At the beginning of the war, which was the initial plan (before Franco became Generalísimo) of the nationalists for Spain after they defeated the Republic? Did they wanted to restore the monarchy, transform the republic or begin another dictatorship?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
Hello r/AskHistorians! You may already know me on here as someone who answers the occasional question about George Orwell, or the author of numerous over-enthusiastic posts about the recent AskHistorians Digital Conference. During the day, however, I'm a historian of 1930s Europe - more particularly, of the ways in which people responded to the Spanish Civil War of 1936-9.
What has always fascinated me about this conflict - and hopefully interests you as well! - is that what might otherwise have been a minor civil war in a fairly unimportant European state became a crucial battlefield in a much wider confrontation between fascism and anti-fascism. Spain swiftly became a global phenomenon, inspiring and horrifying people all around the world. Many were moved to respond and take matters into their own hands - by becoming political activists, by collecting money, food and medicine, and by volunteering to join the fight themselves, in completely unprecedented numbers.
Exploring the motives, organisation and experiences of participants in these movements has been the subject of my research for just about a decade now, and I welcome any questions you might have! I'll also do my best to address any broader questions about the Spanish Civil War and the wider ideological conflict between fascists and anti-fascists during the 1930s.
For anyone interested in learning more about my particular research in more depth, I'm currently running a competition on Twitter to give away a copy of my recently-published book that focuses on Scottish responses to the civil war! You can also buy a copy direct from the publisher using the discount code NEW30 to get 30% off, if you wisely don't like trusting to luck when it comes to important matters like acquiring new books.
That's enough from me - go ahead and Ask Me Anything!
EDIT: I need to step away to a meeting for 45 minutes, but will be back and will have plenty of time this evening to keep answering! So many really excellent questions already, thanks to everyone who has posted!
EDIT 2: I'm back and doing my best to catch up! I'm a bit blown away by the response so far, and am doing my best to work through and give decent answers. On a slightly personal note - the meeting I mentioned above was a job interview, which I was just offered, so the good vibes in here is the cherry on the cake of an awesome day!
EDIT 3: I think this is roughly what a zombie apocalypse feels like - you shoot off a careful, well-aimed answer to the head, and there are two more new ones waiting to be dealt with. I will at some point need to sleep, but I'll do my best to keep answering over the weekend - thanks to everyone who has taken the time to ask questions!
187 Answers 2020-11-20
I mean, the Europeans were coming from far away, buying people in bulk, and then sailing away with them, never to be seen again. Did they know that the people being sold were being sent to the Americas? What did they think the Europeans were doing with all those people?
2 Answers 2020-11-20
Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
4 Answers 2020-11-20
I was looking through a few old threads and it seems that sengoku era armies had a pretty low number of archers, even before muskets became wide spread.
Why is that? Were sengoku era archers not effective the way english longbows were?
I know that samurai were mounted archers, but it seems that sengoku era armies never had large amounts of foot archers the way other cultures did, it was mostly spearmen. And it seems that at some point, sengoku era cavalry started to switch to the spear for charges instead of mounted archery (I think Takeda Shingen popularized that?).
1 Answers 2020-11-20
Jamestown was settled in 1607 I think. I know they were there for gold, but by 1609-1610 they'd been there for 2 or 3 winters. Why did they not prepare for winter; why rely on trade with the (less than friendly) locals after several years of settlement? Surely it was realised at the time that it was an unsustainable way to survive.
1 Answers 2020-11-20
When I was a young child growing up in the late '70s and early '80s, the elementary-equivalent school I attended (built in the 1950s) was spacious, with detached classrooms, large playing fields, and no internal hallways. There was a strong emphasis on outdoor learning: we had classes outside on the grass and a great deal of emphasis on being outside whenever possible.
To what extent (if any) did the principles of that mode of education bear the scars, or reflect the lessons, of the worldwide polio epidemic before there was a vaccine? Did school architects and education departments and administrators take polio into account when they designed new buildings? If so, when did those kinds of lessons start to fade from public consciousness?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
There is a sudden shift in portrayal in many of these famous fairy tales.
The Disney versions are more fairy-like, colourful and optimistic and child-like, but the originals are often more cruel or even heartbreaking, especially that these stories were meant to have moral themes for the children who were reading them.
Like in the Little Mermaid, the mermaid commits suicide, or in Pinocchio, it was originally intended to end with Pinocchio being hanged for his misbehaviours, or unlike in the Jungle Book, Mowgli kills the tiger and even becomes ostracized by the nearby village and destroys it entirely out of revenge, or Sleeping Beauty was actually raped and impregnated by a monarch while she was sleeping.
