I am working on a game set in the cold war, and I was initially against the idea of having “influence” be some arbitrary number, which I thought would be too gamey. But after a bit of research I came across the percentages agreement where Churchill and Stalin agree on spheres of influences using percentages.
I have looked up a few sources on the agreement, and most just seem to regurgitate the same few information (considering how “crude” the agreement was, I am not surprised there’s not many sources on the) but the one part that I am wondering and that isn’t even mentioned anywhere is what did the percentages of influence actually mean in the real world? How does having 50% or 70% influence translate to the real world?
Thank you all in advance for your answers :)
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Hi, here’re in Italy people always wondered if Mussolini actually wanted war, i know that from the 20’ to the end of the 30’ Mussolini wasn’t seen that bad by the people but when war started, inflation went up and there was a whole civil war people hated Mussolini. Maybe he thought that his “Parallel war” stragegy would work? I’m asking here because anyone else has a clear answer
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Apologies if the premise of my question is off and there were large African states prior to European colonization.
When I try to research pre-colonial African nations I find maps like this one. On that map, it shows a few small African states and large swathes of stateless land.
Why is this? Were there political, technological, social, or geographical reasons why Africa was not covered in nation states (or something similar to nation states) before European colonizers arrived?
Alternatively, if the stateless land on the linked map above was primarily inhabited by tribal societies, how advanced were those tribal societies?
3 Answers 2022-11-16
I don't even know if this is the right place to ask this and I honestly lack the proper language to ask google. So how do we translate ancient languages without linguistical keys (like the Rosetta Stone)? Are there real examples of this being done?
How about living languages? How did European invaders learn first people's languages at first? Or the inverse.
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Hi, I'm pretty interested in audio or visual interviews of world war one veterans. I've watched most of the interviews on YouTube and I've really enjoyed them. The problem is, I can't seem to find any long interviews of World War One veterans that were made before the 80s. Maybe its just my search engine use incompetence but most of the videos I've seen are from the 21st century. I know these interviews are out there, can any one recommend a good place or film to find one?
2 Answers 2022-11-16
For example. The bronzes have both Latin and Etruscan inscriptions and generally seem to point to cultural and religious overlap.
Does this find actually change our interpretation of how Roman and Etruscan elites interacted during the period of Roman expansion? I'm always skeptical of these pop-history articles with sweeping claims that pivot around a single find. Especially when the academic interviewed in the article uses much cagier language like "has the possibility to rewrite".
What is the actual significance of this find?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
3 Answers 2022-11-16
Hi there, for an assignment, I am comparing Prospero's magic book to other historical examples of spellbooks or something similar, I feel like I have some things on the tip of my tongue but just cannot quite place exactly what I am going for here. The only one that springs to mind is the Necronomicon, but if there are others, fictional or otherwise, would love a handful of ideas. Thanks!
The entire prompt is very open ended and the topic is my choice so hoping it is fine to ask here rather than in the HW specific subreddit.
2 Answers 2022-11-16
Hi! I have looked at a number of sources and cannot come to a conclusive answer. As the title suggests, I'd like to know how many troops would be able to be transported on various ships around 1500-1600s. I've seen a number of sources say that a crew of 50 for a Carrack or 20-30 for a Caravel. But, mainly I find sources stating how much tonnage of cargo it can carry. I'm unfamiliar on how to translate that to actual troop counts.
How would a medieval army, for example, transport 15,000 soldiers from one coast to another? I understand that they may use a fleet of many variety of ships. I'm interested in knowing which types would be mostly used and how many actual soldiers, not crew, would be able to land ashore.
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Was cheese generally something made by each family? Was it generally aged, or were soft/fresh cheeses more common?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
I understand the reason behind why Native Americans are called Indians or American Indians, but why hasn't there been a push to change it? Respected news outlets like NPR still use that term, and so do many books. Why not call them Native Americans or something similar?
2 Answers 2022-11-16
Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.
Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.
