What was Putin doing during the final years of the USSR and his first years in politics?

4 Answers 2014-09-20

Solid History of Medieval England books?

Been playing a lot of Crusader Kings 2 and its reawakened an interest in history.... haha.

Guys and gals! What are some good books of English Medieval history?

Here are some things that would make the reading a "desirable" book:

  1. A more dense, textbook feel to the book. After being a history major in college, I just don't really like books without citations anymore.
  2. A view not so focused on kings. Yes, kings were a big deal, but I've become frustrated with books that mention the actions of powers outside the King's authority and not explaining why they were doing that. History isn't what, it's why and how, so tell me why and how these outside factions developed!
  3. A view not constricted by borders. It's almost like if it didn't happen in England, it didn't happen AT ALL to some writers.

2 Answers 2014-09-20

Did all major armies during WW2 use the same kind of chain of command?

I'm referring to this structure: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_organization#Armies (linking to Wikipedia because the page contains stats and therefore it should be okay according to the rules).

I wonder how many armies worked on squad or even fireteam level, considering some would just charge into the enemy?

Also how did the chain look like with communist and nationalist China fighting alongside the common enemy? Did they give each other orders to attack on a certain place at a certain time?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

Last week crashcourse promised a discussion on why a balkan conflict in 1914 turned into WW1, and why that didn't happen with previous balkan conflicts. This week's episode didn't seem to deliver, could someone here shed some light?

Last week's episode: How WW1 started

This week's episode: Who started WW1

1 Answers 2014-09-20

Is the story of "the cruel lord who had a monument built and then imprisoned the labourers under it to keep its secrets" actually true for any historical figure?

It's said this was the case for the Taj Mahal. I'm reading Game of Thrones by George RR Martin right now and find a character in the story might have been guilty of this also. But was it proven to ever be done by an actual ruler or such?

3 Answers 2014-09-20

What were the most widespread names in Europe before the rise of Christianity?

2 Answers 2014-09-20

What would conversations and relationships between soldiers have been like during the Second World War?

In movies and TV, when they aren't discussing movements, plans, etc. soldiers seem to talk about their sense of duty, why they're there, and sometimes really deep topics. I find this unlikely, tho. If you're stuck with a group of men for 5 years, assuming you and they survive, what do you have to talk about? You've been at war for years, and away from everyone and everything you cared about before. I'm a road construction worker and spend more time away from home with the same 15 guys than I do actually at home with people I care about, not that I don't care about my coworkers, but it's different from, say, my family. We work together, eat together, and stay in the same uncomfortable lodging together. We become almost too comfortable with each other at times. I feel like their conversations would be similar to ours: a good chunk of talk is about work, but a lot of it is just messing with each other and making fun of one another. Every now and then you have a one on one conversation with someone, and it might get a bit personal, talking about home and family. But for the most part we are just "loving assholes" to one another. We can fuck with this guy, but if somebody else gets on his case they better watch out. You know? I always imagine it would be more like that than anything. I realize that war and road building are very different, but you're still with a group of (often quite crude) men night and day.

With that said, how would this have differed between forces? What would Americans be like compared to Japanese? British and German? Russian? Canadian? Italian? Etc.

So, what were relationships and conversations like between soldiers in different armies during World War II? And what did soldiers talk about when they weren't discussing the war?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

How closely related are modern Italians and ancient Romans?

  1. How closely related are Northern and Southern Italians to the Ancient Romans? Correct me if I'm wrong, but the South and Sicily has a distinct Greek heritage - were they ever Romanized or Latinized?
  2. Did the Lombards, Celts and Germanics make that much of an impact on the genetic identity of the Northern Italians? If so, can you explain how severe the change was?
  3. How much of an impact did the Arabs, Normans and Spaniards actually have on the genetic identity of Sicily? Are most people of Greek heritage? Do certain regions have different ethnic groups, for example, the west has a higher percentage of Ethnic Greeks whereas a city like Palermo may have a number of people who descend from the Normans?

Thanks!

2 Answers 2014-09-20

Why was there such a variance in tracklists/album covers in the international releases of older albums?

I was reading about the Beatles album, Revolver, and the author mentioned that the Russian release inexplicably had different images in the famous collage cover. The same article pointed out that the American release of Revolver was missing 3 tracks that were included in the English release. Why all the funkiness with these old international releases (there are hundreds of examples of this occurring)? Why did records companies do this?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

In the first US presidential election, did voters vote for a candidate or an elector?

