Why do you think people become interested in a certain period in history?

12 Answers 2015-11-19

How many Soviet civilian deaths can we directly attribute to the actions and polices of German military forces and the occupying administrations?

Over 14 million Soviet civilians died as a result of WW2.

My question is exactly how many of these deaths can we attribute directly and explicitly to German forces whether they are the Wehrmacht, the SS, Waffen SS, SD, or the occupying civilian administrations like the one run by Erich Koch in the Ukraine.

What number of the 14 million+ deaths were the result of genocide as opposed to unintentional collateral damage that occurs during wars of a colossal scale like the Eastern Front?

How many were shot, burned, gassed, bayoneted, starved, beaten, worked to death, left to die from exposure to the elements and disease etc because they were seen as subhuman in the eyes of the Anti Slavic Germans?

Is an estimate like this even possible?

From Wikipedia:

The Russian Academy of Sciences in 1995 reported civilian victims in the USSR at German hands totaled 13.7 million dead, 20% of the 68 million persons in the occupied USSR. This included 7.4 million victims of Nazi genocide and reprisals; 2.2 million deaths of persons deported to Germany for forced labor; and 4.1 million famine and disease deaths in occupied territory. There were an additional estimated 3.0 million famine deaths in areas of the USSR not under German occupation. These losses are for the entire territory of the USSR in 1946 to 1991 borders, including territories occupied in 1939–40.[24] The deaths of 8.2 million Soviet civilians were documented by the Soviet Extraordinary State Commission.[25]

Is 13.7 million an accurate estimate or should it be lowered?

1 Answers 2015-11-19

How were illegitimate children viewed in medieval China?

I'm putting together a backstory for a D&D character who comes from a region analogous to China (Tian-Shu from Pathfinder in case anyone is wondering). My current backstory is that she's the illegitimate daughter of an upper class family and I'm just looking for a bit of real world history to flesh that out.

1 Answers 2015-11-19

What happened to soldiers of the Polish Army who fought and lost against Nazi Germany? How did the Germans so dismantle to Polish armed forces and did any prisoners survive the war?

1 Answers 2015-11-19

Why did the Industrial Revolution occur first in Great Britain?

So my AP European history class finally got to the 18th/19th centuries, and have started talking about the Industrial revolution, but I feel like our class sort of glossed over why it occurred first in Great Britain and jumped straight into its defining characteristics.

1 Answers 2015-11-19

AMA: Alaska's Aviation History

I'm Katherine Ringsmuth, author of the new book, "Alaska's Skyboys: Cowboy Pilots and the Myth of the Last Frontier." I teach Alaska History at the University of Alaska Anchorage and I'm here today to answer your questions about Alaska's aviation past or any other Alaska-related topic you may be interested in.

11 Answers 2015-11-19

[Urbanism] Why was "blockbusting" effectively unopposed in northern U.S. cities from the late 1940s-1970s?

Just read this very interesting 1962 article on the practice, Confessions of a Blockbuster. The anonymous author of the article, a self-styled "blockbuster", lays out his MO as follows:

I make my money—quite a lot of it, incidentally—in three ways: (1) By beating down the prices I pay the white owners by stimulating their fear of what is to come; (2) by selling to the eager Negroes at inflated prices; and (3) by financing these purchases at what amounts to a very high rate of interest.

The crooked realtors were cheating white homeowners of a sizable portion of the equity in their homes, while turning around and bilking the black buyers with ruinous mortgages and interest schemes they could never hope to pay off. In effect, they were robbing whites and blacks of their life savings while contributing to urban blight and overcrowding. Why did city governments, segregationist homeowners' associations and liberals seeking to improve the lot of northern blacks never find common cause to root out the practice? Did any mayors, governors, or presidents between Truman and Reagan ever even acknowledge the problem or lay out a plan to deal with it?

1 Answers 2015-11-19

What was the process of converting "Königsberg" to "Kaliningrad"? Was it just a name change, or was there a more fundamental shift?

A quest to figure out what year a map in my German class was made lead me to the Wikipedia page on Kaliningrad, where it stated that the German citizenry was forcibly expelled and replaced with Soviet citizens, the German language was changed to Russian, and the city then closed to the public due to strategic reasons. It's not terribly specific, and Wikipedia isn't famed for its reliability, anyways, so I'd like to know more.

EDIT: Thought of another question: do German speakers now refer to it as Kaliningrad or Königsberg, and at what point did that shift happen? The map has it labeled "Königsberg", and I'm hoping that could give some clue as to what year the map was made in.

2 Answers 2015-11-19

"in modern history (20th century) every war was either between a free state and a police state or two police states." Is this true?

I was just watching a debate, and the person makes a statement that in modern history (20th century) every war was either between a free state and a police state or two police states. Is this true?

1 Answers 2015-11-19

In World War Z, one of the characters claims that the population explosion in China was because Mao thought it was the only way to win a nuclear war. Is there any truth to this?

And while we are at it: how was population growth in China controlled?

3 Answers 2015-11-19

Did the Romans or Greeks have any battle cries?

1 Answers 2015-11-19

Questions about "body shaping clothing" and how to deal with an out-of-fashion body shape 1800-1950

I know corsets are a staple of a lot of European women's clothing, and the shape from corseting changed between the Elizabethan flat-fronted, and the Victorian wasp, and so on, but what if you couldn't get the ideal shape because your body just isn't shaped that way?

What if you were a super skinny Victorian woman with no boobs or hips? A corset has nothing to smoosh, so it wouldn't really help. Likewise in the 1920s - what if you're super busty/curvy, and can't fit into a flapper dress because of huge boobs? Are there 1920s equivalent to modern chest binders? What about big hips?

