How much was Teddy Roosevelt exaggerating when he claimed the US had freed Cuba and the Philippines, asking in return "nothing whatever save that at no time shall their independence be prostituted to the advantage of some foreign rival of ours." ?

In this speech, Roosevelt claims:

  • "...never in recent times has any great nation acted with such disinterestedness as we have shown in Cuba. We freed the island from the Spanish yoke. We then earnestly did our best to help the Cubans in the establishment of free education, of law and order, of material prosperity, of the cleanliness necessary to salutary well-being in their great cities. We did all this at great expense of treasure, at some expense of life, and now we are establishing them in a free and independent commonwealth, and have asked in return nothing whatever save that at no time shall their independence be prostituted to the advantage of some foreign rival of ours, or so as to menace our well-being."
  • "In the Philippines we have brought peace, and we are at this moment giving them such freedom and self-government as they could never under any conceivable conditions have obtained had we turned them loose to sink into a welter of blood, and confusion, or to become the prey of some strong tyranny without or within."
  • "The Tagalogs have a hundred-fold the freedom under us that they would have if we had abandoned the islands."

How much freedom and self-government did the US allow Cuba and the Philippines to have?

Was the US really getting nothing from the deal but the assurance that rivals would not occupy these newly-liberated islands?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Why didn’t English develop gendered words for ‘cousin’?

Please let me know if there’s a better linguistics sub that this belongs in!

Seeing someone use the term ‘nibling’ as a gender-neutral term for a sibling’s child got me thinking.

In English, we have both gender-specific and gender-neutral terms for immediate family members. Mother/father/parent (+grand), sister/brother/sibling. The gender-neutral and multiple version isn’t related to the masculine term, as it is in a lot of Romance languages (like padre - padres).

For non-immediate family, there’s usually only gender-specific - aunt, uncle, niece, nephew - for both singular and multiple. We don’t have a word that encompasses all of my aunts and uncles at once, for example. The exception seems to be cousin, which doesn’t have gendered options. Is there a linguistic basis for this? How did the English versions of these words/concepts develop, and why don’t we have separate terms for male and female cousins?

3 Answers 2022-10-16

Did W. European thinkers/scholars know the identity of famous Islamic Scholars?

Sorry if it is a silly question but I cannot seem to find a simple yes/no answer. Did famous thinkers in late medieval Europe know the real identities of thinkers from the Islamic World such as Averroes (Ibn Rushd) or Avicenna (Ibn Sina)?

It seems like their ideas were popular, and debated, but did say students at Paris University in the 1400s know the two aforementioned thinkers were Muslims? Or from Asia/Africa? Or did they think they were from somewhere else? Thank you

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | October 16, 2022

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2022-10-16

How did aristocratic Ancient Romans treat bastard children?

I was wondering what happened to the illegitimate children of powerful Roman senators, generals etc, especially those with enslaved mothers. What sort of social status and life prospects might they have had?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Up until Norway split from Denmark in 1814 were Norwegians considered to be Danes? Was it just a region like Jutland or was there a percieved otherness to them?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

What happened to weapons and armor (and remains) of fallen medieval soldiers?

I feel this gets rarely mentioned, but a big battle happens, lots of people die, the winning army marches on, but what happens to the remains of the battlefield? Were the losing soldiers scavenged, buried and/or burned? Was it done by members of the army or "locals". Are there records of big losses having a noticeable impact on the metal economy of a region (based on my knowledge, getting iron/steel required a lot of work). If the answer is too complicated long, I'd be happy to get pointers to more detailed sources.

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Was the attitude displayed towards oral sex by both Bill Clinton during the Lewinsky hearings and the character Veronica in the film Clerks (1994) typical for the culture of that time?

In the film Clerks (1994)Dante and his girlfriend have a fight about sexual partners.

She says she has only had 3 while it later comes out that she has had oral sex with 37. She maintains that oral sex is only "fooling around" and not actual sex.

During the hearings about the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal in 1998 Bill Clinton famously denied having a sexual relationship with Monica Lewinsky. When it came out that they had oral sex on multiple occasions he also defended it by saying oral sex is not sex, just "fooling around".

Was this a common cultural attitude at the time?

3 Answers 2022-10-16

In modern times, there have been a number of famous football stadium disasters. Were there any Collosseum or Amphitheatre or racetrack disasters?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Eric Hobsbawm wrote in one of his books, "In 1789 50% of the French people did not speak [French] at all, and only 12 to 13% spoke it 'fairly'". What languages did these people speak, and was the same true in other European nation-states (e.g, Sweden, England, Spain, etc?)

2 Answers 2022-10-16

US Civil War: I’m watching Ken Burn’s doc and it mentioned that the CSA Constitution prohibited international slave trade. Assuming that’s true; why would the CSA do that? Just to protect their own business?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Are there examples of royals wearing elaborate masks to hide their disfigurement?

I’ve been watching House of the Dragon, where there’s a sickly royal who dons a golden mask that covers half his face, to hide a disfigurement. It reminded me of Edward Norton as King Baldwin in the movie Kingdom Of Heaven, who wears an elaborate full face mask to hide signs of leprosy.

