What is the best estimate for the population of the Americas in 1491 and how did it compare to other continents?

2 Answers 2014-02-19

Have there been other examples of "wars on drugs" or prohibition in the past?

1 Answers 2014-02-19

Arms and weaponry of the average citizen in the ancient west.

  1. Were citizens allowed to carry weapons in Rome and Greece? If not, what was the punishment for doing so?

  2. What kinds of weapons would the average citizen carry? How about thugs, thieves, "gang" members?

  3. Was there "gang" warfare?

Bonus question: what were criminal gangs like in the ancient west?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-02-19

Is there a link between the severity/nature of punishment and the likelihood of recidivism?

In the spirit of the recent criminal history Monday and the interesting thread on the abolition of capital punishment in England, I wonder if there might be any demonstrable link between recidivism and the nature of punishment in England during the Victorian age of reform?

With the cessation of transportation and introduction of probation, Darwinian ideas of criminal heredity gaining currency, Lombroso, and penal reform, there're hundreds of distinct threads that might have had an influence. Is it possible to identify any marked influence of punishment-type on habitual reoffence in this big continuum beyond the vague deterrent effect that's so often referred to?

1 Answers 2014-02-19

Has there ever been an offensive or invasion in which both armies left, and couldn't find the other?

Like, let's say Italy launches a navy with a landing force to hit North Africa. North Africa did the same to Italy, and upon landing, both nations can't find their enemy's main force. Also applicable to land offensives.

Just using Italy and North Africa because they're the best locations I could think of.

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Historians and redditors How baldness(Hair lost) was perceived throughout history?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

How did the Crimean War happen?

How did the Crimean War happen?

How did Russia get involved in a war with the Ottoman Empire than expanded way beyond their initial plans?

Why did Britain and France get involved?

Was the war really mismanaged by all powers?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Southern Song Dynasty Influence in Japan (Economic & Cultural)

During the Southern Song Dynasty, there was quite a bit of economic restructuring and growth. I'm aware that Song coins became more common in East Asia, but how much of an influence did they have in Japan specifically? I'm not familiar with Japanese currency, so sorry if this is an obvious or dumb part to the question, but to what extent did the coins see use or influence Japanese currency? Also, did any of the tested paper currency at the time make it over or have any influence (there's less records of the paper currency leaving China)?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

[META] Over-zealous Moderation and Thread Quality

Now, I don't consider myself a 'quality contributor' to this subreddit, but when it looks like a question is going to go unanswered, I give it a shot. Here are two recent occasions when I've done this.

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1wswf9/use_of_performance_enhancing_drugs_on_german/

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1y9m0g/is_this_photo_truly_the_last_photo_of_hitler/

The issues I have with the moderation of these comments is:

Both comments took place on very low-traffic threads which would not have gotten answered otherwise.

In both cases my information was good.

Moderation detracted from rather than added to the discussions. Clearly both these moderators were just trying to justify use of their petty internet powers.

5 Answers 2014-02-18

Island swapping. Nutmeg. Treaty of Breda. (1667) Who got the better deal?

So, the Second Anglo-Dutch War (1665-67) concluded with the British and Dutch trading New Amsterdam (Manhattan) for the Island of Run (Banda Islands in Indonesia).

Sources: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banda_Islands http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Breda_(1667) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nutmeg

This means that the Dutch had a monopoly on spices like nutmeg (a hallucinogen), mace, cloves and other spices until roughly the Napoleonic Wars (1803-15) while the Brits had power over the American territory and the taxing opportunities until the American Revolution (1765-1783).

Clearly maintaing these powers over the Americans and the Indonesians as well as fighting off other enemies to protect these investments must have been costly relative to the proceeds that they generated. I know that this is all an oversimplification of this topic, but I am curious if there is a way, or established theories, on quantifying who got the better deal from the Treaty of Breda?

And, really? Nutmeg? Are we missing out?

3 Answers 2014-02-18

Military history: During the Napoleonic war why did the British army not convert regular red coats to rifled muskets? As they already had green coat brigades and could see the benefits.

When the rifle brigade was set up in 1800 it soon proved itself to be very useful at infiltrating enemy lines and sharpshooting, thus it was observed by many generals in the army that the rifled guns had better accuracy as well as better range than there musket counterparts. Given this general agreement by the "top brass" about the rifles benefits (that arguably out weighed its weaknesses):

why did the British army never upgrade regular soldiers of the line / red coats to this "obviously" superior weapon?

