Why did Haitians declared empire and not kingdom, and then switched to kingdom?

If Iam not wrong, Haiti was the smallest empire in the world back then, and I wonder if it was just because they wanted to sound more cool of if it had deeper meaning. The fact that they went from republic to empire to kingdom to empire to republic makes it even more weird - also why did they switched from empire to kingdom when they already had "Imperial tradition"?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Were the New Model Army of England during Cromwell's time meritocratic or at least the officers less aristocrat-centric compared to the later militaries of England/UK?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Why does Israel have a parliament without any kind of local constituencies?

I can see the attraction of a hybrid system such as several countries including Germany and New Zealand implemented, in which there are constituencies and also a separate vote for a party list. But the Knesset system is close to unique as far as I know, and it seems (in recent years - much less so in the past) to cause chaos and constant new elections. What was the rationale behind its adoption?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Would it, in November 1939, be possible to ship something to Finland by the Barents sea?

Would it, in November 1939, be possible to ship something to Finland by the Barents sea? At the time I believe they did have a coast at the Barents sea. The main point would be to bypass Germany and their tendency to capture shipments of arms going to Finland.

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Back when people did not have indoor plumbing, and relied on outhouses for human waste and wells for ground water, how did they keep their drinking water safe?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

How did the game "Rock, Paper, Scissors" work before scissors were invented?

TBF I could ask the same question about the paper I suppose. We don't need to worry about the rocks.

If it's easier I would also be curious to hear what the origins of this game were. Perhaps it didn't exist until after scissors were invented.

I am also wondering if different cultures have their own versions of this game with different objects but the same rules.

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Where did "rangers" originate and what did they actually do?

In many medieval fantasy settings, and of course among park services and militaries today, the word "ranger" implies some kind of militant survivalist. But where did the term "rangers" actually come from, and what did they actually do?

Does the term "ranger" actually appear in any medieval texts, and was it a real profession outside of the Tolkien-esque fantasy connotations?

2 Answers 2022-11-02

Does anyone know of a primary source that was written by Sophie de Grouchy?

I'm currently studying the French Revolution and I have, so far, been unable to find a work written by her other than Letters on Sympathy. Any recommendations would be much appreciated as I need to find at least one to two more.

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Why did Pope Urban II agree to help the Byzantine Empire when they were Orthodox instead of Catholic?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

What’s happening with the “s’s” in the Dunlap broadside version of the U.S. Declaration of Independence?

Here is a link to a separate post with pics of the handwritten vs. broadside copies I was able to find online.

The first pic includes a link to a National Geographic article which suggests that though it was drafted on 7/4, getting it in circulation and even getting signatures for the document was a fairly extended process, with several (7?) of the final signatures added at some uncertain dates following the August 2nd “signing date.”

The second pic includes a link to an incredibly thoughtful article written by a librarian on some of the process involved with circulating, getting agreement on, and signing the Declaration. For example, it looks like the version George Washington ended up using was read aloud to the troops, and only the first 54 lines remain (I like to think that Mr. Washington just got impatient at the length and “edited” it when he thought he had read enough :)). The article also suggests that one of the anti-counterfeiting watermarks seem to have included (I tend to think deliberate?) typos, which suggests some potential explanations for my question to me.

My question is more or less limited to the title (what’s the deal with those “s’s”?), but always happy to learn more! :)

Edit: Caught a typo. There might be more. :P

1 Answers 2022-11-02

How medieval is House of the Dragons succession fight?

I‘m having an argument with somebody about this. I feel that the fight over the arguably legitimate line of succession in that show feels odd because it is lacking any meaningfully presented backdrop.

Its mostly about if first born girl or the later born boy is the legitimate heir, priority of gender or priority of firstness, both lines of argumentation are presented as equally valid. The debate is shown taking place in what feels like a vacuume, and as mere rhetorical strategies, and not as having much to do with broad stroke societal views about the proper gender for a monarch.

I think the show is lacking something in the presentaion of that question, but my friend says its pretty close to how those arguments would have felt around 1100 ad in europe.

Is there a sensible answer on who of us is more right?

2 Answers 2022-11-02

What was the original purpose of the Prussian education system?

Much has been written about the Prussian education system being created as a way to create compliant nationals that could work in factories or serve the purposes of the Nation-state. However, it seems that the Prussian system dates back to the XVIII century, well before the French Revolution or even the appearance of most modern factories. What was the original purpose of having a compulsory education free for everyone?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

How op/usefull/good where archers in medieval battles?

Like, in a certain way, you were far, usually a lot of archers, and have a weapon that can kill at a far good distance.

How actually usefull where archers? Did every army had a section of archers? How would they deal with flanking cavalary? Were shield enought to proctect against archers?

I understand their usefull in sieges, but i'm focus on field battles

I've heard of the english longbowman but would like a bit of more information on the matter

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Why does every state in America have their own process for getting a medical license rather than just having one national medical license?

I'm a doctor and this never made sense to me. As far as I know, in every other country, once you're licensed as a doctor, your license is valid everywhere in the country. But in the US, I'm suddenly "practicing medicine without a license" if I cross state lines.

2 Answers 2022-11-02

Are there still palimpsests to discover?

Reading this article, I was excited to see they had discovered something lost from antiquity (astronomer Hipparchus’ map of the stars) in a palimpsest recently. I often think about all the literary works we have lost to history, and it makes me sad. I sort of assumed most palimpsests had already been checked as much as possible, since the demand for discovering lost works must be huge, but are there still many palimpsests out there to be scanned, and lost works to be discovered? (Like, in the Vatican Archives or something).

I still hold the hope that some day we might discover parts of one of the lost works of Aristotle or Cicero or the Stoics, or maybe text that filled in some of the lost parts of plays that only survives in fragments.

