When did rulers personal finance separate from the governments?

Please correct me if I am wrong but it is my understanding that early monarchs would fund all state expenditures out of their own private money. If they wanted to buy a beer, or build a public road it would come from the same purse. Most of the monarchs funds would come from land that they as individuals owned.

Later monarchs had separate finances from the state. Citizens didn't pay taxes to the king they paid it to the government, just like the king didn't buy ships for the navy, the state did.

How and when did this transition occur? Or am I way off?

3 Answers 2015-06-10

When lafayette came to Yorktown, what was on the hermione?

Did he bring slaves?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

What are some good cultural history books on Colonial North America?

I understand this is a very broad question but I'm seeking out a broad topic. I know in broad strokes what the political history of the North American colonies looked like, but what was the experience of inhabiting a British or French or Spanish colony in the "new world," like? How was the experience of an inhabitant of Williamsburg different from the experience of a similarly situated person in an English urban zone? What kind of music did they listen to and was it significantly different from the music that was enjoyed in the home country? Was the experience of religion for a "Puritan" in New England or a Catholic in Florida significantly different from the experience of their European counterparts? These are just questions off the top of my head but I'm really just sort of looking to dive in and learn something new about a period and place I don't know all that much about. I hope this question isn't too vague!

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

2 Answers 2015-06-10

What are the true historical events that inspired Game of Thrones?

I've seen posts and heard people talk about GoT being based on actual happenings, what are they?

Edit: that includes A Song of Ice and Fire.

1 Answers 2015-06-10

How did Singapore go from a "third world" country to a "first world" country in one generation?

I'm interested in learning more about the contributing factors in Singapore's rise to wealth. I realize there are probably many, many factors, but I'm looking for an overview. Maybe someone could point me in the direction of a website or a book on the topic for more details?

(I'm not sure if "third world" and "first world" are the appropriate terms)

5 Answers 2015-06-10

Approximately what percentage of Americans *actually* have Native American heritage?

I have to admit, I'm one of those people who supposedly has a Cherokee great-great-great-grandma. Although I've found evidence that actually supports this (old census records) I'm still skeptical. A lot of people say that they have Cherokee or other Native American ancestry and I'm not sure it's true. On the other hand, I don't want to sit over here denying my heritage if it's likely that the records are accurate.

So historically, how much mixing actually occurred? How likely is it that the records I found are accurate? Is there some reason that 200 years ago someone that wasn't might claim they were a Native American? If there is, is that what attributes so many people claiming a heritage that they do not have? I just wonder if it's something that at some point people decided was "cool" and they made it up or if it's something that was true and buried in family histories until it became socially acceptable after the Civil Rights Movement or something.

Thanks!

3 Answers 2015-06-10

When did going on vacation become a thing?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

How would society be different today had the millions that died in the most devastating wars, famine etc, actually lived?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Why didn't Portugal try to expand into the Caribbean in the 16th and 17th centuries?

Why didn't the Portuguese join the Spanish, the English, the French, and the Dutch in the battles for control of the Caribbean region? Or did they and I'm not aware of it?

2 Answers 2015-06-10

In Bernard Cornwell's 1990 book, 'Sharpe's Waterloo', and in the 1997 TV adaptation of the same name, William II, The Prince of Orange, is portrayed as a militarily incompetent coward. What was the real Prince of Orange's military record, and is there any basis to Cornwell's polemnic depiction?

With the upcoming Bi-Centennial of the Battle of Waterloo on the 18th of June, I finally sat down and read Bernard Cornwell's 'Sharpe's Waterloo,' and watched the accompanying 1997 film. In both works, I was surprised by the depiction of William II of the Netherlands' as incompetent, selfish and cowardly. Knowing very little about the man, and having done little further reading than Wikipedia vis-à-vis the battle itself, I'm unsure of the accuracy of this portrayal. I can only assume it's embellished to a degree, but I'd be fascinated to learn more.

