Was there any precedent for the idea that Aeneas founded Rome or did Virgil just invent the concept wholesale?

I've been doing a lot of reading on Homeric myth and was struck by something. Plenty of Greek kings claimed descent from Greek heroes, such as Achille's son Neoptolemus. The myths explicitly tie the fate of these characters to the Greek cities they returned to or established. But those character already survived the Trojan War, so tying their fates into your history wouldn't be too hard. In the case of Aeneas, however, I was bit confused. There's not much reason to write about a guy escaping Troy unless you have a story to tell involving what happens next, and no one in Greece would've cared enough about Rome at the time to say that Aeneas founded it. So where did the ideas that Aeneas escaped Troy and eventually founded Rome come from? Did Virgil just make it all up or was it already somewhat established?

1 Answers 2021-03-27

Did the invention Hangul affect the pronunciation of spoken Korean?

I realize this might be a question for a language sub but thought I'd start here.

Non-Korean who speaks/reads a smattering. Korean homophones have always fascinated me: eg, according to my dictionary 무 ("mu") can mean 1) a radish, 2), military affairs, or 3) nothing. Although spelled the same way in Hangul and (to the best of my knowledge) pronounced the same way, they have distinct hanja.

Prior to the invention of Hangul, would these have been pronounced differently? Was there more variation to phonemes in Korean prior to the 15th century?

2 Answers 2021-03-27

Between 1959-90s much of Western Europe suffered domestic terrorism (e.g., the Troubles in UK/Ireland, Italian Years of Lead, Basque seperatists in Spain, RAF in West Germany). However, one notable exception appears to be France, which suffered international terrorism instead. Why the difference?

1 Answers 2021-03-27

After the end of WWII, did many black American troops stay in the UK instead of shipping home and if not why?

I apologize of the "why" is a bit leading, but given the differences of treatment between the two countries I'm kind of wondering if there was a specific reason.

1 Answers 2021-03-27

Did x- rays reveal a hidden epidemic of child abuse?

A story I heard in a documentary claimed that when x-rays became common doctors were puzzled by some children who had far more healed fractures than most. Sometimes dozens. After several years of searching for the medical condition that caused these kids to have fragile bones the doctors came to the sickening realization that there was no medical condition. Just abusive parents.

Is there truth to that story? Can anyone fill in more details?

1 Answers 2021-03-27

Did the British government make decisions on colonisation in the 18th century? Or the monarchy?

2 Answers 2021-03-27

Why did Germany so heavily utilize submarines (as opposed to surface ships) during WW1? Were the U-boats a deliberate strategy to more cheaply even the odds against the more powerful Royal Navy, or was there more to it that that?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Why is the Second Sino-Japanese war viewed as separate from World War 2?

Hello, historians. Pretty much what it says in the title. Why do we view the second Sino-Japanese War as a conflict separate from World War 2?
When I read history or discuss it with academics/historians/fanboys like me, I pretty much hear the same perspective - that the kick-off for WW2 was the invasion of Poland. Why not the Battle of Lugou Bridge? Or the Battle of Shanghai? Or even the invasion of Manchuria by Imperial Japan? The Second Sino-Japanese war precedes then runs concurrent with World War, has most of the same nations involved (Aside from Nazi Germany) and terminates with the same event.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

What was the Native American view of theft?

I remember hearing when I was young something about Native Americans not viewing theft as wrong unless caught. I understand that using the term Native American is extremely broad, but if you have any information on the topic or could refer me to some sources that talk about this, that would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

In "Life of Bryan" the jewish people talk of all the benefits that the Roman ls brought them. How true is this? Did being conquered by Rome actually improve the lives of the people they conquered?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

How did the British empire rise?

How did the British empire rise? I don’t understand with what they started. Maybe someone here can explain it to me

1 Answers 2021-03-26

How did people with disabilities duel in duels in a world that didn't always see them as lesser citizens?

Around the world, duels had different traditions. Sometimes it was sword fighting, sometimes it was taking a few paces back and firing rounds, and so on. So I imagine it would've been easy to see how a medical condition could complicate matters. It would be unfair, for example, if someone with a limp was challenged to a duel and it came time to walk ten paces in a certain direction. Were people with disabilities accommodated during the duel? And since duels were almost always between citizens of equal hierarchal standing and spoke for this equal standing, how did this issue always coming up, however often it did, not have a bearing on how people thought of people with medical conditions in relation to societal standing?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Native Americans were revolted by European people's smell.

I just learned from a Native influencer that the colonizing Europeans had poor hygiene and the Natives were appalled by it, and I found it interesting (and kinda funny to be honest. Edit: because the Natives would throw flowers and incense on the colonizers to mask their smell, which they thought it was the natives way of praising them.) And that's kinda funny to imagine.

