A lot of the books, shows, etc always paint the confederates in a good way or try to push the "lost cause" myth. I'm trying to write a novel about the civil war (fiction) and I want to learn about Union soldier's way of life. Camp life, battlefield life, the struggles, the jobs. Why battles happened/why certain strategies were made. I don't want to hear any more defending of the south or praising of Lee. I don't know if I'm sounding dumb or not, but I'm fairly young and the only education I got on this subject was a 3-week course in 8th grade, thanks.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
Much is often said about the trench systems of the western front in WW1, and they are often described with wordage that indicates a single, unbroken line of trenches stretching without interruption from the Swiss border to the English channel.
But how contiguous were these trench systems actually? Could a soldier in actuality walk all of the way without leaving the trench system? This question excludes of course the considerable hinderances and dangers of offensives, sporadic artillery bombardment, sniper fire. As it is quite difficult to dig trenches across rivers, these are also excluded from this theoretical.
I am aware that the trench system was also often in flux due to capturing and recapturing of trenches by both sides. Did this create broken trench lines? And were there other obstacles of the natural variety besides rivers that hindered a fully conjoined trench system from forming?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
Obviously it's tied to the civil war, the Presidents who got us into the civil war are obviously not going to be remembered fondly by history, but I would like a bit more depth.
Also, I would love a recommendation of a popular history book that might address the subject in a bit more depth, preferably something available in an audiobook.
Thanks!
1 Answers 2021-07-03
1 Answers 2021-07-03
2 Answers 2021-07-03
I was reading “The Plantagenets - The kings who made England” and in one instance it is mentioned Geoffrey Plantagenet died of a fever in 1151 at the age of 38. Do we know what sort of illnesses would have been described as fever in the Middle Ages? Are there illnesses that were more deadly then due the lack of modern medicine?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
I simply can’t imagine the first few Nobel prizes being that big of a deal. I’d assume no one knew what it was. So, when and why did it start to become such a widely respected prize? Or was it really like that since inception?
Edit: grammar
1 Answers 2021-07-03
At the beginning of Chapter 1 of his book "Epic Continent: Adventures in the Great Stories of Europe", Nicholas Jubber says (emphasis mine), "Composed roughly at the end of the eighth century BC and attributed to the bard known as Homer, [The Odyssey] is so familiar - with its Sirens and Cyclops and the great battle in Odysseus' hall - it's easy to forget that it predates the invention of mealtimes of the minting of coins."
It had never occurred to me to think of mealtimes as something that had been invented. Upon reflection it makes sense, as there must have been some transition point between grazing behavior and organized meals, but I don't know anything about eating behaviors in the period before mealtimes were a commonly accepted standard.
If I'm a general laborer during this time period, what are my eating customs like? Do I have set breaks when I get to eat? Do I just graze throughout the day when I get a chance? Is it the same for a wealthy land-owner, or do they have either a more rigid or more flexible eating schedule?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
There are lots of stories of situations like this like with David and Goliath or the Horatti, but they all seem to be legend. How would a fight like this work and would the losing side accept defeat or continue fighting against their word?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
And are there any good explanations for their success?
Wikipedia article on "The Martians"
RestrictedData on whether their religious/immigrant status was a security concern, during the Manhattan Project (Another, less positive, answer by him
RestrictedData, again, commenting briefly on "The Martians," outside of the Manhattan Project, in the only AH thread with an answer I found. The thread doesn't include that they were - so far as I can tell - all Ashkenazim, though, and A) if Budapest's public schools were greatly superior to public schools in other major cities, how so and why? And B) even if the Ashkenazim of Budapest were the most motivated to emigrate, they weren't uniquely motivated to emigrate: Supposing there was a proportionate number of ethnically Hungarian scientists from Budapest achieving equal success, who were they and why aren't they listed as "Martians?" (E.G., Did the joke start within the Jewish community, tacitly only extending to the Jewish examples, or some-such?) Apparently, Budapest was ~25% Jewish in 1900 (Can anyone verify the nickname "Judapest?), so there should be roughly four times as many "Martians," if ethnicity was not a factor.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
So I'm planning to write a fantasy book series based on the 12th century but I'm finding some trouble shifting through the internet for the information I need.
