Considering the popularity of wine and ale in the Middle Ages, was fetal alcohol syndrome common?

If not, what drinking sources were safe for mother/fetus?

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Napoleonic Era Naval Questions

I just finished "Desolation Island" by Patrick O'Brian and I had some questions that I was hoping someone might be able to answer for me.

  1. In the beginning it seems the main character (Captain Jack Aubrey) has some sailors from previous adventures serving him personally such as his coxswain, steward, and some old sailor who tends to his daughters. Was this a usual practice for naval officers to retain certain sailors during shore duty (can't think of a better word) for personal household service?

  2. One ship takes on fresh water in Brazil. How did they secure fresh water and did they keep it fresh on the ship? Was this just spring water, boiled water, etc. and did they understand the purification process at this time?

  3. One plot device throughout the book is the transport of prisoners to a prison colony. How were people selected to be transported to such a colony?

  4. Last one. William Bligh is mentioned in the book and I was wondering whatever happened to his career post-Bounty mutiny. It says he ran one of the prison colonies but was that a slight against him? It seems he was a very good seaman but was his career tarnished by then?

[EDIT] 5) This is the for real last question. There's talk of different consulates around the world (I think the book takes place roughly right before War of 1812) and I was wondering how were these managed? Why would the US have a consulate at the Cape of Good Hope? It's mentioned it's because of the trade ships with the east but I guess I'm at a loss of what a consulate's purpose was at this time since my only frame of reference is a modern diplomatic mission which focuses on visas, passports, cultural missions, etc.

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Were the war crimes of South Korea really greater than American war crimes during the Vietnam War?

I was at the Vietnam War Remnants museum in Ho Cho Minh City recently and overheard an American saying that the South Koreans were far more brutal to the Vietnamese during the war and that it was hardly ever talked about. A quick google does give some backing to this claim but many of the links are dead and references hard to check in the wikipedia articles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Korea_in_the_Vietnam_War Is the claim substantial?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

Name of this gas mask

Hello Historians! I own this gas mask and I'd like to know the name of it, I dont suppose any of you know it? imgur.com/a/wywZ3

Sent from my iPhone

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Was the United States the first country to have money called "dollar"? Where did the name come from? Why was it chosen? Why have so many countries adopted the name?

1 Answers 2015-07-13

When did champagne shift from being served in "coupe" style glasses to the more common flute that we see today?

I have noticed this in old film and tv shows where everytime someone is seen drinking champagne it's almost always served in a champagne coupe. However these days it seems to be more commonly served in a flute.

Am I even correct in this observation? I am just curious as to when the coupe went out of fashion and if there was any particular reason?

*edit - spelling

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Petersburg Siege during U.S. Civil War

Why did the Union face the Confederates in a comparatively static position for almost 10 months at Petersburg? Why didn't they get out and go around the Confederates? At a minimum, this would have gotten the Confederates out of the trenches and into a more exposed position where the Union could let their superior numbers and supplies come to bear.

1 Answers 2015-07-13

What is the history of the stereotypical "evil laugh"?

Earlier today while listening to some video game music the question crossed my mind about where the stereotypical 'evil laugh' that comes up so often in music, games, movies, books, and so on comes from. Think this sort of thing, the ol 'muahahahaha'. Where did it first appear? Are there instances of old literature that describe such a laugh, or is it the product of more modern times when audio recording became more prevalent? These days it's practically everywhere in all forms of popular culture and it's hard to imagine what iconic thing denoted that a certain individual was the 'bad guy' before the evil laugh. That being said, as a follow up question of sorts, what was used commonly to denote the 'bad guy' before the occurrence of the evil laugh we know today?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

How did the Byzantines and Nords come in contact with each other prior to the forming of the Varangian Guard?

They both seem very far away from each other so why did the Greeks even bother dealing with the Vikings?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

I am currently in Mallorca, and the weather is oppressively hot. How did the Roman soldiers manage to march around in this (and other hotter places) in full kit, let alone conduct a battle in the heat of the day in the middle of summer? How many casualties were simply due to the heat?