Am I misguided to cling on to that hope, or are there more to discover out there with technology than we think?

1 Answers 2022-11-02

Has anyone ever actually avenged their murdered monarch parent and reclaimed their kingdom?

It seems like such a common trope in movies and plays and books, but has it ever actually happened? I can imagine it likeliest in small settings, like tribes or village fiefdoms, but are there notable instances of it happening on the scale of, say, a medieval nation, or a city-state?

6 Answers 2022-11-02

What motivated the Shōgitai and other pro-Tokugawa troops at Ueno to keep fighting after Tokugawa Yoshinobu surrendered in the spring of 1868?

From what I understand, Yoshinobu had gone to war somewhat reluctantly in January 1868 and surrendered not long after his allies deserted him after the bakufu's defeat at Toba-Fushimi; why did elements of the army accompany him to retirement at the Kan'ei-ji in the first place, and to what end did they continue to fight against the Satsuma-Chōshū forces for the next few months? For the other post-surrender forces, the motivations seem pretty clear – the Northern Alliance attempting to preserve autonomy for pro-Tokugawa domains and prevent a total monopoly on power for the Sat-Chō coalition; Enamoto Takeaki attempting to establish an autonomous haven for Tokugawa retainers on Hokkaido. But ostensibly, there seems to have been little reason to wage war on behalf of a leader who had essentially surrendered twice in the last 6 months, first politically and then militarily.

1 Answers 2022-11-01

"The modern world is only against antisemitism because it was associated with Nazis": how true is this and for how many things?

I've heard people claim that the only reason the modern world is supposedly against antisemitism, unethical human experimentation, dictatorships and what have you, is because the Allies (specifically the US) wanted to use them to denounce Nazi Germany, or because they wanted to distance themselves from Nazi Germany and the newly-discovered Holocaust. How true is this and for which things other than antisemitism?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

Why were the Manchus assimilated into the Han despite ruling the last dynasty and never facing any widespread persecution?

And why were they assimilated so thoroughly (native speakers in the double digits, few continuing remnants of culture) instead of persisting as a distinct minority?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

Why did Nevada flourish as a destination for "sin" (gambling, divorce, sex work, etc.) while having a substantial Mormon population?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

I have just seen a claim that the association between witches and flying broomsticks is because women would lace brooms with hallucinogens like fungus-infected rye and then shove them up their ladybits. Is there any merit to this claim at all?

So I study beer and brewing, previously as a profession but nowadays more as a hobby. I've even managed to answer a question in this sub before, which was very satisfying!

In the field, a lot of people are familiar with the story of how the stereotypical figure of the witch came through the male-dominated clergy and other parties interested in seizing beer production for themselves associating alewives with the devil and evil magic.. It's a mundane, typical story of social segregation through the use of spirituality, and it seems generally accepted to be true. The association between witches and brooms would thus come from the sensible fact that brewing involves a lot of grain and dust, so alewives would always have a broom around.

Just saw someone on reddit link this article however, and this one, weirdly enough from the same website as the other one I linked, claims that women would rub hallucinogens on brooms then shove them up their genitalia to get high, and that is how the association between witches and brooms came about.

Of course, one theory does not contradict the other per se, but one feels far fetched to me. Is there any credible evidence of the practice of using brooms for recreational drug use in any moment in history?

e: the links I posted aren't meant as sources of any kind, just illustrations of both theories

1 Answers 2022-11-01

What did Winston Churchill think of Wilhelm II?

I've read that Churchill offered asylium to the ex-Kaiser in 1940, but he declined. Also, Churchill and Wilhelm met when he was still Emperor. What was Churchill's opinion on the former Emperor? Did he really think that Hitler wouldn't have raised to power if Germany was still a monarchy?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

What did people eat in travel (the middle ages and early modern era)?

I asume most of the traveler's diet would be bread, since it was the biggest part of one's diet in general with dairy products in the second place, followed by dried meat and fruit. I'd like my to get more specific information, such as how was the food stored, who could afford meat and if there were any products associated especially with traveling? How about water or any other drink - what was the general drink of choice?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

Were people more accustomed to touching each other in the past (the middle ages and early modern era)?

I have to study the history of the literature at my university and recently we've been dealing with some works from the middle ages. Most of the stories are full of displays of affection such as men kissing. Funny for a modern reader, especially if these are military men (knights) we're talking about, isn't it?

Later on, I came across information about once popular communal sleeping such as servants sharing beds with their masters of the same sex, that seemed to be the case for a long time.

All of this made me wonder, whether back then people were more accustomed to displaying affection or simply touching each other. When and why did it stop being the case? Personally, if I were to share a bed with a stranger, I'd bite their hands off. Would be great-...-great-grandma do the same?

1 Answers 2022-11-01

Where did Italians originally immigrate from, before ending up in (what is now) Italy?

After taking an Ancestry DNA test, I was shown some obvious inheritances such as Italian (mostly Central Southwestern), Japanese, and European/Ashkenazi Jew (I am aware of specifically German and Polish Jew ancestry). I also have traces of English, Welsh, and Scottish DNA (6-10%). The smallest fractions of DNA I have are of Cyprian, Greek/Albanian, and Egyptian origin. Based on historical migration/immigration (apologies if I’m using incorrect terminology), is it most likely that these traces come from my Italian ancestors?

Also, where could I learn about the migrations of people over time? I attempted to look on Wikipedia but the articles I read went right over my head, leaning very heavily into complicated genetic jargon that I’m not knowledgeable enough to understand.

If this is better suited for r/Genealogy, please let me know!

1 Answers 2022-11-01

68 / 7255

Back to start