What I'm looking for is:
What did battles look like (Unit information such as cavalry to infantry ratio).
List of common titles and their meanings (the role of a Knight, noble positions etc).
What did armour look like for Knights and common infantry?
Appearances of clothing worn by the rich and the poor.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
Today:
AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.
Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.
So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!
2 Answers 2021-07-03
Thomas Jefferson owned many more slaves than any other framer of the Constitution. According to the Monicello organization, 400 people were enslaved at Monticello; the other 200 people were held in bondage on Jefferson's other properties. At any given time, around 130 people were enslaved at Monticello.
What was life like for the slaves of Monticello? And how many worked in the house as opposed to working in the fields? How were they treated by Jefferson compared to slaves on other plantations? What were the duties of Jefferson's slave children and how were they treated? What became of Jefferson's children? We know the book Clotel is a work of complete fiction. From what I've been able to discover, Jefferson wanted his children to become musicians, perhaps fiddlers - an ideal trade for them in that time and place.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
1 Answers 2021-07-03
1 Answers 2021-07-03
This might be a question relating to all of eastern Russia, but I focused on the more clearly similar ones. Primorsky Krai is at 12/km2 while Heilongjiang is at 70/km2. Why couldn't Russia develop these regions like China could? Did they ever attempt to encourage migrants from Asia?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
I’ve found a lot of documents in our 1856 house in the attic - there was a fire sometime around 1900, and it’s all just been left up there. The ash created an oxygen seal for the documents the fire didn’t destroy.
One document is a boot price list for 1889, Pittsburgh…and it seems really pricey. $40-50 for boots, back then! I can’t tell if it’s a lot price or what…just seems odd. Can you give me any context? I can’t seem to include the images here, but they’re in my post history, last post.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
I am currently writing something on World Anvil. In the article I'm writing, there is a nation known for it's cavalry called Erzia. I'm just wondering if there are variations of knights that appeared in medieval history cause i wanted to take inspiration from it.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
In 1798 stainless steel was invented. It was cheaper than carbon steel, stronger, easier toaintain but it became dull very easily.
The sabres (swords used by hussars and other cavalry) were well used from early modern warfare until World War One. So, this means swords and stainless steel co-existed for 100 years.
My question is, were there any instance of stainless steel sabres in those era? As i reason, poorer soldiers that couldnt afford carbon steel would order stainless steel blades from blacksmith as it was cheaper and easier to maintain. Even if it is harder to avoid dullness, sabre charges were only were one of two times in the combat and rest of the melee charges were made by bayonets and lancers. Also it is better than nothing.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
I'm particularly interested in Insular Christianity in the early medieval period, btw.
I seem to be presented with two conflicting points of view, that make this seem difficult for me.
In the modern day, we're a bit more relaxed on what is or isn't allowed according to the Bible, and many modern Christians would think nothing of eating bacon and eggs for breakfast, or wearing a shirt made of multiple types of fabric. But Christianity appears to be much more important for medieval people.
So was it only the priesthood that took the Bible hyper-seriously?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
In light of the important discussions about the treatment of indigenous people in Canada. I'd like to hear if anyone can explain the relationship of the Nordic countries visavi the sámi in education and family policy in the 19th/first half of the 20th century. I know the question is broad, but any insights would be appreciated. The compulsory schooling introduced in the 1930s in Sweden of course would be ill-suited for a Nomadic people, and "modern" ideas impressed, but was there an expressed policy to forbid children to speak sámi? According to Wikipedia, Norway seem to have been harsher, but to what degree? Did the finnish/russian Sámi have more autonomy and self-control? Was separation of families just a side effect or intention?