Fitness aside (and they must have been supremely fit), they must have had good water supplies; but even so, the risk of heat exhaustion under armour in 34C of heat or more must have been extremely high.

1 Answers 2015-07-13

When did the Roman legions stop being made up exclusively of citizens?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

What are some times powers/people have failed to censor history?

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Book recommendation on the development of military logistics?

Would love to get book recommendations on how military logistics has developed, in particular in Europe. I am particularly interested in medieval to early modern to Napoleonic era, for land warfare, although I also welcome broader coverage.

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2015-07-13

Seeking professional advice

Hi, everyone. I'm a new PhD student at a major research university. I'm looking for advice from professional historians about something that I feel silly asking my advisers: how "original" does my dissertation have to be? I'm finding the whole idea of making an "original contribution" a bit daunting. I mean, do I have to shoot for a topic that no one has ever written about before? Is it all right to tackle a historical topic/question that has been asked before in hopes of finding a new angle?

3 Answers 2015-07-13

Has America even won a war/conflict or proxy since WW2? I even take hearts and minds of the people of the country.

1 Answers 2015-07-13

What are the origins of not placing one's elbows on a table?

In a /r/askreddit thread someone cited this as being a social unacceptable thing to do. During my time in the Navy I was told this was the reason for it..."It originally started from when sailors where eating on ships and they would put their elbows on the table to keep their dish from sliding during rougher seas. As this became a habit for them they would also do it while not out to sea and at pubs and such. Well sailors didn't have the best reputation for being clean, and well-mannered so non-sailors didn't want to be associated with them and thus would not put their elbow on tables. Hence where this rule came from!"

Is there any truth to this, or is it likely made up?

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Get Cultured! - Massive Cultural History Panel AMA

Hi everyone! Today's panel AMA will have a bit of a different tone than our regular panels; instead of focusing on a specific period or topic in history, we will talk about our work in a specific subfield of history: cultural history. My hope is to give some of our flairs with obscure specialties some exposure, while simultaneously introducing many of you to a subfield of history that you may be unaware of. Think of this panel as a half-AMA, half-workshop: we will all be glad to discuss questions about our fields of research, but we will also answer questions about the nitty-gritty of doing cultural history: how does a cultural historian conduct their research? What kinds of sources do we use, and in what ways do we use them?

So then, what is cultural history? Admittedly, it is a fairly nebulously defined subfield when compared to its sisters like economic or military history. Peter Burke answered the same question thusly: “it still awaits a definitive answer.” Cultural history can be done across time and space, and study nearly any aspect of a society: there exist cultural histories of animals, of clothing, of landscapes, finance, religious beliefs, warfare and so on. Burke posited that because cultural historians study such a multitude of subjects, it is their methods, not objects of study, which unites them:

“the common ground of cultural historians might be defined as a concern with the symbolic and its interpretation. Symbols, conscious or unconscious, can be found everywhere, from art to everyday life, but an approach to the past in terms of symbolism is just one approach among others.”

We look at any aspect of a society, how it is created as a symbol and how that symbol is interpreted and by members of a historical culture. Accordingly, this will be a fairly open-ended panel where we invite you to discuss our objects of study and our methods. We are cultural historians, ask us anything!

Here is the massive list of our panelists, their areas of research and the kinds of topics they would like to address today:

  • /u/depanneur is a historian of the imagination who is broadly interested in popular belief and the supernatural in medieval Europe, and is specifically focused on that topic as it pertains to early medieval Ireland. His other interests include the intersection of landscape and culture, magic in the pre-modern world as well as animals and animal symbolism. He is willing to discuss the forest in medieval imagination (especially in Ireland), the supernatural in early Irish history and the methods used to study popular cultures in pre-modern Europe, as well as their problems.