Lots of famous fairy tales have this same theme, even the Grimms brothers ones which sounds like unfairy-like.
So how come these original versions where more gruesome even though they were intended to be made for children?
How did these stories shift to a more light-hearted setting as time progressed?
2 Answers 2020-11-20
1 Answers 2020-11-20
I read a post elsewhere on Reddit where some of the comments asserted that, at the start of the war, the Confederacy had a significant advantage in the quality of its generals. Allegedly, all of the West Point graduates with experience commanding infantry sided with the Confederates, leaving the Union with officers who knew logistics and supply lines rather than how to command troops on a tactical level.
Is this a fair assessment of the relative capabilities of the generals on both sides of the Civil War at its outset?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
I'm currently watching "The Plot Against America" which posits a counterfactual world where Charles Lindbergh ran against FDR in the 1940 election.
It seems plausible that Charles Lindbergh would have sought the nomination that year, but why didn't he?
Please also note that I have read "The American Axis: Henry Ford, Charles Lindbergh, and the Rise of the Third Reich" by Max Wallace some time ago. Perhaps I am forgetting some crucial argument!
1 Answers 2020-11-20
Many Japanese had settled in occupied parts of China, Korea, and Taiwan. What happened to them after Japan surrendered? Did most stay on and integrate into society or were they kicked out/flee?
As a bonus, many what happened to the wives and children of Japanese soldiers in these 3 countries?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
I'm really big on geography and climate. San Diego, southern city in California, is at the start of a much more arid and dry climate as you go south from Santa Barbara, LA, etc.
The border is based on where the Spanish had Baja and Alta California before the U.S. took control, right?
Specifically, I want to know: Why is this where the border was declared? On a slope (not directly E-W), and did the climates have something to do with it (did Alta California have the 'better' weather in a sense)
Thanks!
1 Answers 2020-11-20
Were English children from military families born in India in the 19 century sent to England for an education?
2 Answers 2020-11-20
Sorry if this has been asked before, but I just finished watching a fascinating documentary by Lucy Worsley, If Walls Could Talk- The History of the Home, all about bathrooms throughout the ages.
In it, she mentions that contrary to popular belief, medieval people bathed quite regularly in public bathhouses.
My question is, if people were indeed keeping themselves quite clean, why do historians say the plague spread because of lack of hygiene. Was it because the bathhouses were public places, because of a lack of hygiene at home, or simply a result of overcrowding?
Looking forward to hearing some answers and I'm sorry if this seems like a silly question. Thank you!
1 Answers 2020-11-20
hello I’ve been having issues understanding the Republican and Democratic flip of the 1960s and 70s and maybe late 50s. i’m trying to wrap my head around the main reason why Democrats and Republicans flipped. like I’m not sure what changed about each party including economic policy and racial policy, thank you
1 Answers 2020-11-20
Africa was exploited by European nations for it's vast natural resources, but as far as I can tell Europeans did not move to Africa and settle there like they did in the America's. Why is this?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
How did the Americans, Canadians, Australians, etc view the indigenous populations? Were their views similar, or different? Did they view them as just a nuisance? As sub-human, or just uncivilised? Would they feel any remorse or pity for them? Did their opinions change over time, though the various generations, or did they stay the same? What were their different policies for dealing with them?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
In this lecture, Iván Szelényi claimed that
Before Marx, you went into a museum and the museum was about great people. Right? These were kings and queens and generals and popes whose pictures were presented there, and this was the way how history was described. Now you go into a history, and now you can see this is a living room, how people lived in Roman times, and this is the way how they ate, this is the way how they cooked, and these are the instruments by which they produced the stuff what they cooked in their kitchen. Right? This is how a modern historical museum looks like, and this comes–this is really a revolution from Marx. History is not the history of great ideas and great men, or great women. History is the idea of the actual way how people lived and produced and reproduced their ideas.
To what extent is this true? As far as I'm aware, Marx wasn't a museum curator. But was Marx's thought, i.e. Marxism, in some way responsible for the way the museum is organized and presented, and how much did this affect the museum?
1 Answers 2020-11-20
1 Answers 2020-11-20
I was browsing the web and I came across the term, I'm currently trying to learn all about religions and their origins and it would be greatly appreciated if someone can explain this to me
1 Answers 2020-11-20
2 Answers 2020-11-20
1 Answers 2020-11-19
1 Answers 2020-11-19