Did the Egyptians just live amongst all these pyramids, tombs, and artefacts - taking no notice of them until the arrival of the first western archaeologists?

Or did they conduct their own discovery’s that we just never hear about?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

For experts in early to mid-19th century US history: What was this building and what are these objects?

Recently I came across the stone and brick ruins of a structure in the woods, buried under some brush, in the DC suburbs. The area used to be farmland. I found some old 19th century rectangular nails so I reckon the structure is originally quite old though it was probably used through the mid-20th century. Am very curious about its one-time purpose and its origin. Maybe these items, located nearby, are clues as to what it was. PHOTO HERE: https://imgur.com/a/XiIdDFs A tenant house? A blacksmith shop? Some other thing I don't even know about?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

The Republic and Make-Up

In the Desmond Lee translation of Plato’s Republic, section 373b/c, women’s dress and make-up is given as one of the elements of a more ‘luxurious’ society, the exact quote is as follows:

“there will be manufacturers of domestic equipment of all sorts, especially women’s dress and make-up”

My question is, how accurate a translation is ‘women’s dress and make-up’, i.e, were these concepts particularly ubiquitous in Ancient Greece and, if so how did that relate to the position of a woman in an Ancient Grecian society?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

“Fly five to stay alive” source?

I remember reading somewhere that new fighter pilots were given the advice to “Fly five and stay alive”, as in fly five sorties to gain experience and situational awareness in dogfighting. Am I imagining things or is this somewhere?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

What exactly were the differences between the Wehrmacht and the Waffen-SS?

I know the Wehrmacht was the Nazi German army, but I've read some books that refer to the SS as a "paramilitary group." Were they not actually officially sanctioned? What was the organization exactly?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Gender disparities after WW2

During WW2 a lot of men died during battle leaving behind a distorted sex ratio. What were the consequences of that? Did many women die having never married? Were there any sort of human trafficking crises, similar to recent trafficking of North Korean women to become wives of Chinese men, as a consequence of a distorted sex ratio due to the one child policy?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Is it just a coincidence that the US, UK, and France have the same colors on their flags?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

How much of the argument "Western powers have good economics just because of Imperialism and Slavery" true?

I'm hearing this by a lot in the internet from non-western country users. For example in Turkey we can't compare ourselves to Europe or US because they did a lot of imperialism.

I cannot accept this argument because of Germany or Scandinavian countries. Germany literaly lost 2 WORLD wars and Scandivian countries weren't the part of imperialism and were mostly neutral.

So what do you think about this?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Historians that have added history to video games, movies, and books, how do you decide how to fit historic elements together and with the plot?

I apologize if this question doesn't belong in this sub but I wanted to know how historians contribute to and perceive games like Assasins Creed, which often uses history to add to the story. I've heard people say they look at historic information in movies and video games as a way to get interested in the history, not to learn it because movies and TV shows are obviously going to take some liberties for the sake of plot and action. Also, is it concerning if a setting is mixed and matched from different moments in history. Say if a king was made to represent a Chinese emperor who has knights, alchemists, and Native Americans serving under him, would this be too jumbled up to tell history in a meaningful way?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

SS and the Wehrmacht

What was the relationship between the SS and the Wehrmacht like? Were there ever any major feuds between the 2 groups?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Patrick O'Daire joined the IRA in the Irish War for Independence, but went on to join the British Army to fight in WWII. How much precedent was there for former enemy combatants to join the British Army?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

According to some sources, the West Saxon army circa 786 consisted of no more than a few hundred at most, and many other (small) anglosaxon kingdoms had the same numbers. Is this true? How did this change so much in a hundred years?

What I meant with the second question is a comparison with the late IX c. armies.

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Saturday Showcase | November 21, 2020

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2020-11-21

What did the Chinese think was to the North? And why didn't they explore there more?