Nowadays when you cast your vote, generally the ballot has both the name of the candidate and (in fine print) a slate of electors pledged to vote for that candidate. Was it the same case in the 1788-89 election, or did voters choose electors without necessarily knowing which candidate the electors would vote for?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

How did Mohammed and his followers--and, for that matter, his immediate predecessors and fellow Arab people of the time--come to believe in a bunch of the same stuff as the Jews did?

I guess I've sort of taken for granted that Christianity, Judaism, and Islam are the "Abrahamic faiths." Recently, though, out of curiosity, I decided to sit down and read the Koran, and as I sat there scanning through the Adam and Eve story, or reading something about Moses, it struck me that I had no idea how these common elements of belief ended up in Arabia anyway--how did this guy in 7th century Arabia, who wasn't a Jew, come to believe this stuff?

Certainly, I know enough to know that Islam didn't grow out of Judaism as, say, Christianity did, but evidently, pre-Islamic Arabs shared a lot with them. How much do we know about Pre-Islamic Arabian religion? Is there some specific name for the religion that Mohammed was born into? In addition to the populations of outright Christians and Jews there, were there particular groups that were more "Abrahamic" and those that were more "pagan?" I know that a lot of Islamic religious practice had something to do with what was already there--the locals had been performing rites around the Ka'aba, albeit very different ones, for instance, but how "Abrahamic" were those folks? How and when did Abrahamic beliefs get to the area?

3 Answers 2014-09-20

Sami pre christian religion

I find myself wondering about the the religion of the sami people before their conversion. I heard that Læstadius wrote about their beliefs, but I have heard that it isn't a complete account. I also understand that their religion was similar to the Finnish pagan religion.

My question ultimately is this. What do we know of the Sami religion and what can we assume about it based on other similar religions.

1 Answers 2014-09-20

What books can I read to understand the economic Schools?

Hi everyone!

I already have a basic understanding of economics (Mankiw, Sowell...) but am still out pf the water whenever the schools get brought in (that is keynesian... And so forth)

What schools should I be familiar with and what can I read to understand each of them?

Thanks!!

1 Answers 2014-09-20

Why was the Italian army so poor in WW2?

With all the troops and supporters Mussolini managed to round up, why did lose almost every battle they fought?

2 Answers 2014-09-20

How sure are we of the family tree of the British Royal family? Is there any reasonable suspicious of adultery or outright fraud at any point?

I read Price William's Wikipedia page and it says he can trace his family tree back to William the Conquerer. That's a thousand years of history! Idle speculation aside is there any real evidence to suggest that this is not true?

5 Answers 2014-09-20

Saturday Reading and Research | September 20, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

7 Answers 2014-09-20

Why did Ming China institute a policy of isolationism and was this the cause of China losing the technological and economic edge it had over other societies at the time (i.e. Europe)?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

Was Scotland a major power in Europe before the Acts of Union in 1707?

3 Answers 2014-09-20

Have there been political revolutions that weren't peasants vs monarchs, or battles for secession?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

What sort of buildings would be found in a roman town? How would a hamlet, town and city differ regarding types if structures?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

How considerable was the influence of the Epic of Gilgamesh on ancient Mesopotamian civilizations?

Basically what the title says. Would it be accurate to say the Epic of Gilgamesh was as influential (and popular) among the Akkadians, Assyrians, Babylonians etc. as the works of Homer were among the Greeks and Romans?

1 Answers 2014-09-20

I just read "The New Jim Crow"... I'm wondering why all other immigrant groups succeeded more than blacks, when facing similar prejudices?

The Chinese, the Irish, etc... were they not equally uneducated, unskilled, and segregated from the mainstream?

2 Answers 2014-09-20

If Hawaii was an independent nation until it was annexed by the United States, why does the Hawaiian flag have a Union Jack on it?

4 Answers 2014-09-20

What were the historical names of the Byzantine Empire and the city of Constantinople?

What did the inhabitants call themselves and how were they referred to by others (Arabs, western europeans, barbarians, etc.)?

2 Answers 2014-09-20

Did the decline of telling stories as a pastime have a profound impact on the way we speak?

For much of human history, telling eachother stories was a great way to keep eachother entertained, and to provide food for thought on topics such as history, society and morals. With the introduction of radio, film and television, people are less and less inclined to tell eachother stories for entertainment.

A thing I noticed when listening to old speeches, is that statespersons used to be much more dramatic and elaborate in their speech patterns than their contemporary counterparts. I'm wondering if the two phenomena are related?

3 Answers 2014-09-20

6293 / 7255

Back to start