How accurate were the historical claims in this week’s r/BestOf post that sought to set the record straight on the insignificance of the USA’s contributions in WWII?

Here’s the post I’m referring to:

direct link

BestOf link

I appreciate a good “lies my teacher told me” reveal as much as the next guy, but the amount that this post diminished the USA’s contributions went much further than I expected — making me wish I knew a real historian who could comment on the truth of these claims.

1 Answers 2021-09-24

How did ancient people keep their beer from going bad?

I have recently started brewing beer and I am always cleaning and sanitizing my equipment to keep stuff from being contaminated. I have heard that beer is one of the oldest products ever created. So how did people in the ancient past keep their stuff from spoiling ?

1 Answers 2021-09-24

Charles de Gaulle, and trust

I know nothing about post-War France, but was de Gaulle really not trusted by Western leaders? I've read that Eisenhower wouldn't allow France to have a nuclear program because of his distrust of de Gaulle. Did he have his own agenda as a politician?

1 Answers 2021-09-24

How did World War 1 affect 9/11?

Someone commented on this issue. Was he right and if so, how did it affect him?

1 Answers 2021-09-24

I am not a historian, but I assume that a key motivating factor for the Viking raids of 793-1066 was the cold and harsh climate of Scandinavia, meaning the Norse had to find resources elsewhere and take them by force to survive. After the Viking age and raids ended, how was this problem solved?

Something clearly happened to make Viking raids obsolete. If they were still necessary for the Norse people, and it was just a matter of their neighboring countries becoming so good at fighting them that Viking raids couldn't happen anymore, Scandinavia would have experienced massive poverty and famines and never have progressed. It can't have been improved climate conditions in Scandinavia either, if anything things got worse with the beginning of the Little Ice Age in the mid-13th century. The only other thing I can think of is technology, but could it have progressed so much in the 11th century?

So how come Scandinavia transitioned from a land populated by people that were seen by the rest of Europe as low-tech "savages" who had to plunder (even settle, in some cases) more fertile lands to survive, to a collection of "typical" Christian medieval kingdoms who had normal diplomatic relations with the rest of Europe? How did they manage (without raiding) to achieve a level of material comfort high enough that their society stopped being centered around war and raids, and why couldn't that happen during the Viking age?

1 Answers 2021-09-24

I was watching an old episode of Bones where they said Argentina sent 10,000 blank passports to Germany at the end of WWII. Did that really happen and if so what would motivate Argentina to do that?

1 Answers 2021-09-24

How accurate is this Twitter thread about the necessity (or lack thereof) of the use of nukes in Japan?

Thread all makes sense and I believe is written by someone who knows their stuff but I just wanna know if there's anything in here that more seasoned historians would find objectionable.

2 Answers 2021-09-23

Had they been ready early enough, were there plans to deploy atomic weapons in other countries besides Japan during World War II?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

I'm part of a small group of Bretons in 1220 and we've started construction of a settlement. Who will be first to demand something of us and what will they demand?

Hello, I'm part of a tight knit group of a dozen or so Bretons that have decided to construct a settlement near the ruins of the Temple of Mars about 8km outside Dinan in our homeland of Brittany (our reasons for doing this are our own). It's 1220, and we're well enough off to hire laborers as well as a few men-at-arms, for a total of ~50 people. Currently, we're constructing shelters, a storehouse, and light fortifications, though we've been carefull to avoid anything that might be construed as castle-building. We hope to establish a small, enduring community here.

We've not actually asked anyone for permission to do this - will this be a problem? Who can we expect to first show up at our door with some demand? And what sort of demands might they make of us?

And as a sub question, what parts of this scenario are unrealistic, starting from the assumption that we have this tight knit group and decent resources?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

In books like The Count of Monte Cristo and the Sherlock Holmes Short Stories, there is constant reference to incomes and estates. Where were Georgian/Victorian era ‘incomes’ derived from? And does was an estate owner by definition a noble?

Apologies if this has been addressed elsewhere, I was not able to find a similar post.

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Tiananmen 1989: Is it true that the Chinese army used tanks to crush the dead bodies of protesters to be able to wash them into the sewer?

This is frequently mentioned here on reddit and elsewhere, but is it true, and do photos that claim to document it come from reliable sources?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

How come European settlers weren't wiped out by American diseases?

As we are all taught in school, Europeans brought diseases that the Native Americans didn't have immunity to and most died from that. Wouldn't there be many American diseases that the Europeans wouldn't be immune to? Why wasn't that an issue for the settlers?

