What single discovery/invention caused the biggest loss in jobs due to redundancy?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Who made the paper during the printing revolution of the Renaissance? Did they get rich making paper?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Why has there not been a cout de ta in North Korea yet?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

How did the Spanish win the Battle of Cartagena in 1741?

I mean the British outnumbered them almost 10 times over, how could they fuck up this bad?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

How would gay men and lesbians find each other in homophobic cultures without being found out?

I suppose this question can be applied to some cultures in present time also, but for example, if a gay man in the middle ages in Europe (according to Wikipedia there was homophobic intolerance at this time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homophobia#Origins) wanted to find another gay man, how would he do it without attracting unwanted and possibly dangerous attention from authorities/public/etc?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

How sensible was the concept of equipping bombers with heavy defensive armament during World War II? (B-17, B-24, B-29) etc.

I am by no means very knowledgeable about World War II bomber designs but it seems to me that the addition of so many extra machine gun turrets and corresponding crew members would require a considerably larger, and more expensive, bomber than a more minimalistic design would have required. I understand that some of the guns were served by crew members who had another primary assignment (bombardier/nose gunner, for example) but it also appears (though I might be mistaken) that some crew members only function was to serve as gunners (the ball turret gunner, for example).

Were these designs sensible from a resource allocation point of view, considering both the extra cost and manpower requirements for these bombers? I understand that for most of the war long range fighter cover was not available but did the defensive advantage provided by the gunners make up for this extra expense or could these resources have been used better by building and crewing more, but smaller, bombers instead?

Than you in advance. // Plicated

2 Answers 2015-08-27

If the Civil War was truly about slavery, as so many of my fellow citizens of the north love to believe, then why were there slave owners in the north?

2 Answers 2015-08-27

Why is Mao Zedong responsible for an estimated 40 to 70 million deaths when China's population grew from around 550 to over 900 million during the period of his leadership?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-08-27

How does /r/AskHistorians feel about the show "Vikings" on the History Channel?

Does the show accurately show what we know about viking traditions and life in Scandinavia?

Are the fighting styles, weapons, and armor of the time in line with what we know about viking raiders and their counterparts?

How much of the show's mythology and legends are accurate compared to the sagas of the vikings?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

How often did slaves successfully escape their slavery and make it to freedom in the North?

I'm watching Django Unchained, and it got me to wondering how often slaves in the American south were successful in their escape attempts. Are there any statistics on the subject? Would the average escapee have had a decent chance of making it to freedom?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Was the SS a government? Could you say the SS was a government.

Today I recieved the following response in relation to this same question, and it goes as follows:

I am not an expert on German politics (I have an uncle who is a well known war historian but I don't think he'd appreciate a phone call from me at this time of the morning!) but this is my understanding of how Hitler came to power:

Paul von Hindenburg was Germany's president elect in 1925. It was Hindenburg that appointed Hitler (who was, at the time, the leader of the increasingly popular Nazi Party in Germany) as Chancellor of Germany in 1933, making him an official part of the ruling regime.

Hindenburg was pressured/harassed/bullied by Hitler to give him that gig, and although he apparently didn't like Hitler (even though they were both pretty horrible) he caved to Hitler's demands and gave him the role even though he'd been saying no thanks and go away Hitler for years (Hitler was an annoying little turd from the get go).

After dissolving the parliament twice, aiding the Nazi party's rise to power and dismantling agreements around civil liberties, Hindenburg signed the Enabling Act in 1933 which began the process of transforming the Weimar Republic (the federal republic and semi-presidential representative democracy established in Germany in 1919) into the Third Reich.

The Enabling Act gave Hitler's administration legislative powers. Hindenburg died the following year (1934), after which Hitler declared the office of President vacant and made himself head of state.

In a nutshell, Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany from 1934 to 1945.

As ill gotten as it was, Hitler was indeed head of state and horribly, everything he did was borne out of his self-appointment to that role.

So although it's totally hideous, Hitler did run the government of the day at that time in Germany. Foul.

How accurate is this?

Any help given is very much appreciated as always!

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Author Tony Judt claims "because Germany didn't pay its [WWI] debts, the cost of victory victory to the Allies exceeded the cost of defeat to Germany, which thus emerged relatively stronger than in 1913." To what extent is this true?