2 Answers 2015-06-10

How famous would the Marquis de Lafayette have been with the average American at the end of the Revolutionary War?

Would average commoners on the streets of cities throughout the new country have known who he was, and his contributions in the war?

Or would he have been known primarily to wealthy men of means, commanders in the revolutionary army, and the men who directly served with or under him?

As a somewhat related question, did Lafayette's service in the war have any impact from what we can tell on early American impressions of France, beyond just what general French support during the war would have done?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

What was the "slanted light" phenomenon in the late 530s Byzantine Empire?

In this comment regarding the Eastern Roman Empire /u/Ambarenya mentions in passing

a series of devastating droughts probably caused by the strange "slanted light" of the late 530s

What was this "slanted light" and how did it contribute to the droughts?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Didn't the color of Pirate Flags mean something or is that bad history?

IIRC Black flags were supposed to mean the pirates were more civil while red flags were supposed to mean the pirates were more barbaric.

1 Answers 2015-06-10

If Hitler despised minorities, why did he ally with the Japanese?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Was there language training for recruits of the Roman legions?

I am under the impression that the Roman military contained soldiers from regions throughout the Empire, many of whom presumably didn't speak Latin as a first language. Were these people taught to speak at least basic Latin as part of their training, were they expected to pick it up on their own, or were they simply placed under the command of people who spoke their language?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

What is the significance of the battle of Waterloo for Europe?

This question was borne out of the whole trouble that the Belgian government went through to issue a coin commemorating the battle.

Did the battle contribute to shaping Europe as we know it? What would likely be different if Napoleon had won?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

How did early anatomists explain their knowledge?

I've heard many times about how early anatomists defied laws against body snatching to get cadavers, so that they could dissect them and figure out how the human body worked. When they published books on their findings, what did they say someone asked, "Hey, how did you figure out this stuff?"

1 Answers 2015-06-10

What were some honorifics a typical commoner in ancient greek might use to address one another in day to day conversation?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Can/should examples of mathematical concepts from non-European cultures be considered part of the history of mathematics?

Some context: as a mathematician, I often hear colleagues argue that we ought to consider the mathematics of historical cultures alongside European mathematics as a part of the history of mathematics. For example, "India" or "China" (historical India/China) had a notion of 0 before Europeans did, therefore that should be acknowledged as a major, non-European mathematical development. I am not entirely confortable with this and I hope you can help. What we understand as "mathematics" is, in the sense that its history is rooted in, European mathematical developments that had little influence from India or China. Therefore, can these examples be considered part of the history of what we understand as mathematics? Is this just a matter of semantics? Or, should we ackowledge that are/were many "mathematics" developed at different points in time to varying degrees and our modern notion ought to encompass them all, even those that terminated at some point in the past?

Edit: I acknowledge that this question is not about a specific event, but rather about historiographical methods.

1 Answers 2015-06-10

in the past I've been told by people on here that there are female samurai that fought in combat. How did Women find themselves in the position to do that? Why did their families allow it?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Could pre-Marian Roman troops become promoted regardless of their socioeconomic status?

To clarify, could a soldier of a lower tier, say a poor man that was a Velite, gain a higher rank (Hastati, Principe, Triarii, Equites, etc.) based solely on his performance in battle?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Are there any historical records of a matriarchal society?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

When did Jews migrate to Eastern and Western Europe, and why?

As far as I understand it, by the time of the destruction of the second temple in 70 CE, the Jews were mainly concentrated in the Fertile Crescent, with smaller populations in Rome, along the Persian Gulf and Yemen (though I may be wrong). I'm very curious to know what happened to them that they ended up in the backwaters of Poland and in England, and elsewhere in Europe. Thanks.

3 Answers 2015-06-10

What are some example of the oldest known maps of the layout of a city?

*Examples, sorry.

1 Answers 2015-06-10

5311 / 7255

Back to start