Why did the Allied Powers Divide Berlin?

Why didn't the Soviets argue that since they fought and took Berlin that they should be allowed to keep the whole city as part of East Germany? Why did they decide to split it with the Western Allied Powers?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | October 14, 2021

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

9 Answers 2021-10-14

Are there are documents/books similar to The Evolution of Operational Art by Georgii Samoilovich Isserson, talking about a country's military doctrine would be fought in a hypothetical WW2 or reviewing after the war?

I found The Evolution of Operational Art and thought it was really fascinating. I was curious if there are any other like it out there from other countries. What were they thinking before the war started? Reviewing doctrine after WW2 is also fine!

1 Answers 2021-10-14

did movie trailers exist in the early 20th century and if so what were they like?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

What did the Latin word "inferis" mean prior to the arrival of Christianity in Rome?

One of the most memorable quotes from the 1997 movie Event Horizon is:

Liberate tutemet ex inferis

It translates to "Save yourself from hell".

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the closest concept the pre-Christian Romans had to what we call "hell" was Tartarus. "Inferis" also translates to "underground", but for a pre-Christian Roman, did "inferis" refer to Tartarus, or was the word invented to refer to the Christian concept of hell?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Why Alaric able to achieve what Hannibal can't?

Greetings fellow history lovers,

Firstly I apologize for my English (or grammar) since it's not my first language.

Secondly, I thanks in advance for any responses to my question, on why Alaric are able to achieve what Hannibal can't which is to sack Rome?

I have been enjoying HistoryMarche's series on Hannibal, and somehow rooting for Hannibal inspite of knowing he would eventually lost. Then it comes to mind, the question on why Alaric are able to sack Rome.

I'm looking forward to everyone's responses.

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Why do Sweden, Norway and Denmark not list Oden (Odin/Woden) as their first king when most of the old Anglo-Saxon kingdoms does?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Was the Imperial Chinese worldview and philosophy inherently peaceful or even "pacifist"?

Obviously it still waged wars and dissolved into bloody rebellions and schisms multiple times, but it's often said that the humanist outlook of the dominant threads of Chinese thought tended to disincentivise war. Can we say that the Chinese worldview was genuinely more peaceable than its counterparts elsewhere? If so, how and why did it develop differently?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

was napoleon a bad guy?

what i mean by that is, was he evil, was he comparable to lets say hitler or stalin?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Jesters

Can a Jester insult a King without being beheaded? Are the Jester's included in Wars? Is there still a living Jester today?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

How did women have abortions throughout history before surgical abortions were invented?

There is mention in the Bible of methods so they certainly had ways but what were they?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Slavery Apologists occasionally toss out that Black Africans sold other Africans into slavery. How often did this actually happen and go what extent were the slave-selling factions aware of the horrors of the Transatlantic Slave Trade?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

What are some good books about history of East Asian architecture pre-Western influence?

Preferably that goes into the style and structural evolution across the time as well as regional and explanation about how the structure works and technical diagram (I'm going to use it to make 3d models).

I'm interested in any of China, Korea, Japan. Comparative books about the three are also welcomed.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Anti-Masonic sentiment seemed to be extremely prevalent in the early United States. How was this reconciled with the fact that many Founding Fathers were Freemasons?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Is the movie ''The Favourite'' Plausible?

SPOILERS

What i want to know is if women really could have that much power in that era. I mean, the Queen doesn't have a husband, so i guess she holds all the power, and if she has all the power she can give it to her lover. So i think is plausible, but i wanted to be sure.

1 Answers 2021-10-14

what are some good online resources, YouTube channels, or books to learn about early European Colonization of North America and of the Revolutionary War Era, founding fathers, etc?

So I am taking the time to slowly learn about different parts of US history and I want to start with the first couple of eras. I want to understand how this country was founded first and foremost.

Any recommendations for what to watch, read, etc?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

How did women treat urinary tract infections before the rise of antibiotics?