1 Answers 2021-07-03
Okay I just want to preface that I'm 100% not a Holocaust denier and I think some of the things this person thinks are absolutely ridiculous.
I try to be nice to everyone at work and as you can imagine, this person doesn't have many friends. Being maybe the only person there that's friendly to them, I feel like maybe I'm in a unique position to change their minds.
I listen to lots of online debate panels and I know Holocaust denial can be a weird subject, where if you don't really have enough accurate information on the subjects, the denier can come across feeling like they won and reinforce their belief.
Although I don't really think this person is a skilled debater or even well read or informed on the matter. I kind of was talking to them and asked them why they believed what they believed. The only real thing they said was my question posted, if it was a death camp and not work camp, then why were so many women getting pregnant and or able to get pregnant in such conditions. I tried to push for other reasons about why they deny the Holocaust, but just got a bunch of non answers like I need to educate myself.
I didn't really pushback and kind of just said I disagree but just because I disagree doesn't mean we can't be friends, and said I'd look into it sometime as they wanted me to have an open mind I guess? I kind of just thought people honestly kind of just have sex even in shitty conditions so it's not so surprising, also knowing that people being pregnant doesn't really at all disprove the Holocaust. But again I didn't want to push back without doing some research first and maybe having a more solid pushback as I've never encountered someone who believed this sort of thing.
I didn't want to pushback until I did get more information because I think maybe I'm in a unique situation to change this person's mind. Yeah they might be too radicalized or extremist to even have their mind changed (also believes that jews control the media, and that diversity is being used as some sort of step towards white genocide) but I still think I want to try to change their mind. And I think it would take someone in my position, that they see as a friendly reasonable person. Not just pointing them to a YouTube video or online document.
Sorry about the long story I just didn't want to come across like I'm secretly a Holocaust denier or something.
So specifically answers to that question about the pregnancy in concentration camps would be nice, but also maybe common arguments and counter arguments to people saying there's a white genocide and whatever huge jew conspiracy they probably believe would be appreciated.
Usually I would try to find a debate on YouTube or something.. But I think most of these kind of get removed because no one wants to platform these types of people understandably.
So if anyone also has debate videos I could listen to arguing against Holocaust deniers, people who believe there's a white genocide, or whatever grand jews control everything conspiracy. I find listening to long form debates helps me better understand what arguments these people make even if it isn't the most formal. Actually I almost prefer the less formal debates or arguments sometimes.
I did find this site https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/how-to-refute-holocaust-denial
Which is kind of something I'd be looking for and usually would refer to, although the pregnancy thing isn't on there.
Sorry for the long ramble and story with a simple question. If there's a better subreddit for me to post this to that would be appreciated as well. I'm not really a history expert of familiar with these types of subreddit so apologies in advance if this isn't really the appropriate place to ask this stuff.
TLDR
met Holocaust denier irl for the first time ever. Feel like I can change their mind maybe. Wanted accurate info and to feel confident before pushing back, they asked if the Holocaust camps were real death camps and not work camps, why were so many women there pregnant?
END TLDR
6 Answers 2021-07-03
They were not that much far away and considering trades and other cultures i think they at least probably knew about each others.
1 Answers 2021-07-03
Hi.
I'm listening to a Librivox recording of "Three Times and Out" by Nellie McClung. She's best known in Canada for being a member of the Famous Five, but apparently also wrote this story by Private Mervin C. Simmons, who was a German POW in WWI. In his story, he mentions a situation where Irish prisoners would be permitted to fight given special privilege to "fight against England". I'm aware of what far going on between England and Ireland in 1914, but don't know much about the Irishmen who fought for the Germans.
What exactly happened there? Who actually took the Germans up on the offer? Were they used in German propaganda at the time? What battles did they fight in? How were they received when (if?) they returned home? Any other interesting facts you've got are welcome.
1 Answers 2021-07-03