti, those countries earned their independence peacefully, and much later than Haiti. Did Haiti's position as a nation born of a successful slave revolt lead to hostile international relations--did slave holding countries like the US attempt to undermine Haiti?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

What was the icon of Paris before the Eiffel Tower?

The Eiffel tower has represented Paris in countless contexts, but what was used before 1889? Was it Notre Dame?

2 Answers 2016-04-25

Before toilet paper, how did people through history clean up after going to the toilet and maintain sanitary conditions to avoid getting sick?

4 Answers 2016-04-25

How did blacksmithing vary from culture to culture? What made them stick with their traditional methods?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

Were there many allied witnessess of the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

I am trying to work out the validity of some oft repeated family history. It's been claimed that my grandfather, who served in WWII, witnessed the bombing of either Hiroshima or Nagasaki. I was just wondering if there was any evidence any allied troops, particularly Australians, were in the area at the time.

1 Answers 2016-04-25

The Origins of the Freemasons

Multiple theories have tried to explain the origin of the fraternity. Most center around an aristocratic adoption of the language surrounding stone-working guilds as a method of allegorical teaching. More fanciful theories posit the origin of the organization in the Knights Templar. What is the truth to the best of the knowledge of the historians here?

2 Answers 2016-04-25

When did the concept of terrorism come to exist? What are some early examples of terrorist groups?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

Found an old wrecked car in the woods. What year is it from and what type of car?

I found 2 wrecked cars, some scrap metal, a bottle, and something else I can't identify (the white thing covered in small holes.) Any ideas of what year these are from, what kind of cars and bottle, and what the white thing is? Thanks.

https://imgur.com/a/wj2HC

2 Answers 2016-04-25

During the War of 1812, did the Niagara Escarpment ever prove to be a natural barricade or strategic lookout point?

The Niagara Escarpment stretches across much of S. Ontario. It's a very long, tall, and rocky cliff with some neat lookout points. How much of a challenge was it for the Americans or the British to traverse around it? Did they ever use it to their advantage?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

Could anyone reccomend some good books on the Eisenhower Presidency?

I have recently realized while I know a lot about Eisenhower's military history I've read very little regarding his presidency. I welcome any and all suggestions, thanks everyone!

2 Answers 2016-04-25

What did early Christians call themselves? How/when did the religion become known as "Christianity?"

Just a question after reflecting on the origins of Islam's name that I wasn't really sure where "Christianity" as a term comes from nor if it has always been called that.

1 Answers 2016-04-25

I've had this sketch/painting on my parent's living room wall for as long as I can remember (about 20 years), can someone tell me what (if anything real) it's actually supposed to depict?

like why would someone build cottages that look that ramshackle?

2 Answers 2016-04-25

How accurate is the movie Amadeus?

I was watching Amadeus the other night and I was wondering how accurate that movie is contrast, to real life? Was that really Mozart's personality? Was he really financially unstable due to hitting on young girls at that time?

2 Answers 2016-04-25

Were fart jokes a thing in ancient times, or have we only recently begun to think of them as funny?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

When is the last recorded instance of a general leading his troops into battle from the front?

1 Answers 2016-04-25

How did troops in WWII and WWI not go completely deaf?

They didn't have ear protection as far as I know, and as we all know, guns are pretty damn loud. How is it that everyone didn't lose their hearing?

4 Answers 2016-04-25

Were East Germany's infamous Trabant automobiles exported to other countries?

Paula Kirby, who once lived in the DDR, tweeted this photo of Trabants lined up on a dock for export: https://twitter.com/PaulaSKirby/status/724281792266522625

She doesn't know where else they were sold, though. Film footage from the USSR and other Warsaw Pact countries show plenty of Ladas and Skodas (and even the occasional VW or Volvo) but never Trabants. I'm curious about where else they wound up.

2 Answers 2016-04-24

Where did the Yellow Chinaman stereotype originate, given that many East Asians are light skinned or tan?

1 Answers 2016-04-24

German Combat Doctrine in WW2

I'm interested in doing some casual reading/research into German military doctrine during the 2nd World War. I was wondering if anyone knew of any free, english translated documents available online to use as a jumping off point?

1 Answers 2016-04-24

4327 / 7255

Back to start