How did Hannibal return to Carthage?

It's my understanding that Rome had naval dominance in this period, so travel across the Mediterranean was difficult, so how did he get back?

Did he travel with only a small party so he could sneak across? Had Rome's naval dominance diminished by this time? I've always wondered this but have never seen it covered anywhere.

1 Answers 2016-01-29

After the Germans had conquered most of continental Europe and they were at war with the Allies, what did the German Foreign Ministry have left to do?

Trade talks with the occupied and neutral countries?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

My great-grandfather, who was born in the late 1870s in France, was named Napoleon. Would this indicate that my family were still supporters of the House of Bonaparte or was this just a common name. If it is the former, what can you tell me about Bonaparte supporters in the late 1870s.

I should clarify that I have a basic understanding of Bonapartism during the reign of Napoleon III, I am just more curious about the state of the House of Bonaparte after his abdication and death.

Also, just in case anyone is curious, I am not very old despite my great-grandfather having been born in the 1870s. I just have a family history of older men marrying younger second wives.

1 Answers 2016-01-29

Reading about the history of settlements in the western USA, they often mention the establishment or departure of a Post Office. What was the significance of those?

2 Answers 2016-01-29

In WWII the Nazis were pretty unambiguously "bad guys," did WWI have "bad guys" or just winners and losers?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

My chemistry text says Aristotle's view that matter was continuous put off exploration of atomic theory until the 17th century. Were there any explorations prior to this?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

How come the Allies could fight and win in cold conditions with little winter clothing and limited supplies in the Bulge but the Germans couldn't in Russia?

2 Answers 2016-01-29

Why is Hawaii a US state and not say, Guam or Puerto Rico or any of the other US territories?

3 Answers 2016-01-29

How and why did the slave economy of the Roman Empire give way to what is commonly termed as 'feudalism' in Western Europe?

It is my understanding that the prevailing mode of production in ancient times was a slave economy, and that this held true in Rome up through the time of her collapse. How, exactly, did this give way to the 'feudal' relations of production in Western Europe, with lords and serfs and all that? Did the 'barbarians' who invaded not believe in slavery, after being subjected to it by 'civilized' society for so long?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

History of the Atlantis myth

The lost empire thread has a mention of Atlantis. I remember having read a book which stated that it was clearly considered as an allegory of Athenian society at the start it that it was only quite later (I remember less clearly that christianization was a factor) that people started to consider it more seriously.

Is that story (people started to consider the myth as history only a relatively long time after Plato, and the link of that believe with Christianity) based on facts? What would be a good source on the history of the myth?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

Need help: The Nazis tried to link Jews to Communism, especially after Barbarossa. How strong was this link in convincing other populaces to kill?

I am being asked to speak to an adolescent grade book club after they finish the book, Between Shades of Gray in March. I do have a degree in Holocaust and Genocide Studies and my knowledge on the Baltics and other Eastern European countries between Hitler and Stalin is strong.

However, one of the more difficult subjects when discussing the war in the East to students today is how many in Eastern Europe (the Baltics, Poland, Belorussia, the Ukraine, etc) welcomed the Nazis as liberators. For many students I teach, this is the first time they ever hear this.

But now I'm tasked with going more in depth.

One thing that has tripped me up is the claim that still seems prevalent today: that many Jews in Eastern Europe were communists (or sympathizers) and this somehow "justified" Nazi collaborators' anger during the Holocaust.

This YIVO encyclopedia piece does note the over-representation of Jews in the Communist party - over a quarter in Belorussia at certain point. But many other searches, of course, bring up anti-Semitic and Nazi sympathizing websites.

These claimants often overlook religious Jews who lived in shtetls and held no sympathy for communism. But while differentiating the two, Jews who supported communism and religious Jews, I feel I'm falling into a "categorization trap" that doesn't explain the diversity of Jewish life in Eastern Europe and other nuances.

I'd really like to provide a balanced perspective that shows how Nazi propaganda just focused only on ties to Jewish Bolshevism, while ignoring the large number of non-Jewish elements who despised communism.

To me, the communist-Jewish link is just another chapter of centuries of anti-Jewish prejudice.

I want my points to explain why some populations in Eastern Europe collaborated with the Nazis, and not have it come off as justification - if that makes any sense.

2 Answers 2016-01-29

Why was the Vietnam War not successful?

4 Answers 2016-01-29

Did Germany help fund the Bolshevik Party or Lenin prior to the October revolution?

Sorry if this has been asked before. Searches yielded mostly biased-seeming sources of this information.

I am currently reading Simon Sebag Montefiore's "Young Stalin" and he mentions kind of causally that Lenin was at least partially funded by German interests - ostensibly to help disrupt Russian involvement in WWI.

Are there reliable sources for this information?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

Did ancient/medieval people truly believe in mythological/magic beings?

We have all read fairy tales which contain mystical creatures such as elves, trolls and fairies. Would someone living in Europe in the early Middle Ages truly believe that deep in the woods there were magical beings. Or were the tales used as they are now for children's enjoyment?