Were there pre-modern fake boobs? Fake bums? How do you cope if you're the wrong shape for the fashion of the time?

3 Answers 2015-11-18

Why was medieval Christian piety so strict?

I'm reading the primary source of St. Benedict's rules for monastery life. It exemplifies a lot of cliches about Christian piety--that they don't allow laughter, talking, sex (obviously), or really anything happy at all.

What made them this way? Because I can't imagine that anyone would work so hard to avoid happiness unless they had a really good reason. And lest you say that the reason is heaven, it still begs the question why heaven was so important to them; we don't usually idealize that much unless our lives are unbearable.

Maybe the fact that Rome (a symbol of decadence), which had been the leader of the known world, was sacked around that time (532 CE) and led people to see worldly-indulgence as bad?

2 Answers 2015-11-18

In 16th century England, when a noble was given a title upgrade, was there a public ceremony or recognition to go along with the letters patent?

I'm slogging my way through "The Other Boleyn Girl" (please don't as me why--I'm questioning my own sanity) and it just occurred to me that for all the talk about how Anne Boleyn and her relations were ennobled with titles and offices in the king's household, no historian--in my memory--has written whether or not there was any kind of investiture ceremony enacted publicly to affirm their new titles. Most historians don't even bother to mention the letters patent which was considered the legal document issued by the crown that granted a peerage to an individual. The most that I can recall in this context was Anne's coronation and the controversy it caused, but by that point she was being crowned queen and we all know there's an established ceremony that goes along with that title. But what about when she was made a marchioness? Did she get a ceremony then? Or was it simply a matter of the crown issuing the letters patent and the king saying "BTW, you're a marchioness now, congrats."

1 Answers 2015-11-18

Why did Franco choose King Juan Carlos as His Successor?

As the title asks, why did Franco choose King Juan Carlos as his successor? I never thought of Franco as a Falange ideologue (far more a pragmatist), but it seems a bit strange to me, that he decided to reinstate the monarchy, knowing that it would put in jeopardy his entire supporting column (the Falange army, bureaucracy etc).

Were his supporters not afraid of democracy, and then the very high chance of lustration? And if not, why were the Falange so willing to give up power, rather than install a new dictator from the Falange?

2 Answers 2015-11-18

Which Hungarian territories wore occupied by Romania after WW1 and for how long?

During the Hungarian-Romanian War, the Romanian army had advanced towards the Hungarian capital, Budapest. I am looking for which territories wore controlled by the Romanian army and for how long they held them for until they withdrew.

2 Answers 2015-11-18

Because of the use of the Fat Man and the Little Boy, was World War 2 considered a thermonuclear war?

1 Answers 2015-11-18

How much did Plymouth & Jamestown colonists know about failed colonies at Popham & Roanoke?

Did the Mayflower passengers know much about the failed Popham Colony of 1607? Would they only know minor details about that colony, or would there have been more extensive study into its location, techniques, tools, etc?

Conversely, what did the Jamestown colonists know about Roanoke, other than the fact that its inhabitants disappeared?

Did either Plymouth or Jamestown change their courses, approaches, etc, based on these prior failures?

2 Answers 2015-11-18

Did wars really occurred because of condiments?

I'm super confused, i'm getting the idea that some armies (armies?) would have traveled and fought to get condiments for their or someone's food flavor. I mean, was food flavor really a cause of war or invasion? I know there are wars for quality of life, but this?

2 Answers 2015-11-18

Is there any evidence of purposeful killings during Medieval melees?

It's my understanding that they were not supposed to kill any opponents, but that it could potentially happen by accident. If there is evidence of a purposeful killing, how did they get away with it?

I hope this fits properly into the rules, if it does not I apologize.

Edit: To clarify I mean I am referring to tournament mêlées.

1 Answers 2015-11-18

When a ruler is publicly disposed of, what happens to all the coins/statues/pictures etc with their face on?

I was just doing my homework reading up about the English Civil Wars and reading about how after Charles 1 was executed the Rump Parliament made up a new seal with Parliament on it, not the monarch. It made me wonder what happened to everything else with Charles 1s face on it, and then it made me think about how logistically difficult it would have been to destroy all such royal memorabilia, and then I realised that this problem has probably been faced multiple times throughout history and I should just ask you guys. :D Clarification: I don't just want to know about what happened in Charles 1s case, any examples of relics of a ruler having to be destroyed after they has been despatched would be cool.

5 Answers 2015-11-18

Why did Canada and Australia declare war on Germany so quickly (WW2)?

To the best of my understanding I know that during WW1 Britain still controlled their foreign affairs and so were responsible for declaration of wars. By the time WW2 began however Canada and Australia were completely independent so why did they join the war so quickly and not stay neutral as Ireland did?

2 Answers 2015-11-18

We need help identifying a World War One/Two badge!

Here is an image http://imgur.com/rg3jFwY

Can anyone identify this badge?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-11-18

How did the Soviet Military go from being decimated by purges to victory in Berlin within a decade?

How was this achieved considering most of the best of the Soviet Military leadership was decimated by Stalin's mistrust of the military ? Especially with how disastrous the defence against operation Barbarossa was.

2 Answers 2015-11-18

How did Japan's relations with Europe and the West change from the 1890's to the 1930's?

Also, what were that factors that could've led to this change, like Japan's global standing post-war, and events that led to it. Thanks for any answers you guys may have!

1 Answers 2015-11-18

4788 / 7255

Back to start