A book I read in high school labeled Robert Menzies as a tyrant. Is this justified?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Good book or article on why the smaller German States were willing to cede power to Prussia during unification?

German unification has always been a little confusing to me. Mainly around the point of the smaller/weaker states essentially giving up some amount of sovereignty to Prussia. I know Prussia was the most powerful German state at this point and there were fears of popular revolutions bringing down the various German monarchies, but it is a rare thing in history for a sovereign state to willingly surrender power to another state. I would love a book or article recommendation on this topic.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Why was Entrenched Stalemate such an important part of the Western Front of WW1, but the Eastern Front was more of a Mobile Stalemate?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

3 Answers 2015-09-16

How was William the Bastard able to get Papal support for his invasion of England?

One of my university modules last year involved looking at 1066 and it was emphasised that William the Bastard was given authorisation to carry the Papal banner with him during his invasion of England, showing that he had the support of the Papacy behind him.

However, I've recently been reading Thomas Asbridge's book "The Crusades" and in the introduction he details that until the time of Pope Gregory VII, any fighting and war by Christians was highly frowned upon, and that despite the idea of "just" wars (noted as being solely ones of defence) any and all bloodshed was, regardless, incredibly sinful.

So why did Pope Alexander II support William in his venture despite the fact that it was obviously going to result in bloodshed between Christians? I read somewhere (though I can't remember where) that it was potentially because English Christianity didn't adhere as closely to Catholic doctrine as the rest of Western Europe and so the Pope wanted to reaffirm Catholic power in the area. Was this the case?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How come soldiers in Mesoamerica and Japan didn't make widespread use of larger shields like in Eurasia?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Was slavery common in the Spanish Empire ?

Spanish-speaking Latin America seems to have received many less African slaves comparing to Brazil or the US. Did Spanish elites use native forces as slaves? Was this allowed/encouraged by the central administration in Spain? What did the catholic church think about it?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How strongly did you have to speak out against the Chinese government to be a political prisoner or get executed?

During the Great Leap Forward

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Why did the Roman Empire persecute Christians at various points in its history?

3 Answers 2015-09-16

How acceptable has homosexuality been throughout European history, and what have been the main factors that have made it more/less acceptable as time went on?

Obvious events would be the emergence of the Catholic Church, but apart from this how accepted or taboo has homosexuality been? You often hear that civilisations like the Greeks and Romans treated homosexuality like it was perfectly normal.

3 Answers 2015-09-16

Why did the USSR reject genetics?

From the little I've read about it, the rejection seems to mainly be for ideological reasons. As in it didn't fit with the communist ideas of equality and was too "bourgeois". Surely this can't be the whole story? Was there some economic benefit to it or some other type of pragmatic reasoning behind the rejection?

3 Answers 2015-09-16

In the 19th century and before, How prevalent was pregnancy among prostitutes in brothels and how were those babies dealt with?

3 Answers 2015-09-16

I've got some questions about the Aztec religion. (the Aztec people are also known as "Mexicas").

What kind of rituals did they have?

What kind of "demons" were there? What kind of gods were there?

Did they have any intitiation-rituals? example: the ritual that turns a boy into a man.

Did they have any interesting myths?

Any rites?

Any magic, sorcery?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

When and why are certain Chinese Emperors referred to as "The _______ Emperor" starting in the Ming Dynasty?

It seems to have started with the Ming Dynasty where our histories start to refer to Chinese Emperors as said in the title. What is the significance of this?

Every Emperor from the Ming dynasty has this naming template, but the first three sovereigns from the Qing Dynasty do not follow the same pattern as every other Emperor in the Qing Dynasty. Why is that?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

u/Beltharean mentioned that some of the Saxon nobility disposed of by the Normans went on to become mercenaries, notably in the Byzantine Empire. At the risk of being too vague, can someone explain how this occurred and what impact it had?

Considering the Romans used to control parts of Britain, a long long time before these events, did the Byzantines take particular interest in the origin and history of these foreign mercenaries? Was there any significant informational or cultural exchange?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Who was in the inner circle of Caesar Augustus?

