What kept George Washington from drawing the entire population of the Colonies into the American Revolution?

I'm reading Robert Middlekauff's superb book on the American Revolution, and came across a sentence where he cites Washington's distrust of civilian-in-arms as perhaps the reason he was blinded to the possibility of drawing the entire population into the conflict in a similar way to the French Revolution (p.343).

Middlekauff doesn't say any more on the topic and I was hoping someone could elucidate.

1 Answers 2014-01-08

How much truth is there to the idea that US political parties Republican and Democrat "switched policy platforms" in the early 1900s?

When I bring up political party accomplishments to friends and family, many cite this era (circa 1910s) as a time where previous accomplishments of the Republican Party platform can be attributed to the modern day Democratic Party. I need to discover what happened during this period of time to determine how I view history and the people involved in American historical events.

No, I'm not looking for ammunition to win political arguments. I'm interested to know the truth about the two major American political parties and how we view the progress that America has gained in the past 200 years.

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What was the state of pornography in the Soviet Union?

I'm aware that it was illegal as it went against the ideas of their "Socialist Morality", but how widespread and available was it? How was it acquired? Was it similar to mid-20th Century America in its underground nature?

3 Answers 2014-01-08

Why did Germanic kingdoms in modern France, Spain and Italy end up adopting the languages of the substrate populations while in England the opposite occurred?

Roman Spain, France and Italy all were conquered by Germanic tribes (Visigoths, Franks and Lombards respectively) who created kingdoms there in late antiquity. These kingdoms all ended up speaking the language of the general population and abandoning the Germanic languages of the ruling class.

A similar invasion occurred in post-roman Britain but in this case the kingdoms kept their Germanic languages and it was the native Romano-Celtic languages that were abandoned.

Is there any explanation for this difference?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What are the best books to read in regards to US President Eisenhower's leadership style and methodology?

The older I get, the more respect I have for this guy. I want to emulate him in my own life and want to learn more about how he led people so powerfully with so much integrity.

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Who were the Philistines of the Bible, and where did they come from?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What are some reasons that lead to the Spanish Civil War?

I'm doing the Spanish Civil War for my Spanish class and I'm doing some research at the moment but I need some help. What caused the Spanish Civil War? I don't mind if you prefer to explain in brief.

Thanks

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Kim Jong-un succeeded his father even though he was the youngest of three sons. Was primogeniture observed in Korea historically or is it more of a Western precept?

5 Answers 2014-01-08

Why did the Holy Roman Empire end up so decentralised in the first place?

I was thinking today of Germany and how as a nation-state it's probably one of the youngest of the major European powers. And that led on to - why is that?

I mean, I understand that immediately after the fall of Rome, most of Europe was scattered and divided. But then over time, they slowly began to consolidate and turn into something resembling proper kingdoms.

This never happened for the HRE - what are the specific reasons why the HRE existed for most of its history as a collection of loosely-aligned city-states, whereas countries like France started out divided, but ended up unifying?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What caused the Taiping Rebellion to have such an incredibly high death toll?

I only recently learned about this war, and I was shocked to see that some estimates put the death toll at 20 million, or even higher, making it by far the deadliest war of the 19th century. What factors lead to it being such a destructive conflict?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Holocaust definition

By definition, a holocaust is "destruction or slaughter on a mass scale" (definition from google)

Is there any reason in particular that we only generally use the word to describe either nuclear destruction or the killing of Jews during WWII? Stalin killed many more of his own countrymen. What about Mao?

This is inspired by a post on the front page today that uses the word holocaust to describe what's going on in North Korea. Wouldn't it, then, be appropriate to use the word to describe all of the other atrocities that resulted in dozens of millions of deaths from dictators like Stalin and Mao? Or is it inappropriate to compare what's going on in North Korea to the Final Solution?

I found an old post on /r/askhistorians asking a similar question, and the top comment was that the WWII holocaust was a systematic, intentional destruction of a race of people, and that's what sets it apart from the likes of Stalin et al. How is modern day North Korea different from USSR Stalin?

4 Answers 2014-01-08

Why were 1930-40's era Nazi vehicles' headlights blacked out?

I know this isn't a super profound question by this sub's standards but I can't seem to find any info on this.

Here are some examples

*I guess I could have left out 1930-40's. Derp.

4 Answers 2014-01-08

Why are funeral rites so significiant to understanding ancient cultures?

2 Answers 2014-01-08

Drugs in Victorian Britian

I have started to reread the Sherlock Holmes stories and had an argument with a friend concerning the new portrails of Sherlock on TV, primarily in respect to his drug usage. So, I am curious as to hoe Victorian society saw drug usage and abuse, did they view it as an out right evil or was it accepted/tolerated?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

How would pre-time-keeping societies agree on a time to meet?

Furthermore, how would a sound sleeper not accidentally oversleep an important meeting?

2 Answers 2014-01-08

What are the most contrasting view-points about a single issue or subject that you have encountered from different historians?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

I am curious about Dennis Rodman and if he is in violation of any sort of American laws

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What are some instances where U.S federal courts were probably justified in overturning state law?

E.g. Jim Crow...

Edit: I'm not looking for anything really specific. Just a few examples of cases where federal courts overturned state laws they found to be discriminatory, just for my own information. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What language would King Leopold II of Belgium have spoken at home/to himself?

Belgium is split into Dutch (Flemish) speaking Flanders and French speaking Wallonia. The King was the cousin of Victoria and was- I assume- able to speak quite a few languages. So what language would he have spoken/thought in? Thanks

1 Answers 2014-01-08

What's New in History Wednesday

After a two-week holiday hiatus, we're back again! Last time went well, so let's see if we can keep that up. I know 2014 is still young, but what new discoveries and publications does it have for us already? Feel free to give the some love to the end of 2013 too if you have something else in mind that came up recently.

This series is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

1 Answers 2014-01-08

How did anti-submarine warfare work?

Was watching Das Boot last night and I realized I've never understood how depth charges are used. I know they use planes and such but how can they locate the position of a sub if it's gone silent?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Is there any evidence the Allied Forces experimented with human vivsection during WWII?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Children throughout history

1 Answers 2014-01-08

Is there evidence of population decline in the 3-4th century Roman Empire?

The demise of the Western Roman Empire is usually attributed to the inability of her armies to sufficiently repel the barbarian tribes from migrating due to a manpower shortage. However I have come across information that the empire, both the East and West, showed no population decline.

I got this information from, I believe, Professor Liebeschuetz (“The End of the Roman Army in the Western Empire” in Rich J., Shipley G., War and Society in the Roman World) and I'm asking AskHistorians if this is true?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

I'm a British deserter on the Western Front during WW1. While trying to escape the trenches I am discovered by American soldiers. What happens to me?

Do they turn me In or do they leave me be? What sort of jurisdiction did the allies have in treatment of each others' deserters?

1 Answers 2014-01-08

7228 / 7255

Back to start