To what extent did the struggles between the federales and the unitarios in 19th century Argentina influence Argentine civil society into the 20th century?

I recently read a biography of Borges which drew a comparison between the politics 19th-century Argentina and Borges' own family history.

It suggested that the struggles between the unitarios and the federales, and the dichotomy suggested by Sarmiento of civilisation and barbarism, held particular resonance for Borges because of how the 'intellectual' heritage of his father's side (including an English grandmother) contrasted with the 'criollo' ancestors on his mother's side.

Was this personal to Borges? How, if at all, did the struggles between the unitarios and the federales continue to influence Argentine politics and society in the 20th century?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Did people living 300+ years ago intentionally lift heavy objects for the sole purpose of aesthetics?

8 Answers 2014-06-23

Which wars are believed to have had the most devastating impact on ancient historical sites and artifacts?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

How was Rickets explained before we knew it was due to vitamin D/phosphorous/calcium deficiencies?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

How familiar would British Calvary officers fighting in the Crimean War been with the game of Polo?

My cursory internet research into 19th century Polo is turning up vague results, variously stating that Polo was first played in England by the 10th Hussars in 1834 and also, not played in England until after the Crimean war in the 1860s. Did soldiers in Crimea play polo in their down time, or would they not even have heard of the game?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Is there any historical background to the trope of prisoners breaking rocks?

And if so, why did they do it, other than for punishment? It's a common theme in old movies and cartoons that prisoners break rocks for hard labor, but why would they do it? Surely there were machines that could do the job better, even before the modern era.

2 Answers 2014-06-23

When did numbers start being used to identify players in team sports?

I searched the faq but to my surprise it wasn't there... Which sport was the first to adopt numbers as identifiers? How quickly did it spread to other sports?

2 Answers 2014-06-23

Under whose reign was communism the most effective?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

What's the evidence for the existence of Socrates?

2 Answers 2014-06-23

Monday Mysteries | The Summer of Mystery!

Hey there Sports Fans,
Now that summer has officially arrived, I'll be taking over the "Monday Mystery" feature. Just as the American public neglected the 1932 Ford model B in favor of the V8-equipped model 18, this feature has been somewhat neglected over the past few months, and I'm here to shake things up and rejuvenate the Monday Mystery - or at least make sure it goes out with a bang (just as the Marmon Motor Car Company went out of business after the extravagant, powerful Marmon Sixteen failed to turn a profit).

To make the summer of mystery the best it can be - and definitely not because I'm lazy and/or uncreative - I'd like you all to suggest some topics for upcoming mystery threads. These can be new ideas, or ones we've done in the past that you enjoyed. Here is a list of all our previous mystery features. Adherence to the general theme of "mysteries" is preferable, so we don't steal any of the Tuesday Triva threads' thunder, but there's room for some leeway. Go hog wild!

8 Answers 2014-06-23

I have a few questions about some surprising quotes by Napoleon Bonaparte

So I was just browsing some quotes by 'ole Napoleon (he always had such a flair for the dramatic) and I came across some surprising quotes by him regarding Muhammad ibn Abdullah, and his views on "Mohammedanism". To list them, Napoleon allegedly says:

"Religions are all founded on miracles — on things we cannot understand, such as the Trinity. Jesus calls himself the Son of God, and yet is descended from David. I prefer the religion of Mahomet — it is less ridiculous than ours.

"The Mohammedan religion is the finest of all"

"Muhammad was a great man, an intrepid soldier; with a handful of men he triumphed at the battle of Bender (sic); a great captain, eloquent, a great man of state, he revived his fatherland and created a new people and a new power in the middle of Arabia."

"Muhammad was a prince; he rallied his compatriots around him. In a few years, the Muslims conquered half of the world. They plucked more souls from false gods, knocked down more idols, razed more pagan temples in fifteen years than the followers of Moses and Jesus did in fifteen centuries. Muhammad was a great man. He would indeed have been a god, if the revolution that he had performed had not been prepared by the circumstances."

My question is two-fold:

1.) What is the validity of these quotations.

2.) If indeed true, where and how would a person like Napoleon receive knowledge, historical or otherwise, about Muhammad and Islam? And how thorough could that knowledge be when he is referring to Islam as the "Mohammedan Religion"? I know he technically conquered Egypt, but Im asking more-so in terms of the setting and formality of the education. What piqued my interest in particular is his mention of the "Battle of Bender". I might be mistaken, but I think this is a reference to the Battle of Badr. This was one of the most decisive and fateful battles in the history of Islam, but something that few westerners would be aware of today. How does Napoleon know enough about this to form a strong opinion? I guess a figure of his stature would've had access and inquiry beyond that of your typical yeoman farmer, but does anyone have some deeper insight as to how and why Napoleon could have said these things?