It seems logical that any Chinese explorer could've sailed east around Siberia, through the Bering Sea, and into North America. I am aware that there are plenty of theories about Chinese explorers discovering North America, but from what I could gather from the websites I could find, these seem to be based on scant rather than the wealth of evidence that one might expect to find.
So, this bears the question: What did the Chinese think lied to the North? Why didn't the Chinese just sail north and find the Americas? And if they did, why didn't they do more with that new continent like the Europeans did?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Why did Christianity rise and expanded so rapidly?

I’m just curious why, Romans having all of this groundbreaking schools of thought (Hellenistic and Platonic/Aristotelian philosophies) decided was a good a idea to ditch all of this and basically convert to a new way of thinking? All of a Sudden accepting a monotheist religion, what was the success factor for Christianity?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Why was there a 'Bronze Age' at all? Why didn't people just use Iron extensively from the start?

I have heard that Bronze is actually pretty difficult to create, since it require a lot of Tin in addition to Copper, and since Tin is fairly rare that control on supply of Tin could be a life or death issue for Bronze age states. I've even heard that the extensive use of Iron in the first place was because of the major disruptions in the Tin trade around the time of the Bronze age collapse, being more of a last resort since Bronze was nearly impossible to manufacture in large amounts.

And yet Iron quickly seemed to establish itself as by far the most useful metal, being more robust and much more common than Bronze, some areas of the world never even really had a Bronze age, going straight to iron, notably Sub-Saharan Africa.

So, why was there a Bronze age to begin with? Why didn't people learn to work Iron earlier? It seems like it has less issues than Bronze, especially in terms of availability.

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Why did the black death seemingly not impact the subsequent societies of China?

I am not a historian, but it is my impression that there is a consensus among Historians that The Black Death significantly impacted European history in several different areas (Wiki-page).

I am now 6 months into my journey where I am trying to get an overview of Asian history. My main sources have been The Great Courses Plus, where I have watched/listened to “Foundations of Eastern Civilization”(48 lectures) and “Understanding Imperial China”(24 lectures). The black death is only mentioned in brief, but it sounds like the losses were at least comparable to those seen in Europe. For example, on the Wiki page Consequences of the Black Death, it says,

“The most severe outbreak of plague, in the Chinese province of Hubei in 1334, claimed up to 80 percent of the population.[citation needed] China had several epidemics and famines from 1200 to the 1350s, and its population decreased from an estimated 125 million to 65 million in the late 14th century.”

However, the following discussion of the effects of the black death is only focused on Europe, and in the courses I have followed there is literally no discussion of how the black death impacted the Chinese society.

I am left with the impression that many people died in China, but that things pretty much just continued as usual after that. Is this wrong? Was Chinese society just used to massive disease outbreaks? Am I European-centered when I expect to see something similar to Europe when I read Chinese history?

I wonder if all the changes seen in the period are just attributed to the Yuan dynasty and its fall, and just fail to recognize the impact of the Black Death (again, I am not a historian, just speculating)?

I hope you can help.

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Sengoku Jidai: What was the actual class structure during this period?

I'm prepping research for a TTRPG set in the Sengoku Jidai. I was wondering whether the books I've been using for research are accurate? One of the research books (Sengoku Revised Edition, 2002) says it goes like this (in descending order):

  1. Imperial Kuge - Emperor (Emperor, Imperial Family)
  2. Kuge - Court Aristocracy (Relatives of Imperial Family, Court Nobles, Courtiers)
  3. Buke - Military Aristocracy (Shogun, Daimyo, Hatamoto, Samurai, Ashigaru, Jizamurai, Ronin)
  4. Bonge - Commoners (Farmers, Artisans, Entertainers, Merchants)
  5. Hinin - Non-Persons (Criminals, Entertainers, etc.)

Is this accurate enough to represent the social class? For the paragraphs, is it accurate that it works in descending order if you go from left to right too?