I don't believe that anyone can reign supreme all by himself. Who were the key players in the inner circle of Augustus, who helped him to seemingly reign supreme and what did Augusts did for them in return?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

It seems early Ottoman sultans abdicated and retired before they died at a higher rate than many other contemporary empires. Why was this?

Bayezid and Murad both did it, I'm sure others did as well. I remember it being a huge deal historically that Diocletian retired in Rome, so what's the situation in the Ottoman Empire? I've heard it suggested that this was to ensure a peaceful transition of power, but the Ottomans had peaceful transitions of power when sultans held on until their deaths, so I'm really not sure about this.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Are there any written accounts of slave traders/owners realizing that what they did was morally wrong?

In media they're essentially all portrayed as evil- the one exception I can think of is Benedict Cumberbatch in 12 years a slave. But are there any others?

Edit: any time in history is fine.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Is this verse from the Koran taken from an Assyrian poem about Christmas ? is there a source for that poem ?

Hello,

I am an agnostic who live in a Muslim country and just found out about two great people writers : Theodor Nöldeke and Christoph Luxenberg, during my reading i found out about the "claim" of one of the Koran verse (Al-Qadr) is entirely taken from an old Assyrian poem about Christmas and am very curious about this and want to know if any of you have something that can confirm it, here is the verse in English **as explained by Muslims "expert" ** :

We sent down the Quran in the Night of Destiny.

And how could you know the Night of Destiny? (in arabic the expression "ma-adrak" litteraly mean you don't know, but the purpose is to glorify that thing)

The night of destiny is better than a thousand months of worshiping.

Gabriel and the angels come down with the Lord permission and all his command.

It is a peaceful night until the appearance of dawn.

And here is an English version that i translated without any ideological interpretation :

We sent it/him down on the night of destiny

(yes, the verse literally said "it" or "him" because in arabic there is no difference unless you get the entire contest, but the point here is that there is no mention at all to Koran, holy book, papers or whatever)

And how could you know the night of destiny ?

The Night of destiny is better than a thousand months.

The spirit and the angels come down with the Lord permission and all his command

(also it literally said "spirit" no Gabriel or anything that refers to "him")

It is a peaceful night until the appearance of dawn.

And honestly it kinda make sense when you think of it from a Christian perspective, it really look like a happy poem about the "birth of Jesus".

So, can any of you please back this story ?

PS: no, am not trying to make any religion look better than the other, i don't care about them all, am just curious about this.

Thank you

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Shore Bombardment in the Age of Sail

How were shore bombardments carried out during the Age of Sail? Did the ships sail past firing, merely haul up their sails, coast to a stop and begin firing, or did they anchor before opening fire?

If they anchored, then how did the ships anchor themselves so that their guns face the shore?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Any recommendations for books that focus on the ancient Germans?

I'd like to find some materials that give the story of the Germans, from migrations from Scandinavia until the sack of Rome. I know that's pretty broad, but honestly, I'd like to learn up on them in that date range.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Regional variations of medieval helmets?

When I watch videos or read about late medieval armor (1300-1500), many of them talk about the different helmets ( armets, bascinets, sallets, etc.). I can identify all these ones, but sometimes the author or video maker also makes comments on the region, saying that they can find similarities in the armor attributed to a certain region/power/kingdom/country of Europe (e.g. a Milanese variation pigfaced bascinet visor in comparison to an English one). While I can see different variations from antique helmets when I search them up, I can't tell what is what. Is there any info on how to identify certain helmets from certain regions? Any fashions specific from one kingdom to another's visors/shape/etc. in helmets? Are there any good books that you would recommend that would help identify these?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Why weren't Native American more industrialized as Europeans/Asians?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

What native american warfare techonolgy was the most advanced at first european contact? What time period would it correspond to for europe?

Was any native american technology more advanced than warfare from a european or asian perspective?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

What happened to the Norse inhabitants of Greenland?

I've been reading that Denmark only 'recolonized' in the 16th century - with all contact with Greenland stopping a few centuries prior. What happened to the Norse population that had lived there since the 9th century? Did it die out/intermingle with the Inuit? Are there any stories or legends about these norsemen by the Inuit?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

4970 / 7255

Back to start