Here are the ground rules:
31 Answers 2022-11-16
I'm looking to read 30-40 pages of any primary source document from prior to 1500 CE to analyze the
biases of it. Are there any particular documents that come to mind which has strong bias? Thank you
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Recently finished reading Elizabeth Greenhalgh's The French Army and the First World War, and towards the end she states that conscription ended offically in 2001. After WW1 I can see why, but surely they would have gotten rid of it after the second world war. Did they just forget to end it? Or is there something else to the story?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
As I have read numerous books on that topic and have watched documentaries around that topic, I would like to ask for your honest opinion. Was JFK shot by Oswald or it was a bigger conspiracy? I believe that the Cubans have a huge part in the shooting of JFK because I've read a book last year, Live By The Sword by Gus Russo(1998) in which the author gives a pretty detailed analysis on Kennedy's Cuba obsession and claims that Castro gave a green light about the murder as a sort of revenge because of US attempts to kill him. Oswald's life is detailed also in the book. I highly recommend it. So what do you think - was it Lee Harvey Oswald or somebody else was behind it?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Today marks the anniversary of Oklahoma becoming the 46th State in the United States of America. I'm reading a historical section of a local Oklahoma newspaper which claims, "During the American Civil War, most tribes in Indian Territory supported the South." I am curious as to the veracity of this claim. Did most tribes really support the South? If so, are there any insights into why any particular tribe would side with them? Likewise, any insights into tribal opposition of supporting the South?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Are there any books for students about methods used in contemporary medieval studies to research and write history?
To give you an idea of the kind of thing I'm looking for: something about doing medieval history comparable to the books in Routledge's "Approaching the Ancient World" series for ancient historians (https://www.routledge.com/Approaching-the-Ancient-World/book-series/SE0153), or David Schaps's "Handbook for Classical Research" / Michael Crawford's "Sources for Ancient History" in classics, or David Law's "The Historical-Critical Method: A Guide for the Perplexed" in Biblical studies.
Thanks!
1 Answers 2022-11-16
We would like to know more about the KKK because we are very interested in the political situation during 1865-1945. I hope you can answer some of our following questions.
We know that the KKK was a big group but why was such a radical group popular at that time?
We know that there was a first and a second KKK uprising, what was the difference between them?
On the internet we can find a lot of information about the original KKK group, but less about the group that came afterward. Can you tell us more about this?
How did the first downfall of the KKK happen?
Where did the KKK get their typical clothing from and why?
Was the KKK during the specified time period controlled by one leader or were there many different factions of the KKK?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
Ancient Apocalypse (GH’s show) is the 2nd most watched show on Netflix worldwide.
GH thesis in short: there was a sophisticated civilization living in the last Ice Age that was obliterated by a global natural disaster. The survivors of this civilization transferred their skills and knowledge to hunter gatherers eventually giving birth to important civilizations in Mesoamerica and/or Egypt and/or Asia.
2 Answers 2022-11-16
Like many older Portuguese people, my dad has a lot of nationalist ideas tangled up in our history as explorers and conquerors, and when he made this claim at dinner I assumed it was just another conspiracy theory.
The claim is that Portuguese sailors actually discovered the maritime way to Australia before the Dutch and made contact with native people, but then pretended they hadn't found it because it would've been in violation of the Treaty of Tordesillas.
His arguments are:
- Some linguistic similarities between Portuguese and native dialects (in words like tartaruga, which means turtle in both Portuguese and some local languages)
- The fact that we did "discover" and settled Timor-Leste, "only" 400km away (seems like a fallacy to me, since sailors back then wouldn't have known they were "only" 400km from another land mass, and also 400km on a motorless boat is not an insignificant distance)
Since I found this Wikipedia article, it does seem like, even if this is a conspiracy theory, it's more widely known/debated than just my dad.
So I wanted to ask: how likely do historians find the theory that Portuguese were the first European people to sail to Australia? And where/why did this theory come from? Were old-timey Portuguese people faking maps to try and claim colonization rights over Australia?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
1 Answers 2022-11-16
I was reading some old posts from /u/EnclavedMicrostate and i saw this tantalizing bit:
The core of the Red Flag Fleet consisted of ships and crews hired as mercenaries to intervene in a Vietnamese rebellion in the 1780s. After the rebellion was stamped out in 1799, the crews returned home to Guangdong Province, whereupon it was discovered that the mobile elements of the provincial garrison had been moved inland to fight the White Lotus Rebellion, thus preventing the provincial armed forces from taking action against them – not that the Qing had possessed a substantial naval force since the defeat of the Te family (also written 鄭 but Romanised from Hokkien this time) in the 1680s anyway.
Which inmediately attracted my attention because my understanding was than the Qing never had any significant naval strenght.
So, who was that family? How did they fall?
1 Answers 2022-11-16
I’ve always been interested in medieval weaponry and tactics, finding it to be some of the most intriguing stuff in military history. I know that during that time there were many different weaponry and armor meant for different tactics, so this may not be a good question, but I was wondering that if I was an every day soldier during a time of war, what combination of equipment would I want to have when I see combat?
I’ve heard the Pole Arm or Halberd is considered the most versatile ones, is that true? Would you pair a pole arm or spear with a shield? Any knowledge you have I’d love to hear!!
1 Answers 2022-11-16