What was the economy of Revolutionary Catalonia like? Was it sustainable in the long run?

by TomShoe
k1990

By far the best single source I've encountered on the revolution in Spain is The Spanish Revolution by Stanley Payne. It's a really compelling and well-researched analysis of the roots of revolution in Spain (especially Catalonia) and the nature and dynamics of the revolutionary state after the start of the civil war. There's a lot of economic detail and analysis in there. I'm at work so can't consult my copy right now, but I'll break it out and check back in when I get home.

A couple of notes in the meantime:

  • if you have JSTOR access, 'Catalonia and the Spanish Civil War' by E. Allison Peers provides a good quick-read overview of Catalonia's position and role in the war.
  • the question of whether collectivisation of industry and agriculture was successful (in productivity terms) is a very vexed one; there's significant debate over whether collectivisation (and specifically collectivisation as it was carried out by the various left-wing, anarchist and syndicalist factions at work in Catalonia in 1936-37) was effective either as a mode of operations for a war economy, or for a prospective Catalan state in the long term.
  • inflation was a serious problem in Catalonia during the war: Michael Seidman claims that "Prices in Catalonia rose 6-7% every month [during the first year of the war]." (Source: 'Agrarian Collectives during the Spanish Civil War'.)