I couldn’t find any examples of real historical masks with a Google search. Do we know if this is something rulers have done in the past? Are there any surviving examples or depictions?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Historically, what has been the process for explaining that Santa Claus isn’t real to children?

His legend has been around a long time. Although he’s changed overtime the core belief’s purpose and end goal is for year end reward. Was there ever a process for breaking the bad news to children. Asking as a parent.

1 Answers 2022-10-16

When was Alaska first discovered and explored?

I've seen a few different references to discovery in the early 18th century. It's strange to me that the seemingly small ocean gap between the old world and Alaska didn't allow for an earlier discovery of the Americas. I'd appreciate any insight into the topic!

1 Answers 2022-10-16

What did the Eastern Romans think of their own history?

Suppose I were a child of Byzantine nobility, and I was being educated sometime around the year 1000 CE. Suppose I asked my tutors things like “Who are we? How did we get here? Why have we lost so much territory? Will we ever recover the far-off regions of Gaul or the Exarchate of Carthage?”

What would I be told about what happened to the Western Roman Empire? Presumably I would learn about Trajan. I would learn that he spoke Latin, but my own emperor Basil II, and the rest of my peoples, are speaking Greek. How would that transition be explained? For that matter, would I be taught that Basil II was somehow “in the same line” as Trajan and the others from those long distant days of the old Roman Empire?

If I asked my tutors, “But why was Britannia (to name just one example) lost to the Empire? What was the reason for it?”, how would they answer?

I’ve read that the Byzantines never called themselves that. As far as they were concerned, they were Romans, and no less true Romans as their ancestors. But surely they must have known that something had changed. How did they conceptualize their own transition from what they once were to what they are now (meaning, in my example, the people of Constantinople in 1000 CE)?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

In 1990, Alaskans elected a pro-independence governor. What happened in that period that made voters choose a third-party, pro-independence candidate?

So I was doing a wiki walk after reading this news article: 2 Russians who reached Alaska’s St. Lawrence Island were trying to avoid military service, Murkowski’s office says

From my wiki walk, I found out that in 1990, Alaska elected Wally Hickel as governor, breaking the 2 party system, as he was with Alaska Independence Party. This same Wally Hickel previously served as Alaska's governor from 1966-1969, and was supported Alaskan statehood in his earlier career.

What happened in the run-up to the 1990 election to make Alaska elect a pro-independence governor? What happened to make Wally Hickel change from being pro-statehood to pro-independence?

1 Answers 2022-10-16

Did a lot of Europeans die from Native American diseases?

Context: I know lots of American Natives died due to diseases brought from Europe but I don’t think I’ve ever heard of Europeans dying from diseases of the Americas. Question: Was there a lot of European deaths caused by diseases native to the Americas? If not, can somebody explain why lots of American natives died and not as many Europeans? Wouldn’t both continents have equally diverse diseases?

1 Answers 2022-10-15

In Ancient Egypt, there were different "cult centers" that focused their worship on specific gods or families of them. Did these cult centers ever go to war over disagreements? Did most fellow Egyptians not question each other's beliefs, or did they have theological discussions?

In interested in if there was ever conflict, both between individuals of the same city/cult center and the centers themselves with other towns.

1 Answers 2022-10-15

Why was Maine a part of Massachusetts?

I recently learned that Maine used to be a part of Massachusetts from ~1650 to 1820, but I can't find anything that says why Maine was a part of Massachusetts.

1 Answers 2022-10-15

Ireland had a huge population in 1821 relative to its size — 6.8 million. Egypt only had only 4.3 million. Scotland: 2.1 million. Austria 3.1 million. USA 9.1 million. Mexico: 6.5 million. Why was Ireland so populous? Did it come down to early adoption of the potato?

4 Answers 2022-10-15

Did South African Units in WWII Utilize Black Soldiers in any Capacity?

I was looking at a map of El Alamein the other day and I saw that there was a contingent of South Africans in the British 8th Army. I'm familiar with how the United States army was not at the time integrated, but black American soldiers served in segregated battalions.

Did any black South African troops serve in World War Two? And if they did to what degree were they attached to the white South African troops?

1 Answers 2022-10-15

When and why did folding a letter in on itself and sealing it shut become replaced with using a separate envelope?

1 Answers 2022-10-15

META: Mods of this subreddit have you ever had to debunk of a conspiracy theory? If so when and how?

2 Answers 2022-10-15

How is it that Ancient Egyptian society and culture didn’t survive in Egypt?

Almost all large societies go through periods where they are conquered by invaders, the Persians suffered many conquests by the Arabs and Turks yet Persian society always survived and the conquerers would assimilate to Persian culture. The same applies to China, India, and more. When the Kush conquered Egypt, they assimilated to Egyptian culture, why didn’t this apply later on, and why is Ancient Egyptian culture extinct?

1 Answers 2022-10-15

why didn't people discovered America from Kamchatka? this might sound dumb but kamchatka and alaska are reaaly near, how nobody discovered America from there?

2 Answers 2022-10-15

87 / 7255

Back to start