What animal species appear most frequently in prehistoric cave paintings?

Do depictions of a particular species differ across time and space? If so, what are some of the hypotheses explaining these differences?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in January 16th, 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2014-01-16

Did the human experimentation and research undertaken during WW2 result in anything beneficial?

The research done by the Nazis and Imperial Japanese has been well documented, I'm wondering if the research resulted in anything useful.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

What provisions would sailors bury in the 16th - 17th centuries?

I was re-reading the Secret Voyage of Sir Francis Drake and it mentions he buried provisions in a cove in S America expecting a return to the same hideaway to continue to plunder the Spanish. In general, what provisions would sailors bury that would be valuable but also worth the risk of losing? Along with the dangers of spoilage and rust, there isn't anything I can imagine that is worth burying. Is there any documentation out there that has a specific list of items? My google-foo has failed me. Many thanks for any answers.

Edit: Thanks for the answers. I really enjoyed both comments. I had no idea that meat could last that long without refrigeration. I remember reading a book about Magellan that made it seem like hunting was plentiful around there. I also like the idea of storing all excess repair parts, those seem like one of those "low risk-high reward" burial items I didn't think about.

2 Answers 2014-01-16

Historians! Has anyone written a well-researched, in-depth book exposing how the USSR's Politburo actually worked, who pulled its strings, things like that?

I have always been curious about the inner workings of the USSR during the cold war. The Soviet premier was always a figure of some kind (think: Kruschev, Gorbi, etc.) but... there was always the Politburo. Didn't they appoint the premier? Did he fear them, or regard them as his superiors? Did they set his agenda? Who pulled the strings? I am trying to learn more about the powers that were behind the power in the USSR. The truth, I am starting to believe, isn't what we are told in the official history books. Anything?

5 Answers 2014-01-16

Did Christianity historically oppose that the earth was spherical?

I know that knowledge of the earth's shape dates back to ancient greek society and perhaps further, but the idea that scientists were executed for stating that the earth was round seems to be a popular belief. Does this stem from confusion with the idea of heliocentrism?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Was Fiddler on the Roof at all accurate in displaying the life of Jews in Russia at the turn of the century?

Besides breaking into song regularly, how does the movie compare with the daily lives of a small Jewish community? Would Tzeitel have ever been allowed to marry for love? Would there have been a matchmaker?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

More examples of this kind? (slavery, antebellum thought)

I've stumbled upon Diseases and Peculiarities of the Negro Race by the 19th century scientist Cartwright and found this quote very interesting:

They wander about at night, and keep in a half nodding sleep during the day. They slight their work,--cut up corn, cane, cotton or tobacco when hoeing it, as if for pure mischief. They raise disturbances with their overseers and fellow-servants without cause or motive, and seem to be insensible to pain when subjected to punishment. The fact of the existence of such a complaint, making man like an automaton or senseless machine, having the above or similar symptoms, can be clearly established by the most direct and positive testimony.

What I found most interesting:

  • Cartwright's unwillingness to ascribe motives to the actions of slaves.

  • His comparison of slaves to machines.

  • His claim that black slaves don't experience pain like we (the readership) do.

My questions:

  • How common would you say are opinions like the three above for the era? S.J.Gould thinks Cartwright held a fringe position even in his own era – any thoughts on that?

  • Do you know more examples of the same or similar points in other sources? Even vague ones (primary literature, authors I could check out, anything really).

Any responses are much appreciated! Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Please explain the history of showers/bathing from a historically global perspective.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

With Scandinavian names being patronymics, why did Ragnar Lothbrok have a last name? Even his sons were all known by a patronymic (i.e. Ubba Rangnarson).

2 Answers 2014-01-16

Why, in the early 1900's, was much of Europe colonizing and expanding their empires, while the United States weren't?

Obviously the British and the French had extensive colonies throughout the world, but even Germany and Italy, who were less than 100 years old had fairly large colonies extending into Africa and Asia.

Why does it seem like the United States didn't have an interest in expanding this way? or did they?

2 Answers 2014-01-16

1 How to Historians evaluate the value of information (truthfulness) in historical sources/documents?

I hope the question is not too general... How we can evaluate how biased or objective the author of an anciant book was?

6 Answers 2014-01-16

Searching for a quote by Diderot about d'Alembert

My history professor mentioned a joke made by Diderot about Jean d'Alembert that goes something along those lines:

"d'Alembert's mathematical genius makes him stand on the largest mountain, with his head high in the clouds, preventing him to look down into the valley".