  • /u/vertexoflife is primarily a historian of the book, but focuses specifically on the history of pornography and obscenity, with a heavy focus on histories of sexuality, marriage, and privacy. He has just finished writing a book on the history of pornography, the majority of which can be read at www.annalspornographie.com. He is happy to answer questions about the overlap between cultural and intellectual historians, or how the book can be a cultural force.

  • /u/TheGreenReaper7 holds an MA in Medieval and Renaissance Studies from University College London. His research outputs have been on socio-legal culture in a comparative context in the Medieval West (c.1100-c.1300) with a special emphasis on pre-Conquest Wales. His other chief research interest is the development of the social and martial cultural phenomenon commonly known as ‘chivalry' from its (contested) origins in the twelfth-century to the end of the Hundred Years War. Questions about cultural (vis-à-vis legal) bonds, masculinity, and military ethics very welcome!

  • /u/itsallfolklore has conducted work on Northern European folklore, especially as recorded in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. I have also published on the social/cultural history of the American mining West, working with written and archaeological/architectural resources. My dozen books include studies of Virginia City, Nevada, the architectural history of Nevada, and work with letters from the California Gold Rush. Over three dozen articles include diverse subjects on the same and also dealing with Northern European folklore; I am currently working on a book that is a collection of essays on the folklore of Cornwall. I can address aspects of folklore (particularly as oral tradition manifests in historical documents) and the culture of the Old West.

  • /u/historiagrephour holds a master's degree in Scottish history and specializes in the concept of cultural gradation within the Scottish Highlands. For the purposes of the AMA, I can discuss issues related to elite Lowland and Gaelic cultures in early modern Scotland (roughly, 1500-1700) including cultural influences on marriage, fosterage, divorce, education, language, literacy, honor codes, and hospitality.

  • /u/WedgeHead is an historian of the Ancient Near East specializing in culture and identity. My interests primarily concern the way ancient people expressed their imagination of the self and other (identity/alterity) in texts. I have written on a variety of topics including cultural appropriation during the reign of Assurnasirpal II (Neo-Assyrian Empire), stereotyping and cultural identity in the diplomatic correspondence of the Late Second Millennium BCE (Amarna Letters), and a variety of topics concerning the Middle Babylonian period (c. 1500–1000 BCE) in Mesopotamia. My current research deals with the formation and development of the concept of ethnicity in the ancient Mediterranean world. I am happy to answer anything I can about the cultures of the ancient world or the methods we use to study them.

  • /u/Mictlantecuhtli studies the Teuchitlan culture of West Mexico, a Classic period civilization centered around the Tequila volcano of Jalisco. The Teuchitlan culture is one of many of many cultures that make up the shaft tomb tradition of Western Mexico. What sets the Teuchitlan culture apart from other extensions in Nayarit or Colima is their unique concentric circle architecture called a guachimonton named after the principal site Los Guachimontones. My primary focus on the Teuchitlan culture is less on the hollow ceramic figures from their tombs and more on their architecture. I'm interested in how they were built, why they were built, and their distribution on the landscape. My in-progress thesis is on architectural energetics and labor organization in the context of the Teuchitlan culture's corporate power structure.

  • /u/Shartastic studies African-American athletes throughout the 19th Century into the early 20th Century. His focus is on African-American jockeys and the modernization/commercialization of sport, but he's happy to talk about other sports and athletes generally too.

  • /u/butforevernow is an art historian and gallery curator with a speciality in eighteenth century Spanish art. My current research (for my Master's) focuses on depictions of everyday life in Madrid from/in the later eighteenth century, so I'm particularly interested in the details and workings of that culture, especially the art, theatre, and costume/fashion. I'm happy and eager to answer any questions that I can in that or any related area :)

  • /u/TenMinuteHistory: My research is on the Bolshoi Ballet in the 1920s and 30s, My research interests more generally include bodies, movement and their cultural meaning.