4 Answers 2016-01-29

How are casualty rates in military conflicts calculated?

I am reading a collection of interviews about WW2 ("The Good War" by Studs Terkel) and often the interviewees mention that they suffered a casualty rate well in excess of one hundred, such as 160% or 300%. Does anyone know what this means?

I've searched around online, but I only find casualty rates explained in the sense which I would have expected, with 100% being the maximum. I'm not sure if there's some kind of weighting going on or what.

I hope this is the right place to ask. Judging from what I saw online, it seems like this may be an outdated system so I figured it was more of a history question. Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-01-29

Is there an estimate of human general body performance for the last 1000 or 5000 years ago? How far would our ancestors go?

Everytime I'm on a hike or travelling to a place far away, and I'm walking with a heavy backpack, I keep thinking: If I were not in the year 2k+, would I be able to survive a long walk to a whole other tribe or state? What about going 200Km on foot, over a few days, with your belongings in your back without a road to follow?

Is there any vivid report whatsoever of a long walk of people going to war somewhere, or really long trips, alone or in group?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

Is there any explanation for the paranoia demonstrated in the French Revolution?

I've been listening to Mike Duncan's Revolutions podcast, and one of the things that comes up over-and-over again is the idea that France was beset on all side by foreign and domestic conspiracies that plotted the demise of the nation. Many high-level members of the revolution were killed for suspicion of being involved in a plot against the nation on very flimsy evidence.

Is there a way to understand this social phenomenon? I'm having a hard time believing that anyone involved in the revolution honestly believed in massive conspiratorial plots, or that any of their fellow revolutionaries might be involved in a conspiracy.

2 Answers 2016-01-29

Book recommendations

Almost at the end of Thomas Asbridge's The Crusades, and I'm looking for a similarly recent, comprehensive and well-balanced book on three topics:

  1. The Richard I/Henry II conflict,

  2. The war of the Roses

  3. The byzantine empire in general, from beginning to end

Any help would be much appreciated :)

3 Answers 2016-01-29

Were communities 'safer' before the modern-type police forces?

I'm reading a book, Rebels Against the Future, about the Luddite movement (1812, England) and one thing that keeps making me pause is how there doesn't seem to be any police forces in the communities.

It sounds like there's some local magistrate who has the ability to deputize people, a local militia, and the military that can be used, but there aren't "cops."

How did that make people's lives different from ours?

Was it incredibly dangerous because there was no one to police the area? Was it better because people had to police each other instead of let the cops do it?

I realize "safer" is a subjective word, but I'm hoping it helps express the thing I'm wondering about and you can help me think about it better.

1 Answers 2016-01-29

To what extent was Hitler actually responsible for the evils of Nazi Germany?

Normally, people attribute the things such as the Holocaust solely to Hitler. However, I have also heard that Hitler was more of a figurehead and charismatic speaker for the Nazi party. How involved was Hitler with the actions of the Reich? Was he the policy setter or just its messenger?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

Friday Free-for-All | January 29, 2016

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

10 Answers 2016-01-29

George Carlin and Indians

http://i.imgur.com/lXX5f53l.jpg

I think there's a lot that might be incorrect here. But I don't know. His argument is appealing for a few reasons, not least of which is the revelation that our history teachers didn't have the truth....but this comedian does!

  • original name of India

  • Did Columbus write or say "In dios" (en dios)

  • Was 1970 the first year the term native American was used?

1 Answers 2016-01-29

(Jihad/ Crusades) To what extent is the data presented in this video accurate?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Im0IisZ77QI

The guy has done his homework in terms of the Sirah/ Qur'an, however I am not a historian, and I can't really verify his claims.

Essentially I am interested in whether his claims that the Crusades were a reaction to Jihad, and that the Crusades only had so few battles in comparison are true.

Cheers.

2 Answers 2016-01-29

In the Godfather, Vito Corleone gets a mention in a newspaper as a leader in the underworld, but not for an arrest. Did leaders of organized crime really carry such high profile without consequence?

Hopefully I don't ruin the film for anyone with this question, but there's a bit where Don Corleone is released from hospital and it's reported in the newspaper. Would it have been possible for someone to be reported as the head of a criminal organization and not face any sorts of consequences?

Were the big names of crime like Arnold Rothstein or Lucky Luciano treated this way?

2 Answers 2016-01-29

Arab/Muslim culture used to be the height of technology and the arts. What changed?

I really don't intend this to sound insulting to Arabs and/or Muslims; I just don't know how else to ask the question.

A thousand years ago Arabs in general, and especially Muslims, were the height of culture and technology outside of the Orient. They invented algebra, and a code of laws that was so fair and equitable that we're still talking about it today. Their artistic works were gorgeous -- the Arabic calligraphy alone became a refined art form in itself.

Now, though, the middle east is a little bit more westernized, but I (as an American, anyway) don't see much in the way of new technological advancement or amazing works of art coming from that part of the world anymore.

What gives?

4 Answers 2016-01-29

4578 / 7255

Back to start