2 Answers 2021-09-23

As a Palestinian-American, I've noticed an almost complete absence of Arab authorship in the Arts (Literature, Philosophy) coming out of the Southern Levant before, during, and even a few centuries after the Islamic Golden Age. Why is this & do they exist in corners I still haven't searched?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Were Spartans Actually Foreigners?

Apparently, at least according to my favorite history person on the internet (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppGCbh8ggUs) Spartans thought that they were non-Greek and were "foreign occupiers". My question is where these Spartans correct, or where they actually just Greeks who lived with a myth? If there is a General historical consensus on this matter, how is it ascertained? If there is not a general historical consensus, what are the more popular theories among professional historians?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Did Scandinavian invaders influence gender equality in the western world?

The majority of religions and cultures at the time were / are still very patriarchal , did the culture of the Norse and Scandinavian Vikings influence for gender equality, especially when they integrated into the British islands?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Did the US refuse to share British atomic secrets with Britain?

My understanding is that all the major WW2 powers were working on nuclear weapons in some capacity and that there was a major British effort in Canada (code named Tube Alloys) that, after the US entry to the war, was folded into the Manhattan Project. My understanding was that there was an agreement of shared technology and research from the joint venture but that the British lost their only copy of that agreement. It was made between Churchill and Roosevelt and Truman did not want to honour the agreement with Attlee.

Is this correct and if so how did this happen?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Caesar's "Conquest of Gaul," involves people dying in droves, horribly. It's a bad man's account of his own bad deeds, written not as a mea culpa or an apologia, but as a brag. Beyond the worry of Caesar's political opponents, did Romans generally find this distasteful?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Did the US have to invade the Japanese mainland?

A recent AskReddit thread on the atomic bombs got me thinking. The American gov. (and allot of average Americans from my personal experience) say they had to drop the bombs because an invasion of the main islands of Japan would have caused 10x or more military and civilian casualties and because of that the bombs actually saved lives.

Yet, did this implies the US HAD to invade the mainland, like achieving total-surrender was the only option. But at this point Japan had been pretty much defeated right? The US had taken their empire from them, the US homeland was no longer under threat. Why couldn't there have just been a ceasefire and peace? The Japanese had to have known their position was hopeless, especially with the fall of Germany and Russia about to enter the theatre. Surely they would have accepted any deal that left them in control of Japan and stay alive?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

in Oliver Stone's *The Untold History of the United States,* Stone makes a claim that the Japanese were trying to surrender, but this information was hidden from Truman so that the generals could test the bomb. Is this true? what evidence supports this?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

I've heard countless people say that "prohibition was ineffective" and that it didn't decrease alcohol consumption at all in the US; on the contrary it actually increased it. Is there any truth to this common belief?

I'm strictly talking about the USA period of prohibition, a time that is associated with organized crime booming, which people claim was caused by the illegal booze business

But did it actually fail at reducing alcohol consumption or is it just a myth?
If it didn't, then why not?

2 Answers 2021-09-23

During the height of the Roman empire, I have heard it said that both the Chinese empire and the Roman empire had heard of each other but neither were interested in any sort of communication or trade. Is this true?

And if it was true, what stopped them from an early silk road style trade route. I have read the merchants of the Roman empire would constantly venture past their borders to trade with the "Barbarian" peoples, such as in the British isles before the invasion. Was it the constant threat from the Parthians and related empires that kept Rome from ever considering the far east for trade?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

I need help to identify what is going on in this painting.

Hello Historians.

A friend sent me a picture of this painting: https://imgur.com/a/3wXq3W8

We want to know who the people in the painting are, or rather, from. In my view, I'd say it's an imperial Russian cavalryman and a French dragoon. The setting, the clothes, and equipment suggest Napoleon's Russian campaign. But this is just my guess.

On the back of the painting, there's a bearly readable text where you can see it says "Krakow".

Hopefully, you can help me with this. Thanks!

2 Answers 2021-09-23

During World War 2, did Jews in Japan face any discrimination from the government since it was allied with Nazi Germany?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

In 1897 there were a quarter of a million US saloons, or 23 for every Starbucks franchise today. Every back alley and country crossroads had one, and they were the go-to option for socializing business meetings, and politics. What was the impact when the US made them illegal during prohibition?

1 Answers 2021-09-23

Planning on getting into Chinese history, is the Cambridge history series a good primer?

I'm a beginner, so I wish to make sure buying them is the right call before spending a huge amount of money. I'm having second thoughts because I was told that cambridge history series is generally for people properly trained in historiography and not really friendly for rookies.

1 Answers 2021-09-23

523 / 7255

Back to start