Why didn’t revolutionary or imperial France annex Switzerland?

It just seems weird to me that they didn’t because it’s inside the French “natural borders” eg. west of the Rhine and north of the alps, and they’re majority French speaking. Thanks for any insight.

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Did the scientific revolution in Europe happen thanks to or despite of Christianity?

I am interested in understanding the role Christianity had in the development of the scientific worldview.

I know that the Church, as an institution, often clashed with philosophers and scientists that advanced ideas that contradicted the dogma.

What I would like to know is the effect Christianity - as a set of belief people had about the world and their place in it - had on the development of the scientific approach.

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Galen said, "There is nothing better than playing with the small ball. This is the best exercise since it fatigues the whole body." What is the small ball, and how does one use it for exercise?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

In HBO’s Rome, a noble woman (Atia) is a single mother with control over her household, children and even extending patronage. Could women wield power like this publicly or behind the scenes?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How did East Asia become so developed compared to other asian countries?

How did South Korea, Japan, Singapore(majority chinese population), Taiwan, China and Hong Kong manage to become so successful despite being ravaged during WW2. What advantage did these countries have over their counterparts like India and the rest of SEA?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Was Dungeons and Dragons popular behind the Iron Curtain in countries like Poland, East Germany, and the Soviet Union? Or was it purely a Western phenomenon?

2 Answers 2021-02-15

How useful were the Ottomans in WW1?

Did they contribute to how long the war actually took? When they Surrendered, was it a serious blow to the Central Powers? Or were they merely a distraction to not focus too much on Germany

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Ian Fleming’s James Bond is often depicted wearing a Rolex, driving a Bentley (or Aston Martin) and drinking the finest drinks in the finest places. But in the 1950s and 1960s what would a secret agent’s wage actually be and would there be all the perks that James Bond enjoys?

I’m curious what a spy would have earned IRL during Fleming’s time and what the incentives of a job well done would have been and how far was Bond’s lifestyle from reality?

3 Answers 2021-02-15

It is a well known fact, that many of the American revolutionary leaders where Free Masons. Such as Washington, Jefferson, Franklin etc. However during the American Civil War, was there a significant Masonic presence in the leadership either the Union and/or Confederate leadership ?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

What happened to Jews that were serving in the German military when Hitler took power?

We've all heard stories of the occasional Wehrmacht soldier that happened to be jewish, yet for one reason or another was able to avoid becoming a victim of the Holocaust, whether by pure luck in hiding their identity, or due to some high ranking officer pulling strings to keep them safe. However, I've recently gotten curious as to just how far this went.

So, my questions are, what happened to Jews and other people classed as "undesirable" by the Nazi regime that were serving in the Wehrmacht before and during WW2? Were officers treated any differently from the rank and file? And what about those in specialist roles, such as surgeons and engineers?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How many pitched battles/campaigns/sieges would an average soldier see in their career in different time periods?

So I just watched https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAYsVjKd5yY, where it was mentioned in passing that a 55-year veteran of the 100 years war only saw 3 pitched battles in his entire career. This struck me as a little surprising, since I could easily imagine that a single campaign would involve multiple pitched battles, to say nothing of the long skirmishes, sieges, and harassment of enemy/local forces that would be 90% of the time spent campaigning.

So here's a long multi-part question, specifically regarding around late 1100s to late 1400s:

  1. How exactly do you define a pitched battle? What draws the line between pitched battle and a skirmish?
  2. How many would campaigns an average men-at-arms/semi-professional soldier be called upon in their career?
  3. How many pitched battles, sieges, skirmishes, etc each would a campaign consist of?
  4. How did all of the above vary across region and time, and war? I would imagine most conflicts were mostly 'lets gather a few thousand men and loot some towns/villages', but a long campaign to reclaim Jerusalem or later when the Italian wars rolled around seems very different to me.

Bonus: all roads lead to Rome, so how many battles would a professional soldier of ~200 AD Rome see in their career?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Wheat - When and how did it change and is it lost forever?

I keep hearing about how wheat actually became the glutenous "evil" version of itself around the 1970s, when we had the great - but obviously not very well thought out - idea to "feed the world" by changing the wheat to a GMO version, so that it grew quicker. And now everyone is getting sick from eating it.

Now, there's a lot of hype about "ancient grains" and all that jazz. But I'm wondering if it's possible to just go back a little way in time and eat the wheat our Grandparents ate. I have wonderful memories of bread and jam and baked goods and my Grandparents lived well into their 80s. I'd be happy with that!

But I can't seem to find anywhere, exactly what changed in wheat in the 1970s. I'm guessing they changed the number of chromosomes?? But more importantly, what was the strain of wheat before then called and where can I get it from now? If we managed to save Einkorn and Farro, hopefully somebody had the sense to preserve some of the 1960s stuff too?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Military Aviation History: Did pilots ever use “Open Comms” like Guard to talk to/ taunt Enemies? (Fact checking)

Hello all this might seem like a silly question, but I wanted to confirm a story I heard back in the day via an image post. I’ve lost the screen cap, but paraphrasing the story went as such:

A group of pilots during a long stay conflict over an area (I think they were guarding bomber runs?) would run into the same group of enemy pilots. The story said that they would talk/ taunt the enemy over the radio and would get it the same back and forth. Apparently, it got so bad that they had to send someone to monitor the radio on the runs to make sure their pilots weren’t doing this, which led to the pilots communicating through hand gestures.