3 Answers 2014-06-23

Is there any evidence of any 'undesirables/coloured' persons passing the dictation test set out by the White Australia Policy?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Are there any pre-industrial accounts of children or adults living with cleft lip / cleft palate? How would their lives have differed from that of thieir "normal" peers?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Pope Eugene IV banned enslaving someone on the pain of excommunication. What is the story of this event? How did the catholic church come to oppose slavery?

I've heard about this, and I'd like to know more and the context of these events.

I know St Augustine was very much in favor of slavery. It'd be odd if the roman church was against it so early on.

1 Answers 2014-06-23

The staff and advisers to a daimyo in a feudal Japanese castle.

It seems incredibly easy to find the titles and household servants you would find in Western castles. We're familiar with chancellors and castellans and seneschals and manservants.

What are some of the titles (preferably in romanji) that we could expect to see in a Japanese castle serving a daimyo?

Who ran the day to day operations of the castle for the lord? Did he have a host of advisers with actual titles, or were they simply samurai? Did he tend to have a chancellor or a seneschal? Who was the head servant and so forth?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Why did Hitler serve only 9 months in prison after being convicted of treason for leading the Beer Hall Putsch?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

To what extent is it true that we lost the vietnamese war just because a democratic congress did not supply the South with supplies like we promised we would?

this video by a conservative think tank would have you believe that Saigon fell just because a democratic congress did not uphold the US' promise. To what extent is this true?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Where did surnames from various cultures originate from?

I know some English surnames come from their original trade e.g. Fletcher. What about Chinese surnames? Indian surnames?

3 Answers 2014-06-23

How were Marches, Margraves, Marquisats politically and territorially organized?

Whether its March[er Lord], Margrave, Marquisat, you have examples across Europe of this form of title which was given to lords on the frontiers [usually of Christendom], whether it be in Southern France (Spanish March), or East Germania etc. How were these divided differently from regular Counties/Comte or Duchies/Dux/Duce? And how did the title of Margrave or Marquis evolve from Marcher Lord, or did they not at all?

Did Marcher Lords have more power (hence more autocratic) as it was an unsettled border region, that needed a more direct hand from a military figure, or was it the complete opposite, where the King created these titles, so he could have a weak governor in charge, so he/she could wield authority in subduing the rough border regions of a Kingdom, as an open battleground, not yet ready for permanent nobility.

1 Answers 2014-06-23

How much influence did medieval banks exert over European royal houses and the relations between them?

I apologize if my answer is too vague, but in a course I took at university years ago I recall a professor mentioning off-hand the way medieval banks would strategically back certain monarchs. In particular, I remember my professor talking about how sometimes, if a monarch was unable to pay back loans, banks would finance their enemies in an attempt to basically get the money owed to them through shear force. Any information on the subject would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Before modern times what happened when I person was paralyzed? Were they ever carried around? Were they ever left for dead?

1 Answers 2014-06-23

Have any cultures interned their dead under water?

I know ground burials have an incredibly long history, but have any cultures (besides navies) buried their dead under water? I do mean in natural bodies of water, but burial practices involving submersion in baths or something would also be interesting to hear about.

3 Answers 2014-06-23

How did people back in the middle ages fight sunburn?

I was thinking about this when I was watching some Roman flick.

These people all live in a pretty warm climate and dress accordingly with light and skin revealing attire. So them not having any "pharmaceutical" or medical protection seems like it'd be a persistent issue with no solution other than to you know wear more clothes.

Was this even an issue back then?

2 Answers 2014-06-23

Question on the french revolution

I would like to know to what extent the great debates that shook the french revolution were democratic? That is to say, could anyone walk up and share their ideas? Were only members of a certain class able to voice their opinion? Or were the real important decisions taken aside in secrecy?

Take for example the church Sainte-Genevieve which became The Pantheon. Who made that call? How was it decided at first what men should be buried there?

In short, was the average parisian an active part of the revolution?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-06-23

In the hundreds of years that muzzle-loading firearms were used, why didn't better designs come more quickly?

Were early firearm designers simply not capable of imagining something like a revoler or lever action rifle, or was the construction of the necessary mechanisms simply not available at the time?

Also, with the Spencer repeating rifle having been invented in 1860, why didn't they see more use during the Civil War?

2 Answers 2014-06-23

6597 / 7255

Back to start