  • /u/agentdcf: I am a historian of 19th and 20th century Britain, with particular thematic emphases in culture, environment, and food. My research is a cultural and environmental history of wheat, flour, and bread, and it stands at the intersection of several (usually separate) themes and methodologies: cultural history (which I would define as histories of "meaning," broadly defined), social history, environmental history, food, science and medicine, the body, and consumption. I'm best-equipped to answer questions about food and ideas of nature, though I can take a stab at questions of cultural history across the West in the modern period. I have a lot of teaching experience in Western Civilization, world history, environmental history, and some US history (especially California, my home state); this has given me a long and global view of things, but a fairly spotty expertise.

Please note that not all of our panelists live in the same time zones, so some may answer your questions later than others. Please be patient!

^^^^^^^Obligatory ^^^^^^^shoutout ^^^^^^^to ^^^^^^^/u/dubstripsquads ^^^^^^^for ^^^^^^^coming ^^^^^^^up ^^^^^^^with ^^^^^^^this ^^^^^^^panel's ^^^^^^^title

22 Answers 2015-07-13

Europe's eyes on the American Civil War

What was Europe’s perspective of the American Civil war? More particularly, were any European powers paying extra attention to the US during the war with the hopes of maybe grabbing some land during the aftermath? I would venture to guess that (some) European powers hoped that the economy and manpower of the states would have been decimated to such a degree that an invasion and annexation would be relatively possible. What factors countered this kind of thinking? Also, had any European picked sides (north vs south)? If so, why? (I realize the sub question regarding “side-picking” is quite the question in itself, but I figured it might inform my main question regarding European interests in the war itself).

1 Answers 2015-07-13

Monday Methods| Defining power

Thanks to /u/cordis_melum for suggesting this topic.

To go along with our previous installments defining tribe and defining empire, today we will discuss political/administrative power.

What makes a king/emperor/president/prime minister powerful?

Is Mao's dictum that "power grows out of the barrel of a gun" correct? Is all power predicated on the ability to wield violence?

Or is power negotiated? Is a leader only powerful because they are able to convince people to go along with their wishes?

How much of power is image? Should the construction of monuments and palaces be seen as an indulgence of the powerful, or a deliberate attempt at projecting the image of power?

Next week's topic will be: Storing and Sharing Chronologies.

5 Answers 2015-07-13

Seeking advice on an MA History dissertation question, American Civil War

So I'm going to be doing a dissertation for my MA soon and although I've decided that I would like to do it on the American Civil War although I am yet to come to come up with a specific question.

I was thinking of focusing on a specific regiment such as one of the Massachusetts volunteer regiments and travel to Mass. to visit archives to get primary sources to answer whatever question I choose to do.

I'm struggling to come up with ideas so any help would be greatly appreciated.

3 Answers 2015-07-13

In Massie's "Castles of Steel", the author says that Austria's ultimatum to Serbia just before the outbreak of WWI was fully accepted by Serbia except for two of the demands. What were these demands and if Serbia had accepted them, would it have prevented war in Europe?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

How did Australia end up with such unusual place names?

Was it simply a case of whoever got there first got to name a place? Did they intentionally try to outdo each other in coming up with strange names?

2 Answers 2015-07-13

How old is mail? Who had the first organized long distance message delivery service?

1 Answers 2015-07-13

What major wars were there from 1900s onward? and what were they about?

I'm sorry for the idiotic question but I have no idea where to go or how to start to learn. I never really had the chance to learn about much history so I'm starting from scratch.

I know that WW1 happened and WW2, I have no idea what they were about. I know a little but not much. That's it that is my entire knowledge of the past 100+ yrs.

2 Answers 2015-07-13

So, immediately after WW2, Europe was a mess. How did people get back to where they needed to be or contact people if they had no money, food, water or shelter?

If you need me to elaborate, just ask, but I am wondering how people who had become lost or were misplaced somehow found their families or were able to travel back to where they had to be. Europe is a big place to get lost in, and I am wondering how all of the mess was organised. I do understand that the Red Cross would have had some effect, but what else? How did the RC do it?

3 Answers 2015-07-13

5192 / 7255

Back to start