Now, obviously this story is not only vague, but also from the internet so it is most likely fake or the details are blown out of proportion (though if anyone knows the story and could confirm or deny it that would be cool.). What I will ask though is if there have been cases of pilots communicating with the enemy during combat. I read when short wave radio was still being introduced into planes it was possible to intercept and talk over channels, which was used to give bad info or scramble messages. So it would be interesting if anyone knew of stories, old or new, where pilots talked to each other while in combat.

I look forward to your responses, though in all likelihood the answer is no. Thanks everyone!

1 Answers 2021-02-15

What was going on in the Khanate of Khiva from 1917 to 1920?

Before the 1917, the Khanate of Khiva, along with the Emirate of Bukhara, was a protectorate of the Russian empire. By 1920, these became the Khorezm People’s Soviet Republic and the Bukharan People’s Soviet Republic. I’ve read a little bit about this era in Bukhara, but I haven’t been able to find much information in English about Khiva. So just what was going on in Khiva in the years after the Russian Revolution?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How would a Muslim couple in the levant marry during the era of the Crusades

What sort of arrangement would have to be made with family or religious authorities.

1 Answers 2021-02-15

The fact that there is a long tradition of white Americans claiming real or imagined Native American ancestry suggests that there was no "one-drop" rule for Native American ancestry, unlike in the case of African ancestry. Why did this difference exist?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How big were sumerian armies? And were they capable of actually conquering cities or did they just fight outside the walls?

For what I know, sumerians were mostly city states that were loosely ruled by a stronger city state, Uruk, for example. But what I don't know is if the stronger city states had the manpower and weapons to conquer another city. I read somewhere that the sumerians had around 500 professional soldiers in a city with 30000 people and that in cases of total war the number of conscripts could be around 3000. How accurate it that and how could try use this troops to conquer?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How did infantry front lines were convinced in ancient wars to be put in a position that pretty much means certain death?

As far as I know, front lines in wars were almost always decimated, with cavalry charges and archers pointing at them first, so, how were the soldiers convinced to be put on that position, even when knowing that certain death is coming? They have the option to refuse?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

Did the German SS and death squad units have chaplains? How did those men deal with being counselors for these units?

1 Answers 2021-02-15

How much knowledge was actually lost in the Mongolian siege of Baghdad and the destruction of the many libraries and House of Wisdom in 1258?

This question was influenced by this meme which makes a pretty dubious sounding claim.

1 Answers 2021-02-15

England controlled territory in France until the 16th century. How "English" did places like Calais become by the Tudor period?

England has maintained some territories in France since the Angevin Empire, finally losing Calais in 1558. Obviously they would have been "French" at the beginning (especially as the English court was essentially French as well), but by the Tudors we have English spoken at court and in parliament. Did commoners in Calais learn English or was it just a ruling-class thing?

1 Answers 2021-02-14

How did the richest part of India and China compare with Britain and Netherlands just before the colonization?

I have seen answers here countering the claim of both Indian/china having around 20-25% of the world gdp as the results of their population and that Western Europe may have had higher gdp per capita even before colonization.

However, I think it is unfair to compare India/china to specific rich countries of europe. I am wondering whether this is true when comparing richest part of the Asia with the western europe. Is there any gdp per capita comparison between let's say Bengal/Carnatic states/Yellow/Pearl river Delta and Jingjinji with Britain/Netherlands before colonization?

Essentially, I would like to know if the great divergence in gdp per capita between the east and the west happened before Asian Colonization or after it.

1 Answers 2021-02-14

What was the nature of hides and land tenure in Anglo-Saxon England?

The Geþyncðo states that "...if a ceorl prospered, that he possessed fully five hides of land of his own [7] a bell and a castle-gate, a seat and special office in the king's hall, then was he henceforth entitled to the rights of a thegn."

This made me question just how many ceorls possessed any number of hides at all. How exactly was it possible for hides to be representative of enough land to sustain a household if there were people who were landless and worked on the manor of a thegn or other landed noble?

Additionally, with the land tenures of folcland, lænland, and bocland, would they have been applied to individual hides or have nothing to do with them at all? If it's the former, how would any king draw out new estates to be acquired without displacing the people living on folcland or confiscating lænland/bocland?

I'm assuming the landed nobility must have held their estates as bocland, but who did they acquire these lands from unless folcland was converted by way of a royal charter granting ownership?

1 Answers 2021-02-14

Anne Frank mentioned in her diary she listened often the BBC on her family radio. The Netherlands was occupied by Germany during WWII, how did the signal arrived all the way to the annex? Did the BBC set up clandestine stations?

1 Answers 2021-02-14

Did Europeans in the middle ages know about animals from other continents?

If they saw an elephant, a giraffe or a monkey, would it be something completely alien or would they have known about the existence of such creatures and already knew their names?

1 Answers 2021-02-14

849 / 7255

Back to start