How well accepted is the theory that the Minoan civilization was devastated by a massive tsunami and that this event lead to the the myth of Atlantis?

I saw this on an episode of Secrets of the Dead

Full episode

1 Answers 2014-03-08

What book(s) would you recommend for someone who wants a whole world history?

2 Answers 2014-03-08

When did Opera cross the Atlantic?

Bonus- do we have records telling us what was the first opera performed in the Americas?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

How did Stalin react to the news of the successful Normandy landings?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Smoking in the 17th Century Rus

Hello. I just saw this post on r/MilitaryPorn, http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/50/Ilja_Jefimowitsch_Repin_009.jpg

I was looking at the pipes, and wondered what they were smoking. I know that tobacco was around at the time, and that the Russian Orthodox Church was against it.

My question is whether the Cossacks or other people in the region ever smoked cannabis.

Just wondering because the Crimean invasion by the Turks may have introduced cannabis to the Rus.

Thanks for the help.

1 Answers 2014-03-08

A set of questions regarding Charlemagne and the Franks

  1. Charlemagne was King of the Franks (and Lombards), so naturally what language was his mother tongue? A form of Old German, or old French?

  2. What language did the Frankish people speak?

  3. Franks were a mixture of Germanic peoples, and Gauls, as well as Lombards and Romans. Which of these was most prevalent in the culture and being of the Frankish?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Are there any WW2 documentaries, movies or books worth watching/reading that picture the war from Russian perspective?

10 Answers 2014-03-08

Following some recent posts, discussing historical conceptions of race, what books would AskHistorians recommend to better understand how one should approach race in a historical context?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

help! I'm a writer who is thinking of a Japanese story from a Western Perspective. What book or series of books (or historic resources) should I be reading and looking into?

I must learn Japanese history and the anthropologic perspective of day to day living. The more I learn, the more I want to eat. Just learned these exist. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_Village Are they the same thing as the Forbidden City in Beijing?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Who was the largest player against the Axis (in terms of legwork put forth to stop them) in WWII?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

What were Samurai really like, and what exactly is Bushido?

A while back I read a Cracked article that pointed out that Bushido is actually a modern concept, and was just used to subjugate the Japanese populace into doing what the Japanese Empire wanted.

However, considering that this is from a Cracked article, I'm not entirely satisfied with everything they present, especially the article's comparison to a football player. It's been bothering me for quite some time, and I'm hoping that /r/AskHistorians can provide me with a more professional response than any other place on the internet.

So, what were samurai really like? Were they selfish or honorable? What were their customs? Were they really just hired men? Did they follow a set of morals and strict traditions? I've heard that their morning routine involved contemplating death: what did they do with their mornings? How common was hara-kiri? Is the popular image of samurai today similar at all to what they were really like? What exactly was Bushido, or whatever it was back in feudal Japan? What did it entail?

Furthermore, if you have the time: How comparable exactly were Media val European Knights and Feudal Japanese Samurai? What are some of the greatest exploits and feats that samurai have accomplished or done in history? What are some of the most famous samurai?

I'm sorry if I'm shooting off too many questions, but I'm really genuinly curious about this subject.

Bonus: I saw the film "13 Assassins". Is it just made up, or is there some historical accuracy at all to it?

2 Answers 2014-03-08

Has there ever been a war without a single casualty?

3 Answers 2014-03-08

Did the Genoans really conquer the island of Crimea, and what significance did the island hold to them?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Why were ancient Africans able to deal with starvation much better than Africans today?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Are there any kings who we now know were illegitimate claimants to the throne?

3 Answers 2014-03-08

It is my belief that the Second Punic War is the most important war in all of western history. Is this a common opinion amongst scholars?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Why were the Channel Islands' neutrality guaranteed by a Papal Bull in 1483?

According to this wikipedia article on the history of the channel islands, "In 1483 a Papal bull decreed that the islands would be neutral during time of war." What was the reason for this? Why did the Pope think this was an issue worth his time? How come it was abolished in 1689 following the Glorious Revolution?

Interestingly, the claim is not cited in the wikipedia article I linked nor the list of Papal Bulls article so it may have been fabricated by the author of the article, but that seems unlikely.

1 Answers 2014-03-08

How were black people treated by the Roman Empire?

EDIT: Sorry for the vague term! By "black" I mean black africans, ethiopians.

3 Answers 2014-03-08

What came first, New York City, or New York State (colony?), and why are they named the same thing?

I'm just interested in how the New York name developed in terms of the city and the state.

Was there a city called New York that grew so large and wealthy that it was able to become one of the original 13 colonies?

Or was the colony created and a city named New York after that?

Also what factors went into deciding to name them the same thing? Was there a dispute over the name of either?

3 Answers 2014-03-08

Can someone explain me how explorers in the Age of discovery acquired so fast the language of native?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Was Futurism an art movement that found its very origins in Fascist propaganda, or was it initially separate from it and transformed and used by the Fascists to promote their agenda?

3 Answers 2014-03-08

Were ancient Egyptians considered 'black' by modern standards?

I understand that in modern times the population is predominantly Arab, but has it always been this way? Some groups are arguing that Egyptians were as black as peoples from other areas of Africa, but I find that hard to imagine. Is anyone able to clarify?

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Did Hitler survive the second world war? (xpost from /r/conspiracy) Source inside.

According to everything i learned from history classes and history channel(when it showed history) tells me that the answer of this question is no, but check out the article below. I don't know what kind of site it is, but it does have references to official FBI webpages with intelligence report stating that Hitler fled to South America. What does historians think about this?

http://xposethereal.com/alternative-news/historians-lied-hitler-did-not-die-in-germany.html

1 Answers 2014-03-08

How did the Rothschilds protect their money?

I'm interested more in the financial aspect of it. I know there was a dad and his 5 sons, and they opened offices in several financial centers in Europe. I read the Wiki, and I would like more details about this part:

the new kind of international bank created by the Rothschilds was impervious to local attacks. Their assets were held in financial instruments, circulating through the world as stocks, bonds and debts. Changes made by the Rothschilds allowed them to insulate their property from local violence: "Henceforth their real wealth was beyond the reach of the mob, almost beyond the reach of greedy monarchs."

What are the changes that the Rothschilds made?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-03-08

Was Christian influence responsible for the creation of the idea of Ragnarok in Norse/Viking mythology?

I've created this thread to settle a small debate between two friends of mine regarding how much Christian beliefs and ideas from their neighbours influenced the mythology of Norse paganism.

One of them is adamant that Ragnarok is a creation of Christian missionaries or later Christian revisionism of the old myths. He is also of the opinion that the role of Loki was "rewritten" from a neutral trickster god to the a more Satan-like position by this Christianisation of Viking culture.

The other person in the debate takes the opinion that this apparent change in the nature of various entities in the Norse myths are the result of natural change over time. I'm inclined to agree with this view, although I would think that Christianity did have an influence but more due to cultural osmosis rather than intentional revisionism.

Basically, what we want to know is how Christianity may have influenced the mythology and religion of the Viking peoples.

1 Answers 2014-03-08

7011 / 7255

Back to start