1 Answers 2021-10-14

Multi-lingualism in the time of Alexander

I’m reading Arrian’s Anabasis of Alexander, and in the section detailing the jobs given to Alexander’s friends who were exiled on his behalf during Phillip’s reign, he says that Alexander appointed “Eriguios as cavalry commander of the allies, and his brother Laomedon (who was bilingual) commander of the barbarians taken in war.” I’m assuming that “allies” in this context means Greek troops, and “barbarians” means any non-Macedonians or Greeks? So what does “bilingual” mean in this context— what language are we supposed to understand Laomedon as speaking that is valuable? Is it Greek, or would speaking Greek be assumed for cavalry-class Macedonians (or was the native Macedonian language of the time similar enough to Greek to be interoperable?) If it were Greek, wouldn’t it make more sense to put him in charge of Greek-speaking troops? Or are we supposed to assume barbarian=mostly Persian at this point, and assume he speaks Persian?

More generally, I’d be grateful for any resources someone could point me to on multilingualism at the time— what kinds of people would speak what second languages, where did translators come from, etc.

Thank you!

2 Answers 2021-10-14

Where did servants of illustrious European houses in the 18th and 19th centuries find time to have families? At least in novels of the era, they seem to be on call at all hours, existing as a mere means for such families' ends. Did they often die bachelors/spinsters due to lack of time for families?

1 Answers 2021-10-13

You're invited to a live roundtable next week - All Women Have a Past: Reconstructing Women in History

Join us on Thursday, October 21 at 5 pm EDT for a live Q&A chat about how women have been misrepresented in history!

Ready to register? Reserve your spot here!

The conversation will be moderated by Daniel Howlett (u/dhowlett1692), with Cassidy Percoco (u/mimicofmodes) speaking on "Wicked Queens: the afterlives of Isabeu of Bavaria, Catherine de'Medici, and Marie Antoinette," Dom Webb (u/Dom_Webb) on "Churchill's Angels? the female agents of SOE's F section in popular memory and culture," and Annie Whitehead (u/AnnieAuthor) on "Kept in the Dark: What is the true story of women in power in pre-conquest England?"

Women’s lives have long been the subject of overexcited imaginations. Whether they seek to vilify or romanticize, the sensationalized ways in which women have been represented and remembered rarely does justice to the historical reality, rendering them as one-dimensional caricatures rather than rich, complex characters in their own right. While historical and literary representations of women tend to center around the home and gendered notions of women's roles, in reality women have always been at the center of political and military histories. This roundtable uncovers the stories of elite women such as queens and spies for whom such shallow misrepresentations have become the norm, showcasing how historians now seek to reconstruct the fullness of their lives.

You can read more about the speakers and their topics on the conference webpage. Registration is free, but attendance is limited, so make sure to register now to secure your spot!

Interested in what else we have lined up for the Ask Historians 2021 Digital Conference next week? Check out the full conference program. It's the place to find our full schedule of events, abstracts, and bios for all our awesome speakers! And don't forget to register for the live keynote and networking sessions.

4 Answers 2021-10-13

Why was a Regiment losing it's colors/flag in the days of line battles considered such a big deal?

1 Answers 2021-10-13

Why didn’t civilizations in the Americas develop castles, catapults, and the general medieval sieges we saw in Asia or Europe?

3 Answers 2021-10-13

Cold War Archival Research Help/Looking for the Communications and Electronics Digest

This was a text published by the USAF during the Cold War. Does anyone know how to access it? Here is an example of a title page. I am a PhD student who would be grateful for any help!

1 Answers 2021-10-13

Why did we start calling it "Late Antiquity" instead of "Decline of the Empire"?

This subject may be touchy, but be certain that this is a sincere question that I haven't been able to answer by myself.

AFAIK, the current academic consensus on Vth Century Europe is that the Roman Empire didn't decline as much as it did, well, transform.

Thing is, I do not quite understand where that distinction stands, and what makes "Late Antiquity" a useful concept instead of a pretty word to avoid doing a moral judgement on history.

As an example: nowadays, historians say that Roman Art became less realistic and more symbolic due to cultural changes. Why do historians say this instead of determining that artists just got... worse?

Looking at the arch of Constantine in Rome, surely one can see how statues look more rigid than their I and II century counterparts. Even Byzantine Art during the Macedonian renaissance looks quite a bit more awkward than art from the Augustan period... How are we so sure this was the artistic intent, and not just a lack of expertise on the part of the craftsman?

1 Answers 2021-10-13

Considering his extremely racist and genocidal ideology, why did Adolf Hitler outlaw human zoos?

While we’re at it, is this even true? I often hear it thrown around as a fun fact but I’ve never verified the veracity of this claim.

2 Answers 2021-10-13

497 / 7255

Back to start