I know that Germany took many decades to pay back its WWI debt, and only recently completed paying it off. However, this claim surprises me, especially in light of how terrible hyperinflation was in Germany during the Depression. Does Judt mean that Germany was strong economically until the Depression? Or is Judt's claim non consensus among historians?

(Source of the quotation is the Introduction to Judt's book Postwar)

2 Answers 2015-08-27

What did the governments tried to do to deal with the great famine during the dark ages?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Why was Silicon Valley developed as such in the southern rim of the Bay Area? Why not anywhere else?

Why was the southern part of the Bay Area made into a tech hub?

Other places deserve a revitalization, like maybe East St. Louis and the surrounding area on the east bank of the Mighty Mississippi. Wonder why a tech hub wouldn't get developed there instead.

I wonder what the historical reasons were in developing the southern Bay Area for this.

2 Answers 2015-08-27

Historians specialists, what documentaries from you specific area would you recommend?

5 Answers 2015-08-27

What is the opinion of historians on the real utility of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings? Is it possible that they saved more lives than they took?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

So what [historically speaking] is Amtrak?

What exactly is Amtrak?

I originally asked this question in a thread about the creation of zip codes when I saw this response (great answer thanks to /u/davratta !)

... After 1963, the Postal Service canceled or allowed to lapse, all of its Mail contracts with the railroad companies. Railroads had been losing money on passenger trains, since 1925, but these loses were mitigated by the revenue they got from moving mail and express (small packages) traffic. The Railroad Express Agency was facing serious problems during the 1960s as UPS and the Post Office's own Parcel Post service cut deeply into its revenues.

With the zip code system and the cancellation of most Mail contracts, the final prop that was supporting the money losing passenger trains in the United States was kicked away. That led to a sharp increase in passenger train cancellations during the late 1960s and the creation of Amtrak in 1971.

I'm immediately struck by the fact that a train company is created in the face of lack of demand for trains. I've learned since asking this question initially that that it's owned by the government, but why the hell would the government choose to do something so daft? All cliche^'s aside.

Also, how did/does it differ from its competitors?

How did it come into existence, and by the will of whom?

And were there other companies vying with Amtrak to do what it did?

Thanks as always to everyone who comments here in order to enlighten the rest of us!

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Where there any famous theme parks or theme park-like entertainment centers in Cold War Eastern Block Russia?

I recall a story my undergrad professor told us about Khrushchev's first visit to America. He really wanted to go visit Disneyland, but couldn't because of safety concerns. Angry, he declared he would build he own theme park in Russia. Just curious if Russia or any of the other Eastern Block counties had any 'Disney land' equivalents so to speak.

3 Answers 2015-08-27

When was the turning point for the LGBT community?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-08-27

If the Nazis had waited until after the war to begin the process of the Holocaust, could the economic advantage (of not having to fund both the war effort and the Holocaust) have tipped the scales in favour of the Axis?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Why didn't Hitler tell Mussolini about his plans to invade the USSR?

I saw this on a documentary today. It was a total surprise to Mussolini. I thought the Italians were in it from the start. Why didn't Hitler tell him and when did the Italians get into the USSR war?

4 Answers 2015-08-27

Hesiods three generations of man.

In his book "days and works" Hesiod speaks of four generations of man. Previous to his the "age of iron"

The golden generation of mortal man. The silver generation of man. The bronze generation. "The black death seized them" the cataclysmic even that ended the bronze age? The generation of hero men.

Are these hints at previous civilisations or epochs that have otherwise been forgotten or wiped out, and the proceeding generations are man starting from infancy after some unknown event(s)

Am I missing some point?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

When did shirts first start having collars?

3 Answers 2015-08-27

Can anybody help me find books about Nestor Makhno and the Ukrainian Free Territory?

1 Answers 2015-08-27

Did Chinese officials and attendants change methods of directly addressing the emperor of China between the Qin, Han, Tang, Song, Yuan, Ming, or Qing dynasty? If so what did they say change into through History?

I was browsing through old Chinese shows that idolized the depiction of various famous emperors, but something that got me thinking was the method each emperor was addressed.

I tried to look up on Wikipedia, and it did give methods an emperor could be properly addressed, but I didn't find anything specific to the the addressing segments.

1 Answers 2015-08-27

5030 / 7255

Back to start