Another book (GURPS Japan 2E, 1999) doesn't exactly have a straightforward structure like the above, but from my reading, I think it suggests it goes like this:

  1. Emperor & Imperial Court
  2. Bushi (and below) - Shogun (who puppeteers the Emperor)
  3. Imperial Court
  4. Daimyo
  5. Samurai
  6. Heimin (Farmers, Artisans, Merchants)
  7. Hinin (Beggars, gamblers, entertainers, sorcerers, etc.)

Is this accurate as well?

A video on Youtube suggests that the structure goes like this:

  1. Emperor, Imperial Court
  2. Shogun, Shugo, Samurai, Ronin
  3. Ashigaru, Farmers/Fishermen, Artisans, Merchants
  4. Non-Persons

Is this accurate? Some comments suggest that there was a mistake in the video, but I'm not too sure. What was the theoretical and actual structure they followed during the period? Any book recommendations would be great as well!

Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-11-21

I've heard some activisits claim that the spiritual connotations of the colour white being pure and Godly and the colour black being evil and satanic being birthed from racism. Did native African, American, or Aboriginal religions share this white purity concept or was it in reverse?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

Did China ever have slavery?

And who were the slaves

3 Answers 2020-11-21

How did the Republican party become strong in the south and representative of white elites

After the Civil War and Reconstruction black voters became a majority in the south and of course at that time voted for Republicans. Then white Democrats created all kinds of obstacles to their voting to keep the south white and Democratic and it stayed that way for almost a century

At which point did the image and core values of these two American parties not only change but practically flip? It is especially interesting that apparently white racist southerners heavily refer to the Civil War times while strongly siding with the Republican party, when actually back then they were represented by the Democrats

1 Answers 2020-11-21

What was the actual poetic form of the Epic of Gilgamesh?

As in does it use a qualitative or quantitative metre, and does it include any rhyme/alliteration/something else with a similar role? I’ve been fascinated with its narrative and characterization ever since I first read an English translation forever ago, but it somehow never even occurred to me until right now to wonder about its specifically poetic qualities.

3 Answers 2020-11-21

How Can A Young Medieval Historian Improve Her Palaeography Skills?

Hello everyone, hope you are enjoying the weekend. I've just finished my undergraduate degree in modern history at an Australian university. But in one of my subjects, (which I didn't do well in) I really struggled with paleography.

It was an ancient history elective in 'ancient magic.' The course involved looking at papyri from Egypt and distinguishing it from other papyri. I struggled. I don't understand Coptic or Ancient Greek, and all the writing looked so alike.

During my degree, I developed a strong interest in the Middle Ages, particularly in Western Europe. Unfortunately, my university didn't offer many medieval courses (although I did take one in medievalism, which I did well in). I'd love to do a Masters degree in either medieval studies or history, hopefully in the United Kingdom (a university like York would be terrific).

But I'm concerned that due to my poor performance in the ancient history subject, that I'll flunk the compulsory course on palaeography. Which is why I'm asking for advice on how inexperienced history students can build up skills in medieval palaeography*.

I'm learning Latin, so maybe that'll help. If anyone has any book recommendations, or ideas about approaching medieval palaeography, please share. Because I feel lost, and yet my passion for medieval history remains strong. Also, if anyone has tips on studying medieval history at a postgraduate level in general, please share.

*Of course, there's a difference between ancient Egyptian palaeography and medieval Western Europe texts. I'm aiming to apply in the 2022/2023 academic year in the UK.

Thank you.

2 Answers 2020-11-21

What languages were spoken in Al Andalus? Let's say around 1000 ad.

Old portuguese/galego were spoken in the northwestern part of the península, as they were conquering down the península what languages would they have encontoured? latim based ones and arabic based ones? beber ones? others? And were the languages separated by geography or by peoples? So moors would speak something, christians another and jews a different one for example.

1 Answers 2020-11-21

D-Day tanks

Why did the US design an amphibious Sherman when they already had the LVT and its tank models?

1 Answers 2020-11-21

993 / 7255

Back to start