Did the Catholic church really sell indulgences?

In the romance Les Rois Maudits it is said that the Catholic church never sold indulgences. It is said that in a specific region they charged for a kind of 'pious certificate', which assured that the person went to church, confessed and communed. A pope that was from this region wanted to extend this 'service' to the entire Europe, though.

Still, Martin Luther made a pretty big deal on the subject and split from the church for this specific reason. Is there any controversy on this subject?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

How frequently were handgrenades used in both World Wars?

Usually in movies the soldiers rarely use hand grenades, though especially in WW1 the german Sturmtruppen were issued many grenades. How frequently did the soldiers actually use their grenades?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Is their a precedent for changing capital cities? For example, were the UK's capital change to Birmingham, would there be a set way to do this?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

I was listening to Dan Carlin's Armageddon podcast, and at one point he started talking about the 'combination of eras', specifically mentioning French Cuirassier's wearing gas masks. Are there any pictures of these sorts of things?

Sorry for the title length :\

1 Answers 2014-12-06

What positions in ancient society could a eunuch hold or hope to achieve?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

Japan had been expanding in Asia for years before America declared war on them in 1941, so what happened to that expansion during the pacific war?

Specifically, what did they do with that expansion? Did they keep on rolling along gobbling up China (and others) as they went? Did they halt all advancements and temporarily put on hold the war(s)? Did they make peace and keep what they had?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Before 1AD, how accurate was Chinese knowledge of "Daqin", the Roman Empire? Did they have myths about it?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

Why is it that when Leif Erikson discovered America there was no great attempt to colonize it?

...where Columbus's trip spurred Spain and eventually all of Europe to colonize it akin to the scramble for Africa.

I suppose what I'm really asking is: Where is my Viking colonial Empire?!

EDIT: After some though, could it be:

  • Because economically it was impossible?

  • Because ships of the time could not transport enough supplies for a colony to work?

  • Because Leif wasn't a good salesmen?

  • Because Leif didn't find anything worth money, where Columbus did?

I also read the Wikipedia entry on Erikson, and it said that he sent off a group to explore. Did they bring back a map?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

What made the British 'Line of Foot' so effective against other Line Infantry in battle?

I'm probably using the wrong terminology but it's always interested me how the British Army during the late colonial ages were so efficient in battle.

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Panel AMA – East Asia in the Early 20th Century

The first half of the 20th century was a busy time in East Asia. For this AMA panel, we're looking at the period from the beginning of the First Sino-Japanese War in 1894 until the end of the Chinese Civil War in 1949. It's a period that involves wars, occupations, foreign sttlements and extraterritoriality, imperialism, and the creation of new nations, just to name a few of the highlights. Our panelists for today's AMA are:

  • /u/an_ironic_username is a naval historian who will be discussing Japanese navalism in the 20th Century and the maritime conflicts in the Pacific during this period. He'll be popping in and out during the AMA.

  • /u/Beck2012 will be addressing topics on Southeast Asia and Korea

  • /u/churakaagii is a half-Okinawan who lives in Okinawa, and has an interest in the history of an area that has had a historical impact out of proportion to the size of its land mass.

  • /u/Georgy_K_Zhukov is a military historian here to talk about Warlordism, the Civil War, and the Second Sino-Japanese War.

  • /u/keyilan is an historical linguist based in Taiwan and East China. His areas of interest are: national language policy & planning; Japanese-occupied Taiwan & Korea; Shanghai in the 20th century.

  • /u/thanatos90 is focusing on Chinese intellectual history, particularly the New Culture and May Fourth movements and the rise of communism.

We'll be addressing a wide range of topics, so don't feel limited to the specific subspecialties listed above.

30 Answers 2014-12-06

Martial arts manuscripts

Hi I'm looking for original documents of martial arts (unarmed if possible) from as early as possible in history.

Or documentaries covering that topic.

Any help would be appreciated!

2 Answers 2014-12-06

Are there any good books that talk about Egypt's history from colonial rule to modern day?

Hello, /r/AskHistorians, I come to you not to ask you to do my assignment for me, only to ask for good books that would help me write about it.

If you want more specifics, here is what I've been assigned:

Write a 10-page paper discussing:

  • The country's history of colonial rule

  • The nature of its independence movement, its independence leaders, and nationalist popular front/party

  • The nature of its class/ethnic/religious compromises or consensus, or lack thereof during independence

  • Its position regarding the Cold War conflict; whether it sought a non-aligned position or became part of military pact; played both sides against one another for aid; was part of regional political or economic organizations

  • What is the nature of its economic relationship with the First and Second Worlds?

  • How does the country’s history reflect or go against aspects of the Third World Platform discussed in your readings and in class lectures?

  • Did the independence consensus/compromise hold? If not, what caused its collapse? Was the collapse based on class/ethnic/religious conflict?

  • Did they move away from the Third World Platform? If so, why?

I can also chose to do this with Indonesia, the Philippines, Burma/Myanmar, Ghana, Kenya, Algeria, Iran, or Iraq. I just chose Egypt because of it's interesting history.

This is due for Sunday at midnight, and I really want to do this right. I am not an INR or History major, I'm an engineering major. Apologies for any inconvenience.

ANY HELP AT ALL WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED

And have a good night/day.

1 Answers 2014-12-06

How was alcohol drunk in medieval times?

I hear people talking about how people used to drink beer for breakfast, and how children were given wine to drink. In the Greek myths, binge drinking at feasts seems to be a common theme.

What were the boozing habits of those who came before us? Were women allowed to drink? Did most people drink a lot, or just a little?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Alcohol in the past (in all different eras you're an expert in) - how was it actually drunk?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Why were the Natchez the only people who continued a large amount of Mississippian traditions well into the 18th century?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

When did the thong(women's underwear, well men's too I guess) first appear? And what, if any, purpose did it have other than to look attractive?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Did any seafaring civilizations ever try to use animals to power their ships?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

In what year and battle did the last recorded charge of knights in heavy armor occur? What conflict last saw widespread use of knights in heavy armor?

3 Answers 2014-12-06

Did the Confederacy celebrate the fourth of july?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

How did Salt and Pepper become the predominant spices in the (western) world?

I can see how salt came into predominance as it being a flavour (I am Canadian) enhancer. But why pepper?

And why the both of them? Why not something local to regions?

2 Answers 2014-12-06

Why did French revolutionaries prefer an emperor to a king?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Are these books considered 'History' books?

I have a book review assignment and I'm not sure if either of these books are considered to be historical. How do i know if they're under the genre of history?

No End to Terrorism - Walter Laqueur

The New Terrorism - Walter Laqueur

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Assuming Normal Rules of Royal Succession, Who Would be King Today if George Washington Had Been Crowned?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

Can anyone identify the statue above Lincoln in this photo of his second inauguration?

From what I can tell, it is no longer outside the east entrance. Any ideas? Link to image: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e6/Abraham_Lincoln_giving_his_second_Inaugural_Address_%284_March_1865%29.jpg

1 Answers 2014-12-06

How do historians determine the population of the earth in ancient times?

1 Answers 2014-12-06

6030 / 7255

Back to start