Was it really not generalised just due to firing time?

As well as this, was it due to it being less easy to mass produce?

Thank you for your responses.

2 Answers 2014-02-18

Before contact with Europeans, were there any fermented alcoholic beverages (beer, wine) being consumed by Native Americans, and if so, what were they like?

In terms of the composition of the drinks, alcoholic strength, amount that people would generally drink, social aspects, etc.

3 Answers 2014-02-18

Hypothetical: What is your educated guess of what would happen if the C.S.A. had gotten independence?

2 Answers 2014-02-18

How could you go about winning a fight against Scutum armed Troops?

I'm curious: Given it's great size, it seems that a century of properly drilled troops, equipped with Scutum are almost invulnerable, as the testudo would enable them to survive ranged attack (asides from siege engine such as ballista and the like) and in melee they would prevent a solid wall of shield, robbing the enemy any chance of getting at that sweet Roman flesh.

I'm sure I'm wrong, because the Romans did suffer defeats. But why?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

What is your opinion on Joan of Arc?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Why did settlers in New England ('murica) name all the towns after English towns or European countries?

So I've just been on holiday to Boston, we took a trip up to Maine for some skiing and as we went the above question struck me. Coming from England myself it was novelty to see and drive through all these places with familiar names, as well as seeing some places with names of European countries or capital cities.

Why did they do this instead of coming up with new and original names? I mean, if I founded a new town/city, I wouldn't name it after Brighton (where I'm from), I'd name it something entirely different. Das_Perderdernerterville or something (maybe not quite like that, you get my point).

1 Answers 2014-02-18

What implication did Fidel Castro's stay at Hotel Theresa have?

I'm reading Malcolm X's autobiography and he mentions that Fidel Castros stayed at Hotel Theresa . He says that Castro had won a grand psychological victory over USA's foreign department. He goes on to say that the deparment had forbidden Castro to leave Manhattan but never expected him to stay in Harlem and that it made a strong impression on the black community.

What was the psychological victory and what implication did his stay at Hotel Theresa have?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

How did they prevent people from making counterfeit money before watermarks etc?

I'm wondering what preventive measures people have used through the ages to make it hard to make counterfeit money. Nowadays, we have all kinds of things ranging from watermarks to a mixture of cloth & paper...

How did they prevent people (jewelers, smiths) from recreating their currency?

A side question: Are there any records of people actually making money whenever they needed it & using it to supply their demands, or even of people living large because they made themselves a load of money?

2 Answers 2014-02-18

On Oliver Cromwell.. I've got questions..

I've been studying about Oliver Cromwell, and I see all of his accomplishments as being "God's Will" everytime he speaks about his actions. Yet I don't see any real reason for this conviction, which as far as I can tell, was labelled a "conversion experience". How would you describe what that would have been like? Or why it was so powerful?

It's obvious he believed in God's Will when he turns down the crown to "forsake personal glory". But he sure took a lot of glory from the battlefield and used it to achieve personal and political gain, even securing a life long financial benefit from his battlefield actions.

So what was really going on with Cromwell?

2 Answers 2014-02-18

How powerful were firearms in the XV-XVI century?

I'm especially interested how significate they were on the battlefield.

1 Answers 2014-02-18

What kind of relationship did Reverend George Whitefield and Benjamin Franklin have?

I am aware that Franklin published Whitefield's sermons in his Gazette and Whitefield was happy to allow him to do so. How did their relationship go beyond business interactions?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Why did Byzantine-Western relations change so drastically during the crusades?

Starting with the first crusade where there appears to be mutual relations to the sacking of Constantinople. How did this change occur?

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Was there a reason American adults stopped dressing so formally in public?

When I view old photos, movies, and sitcoms from earlier decades, I can't help but notice how well dressed everyone was. It seems like unless someone was extremely poor, they dressed very formally compared to today's standards. Are there specific reasons why society become more casual in their style of dress?

5 Answers 2014-02-18

What were the primary causes of the First World War?

i.e Imperialism, Nationalism, Militarism, monarchism.

1 Answers 2014-02-18

Constateur Plasschaert Frères

I have a Constateur Plasschaert Frères. I understand the basics of what it was, but I was wondering if anyone knows a bit about them. All knowledge is welcome! All I know is its for timing honing pigeon races and recording the time on paper. Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-02-18

7081 / 7255

Back to start