Unfortunately my professor could not remember the original text and source. I would greatly appreciate if someone could help me out :)

Edit 0: I hope this does not fare as a trivia question. I actually could really make good use of the quote in my research paper.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Why weren't bows and arrows used during the Napoleonic Wars?

Bows seem to be a way more reliable weapon than muskets of the day. Muskets misfired and gunpowder was dangerous to transport. Bows are also a lot faster to reload than muskets. So why weren't bows used instead of muskets?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Are interest payments on loans a fairly recent development? How have cultures rewarded lending?

I am not a historian but a student of economics. Within economics one uses models which include lending, yet this was not always the case. Within Christian, Islamic, and Jewish social doctrines are prohibitions on interest rewarding the lender. This has been posited, within economic circles, to inhibit the growth of economies by not using the funds necessary to those who wished to have them.

How have modern ideas, viz. lending being a good thing, supplanted older ideas about the practice of lending for a profit?

As related questions come in, I may edit this text to clarify my question.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

When did the Roman "broken line" formation become impractical or obsolete as a military strategy and what factors led to its decline?

Edit: I apologize for any ambiguity, I am indeed referring to the manipular formation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rom-mnpl-1.png

3 Answers 2014-01-16

How is an arrow actually loosed from a bow.

2 Answers 2014-01-16

Alcohol on muslim ships

During ancient times when ships had beer to drink for the crew since water would spoil, how was the matter handled on muslim ships since the religion bans alcohol.

2 Answers 2014-01-16

Is Moses, like Jesus, an accepted historical figure, or is there some debate over his existence?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

What accounts are there of Alexander the Great being awkward with women?

Spurred by /u/teekaj2's excellent detail on one of Alexander's amazing victories. It's a bit bewildering to imagine that one of the greatest soldiers who ever lived would blush around pretty women.

1 Answers 2014-01-16

Why was the north against the expansion of slavery?

This isn't the same old "was slavery the cause of the war" or "what was the civil war about" or "did the north go to war to stop slavery" question.

I'm literally wondering the answer to this question: why were the people of the north against the expansion of slavery prior to the civil war?

Today we (mostly) know and accept how horrific slavery is. However, I'm not about to take the step and say the people of the north were somehow morally superior to the people of the south and thought slavery was horrific, so it needed to go.

Nowadays you'd poll everyone: Are you against slavery? Which of the following reasons is the primary reason? Obviously this didn't happen back then.

So, was it about economics - the northern fear that the expansion of slavery would continue to put them on unequal footing with the south, who got low priced labor? Otherwise, considering racism in the north by the majority of people (as far as I can discern), the acceptance by the majority of the idea that black people are genetically inferior, etc, doesn't lead me to believe it really was some great moral crusade by the majority.

Obviously, different people have different reasons so there isn't one answer for every citizen of the north, but what was the most common reason?

And has anyone written about this or studied this in detail? Any books about just this question?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

We all know about Holocaust Denial. What are some other concerted efforts at abusing or manipulating history that the public may not be aware of?

1 Answers 2014-01-16

I'm attempting to find out who owned a Japanese military sword, from WWII, that was passed down to me.

My Grandfather was in the US military, and was a Naval Seabee during WWII in the Pacific theatre. He saw a lot of combat, and during an attack he lost his closest friend to a Japanese soldier. My Grandfather avenged his friend, and brought the soldiers sword, and rifle back when he came home.

What I would like to know is if anyone here could please help me in translating the text that is on the tang of the sword. I'm told that it contains the sword makers name, the soldiers family name, and in some cases the village, or area that it was made in. My hopes are that some day I might be able to return it to it's rightful family.

The link below is a picture of the markings. http://imgur.com/kOURv7

Update: The same picture, rotated. http://imgur.com/a/MXLeO#0

Update: Jan 17 Better quality photos, as well as the Tsuba. http://bigolfishy.imgur.com/all/

5 Answers 2014-01-16

When and how did the ancient hieroglyphic language cease being the main language of Egypt?

Additionally, what was the language spoken by the Egyptian population during the Islamic conquest of Egypt, and how were the invading arabs able to change the spoken language from the current language (I'm assuming Coptic) to Arabic?

2 Answers 2014-01-16

What did the Allies in WW2 do to protect civilians during the bombing raids? or did they at all?

2 Answers 2014-01-16

7201 / 7255

Back to start