I tried Googling this information and haven't found any texts that has the accounts of Native peoples (Aztecs or far Northern/Southern people) descriptions of the Europeans and would like a link to it.

I heard it was mainly the English and Spanish that had poor hygiene. Why?

Please correct me if I am wrong. Thanks.

2 Answers 2021-03-26

Average Viking Population per village?

Writing a book, wanna make a believeable population of a Viking age village in the Iceland - area

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Pregnancy and Alcohol in the Ancient/Medieval Times

We know that consuming alcohol while pregnant can lead to alcohol related birth defects. I have read that physicians in Ancient/Medieval times were somewhat aware of these effects, but why do we not hear of more cases attributed to alcohol related birth defects? Also, alcohol was still consumed by many pregnant woman during these times, why do we not have more accounts of child defects/abnormalities?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Who are the actual Nigerian princes? Did these positions and titles predate colonial rule or were they established by colonisers? How did their roles and status change under colonial rule and in postcolonial Nigeria? Is Nigeria unique in having princes or are there other equivalents in West Africa?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Could you help me locate a document

Hi,

I am new to this subreddit but I thought that you guys might be able to help me. I am taking History in University and I need help identifying a Primary Source.

I was doing research for my dissertation and I came across a report by Nehemiah Robinson labelled " The Twelve Nuremberg Trials and the Fate of the Defendants" in the Truman Library Online Archives. I contacted them regarding the document but they responded with that it was part of their student research files and that they don't have the original. Could you guys please help me locate who has the original so I can contact them?

Here is the link to the document from the Truman Library:

https://www.trumanlibrary.gov/library/research-files/report-nehemiah-robinson-twelve-nuremberg-trials-and-fate-defendants?documentid=NA&pagenumber=1

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Why did the Soviet Union not open a second front against Japan in WWII, especially after the Western Allies took pressure off of them post DDay?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

After the fall of Berlin in May 1945, what efforts did German nationalists make to try hold the country together as one political entity. What actions did they take to reunify East and West Germany in the north army years of both states existence.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Why is medieval Finland so heavily associated with magic? Are there any grounded explanations for why this is?

I was reading this post about Finnish Vikings and in the excellent reply was the line:

Sagas and Medieval Scandinavian sources (or even early modern sources describing Forest Finns in Sweden) are fairly consistent in describing Finns as 'other' people who are skilled in magic.

And so I started searching a bit, and found this source claiming that:

Already at the beginning of the early modern period (1500-1800), Finland was famous for her witches, and especially the great shamans in Lapland.

Where did this reputation of Finland come from? How could it be explained from a modern perspective?

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Early Ancient Greek Shields

The 'Argive' shield seems to dominate popular perceptions of Ancient Greek arms and armour when it comes to shields. However, the description of Agamemnon's shield (Iliad 11.32-37) mentions there being ten knobs of tin (Lattimore's translation, meaning shield bosses perhaps?) around the rim, while various other shields are described as being made of layers of hide, with a bronze facing. What evidence do we have from the late-Geometric period and the early to middle Archaic period of Greece of shields having bosses, whether that be archaeological finds or depictions on vases?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Is it feasible the Ages of Man concept from Hesiod inspired the Book of Daniel II and Nebuchadnezzar's dream?

Apologies if there's a better place for this.

I've gone down a bit of a rabbit hole and I noticed what seems to be a big parralel between the 5 Ages of Man presented by Hesiod in roughly 700 BC and the story of Nebuchadnezzar's dream in The Book of Daniel II. Both presenting ideas of successive developments in mankind from a "Golden Age" to Iron/Clay (with Daniel's interpretation ending with the collapse of the system represented by a statue of layered components to be replaced by the kingdom of heaven) .

Is there any direct connection to these ideas or did they grow independently of each other? If the Book of Daniel was a collection of Jewish Folklore that overlapped with the Hellenistic period, could these themes have been inspired from the Greek text?

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

Why did we stop sharing the same bed with our kin?

I heard that we used to sleep together in large wide beds. Families could stay together, young & old. Why did we stop?

We can still see the evolutionary tendency as children like to snug in a pile, feeling insecure in solitary. Might be an instinct carried over from our animalistic heritage. Could we them assume that our sleep might be better had we brought the tradition over to today? We only think it’s weird as we grew up differently today, but I think not had we been brought up in the past.

1 Answers 2021-03-26

During the Punic Wars, there were a lot of people in the Carthaginian side named Hamilcar and Hasdrubal that were not of relation to Hannibal’s family; the Italian side had a lot of different people named Scipio. Were there naming practices that lead to this abundance of the same names?

2 Answers 2021-03-26

Friday Free-for-All | March 26, 2021

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

4 Answers 2021-03-26

783 / 7255

Back to start